Showing posts with label 2019 Legislative Session. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2019 Legislative Session. Show all posts

Monday, March 11, 2019

Senate Bill 140: A Minor Musing

There were a couple of comments on this partisan divides post that got me thinking. The big question became: is it really possible that South Dakota or the entire United States can devolve into the Northern Ireland of the Troubles and is there an ounce of prevention available in South Dakota? 

Over the weekend, I read this David Brooks column wherein he announces his support for reparations for the decedents of slaves. He also alludes to Native Americans:
From these thoughts we can appreciate the truth that while there have been many types of discrimination in our history, the African-American (and the Native American) experiences are unique and different. Theirs are not immigrant experiences but involve a moral injury that simply isn’t there for other groups. 
Slavery and the continuing pattern of discrimination aren’t only an attempt to steal labor; they are an attempt to cover over a person’s soul, a whole people’s soul.
Let's be clear, these words were written by David Brooks, a writer who espouses radical ideas with the same frequency that Sanka causes caffeine jitters. If Brooks recognizes that Native Americans have suffered "a moral injury that simply isn't there for other groups," then surely South Dakota legislators should recognize the harm that has been done to Native Americans within the state.

No one should be naive enough to expect that the South Dakota legislature will seriously take up the topic of reparations for Native Americans. They should, however, be able to unanimously pass some small measures to help. Senate Bill 140 is indeed a small measure:

The Board of Regents is hereby authorized to develop programs to increase enrollment and improve retention and student supports for any student who is a member of one of the nine federally recognized tribes in South Dakota at state institutions, including exploration of tuition assistance or waiver programs.

The Board of Regents shall report to the Legislature by July first of each year on the activities and progress made in regard to this Act, beginning July 1, 2020.

The bill appropriates no money. The Board of Regents is not authorized to grant "tuition assistance or waiver programs." It is merely authorized to explore such programs. If any piece of legislation can be called anodyne, SB 140 should be the top example.

And yet, Representatives Beal, Dennert, Frye-Mueller, Gosch, Lana Greenfield, Hammock, Howard, Karr, Mulally, Pischke, Post, and Weiss could not bring themselves to allow someone to make it a little easier for Native Americans to attend state colleges and universities.

David Brooks has come out in support of reparations, but these 12 South Dakota legislators cannot support efforts "to increase enrollment and improve retention and student supports" for Native Americans in South Dakota. It does make one wonder if South Africa may be a better analogy than Northern Ireland.

Sunday, March 10, 2019

What's The Difference Between South Dakota's Political Leaders And A Junior High Student Council?

Sadly, the answer appears to be nothing.

Bob Mercer reports that legislators, like the young'uns, are leaving their homework until the last minute.

Then appropriators left a long list of agencies hanging Thursday because of a scheduling quirk that senators needed to be at their desks by mid-morning to start casting votes.
The panel isn't scheduled to official return to work until Tuesday, facing an agenda that has 16 big areas of spending, including state government’s largest departments such as social services, education, corrections, the state universities and the court system.

To make the analogy more cringeworthy, Mercer reports that Governor Noem is using candy as a thank you for votes. The treats apparently also served as a message to let everyone know who is and is not her friend.

14 senators who voted against industrial hemp last week found on their desks Thursday boxes of Dots candy and thank-you notes from Noem for sticking with her. 

The small treats strengthened the feeling among legislators and lobbyists that the governor indeed might veto the hemp bill, especially after two Senate votes went 21-14 in a chamber where a veto override requires at least 24.

Democrats then decided to squander their chance to look like adults by resorting to juvenile behavior of their own. Dakota Free Press reports that Ann Tornberg, the current party chair, and Larry Lucas her running mate as vice-chair candidate offered to buy voting delegates lunch when the South Dakota Democratic Party Executive Board and State Central Committee Members meet later this month. Commenters on the DFP post claim that the email did not go out to all members of the party's Central Committee. They implied that those who were not voting for Tornberg did not get the email invitation. Like the the young'uns, the Democrats' apparently have a tribal lunch room. 

The farm economy is hurting; nursing homes are closing, and schools are not being fully funded. Meanwhile, leaders in government and members of the loyal opposition are passing notes asking "Will you be my friend? Circle yes or no."


Sunday, March 3, 2019

Let's Talk About Talk

Pat Powers continues to bang the drum for House Bill 1087, legislation that purports to ensure South Dakota's public colleges and universities protect free speech on campus. In the past 24 hours, he has devoted 3 posts to the subject.

I've opined that HB 1087 will not change anyone's mind. In fact, I believe it will do little except increase paperwork.

I consider myself as close a free speech absolutist as possible. I'll accept the fact one should not yell fire in crowded theater if there's no fire, but young'uns should be able to wear their black armbands in school; folks can wear MAGA hats or Trump is the Devil t-shirts to their hearts' content, and people I disagree with should be able to march for causes they believe in.

I'll even stipulate that no one has the right to not be offended, although a democratic republic works far better when people avoid deliberately offending others. I believe that violence that surrounded Charles Murray's speech at Middlebury to be reprehensible .

That said, the biggest problem with HB 1087 is that it begins with the premise that colleges are awash with liberal thought and that all conservative intellectuals are denied access to the ivory tower. Therefore, the power of the state must be brought to bear because no other venues exist for conservative speech in any other part of the public square.

Republicans used to be wary about state intrusion into these issues because they understood the state to be a leviathan. They would have opposed legislation like this if it had been proposed by progressives. In that case, Republicans would argue that state power is a cudgel that that will be used to destroy free speech or promote liberal speech at the expense of conservative speech.

Powers points to the USD Student Bar Association Hawaiian Day party being changed to Beach Day as proof that HB 1087 is necessary. Yet, that situation was taken care of without the legislation. Further, it's not clear what was "intellectual" about that debacle.

In addition, I keep wondering what views cannot be expressed. I'm all for bringing Noam Chomsky and Charles Murray to campus on the same night and letting them argue. I don't see anything in HB 1087 that encourages this sort of academic debate.

HB 1087 seems to go beyond debate or intellectual argument. Instead it seems to weigh all ideas as intellectually equal. As such, it prompts questions: Should a geology professor allow a young earth creationist to hold forth for a whole class period or two class periods in order to insure intellectual diversity has been developed or preserved . Should an African American history class give time to someone to espouse the virtues of blackface as an art form? If a professor contends that FDR acted properly at Yalta, does the University have to give equal time to someone who believes Yalta was an act of treason?

Powers also rejoices that the President has announced an executive order about speech on college campuses. Although the text of the order is not available, I doubt that anything in the executive order will protect someone on a college campus who contends that Trump's is likely to use his MAGA hats like Gessler used his hat in the William Tell tale. In fact, given Trump's desire to weaken libel laws, that speech might get the person sued.

For years, the argument has been that the best cure for bad free speech is more good free speech. HB 1087 doesn't seem as if it will promote an free speech.

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Governor Kristi Noem After 47 Days: A Minor Musing

I proudly voted against Kristi Noem twice in 2019. I had numerous reasons, but one of the largest was the nagging question of how a Governor Noem would handle the South Dakota Republican Party's far right fringe.

During the campaign, Noem indicated she would sign a permitless carry bill, something of a grail for that fringe. She kept her promise, signing the bill with more than a little pageantry in the capitol rotunda.

A week later, Noem called legislative leaders to what was allegedly a come-to-Jesus meeting:

By all accounts, Noem was sick of the weird stuff coming from the Legislature, in particular the House, when she summoned legislative leaders to her second-floor offices last week. Her message was simple: Cut it out. 

There was the issue with the prudish dress code drawn up by House leadership, the one that several Republican women objected to. There was the spat between House Speaker Steve Haugaard and longtime lobbyist Yvonne Taylor, where Haugaard banned her from the House floor because she wrote something in May that he didn’t like.
 

Noem was also upset that House leaders were trying to submarine her budget, demanding a 3 percent cut. And she wanted to know why there were more than 40 bills that had been introduced without meaningful content. These bills – vehicle bills or hoghouse bills – are used by lawmakers to spring surprise legislation late in the session before anyone has had time to review them. They are the antitheses of open government.

From a distance it's unclear if Noem's scolding ending the "weird stuff" or if the legislative calendar forced a halt to the surreal proposals. 

For his part, Speaker Haugaard led efforts to defeat House Bill 1175 which would have established an Early Learning Advisory Council because such a council would be  "a transformational approach to instilling a—more of a socialist agenda into the system.” The Early Learning Advisory Council would have consisted of parents, representatives of various state agencies, and educators. Haugaard's weirdness seems to be continuing apace.

On the less weird end of legislature, Noem's signature civics education proposal has become a 10 question trivia game and the legislature may well pass an industrial hemp despite her opposition.

Today, Noem suffered another setback; this loss coming at the hands of Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg.
The Senate Judiciary Committee voted 5-2 to send the cornerstone of Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg’s legislative agenda to the floor. The move comes a day after Republican Gov. Kristi Noem said she’s asking that lawmakers hold off on reversing the policy, citing the cost.
That cost is $53 million.

I hope Noem wins the presumptive probation fight. I was pleasantly surprised the took on the legislature over some of the nonsense resolutions and hoghouse bills. I hope the legislature passes industrial hemp legislation this session.

All of these struggles, however, indicate that Noem gave the Republican fringe a golden calf they had been pining for, but they seem unwilling to respond in kind. 

Thursday, February 14, 2019

What Are South Dakota Republicans In The Legislature Afraid Of?

The 2019 legislative session prompts me to return to a theme that I have blogged about before: fear, especially Republican fear.

South Dakota Republicans seem to operate under the following principles:
  1. Evil exists in the world. In fact, it might be rampant in the world
  2. Virtuous folk must be vigilant and fight evil at every opportunity.
  3. Eternal verities exist and nations and individuals violate them at their peril. (The exact nature and source of these verities seem to differ based on the Republican speaking.)
  4. Virtuous folk must be vigilante and fight to preserve these eternal verities from any alteration or amendment.
The permitless carry, ideological diversity, and petition regulation bills all illustrate these principles.  More importantly, these efforts illustrate needless fear and what happens when fear drives people to take the principles to the extreme.

Evil people may be lurking around the corner, so people need to carry concealed guns. This notion persists despite the fact that South Dakota's violent crime rate remains low.

Some professor apparently has given a lecture that questions some commonly held belief, so something must be done to prevent that those words from being heard by innocents without at least 1000 bits of correction. Once again, this fear seems to defy facts. Republicans, purportedly the conservative party, are gaining members whereas the allegedly liberal Democrats are losing members.

Clearly, the people can't be trusted to use the petition process properly when they have the temerity to disagree with the legislature.

At the state level, South Dakota has been a de facto single party state for decades, yet Republicans are proposing legislation that makes one believe they are scared of every new idea, the present, the future, and their own shadows.

(I suppose I should have linked to some of the bills, but visiting the SDLRC website is getting a bit depressing.

Monday, February 4, 2019

Senate Bill 68: Parts is Parts?

It's cold and windy and I am feeling nostalgic for my youth when I was young and foolish enough to enjoy cold and wind. I have no other excuse for wondering if the following language from Senate Bill 68 was inspired by an old Wendy's advertisement.
For the purposes of this title, the term, poultry, includes anything containing meat intended for or capable of use for human consumption, that is derived, in whole or in part, from any domesticated bird intended for human consumption.
Apparently, South Dakota will now codify the fact that big parts can be cut up into little parts and then fused into a big part because "parts is parts."

HJR 1005: The Article V Convention Silliness Returns

I've previously mused about the dangers of an Article V convention and predicted that the South Dakota Legislature would take up the proposal during the 2019 session.

House Joint Resolution 1005  
calls for a convention of the states to "to impose fiscal restraints on the federal government, to limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and to limit the terms of office for federal official and members of Congress."

HJR 1005 
will be heard by the House State Affairs Committee on February 6. The committee meeting begins at 7:45 am. There's no drama about whether the resolution will emerge with a do pass. Representatives Anderson, Beal, Hansen, Haugaard,, Kevin Jensen, Kent Peterson and Qualm are all sponsors of the legislation and they constitute a majority of committee.

HJR 1005 offers no specifics. It does not define "fiscal restraints" nor does it state what federal government powers it seeks to limit or the degree to which federal government's jurisdiction shall be limited. Finally, it does not list the federal officials that its backers believe must be subject to term limits.


In my previous post, I mentioned the threat of a runaway convention. 
In order to assuage concerns, the sponsors offer this language:

This application is made with the express understanding that an amendment that in any way seeks to amend, modify, or repeal any provision of the Bill of Rights is not authorized for consideration at any stage. This application is void ab initio if ever used at any stage to consider any change to any provision of the Bill of Rights;

I am glad that Congress shall still be prevented from making laws limiting the freedom of the press, assembly, and one's ability to worship freely. I am overjoyed that the troops Donald Trump is sending to the Mexican border will not be "quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner." And although the courts have stripped away many of the protections that should be inherent in the term "unreasonable searches and seizures," I appreciate that convention will not remove what remains of that right. 


Preventing the convention from targeting the Bill of Rights does not prevent it from altering other amendments. The convention can target the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause. Given that one of HJR 1005's goals is to limit the federal government, it's almost a certainty that a convention called under these vague limits will attempt to remove the equal protection clause. Further nothing in HJR 1005 prohibits the convention from repealing the Nineteenth Amendment that ensures women are allowed to vote.

I hope the following example is not under consideration, but one can "limit the terms of office for federal officials" by inserting the clause "With the exception of Donald Trump the 45th President of the United States and his heirs," to the beginning of Twenty-Second Amendment. Every President who is not Donald Trump or an heir is limited.  

The sponsors fancy themselves "guardians of liberty." This inflated opinion of their importance indicates that these legislators have forgotten that the Constitution is tool to protect "We the people" and that the Tenth Amendment reserves rights not only to the states but also to the people: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."


Nothing in HJR 1005 allows one to believe that citizens will be more free after the convention that the resolution calls for. Its loose language and lack of definitions make a runaway convention a certainty.

Sunday, February 3, 2019

Besides Paperwork, What Does HB 1087 Hope To Accomplish With Its Demand For Ideological Diversity

A few decades back, a good friend told me that my job as a teacher was to "comfort the troubled and trouble the comfortable." If one Googles that phrase, one will frequently find it attributed to theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer. In all likelihood, the statement paraphrases a statement made by the fictional Mr. Dooley, a character created by Finely Peter Dunne.

That phrase popped into my head when I read the text of House Bill 1087, "An Act to promote intellectual diversity at certain institutions of higher education." Encountering intellectual ideas that differ from one's own is indeed uncomfortable. In fact, as this Scientific American article points out,
To avoid coming to undesirable conclusions, people can fly from the facts and use other tools in their deep, belief-protecting toolbox.
This New Yorker article points out that emotional appeals may be a bit more effective, but emotions are not scientific :
Providing people with accurate information doesn’t seem to help; they simply discount it. Appealing to their emotions may work better, but doing so is obviously antithetical to the goal of promoting sound science.
One should add that emotional appeals are rarely intellectual.

This is not new science. As this Atlantic article points out,

“A man with a conviction is a hard man to change,” Festinger, Henry Riecken, and Stanley Schacter wrote in When Prophecy Fails, their 1957 book about this study. “Tell him you disagree and he turns away. Show him facts or figures and he questions your sources. Appeal to logic and he fails to see your point … Suppose that he is presented with evidence, unequivocal and undeniable evidence, that his belief is wrong: what will happen? The individual will frequently emerge, not only unshaken, but even more convinced of the truth of his beliefs than ever before.” 

This doubling down in the face of conflicting evidence is a way of reducing the discomfort of dissonance, and is part of a set of behaviors known in the psychology literature as “motivated reasoning.” Motivated reasoning is how people convince themselves or remain convinced of what they want to believe—they seek out agreeable information and learn it more easily; and they avoid, ignore, devalue, forget, or argue against information that contradicts their beliefs.

One should be wary of assuming facts not in evidence, but one would hope that Representatives Sue Peterson  Haugaard, and Qualm and Senators Stalzer, Brock Greenfield , Langer, and Maher, the legislation's prime sponsors would be aware of these studies.

One would also hope that they, conservatives in good standing, would not be proposing this legislation merely to cause liberals discomfort. If so, they might be creating more committed liberals. The research indicates that people of all stripes will not change their minds merely because they are confronted by different ideas.

This desire to confirm one's beliefs despite evidence cuts both ways. Conservatives, trained from youth in the way they should go, will double down on their beliefs despite facts or theories to the contrary. The alleged liberal dominance of South Dakota Universities should not have an adverse effect on young conservatives' ideological certainty.

One wonders what the sponsors of the legislation hope to accomplish as they demand public universities expose students to a "variety of ideological and political perspectives." (As a side note, "ideological" and "political" are not necessarily synonyms for "intellectual.") Perhaps the sponsors merely want to comfort themselves as they cause discomfort for university officials who have to do the reams of paperwork this legislation necessitates.

Saturday, January 26, 2019

Some More Musings About Civics

Over at Dakota Free Press, Cory provides an excellent line-by-line analysis of HB 1066, legislation designed to enact Governor Noem's proposal to mandate every South Dakota high school student pass a civics test before graduation. 

I have been snarky about the various civics requirements being advanced during the 2019 South Dakota legislative session.  This proposal and and silly sticker legislation are egregiously bad.

What is the civics test or sticker supposed to accomplish? The Brookings Institution asserts that civics education goes beyond memorizing facts:
The aim of civics education is broader and includes providing students with an understanding of how democratic processes work, as well as how to engage in these processes. A high-quality civics education thus includes opportunities for students to engage in activities within the classroom that model what democratic processes look like, as well as opportunities to participate in the civic life of their communities and learn from this participation as a formal part of their coursework.
It might be useful to adapt the goals of the Center of Civic Education to a civics curriculum. Students should, 
1. Gain "an increased understanding of the institutions of constitutional democracy and the fundamental principles and values upon which they are founded"  
2. Acquire"the skills necessary to participate as competent and responsible citizens,"  
3. Develop the "willingness to use democratic procedures for making decisions and managing conflict," 
4. Become part of "an enlightened citizenry by working to increase understanding of the principles, values, institutions, and history of constitutional democracy. . . ."
The American Federation of Teachers asserts "[w]hen civics education is taught effectively, it can equip students with the knowledge, skills, and dispositions necessary to become informed and engaged citizens."

Neither a test nor a sticker will help develop skills necessary to participate in local, state, or national government. More importantly, neither will solve the problem of apathy or misinformation. Earlier today, David Montgomery, a former Sioux Falls Argus Leader reporter re-tweeted the following screen grab.



The desire to seek news has decreased and headlines, not the article's content, dominate news consumption. It's doubtful that a civics test or sticker will change those habits.

If the goal of a mandated civics test is to make students better citizens, advocates of tests or stickers have the burden of proof to show how the test will change social media behavior and help develop the skills and desire to participate in civic life. As written, the bills may help students regurgitate facts, but belching facts does not help civic discourse.

Representatives Pischke and Brunner and Senator Nelson Embrace Marriage Equality

Ok, the post's title might be overselling the point a bit, but Pischke, Brunner, and Nelson are becoming more inclusive. They want South Dakota's legal definition of adultery to apply to every married person.

If their legislation passes, a married person who has voluntary sex with a person not his or her legal spouse will be guilty of adultery. It won't matter if the person is gay, lesbian, bisexual, or straight.

Pischke, Brunner, and Nelson are co-sponsoring HB 1107 which changes South Dakota's legal definition of adultery. If HB 1107  passes, state law will read, "Adultery is the voluntary sexual intercourse of a married person with any other person to whom he or she is not married."

Currently, the law reads, "Adultery is the voluntary sexual intercourse of a married person with one of the opposite sex to whom he or she is not married."

The definition of adultery is found in section 25-4 of South Dakota's Codified Laws. That section covers divorce. Pischke, Brunner, and Nelson are acting like social liberals and allowing aggrieved same-sex spouses to use adultery as grounds for divorce.

It is a little odd that folks who have strenuously argued for the sanctity of marriage would make it easier for anyone to divorce

In fact, some cynical folk might argue that the legislation is being being proposed as a form of sour grapes in reaction to Obergefell decision which legalized same-sex marriage. Those folks might contend that these legislators are making divorce easier for marriages that the legislators never considered valid.

I will be curious to see if anyone argues against this legislation because it removes from state law the premise that marriage is between one man and one woman. 

Tuesday, January 22, 2019

What All The Civics Education Proposals Miss: BS Detection 101

The 2019 South Dakota Legislative Session is awash in civics legislation and proposals. HB 1051 will put a sticker on diplomas of students who "demonstrate competencies" in the following:
(1)    An understanding of the basic principles of American democracy and how those principles are applied in a republican form of government;
(2)    An understanding of the Constitutions of the United States and of this state;
(3)    Knowledge of the founding documents and how those documents shape the nature and function of the government; and
(4)    An understanding of landmark United States Supreme Court cases and the impact of those cases on law and society.
SB 52 requires a semester of civics education. Governor Noem wants students to pass the citizenship test.

There's nothing inherently wrong with any of those proposals, but they miss the point. Any civics education program should begin with long unit on BS detection. I'd suggest this video as start. It has the basis of two weeks worth of lessons if not more.

Friday, January 18, 2019

A Minor Musing On South Dakota SB 55 And God In Schools

I am bewildered as to why Senate Bill 55 exists. SB 55 requires that the national motto In God We Trust "shall be displayed in each public school. The display shall be located in a prominent location within each public school. The display may take the form of a mounted plaque, student artwork, or any other appropriate form as determined by the school principal."

When I had the privilege to teach world literature classes, I taught a unit on the Bible. I frequently supplemented the textbook with the Garden of Eden, David and Goliath, and Saul on the Road to Damascus passages. When I taught The Grapes of Wrath, I spent a class period discussing how Steinbeck inverted the biblical account of the search for the promised land.  I taught Flannery O'Connor stories every chance I got. I usually told students that O'Connor believed her "subject in fiction is the action of grace in territory largely held by the devil." It is difficult to teach literature with discussing grace, Christ figures, and a heavenly host of biblical archetypes and allusions.

Conservative and liberal students took my world lit, American lit, and AP lit classes. No conservative parent ever thanked me for exposing students to the Bible. They didn't show up at a parent-teacher conference and say that "the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart” and we know that "it shall not return. . .void, but it shall accomplish that which [God] please[s]." Nothing close to that ever happened.

Nor did liberal parents contact Cory Heidelberger to have him charge into my classroom followed by an army of ACLU lawyers wielding 666 cease and desist orders. I expect a few students whom I bored to tears would have welcomed the intrusion, but nothing close to that ever happened either.

If the goal is to get students to see the phrase "In God We Trust," directing that principals place the motto in "a school entryway, cafeteria, or other common area where students are most likely to see the national motto display" means that the motto will become background noise like lunch menus, daily announcements, and posters reminding everyone to wear school colors on Friday. I can guarantee that students will pay more attention to lunch menus than they will the motto. I doubt the motto will remind them to say a table grace before they eat.

Finally, I'm willing to bet that most, if not all, of the legislation's sponsors complain about students being addicted to their phones. They should know that young'uns will be checking Snapchat or Instagram or texts from work on every trip through all common areas.

In short, God is not absent from public schools and SB 55 is an ineffective solution in search of a problem.

Thursday, January 17, 2019

A Minor Musing: Skrulls And South Dakota Legislative Resolutions

Skrulls! That's right. Skrulls have apparently replaced many practical, no nonsense South Dakota legislators: good solid folk who believe that hard work is its own reward. How else does one explain the desire to hand out stickers and pass "give everyone a trophy for participating" resolutions? Shapeshifting Skrulls have taken on the form of South Dakota legislators and replaced the good folk South Dakotans elected.

Senate Concurrent Resolution 5 (SCR 5) provides the most obvious proof that something is amiss. SCR 5 commends Senators Thune and Rounds for supporting Brett Kavanaugh's nomination.

Let's review: a Republican state legislature commends the states's Republican federal senators for supporting someone nominated by a Republican president. Thune's and Rounds's votes were hardly profiles in courage. No South Dakota Democrat is going to win campaigning against the Kavanaugh vote. In fact, voting against Kavanaugh would have increased the chance of a Republican primary challenger. There's no need to commend someone for making a politically expedient vote. Republicans would know that. Skrulls probably would not.

More importantly, the resolution commends Thune and Rounds for supporting Trump, an act they perform with extreme regularity. Thune votes with Trump 95% of the time. Rounds is in line with Trump's positions on nearly 92% of his votes. The odds of the two men voting against Trump's nominee is only slightly higher than the odds of fictional Skrulls taking over the state legislature. (The odds of Trump's positions aligning with South Dakotans" best interests 90% of the time is likely lower.)

Republicans used to be republican. At the state level, they worried about the state first. Is it too much to hope that some work will get done about roads or nursing homes that are disappearing before the legislature devotes time to handing out participation trophies to politicians for taking politically expedient votes?

Sunday, January 13, 2019

A Modest Proposal To Amend HB 1041

Last year, I wrote a post about my Republicanism. Since then, I have read a good number of conservative authors at places like The National Review and The American Conservative. These articles repeatedly pointed out that conservatives and Republicans believe in freedom and responsibility, Further, Republicans and conservatives understand, in ways that other mammals cannot, that the world is filled with bad actors.

HB 1041 is a bill to "provide for the carrying of a concealed pistol without a permit." The legislation's sponsors certainly will contend that they proposed the legislation because they realize that freedom to carry pistols without a permit is the only available method to stop unabated wickedness wherever a good conservative or Republican  may find it.

According to the Argus Leader,
Republican Rep. Drew Dennert is sponsoring a constitutional carry bill in the House. He says backers have the promise of the governor and support from the public and both legislative chambers.
Given that Governor Noem seems supportive, one hates to temper the enthusiasm of "constitutional carry" advocates. Obviously every Republican or conservative who carries a pistol under HB 1041 will train weekly to become as proficient with a pistol as Wild Bill Hickok, Such people will, of course, never crack under pressure nor will they ever miss their intended target.

That said, South Dakota still retains a few Democrats. Some have even been elected to the legislature. The state also has a university system, and these educational institutions are known to be the last bastions of socialists and other nefarious scoundrels. It is, therefore, not beyond the realm of possibility that an irresponsible person might take unfair advantage of the "constitutional carry" freedom provision and carry a concealed pistol or several concealed pistols. Because South Dakota is home to 800,000 resident, it is not unlikely that several thousand feckless folk may abuse the the "constitutional carry" freedom. These capricious citizens may accidentally wound themselves or others.

It, therefore, becomes one's duty to offer a modest proposal, with all due apologies to Jonathan Swift, in the form of an amendment to rectify the situation.

The amendment would require every person carrying a concealed pistol also carry a trauma kit. The kit would contain gauze with a clotting agent, a chest seal, a trauma bandage, medical tape, a tourniquet, and heavy duty medical gloves. It would also require that the person carrying the concealed pistol and trauma kit should be able to show proof of competency with the medical items being carried. This proof could be demonstrated either by certificate of training or a field test consisting of properly applying the tourniquet and other items in the kit.

Some conservatives or Republicans may contend that this proposal springs from some hidden liberal bias. In an effort to allay such fears, prudence moves me to point out that a Blue Force Gear Micro Trauma Kit NOW won the 2018 NRA Golden Bullseye Award for "Accessory of The Year." If it as an approved NRA accessory, surely conservatives and Republicans cannot object to making it part of a "constitutional carry" law. (Neither the NRA nor Blue Force Gear sponsor this blog.)

I cannot conceive of a Republican or conservative legislature not wanting to ensure that freedom is accompanied with responsibility, so I eagerly anticipate sponsorship, debate, and passage of the amendments proposed above.

Saturday, January 12, 2019

South Dakota Senate Acts Like An Abuse Victim

Per Axios, six of the ten states hardest hit by the shutdown voted for Trump. South Dakota is one of those states. Axios points out that "[o]ffices of the USDA's Farm Service Agency, which help farmers affected by China's soybean tariffs, are closed due to the shutdown. Further, agencies including the Indian Health Service and Small Business Administration are shuttered.

Meanwhile, the South Dakota Senate passed a resolution supporting Trump's monument to his own narcissism. Although Senator Stace Nelson's hyperbolic "black wind of death to race across this nation from coast to coast" will likely garner the most attention, it's Senator Lance Russell's plaintive desire to protect Trump from those with "nefarious motives" that indicates the need for an intervention.

After the original resolution was amended to reflect the historically accurate fact that nearly all walls including the Great Wall of China, Hadrian's Wall, and the Berlin Wall fail, Senator Lance Russel worried about Trump's feelings:

Lance Russell, R-Hot Springs, saw the amended version as a watered down version of the original resolution. He said that amending the resolution is on par with "the games that get played in Washington." He said he hopes the amended version doesn't send a message that South Dakota doesn't support Trump. 

The Senate needs to support Trump in constructing a wall across the entire southern U.S. border because the problems Trump is describing aren't "a manufactured crisis," Russell said. Trump is "trying to elevate all of us" by taking on the border issues, he said, adding that the South Dakota Senate needs to support Trump and the amended version of the resolution doesn't do that.
 

"It is a crisis, and Trump didn't manufacture it," Russell said. "It's been around for a while. ... When we are watering down what we're doing here, I understand the politics of the situation, but this gives people with nefarious motives to question what the president is doing and what he was elected to do."

Let's be clear. If the wall were that important, Trump had a Republican House and Senate for two years. They could have passed the funding, gone to reconciliation to avoid the filibuster, and started construction. Instead, South Dakotans are being hurt and the legislature is looking to protect the person responsible for causing the pain.

According to Russell, South Dakotans need to support Trump even when he creates policies such as tariffs and shutdowns that adversely affect South Dakotans. It doesn't take any reading between the lines to get to abuse victim phrasing: "Trumpie just wants what's best for me; my Trumpie doesn't want to hurt me; he just gets angry sometimes. It's my fault really."

Thursday, January 10, 2019

A Minor Musing About Tests, Citizenship And Otherwise

Let's begin with a point of agreement. It appears both Governor Noem and I want young'uns to be good citizens. Some of the best debaters I coached served as legislative pages.  Lincoln-Douglas debaters spent hours researching the nature of good and bad governments. Policy debaters, their desire to have every discussion reach a terminal impact notwithstanding, debated what the U.S government should and should not do. Public forum debaters argued about a little bit of everything relating to important political events. In one way or another, each of them dealt with what it means to be a good citizen.

Governor Noem doesn't want students to debate about the nature of good government or what constitutes a good government policy. Instead, she wants students to pass a citizenship test in order to earn a high school diploma. This is a bad idea.

First, I cannot count the number of times I have supervised a study hall and heard a freshman say, "When am I ever gonna use this?" when doing an Algebra I, physical science, or world history assignment. Every grammar class that I taught had a student who said, "I don't need grammar; I talk good." The reaction to the citizenship requirement will be the same if not worse. "I don't need to think about citizenship; I vote gooder than you" is not a habit or a syntax that South Dakotans should encourage.

Second, if the testing that has come with No Child Left Behind, Common Core, and any other education policy conceived in the 21st Century has shown anything, it's that the mandated measurement ceases to be a measurement: it becomes the goal. In other words, the test will soon become more important than good citizenship. I may be in a minority, but rational, curious, and independent voters should be the goal. If this policy is enacted, the goal will become good test takers.

Third, the citizenship test may require students to know that Hamilton, Madison, and Jay wrote the Federalist Papers, but does it require them to explain why "Federalist 10" or "Federalist 51" matters in 2019? The test may require students to know that the first ten amendments to the Constitution are known as the Bill of Rights, but will they be able to discuss why the absolute phrase "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State" has caused so much controversy over the past few decades? If the test requires students know the term "checks and balances," will it also include examples of when checks and balances have been successful or failed? In short, it's doubtful students be able to explain how the United States government works; they will just identify a few concepts.

Finally, my cynical nature causes me to suspect that this proposal is a throwaway line designed to further the impression that Republicans are the sole possessors of virtue, rectitude, and patriotism whereas non-Republicans hate the every decent part of western civilization writ large. Creating good citizens is an important goal, especially for a credal nation such as the United States. It's certainly a far too important goal to become a political talking point.

Saturday, January 5, 2019

An Open Letter To South Dakota's 2019 Legislators

Dear Legislators,

We live in an angry era. In my memory, citizens have not been this divided since the Vietnam War/Watergate era. We also live  in an era in which many believe that people are entitled to select their facts as well as their opinions. You have chosen to serve in interesting times.

Given the divisiveness and anger rampant in political discourse nationally and online, I have three small requests that I believe are achievable and may even be bipartisan.

First, I don't expect you to agree on everything. In fact, the two of you whom I know personally may vote against each other 75% of the time. I would ask, however, that you remember the words of a former state legislator from Illinois who urged that people act "with malice toward none [and] with charity toward all." If South Dakotans are indeed the friendly, neighborly folks we claim to be, this request should not be that difficult to fulfill.

Second, put South Dakota first and the national debate second. Although many politicians seem fixated on a large construction project far south of us, many South Dakota communities struggle to maintain their infrastructure. In addition to physical roads and bridges, work to bridge the divide that separates South Dakota's Native American community from the rest of the state's citizens. Further, don't leave education for the last moments of the session. South Dakota's students at all levels deserve better.

Finally, accept that change is a constant. In 1999 many were worried about a Y2K computer glitch creating economic ruin if not societal collapse. Google was not commonly used as a verb; Facebook did not exist, and birds were the only species associated with tweeting. In short, remember that many current controversies will not matter 20 years from now Seek the counsel of clear headed people who look to the future to guide your deliberations and decisions.

As is often the case, Shakespeare offers the best closing: as you serve during 2019, "God's benison go with you and with those who make good of bad and friends of foes." (Macbeth Act II, Scene 4)

Thursday, January 3, 2019

A Musing About State Senator Stace Nelson's Wall Resolution, Facts, Lies, Truth, And Politics


I thought of Moynihan this morning when I read this Stace Nelson's comment on Dakota Free Press.
35+ posts of personal attacks and absolute rubbish with not one intelligent comment about the actual bill. Who does that? The Trump Derangement Syndrome is alive and well. Ranting and raving and not one of you have read the actual bill.. If you can’t debate the issues? Make things up and lie, lie, lie.
Nelson's outburst was in response to comments about his proposed resolution supporting Trump's border wall. His comment also contains a draft of his own resolution. My comment which contained a link to a Washington Post article and used numbers that come from various media sources was apparently one of those pieces of "rubbish."

Perhaps I am being nostalgic and naive, but the Moynihan assertion was made a time when people agreed what the facts were and political arguments were about the implications of those facts. Granted, I can't remember a time in my life when someone didn't mutter something about lies, damned lies and statistics or utter the phrase "figures don't lie, but liars sure do figure." Even with those caveats, it seems that people used to agreed about what the facts were. The political arguments were about the best way to deal with those facts.

In 2019 no one seems willing to agree what the facts are. I believe that Trump has said 3924 false things as president as of this writing. Based on his comment cited above, Nelson may accuse me of having Trump Derangement Syndrome. Nelson's proposed resolution contains a copious amount of numbers, many of which Nelson claims he found in congressional records. I recognize some of them as numbers originating from sources that I believe to be biased. As I did at Dakota Free Press, I will point out that Trump seems to have made up the number about the cost of illegal immigration. Many supporters of the wall will claim the article is an example of mainstream media bias.

A few years back, Chris Mooney wrote an article "The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science." These conclusions seem relevant to the point at hand.

In other words, people rejected the validity of a scientific source because its conclusion contradicted their deeply held views. . . . The study subjects weren’t “anti-science”—not in their own minds, anyway. It’s just that “science” was whatever they wanted it to be. “We’ve come to a misadventure, a bad situation where diverse citizens, who rely on diverse systems of cultural certification, are in conflict,” says Kahan. 

And that undercuts the standard notion that the way to persuade people is via evidence and argument. In fact, head-on attempts to persuade can sometimes trigger a backfire effect, where people not only fail to change their minds when confronted with the facts—they may hold their wrong views more tenaciously than ever.

Were this post a high schooler's original oratory, I would expect a solution at this point in the composition. I don't have one. I'm going to try to approach issues like I approached judging a debate round and look for the best evidence and the best arguments. Nelson and other supporters of Trump's wall will likely claim they're doing the same thing.

If we can't agree about facts and Mooney is correct that evidence and argument only cause people to hold their views more firmly, the political climate will get more charged and angry. To apply an overused Thomas Hobbes statement, it will be nasty and brutish, a war of everyone against everyone. Welcome to post-truth America.

Saturday, July 21, 2018

Some Musings About Article V Convention Silliness That Will Surely Occur In Pierre in January 2019

Last month, Bloomberg writer Noah Smith posted a tweetstorm that demonstrated the risks an Article V constitutional convention poses. Smith opined that one of those risks was an end to birthright citizenship. This week Michael Anton of Hillsdale College proved Smith prescient when he wrote a Washington Post opinion piece arguing for the end of birthright citizenship. 

Last year, the South Dakota Legislature debated two conflicting Article V resolutions. Thankfully, Senate Joint Resolution 3 died with 16 senators voting in favor and 18 opposing. House Resolution 1003 which which would have rescinded a 2015 resolution for an Article V convention to consider a balanced budget amendment was deferred to the 41st legislative day. There will no doubt be a 2019 Article V Resolution, so let's deal with the dangerous silliness now.

In addition to Smith's fear about the elimination of birthright citizenship, numerous reasons exist to oppose an Article V convention.

First, with all due respect to the 330 million people residing in the United States, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and Benjamin Franklin won't be there. If one wants to charge me with doubting my fellow citizens' ability to use their reason to govern their passions, I plead guilty.

Second, history proves it's impossible to prevent a runaway convention. The convention that Madison euphemistically called "the business of May next" was called to revise the Articles of Confederation not produce the current Constitution. (I willingly cheer the fact that the Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation; however, I refer readers to my first objection.)

Third, once the Article V convention gets out of hand, as it surely will, its targets will include the equal protection clause, long a project of 14th Amendment deniers, the 17th Amendment because Americans allegedly "have never had the right to elect their senators." and the 22nd Amendment because Donald Trump wants more than two terms. Of course, birthright citizenship will be a target as well.

Finally, both former Associate Justice Anton Scalia and former Chief Justice Warren Berger opposed an Article V convention. If two jurists who had diametrically opposed views of the limits of the Constitution could agree on that issue, then perhaps it's a really horrendous idea.

It's summer and the legislative election season, like baseball's pennant races, won't get serious until September. The resolutions won't be in the hopper until January, but voters should always be vigilant to protect themselves from dangerous ideas.