Showing posts with label Article V convention. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article V convention. Show all posts

Monday, February 4, 2019

HJR 1005: The Article V Convention Silliness Returns

I've previously mused about the dangers of an Article V convention and predicted that the South Dakota Legislature would take up the proposal during the 2019 session.

House Joint Resolution 1005  
calls for a convention of the states to "to impose fiscal restraints on the federal government, to limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and to limit the terms of office for federal official and members of Congress."

HJR 1005 
will be heard by the House State Affairs Committee on February 6. The committee meeting begins at 7:45 am. There's no drama about whether the resolution will emerge with a do pass. Representatives Anderson, Beal, Hansen, Haugaard,, Kevin Jensen, Kent Peterson and Qualm are all sponsors of the legislation and they constitute a majority of committee.

HJR 1005 offers no specifics. It does not define "fiscal restraints" nor does it state what federal government powers it seeks to limit or the degree to which federal government's jurisdiction shall be limited. Finally, it does not list the federal officials that its backers believe must be subject to term limits.


In my previous post, I mentioned the threat of a runaway convention. 
In order to assuage concerns, the sponsors offer this language:

This application is made with the express understanding that an amendment that in any way seeks to amend, modify, or repeal any provision of the Bill of Rights is not authorized for consideration at any stage. This application is void ab initio if ever used at any stage to consider any change to any provision of the Bill of Rights;

I am glad that Congress shall still be prevented from making laws limiting the freedom of the press, assembly, and one's ability to worship freely. I am overjoyed that the troops Donald Trump is sending to the Mexican border will not be "quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner." And although the courts have stripped away many of the protections that should be inherent in the term "unreasonable searches and seizures," I appreciate that convention will not remove what remains of that right. 


Preventing the convention from targeting the Bill of Rights does not prevent it from altering other amendments. The convention can target the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause. Given that one of HJR 1005's goals is to limit the federal government, it's almost a certainty that a convention called under these vague limits will attempt to remove the equal protection clause. Further nothing in HJR 1005 prohibits the convention from repealing the Nineteenth Amendment that ensures women are allowed to vote.

I hope the following example is not under consideration, but one can "limit the terms of office for federal officials" by inserting the clause "With the exception of Donald Trump the 45th President of the United States and his heirs," to the beginning of Twenty-Second Amendment. Every President who is not Donald Trump or an heir is limited.  

The sponsors fancy themselves "guardians of liberty." This inflated opinion of their importance indicates that these legislators have forgotten that the Constitution is tool to protect "We the people" and that the Tenth Amendment reserves rights not only to the states but also to the people: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."


Nothing in HJR 1005 allows one to believe that citizens will be more free after the convention that the resolution calls for. Its loose language and lack of definitions make a runaway convention a certainty.

Saturday, July 21, 2018

Some Musings About Article V Convention Silliness That Will Surely Occur In Pierre in January 2019

Last month, Bloomberg writer Noah Smith posted a tweetstorm that demonstrated the risks an Article V constitutional convention poses. Smith opined that one of those risks was an end to birthright citizenship. This week Michael Anton of Hillsdale College proved Smith prescient when he wrote a Washington Post opinion piece arguing for the end of birthright citizenship. 

Last year, the South Dakota Legislature debated two conflicting Article V resolutions. Thankfully, Senate Joint Resolution 3 died with 16 senators voting in favor and 18 opposing. House Resolution 1003 which which would have rescinded a 2015 resolution for an Article V convention to consider a balanced budget amendment was deferred to the 41st legislative day. There will no doubt be a 2019 Article V Resolution, so let's deal with the dangerous silliness now.

In addition to Smith's fear about the elimination of birthright citizenship, numerous reasons exist to oppose an Article V convention.

First, with all due respect to the 330 million people residing in the United States, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and Benjamin Franklin won't be there. If one wants to charge me with doubting my fellow citizens' ability to use their reason to govern their passions, I plead guilty.

Second, history proves it's impossible to prevent a runaway convention. The convention that Madison euphemistically called "the business of May next" was called to revise the Articles of Confederation not produce the current Constitution. (I willingly cheer the fact that the Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation; however, I refer readers to my first objection.)

Third, once the Article V convention gets out of hand, as it surely will, its targets will include the equal protection clause, long a project of 14th Amendment deniers, the 17th Amendment because Americans allegedly "have never had the right to elect their senators." and the 22nd Amendment because Donald Trump wants more than two terms. Of course, birthright citizenship will be a target as well.

Finally, both former Associate Justice Anton Scalia and former Chief Justice Warren Berger opposed an Article V convention. If two jurists who had diametrically opposed views of the limits of the Constitution could agree on that issue, then perhaps it's a really horrendous idea.

It's summer and the legislative election season, like baseball's pennant races, won't get serious until September. The resolutions won't be in the hopper until January, but voters should always be vigilant to protect themselves from dangerous ideas.