Daniel Patrick Moynihan allegedly said that one is entitled to one's opinion, but not one's own facts.
I thought of Moynihan this morning when I read this Stace Nelson's comment on Dakota Free Press.
35+ posts of personal attacks and absolute rubbish with not one intelligent comment about the actual bill. Who does that? The Trump Derangement Syndrome is alive and well. Ranting and raving and not one of you have read the actual bill.. If you can’t debate the issues? Make things up and lie, lie, lie.Nelson's outburst was in response to comments about his proposed resolution supporting Trump's border wall. His comment also contains a draft of his own resolution. My comment which contained a link to a Washington Post article and used numbers that come from various media sources was apparently one of those pieces of "rubbish."
Perhaps I am being nostalgic and naive, but the Moynihan assertion was made a time when people agreed what the facts were and political arguments were about the implications of those facts. Granted, I can't remember a time in my life when someone didn't mutter something about lies, damned lies and statistics or utter the phrase "figures don't lie, but liars sure do figure." Even with those caveats, it seems that people used to agreed about what the facts were. The political arguments were about the best way to deal with those facts.
In 2019 no one seems willing to agree what the facts are. I believe that Trump has said 3924 false things as president as of this writing. Based on his comment cited above, Nelson may accuse me of having Trump Derangement Syndrome. Nelson's proposed resolution contains a copious amount of numbers, many of which Nelson claims he found in congressional records. I recognize some of them as numbers originating from sources that I believe to be biased. As I did at Dakota Free Press, I will point out that Trump seems to have made up the number about the cost of illegal immigration. Many supporters of the wall will claim the article is an example of mainstream media bias.
A few years back, Chris Mooney wrote an article "The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science." These conclusions seem relevant to the point at hand.
In other words, people rejected the validity of a scientific source because its conclusion contradicted their deeply held views. . . . The study subjects weren’t “anti-science”—not in their own minds, anyway. It’s just that “science” was whatever they wanted it to be. “We’ve come to a misadventure, a bad situation where diverse citizens, who rely on diverse systems of cultural certification, are in conflict,” says Kahan.
And that undercuts the standard notion that the way to persuade people is via evidence and argument. In fact, head-on attempts to persuade can sometimes trigger a backfire effect, where people not only fail to change their minds when confronted with the facts—they may hold their wrong views more tenaciously than ever.
Were this post a high schooler's original oratory, I would expect a solution at this point in the composition. I don't have one. I'm going to try to approach issues like I approached judging a debate round and look for the best evidence and the best arguments. Nelson and other supporters of Trump's wall will likely claim they're doing the same thing.
If we can't agree about facts and Mooney is correct that evidence and argument only cause people to hold their views more firmly, the political climate will get more charged and angry. To apply an overused Thomas Hobbes statement, it will be nasty and brutish, a war of everyone against everyone. Welcome to post-truth America.
11 comments:
If I was a cannabis lobbyist in my home state of South Dakota I would draft a resolution that acknowledges some medical procedures are offensive to some voters as a concession to principled conservatives like Senator Nelson. I’ll say it again: the only way to a robust democracy in South Dakota is for conservatives like Nelson and Steve Hickey who are stuck in the scandal-plagued SDGOP to break away and form a viable third party.
The Washington Post fact-checker says that as of this week, Trump has uttered 7,645 falsehoods during his presidency. The use of the term "Trump Derangement Syndrome" is an attempt to retaliate for the “Obama Derangement Syndrome.” There is a big difference. The hatred for Obama was largely a matter of the endemic racism in our country that has its roots in slavery. People might disagree politically with Obama, but there was no perfidious lying, nefarious scheming, or blatant insult abuse to give a pretext for the hatred. The hatred of Trump is for his constant lying, his extensive, iniquitous business record, and the malice and abuse he inflicts on women and others he chooses to perceive as enemies. Those, such as Stace Nelson, who preen themselves with claims of honesty and integrity and beneficence toward fellow humans while calling Trump critics dishonest betray their own uninformed perfidy. While it is pointless and hopeless to confront Trump and his minions with documented facts, it is important for those who believe that our democracy functions only when an honest truth guides it to keep a record of who honors the facts and who dishonors them.
Larry,
I don't disagree with you that a 3rd party would help South Dakota. I think it would be easy to make common cause with Hickey given his history on the death penalty and usury.
I take you at your word that Nelson is as honest as the first day of summer is long, but I don't know how many folk would follow him.
Dr. Newquist,
Thank you for stopping by. I certainly agree "it is important for those who believe that our democracy functions only when an honest truth guides it to keep a record of who honors the facts and who dishonors them."
This post, like far too many of my posts, is an effort to think out loud about the problems I see. In this case, I am worried that we will keep two separate histories because one side will make up facts that they will claim the other side has dishonored. I lack the foresight or the reasoning skills to see a solution.
When we speak truthfully, with no attempt to mislead, misdirect or deceive, that truth stands alone on the accurate side of history. Those who choose not to analyze the truth, believe the truth or to denigrate the truth are those who will be relegated to that group dwelling forever on the wrong side of history. Those who can't recognize the truth are the "high value voters" we liberals need to continually address. The truth will eventually shine it's worth to all.
Mr. Newquist,
The Obama Derangement Syndrome was no more racist than the Obama Gaga Syndrome was based on his race. Hard conservatives went bonkers on all things Obama because Obama was a liberal. Hard liberals get googly-eyed over Obama because Obama was a liberal. Different sides to the same coin.
Trump Derangement Sydrome is similar. Liberals go bonkers because Trump mocks most things liberal and from Obama.
Personally, I think ODS, OGS, TDS, and TGS are all irrational. What is really crazy is when Trump adopts an Obama position- Both sides change their minds. General Mattis is a good example. Obama fired Mattis for opposing military withdrawals, a firing decried by conservatives and applauded by liberals. Now when Trump fires THE SAME GUY for THE SAME REASON, liberals go bonkers while conservatives applaud. You just can't make this stuff up.
Whether it be Obama or Trump, while President, they are our President. When we disagree with one or the other on policy, we should feel free to express ourselves. When we agree with one or the other on policy, we should feel free to express ourselves, And, on election day, as citizens express our preference for the next term.
Troy,
I usually appreciate your comments when I read them on other blogs even when I disagree with you.
I think you're correct that becoming deranged or gaga over politician is counterproductive. I've read several articles over the past few months about politics taking over as religion and giving people "something to believe in." That trend at best creates a disconcerting cult of personality. At worst, it does things like cast Trump as a King Cyrus figure. I would make that statement if Democrats starting saying a candidate was somehow a modern Joshua leading people across the river to a new promised land.
That view of Trump along with his lying more than previous presidents may be why Trump upsets me in ways that a Romney or Kasich wouldn't have. (Heck, I may well have voted for Kasich in 2016.) Bush 43 played the country boy to the extreme and Obama was too cool by half, but neither grated the way Trump does.
Porter,
I hope that you're right that those who support truth will indeed be on the right side of history. I sometimes wonder after reading a little Orwell or listening to the political debates that seem to have two different sets of facts.
Troy’s racism and dependence on his chosen superstition that rationalizes the perversions of its celebrants cloud his moral arguments rendering his entire written history in South Dakota’s blogosphere entirely inert. Why he continues to do it is just further evidence of his lack of self-awareness. His lumping in of Barack Obama with this president is an not only an insult to me but to his entire readership. Suffice it to say that my restraint here is a courtesy to Leo’s sensibilities and not a capitulation to Troy’s ridiculous assumptions.
Kal, I totally agree. Politics is not only becoming the new religion for the unchurched, too often the churched is making politics the manifestation of one's faith, which is mis-guided at best.
Post a Comment