Showing posts with label income inequality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label income inequality. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Quotation And Chart Of The Day: The Rising Tide Isn't Lifting Everyone Edition

The quotation is from this New York Times article:
The American middle class, long the most affluent in the world, has lost that distinction.
While the wealthiest Americans are outpacing many of their global peers, a New York Times analysis shows that across the lower- and middle-income tiers, citizens of other advanced countries have received considerably larger raises over the last three decades.
After-tax middle-class incomes in Canada — substantially behind in 2000 —now appear to be higher than in the United States. The poor in much of Europe earn more than poor Americans.
The chart can be found here.

Unlike middle class income, chart will get larger. Just click.

Monday, January 21, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Inequality And Opportunity Edition

From this Joseph Stiglitz commentary in the New York Times:
Our skyrocketing inequality — so contrary to our meritocratic ideal of America as a place where anyone with hard work and talent can “make it” — means that those who are born to parents of limited means are likely never to live up to their potential. Children in other rich countries like Canada, France, Germany and Sweden have a better chance of doing better than their parents did than American kids have. More than a fifth of our children live in poverty — the second worst of all the advanced economies, putting us behind countries like Bulgaria, Latvia and Greece.
Our society is squandering its most valuable resource: our young. The dream of a better life that attracted immigrants to our shores is being crushed by an ever-widening chasm of income and wealth. Tocqueville, who in the 1830s found the egalitarian impulse to be the essence of the American character, is rolling in his grave.

Monday, April 23, 2012

Resentment: A Post Created Because Three Things Converged

At Slate, big boy bloggers, Matt Yglesias and Timothy Noah are discussing Noah's book The Great Divergence: America's Growing Inequality Crisis and What We Can Do about It.
Noah makes three points about inequality.  First, he concedes it's necessary in a capitalist system.  Second income inequality is growing.
Why is it necessary to reward so much more today than in 1979 the effort and skill (and dumb luck) that gets you into the top 1 percent of incomes (i.e., above about $350,000)? In 1979 the top 1 percent consumed about 10 percent of the nation’s collective income. In 2010 it consumed about 20 percent. (That includes capital gains.) Sure, the economy was in lousy shape in 1979. But the top 1 percent contented itself with 9-12 percent of the nation’s collective income for three decades prior to 1979, during the great post-World War II economic boom. Indeed, income share for the top 1 percent fell a little during that period. From the early 1930s through the late 1970s incomes in America didn’t become more unequal; they became more equal. So clearly the top earners can get by on much less without undermining capitalism.
Growing inequality matters, according to Noah, because it produces resentment.
So that’s why growing inequality isn’t necessary. Why is it worrisome?
Because it creates alienation. I worry less about the 99 percent (which, let’s face it, includes a lot of pretty affluent people) than about the bottom 60 or 50 percent. Income earners at the median have not shared in America’s prosperity. They’ve actually seen their incomes go down (after inflation) during the past decade, and over the past three decades their increases seem pitiful compared both with people earning top incomes (and here I mean not just the top 1 percent but the top 10 and even 20 percent) and with people at the median during the postwar era. For a long time economists said: Wait until productivity rebounds. Then working families will get their share. But when productivity rebounded like crazy in the aughts, working families saw no reward.
What this means is that if you’re at the median you have no positive reason to care how the economy does. Your only motivation is fear—if the economy does really badly you may lose your job. But there’s no upside.
Noah's conclusion seem to echo the findings Cory blogged about this morning at the Madville Times: the perception of unfair treatment produces resentful workers and dangerous results.  The Chrystia Freeland column that prompted Cory's post seems to support Noah's conclusions.
Does our perception of fairness influence how hard we work? Their answer is yes - workers who are underpaid don't work as hard.
The two professors' conclusion was based on the responses of experimental subjects. In his Berlin talk, Dr. Falk also cited an American real-world example that points to the same conclusion. A bitter fight between workers and management at Bridgestone/Firestone's plant in Decatur, Illinois, in the mid-1990s, including a long strike and the hiring of scabs, coincided with the production of poorer-quality tires.
"Looking before and after the strike and across plants, we find that labor strife at the Decatur plant closely coincided with lower product quality," a paper on the subject by Alan B. Krueger, a Princeton economist who is now the head of the U.S. president's Council of Economic Advisers, and Alexandre Mas, also of Princeton, reports. "Monthly data suggest that defects were particularly high around the time concessions were demanded and when large numbers of replacement workers and returning strikers worked side by side."
Workers who feel they are being treated badly aren't just unproductive; they can be downright dangerous.
The last little item about resentment causes me to think that those who have the money and make the rules should know better.  During a class discussion about Othello, I started comparing Iago to Machiavelli and was reminded that Machiavelli counselled his prince to avoid the excessive resentment of his citizens.
Nevertheless a prince ought to inspire fear in such a way that, if he does not win love, he avoids hatred; because he can endure very well being feared whilst he is not hated, which will always be as long as he abstains from the property of his citizens and subjects and from their women. But when it is necessary for him to proceed against the life of someone, he must do it on proper justification and for manifest cause, but above all things he must keep his hands off the property of others, because men more quickly forget the death of their father than the loss of their patrimony. Besides, pretexts for taking away the property are never wanting; for he who has once begun to live by robbery will always find pretexts for seizing what belongs to others; but reasons for taking life, on the contrary, are more difficult to find and sooner lapse. But when a prince is with his army, and has under control a multitude of soldiers, then it is quite necessary for him to disregard the reputation of cruelty, for without it he would never hold his army united or disposed to its duties. . . .
Returning to the question of being feared or loved, I come to the conclusion that, men loving according to their own will and fearing according to that of the prince, a wise prince should establish himself on that which is in his own control and not in that of others; he must endeavour only to avoid hatred, as is noted.
It's rare that three different items from three different sources come together with a similar conclusion: creating resentment is dangerous and should be avoided,  What's frightening is that no one seems to care.

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Health Care Reform Irony

David Frum sardonically points out,
As we all know, a healthcare mandate is tantamount to the extinction of economic freedom. Yet the Heritage Foundation's 2012 index of economic freedom in the world ranks mandate-loving Singapore the second-freest country on earth. The United States drags along in embarrassing 10th place, behind 6th place Canada—which relies of course on a single-payer government healthcare monopoly.
Singapore's mandate doesn't keep its rich folk from hoarding a larger percentage of wealth than rich folk in the United States.  Singapore has the second largest rich-poor gap; the US is ranked third.

Let's review:  Singapore with a health insurance mandate lets the rich keep more of their money and has more economic freedom than the US.  I'm confused; I thought Republicans were for allowing those at the top of the economic ladder the freedom to concentrate wealth.

Sunday, August 21, 2011

Some Economic Queries

The Madville Times points to this Washington Post editorial that questions Republican economic theory.  South Dakota Politics counters by pointing to a New York Times article that indicates the green jobs initiatives fail.

Dr. Blanchard also takes issue with Cory's assertion that
Republican economics is wrong, intellectually, empirically, and morally. It’s really just class warfare, trying to convince the majority that government has no role in the economy so they can take the government’s hand off the tiller and let wealth naturally accumulate upward.
Blanchard responds,
The green jobs agenda is an intellectual and empirically verified farce. My friends on the left will still believe in it, and insist that we invest in it. What else could they do? But this kind of spending on useless things means that somebody isn't getting a raise and somebody else isn't getting a job. That might matter morally.
I have been thinking a lot about conflicting priorities and underlying problems lately. The fact that the country needs more jobs is indisputable.  Blanchard's rejoinder, however, seems to miss the point of Cory's question about economic policy and morality.

Politifacts rates as true the claim that he 400 richest people in the country control as much wealth as the bottom 50% of the population.  In other words 400 people control as much wealth as 150 million people.

The PBS NewsHour has developed this chart to show the how wealth is distributed in the United States.

 

Blanchard wants to leave morality out of the conversation, so I won't ask if this distribution is moral.  Instead I'll ask the following four questions.

First, is this distribution desirable?

Second, is this distribution sustainable?

Third, if the answer to either of the previous questions is "No," what's the best way to change the distribution?

Fourth, how does this distribution affect job creation?

Blanchard and many others are rightly concerned about avoiding Greece's fate.  Avoiding bankruptcy or default is a necessary goal.  However, it strikes me that one needs to work to achieve a more desirable distribution; one that looks like this chart that shows Sweden's distribution.



We may never achieve Sweden's breakdown.  As a country we may decide that this distribution has negative consequences that we want to avoid.  That being said, it seems blatantly obvious that the bottom 60% need more than 4.3% of the pie.

Friday, August 19, 2011

Income Inequality Through Satirists' Lenses

Conor Friedersdorf has a great essay illustrating that Jon Stewart is a better satirist than Rush Limbaugh.  Given my attitude toward Limbaugh, I obviously believe that Friedersdorf damns with faint praise.  If fact,  Stewart and his running mate Stephen Colbert frequently rise to the level set by Jonathan Swift.

Recently both Stewart and Colbert have taken to the same subject matter that motivated Swift to pen his most famous satirical essay, "A Modest Proposal."  Swift's speaker begins,
It is a melancholy object to those who walk through this great town or travel in the country, when they see the streets, the roads, and cabin doors, crowded with beggars of the female sex, followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags and importuning every passenger for an alms. These mothers, instead of being able to work for their honest livelihood, are forced to employ all their time in strolling to beg sustenance for their helpless infants: who as they grow up either turn thieves for want of work, or leave their dear native country to fight for the Pretender in Spain, or sell themselves to the Barbadoes.

I think it is agreed by all parties that this prodigious number of children in the arms, or on the backs, or at the heels of their mothers, and frequently of their fathers, is in the present deplorable state of the kingdom a very great additional grievance; and, therefore, whoever could find out a fair, cheap, and easy method of making these children sound, useful members of the commonwealth, would deserve so well of the public as to have his statue set up for a preserver of the nation.
In short the poor are responsible for their own condition and need to take charge of their lives.  Swift's black humor allows him to satirically suggest that the Irish sell their young as a food source for the rich.

Last night, Stewart takes on this sort of "class warfare."
                       
The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
World of Class Warfare - Warren Buffett vs. Wealthy Conservatives
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show Full EpisodesPolitical Humor & Satire BlogThe Daily Show on Facebook


Steven Colbert takes on the same targets.



Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Can the London Riots Happen Here?

This paragraph and quotation from this Andrew Sullivan post interests and disconcerts me.
And the use of social media and nifty little bikes reveals the criminal opportunism here. But even Mary Riddell in the Telegraph sees the background of austerity, accelerating social inequality and the bleakness of the economic future as part of the context:
It is no coincidence that the worst violence London has seen in many decades takes place against the backdrop of a global economy poised for freefall. The causes of recession set out by J K Galbraith in his book, The Great Crash 1929, were as follows: bad income distribution, a business sector engaged in “corporate larceny”, a weak banking structure and an import/export imbalance. [emphasis mine]
The bolded phrasing perfectly describes the United States's economic situation over the past decade.  Further, we are living in era that seems to prize and reward belligerence over competence.  This Frum Forum post compares Mitch Daniels and Chris Christie to make the point.
While talk radio is urging Chris Christie to enter the race, it is demanding that Mitch Daniels exit. The Indiana governor drew accolades from many for his CPAC performance — but Rush Limbaugh and other talkers have blasted him for his talk of a truce on social issues and his decision not to insert a brand-new right-to-work initiative at the top of his agenda.
Why is Chris Christie the heartthrob of the radio right, while Daniels is suddenly an intolerable RINO? Christie is not more conservative than Daniels, and arguably even less so. Christie told the Newark Star-Ledger that while personally pro-life, he won’t use his office to “shove that down people’s throats.” He supports New Jersey’s restrictive gun laws.  And like Daniels, he has decided it’s tough enough to face his public-sector unions that he does not need to start an unrelated fight over right-to-work with private-sector unions. Yet the most acid-tongued of all right-wing commentators, Ann Coulter, has championed a Christie candidacy, asserting that if he declines to run, “Romney will be our nominee and we’ll lose.”
The difference is this: talk radio is not much interested in the substance of a politician’s views or the reasons for decisions. Talk radio wants a confrontational style, and unlike the soft-spoken Daniels, the fierce Christie meets the test. The rule seems to be: it’s OK to be a Republican moderate – provided you are belligerent enough about it. [emphasis mine]
Apparently, belligerence is not enough.  This Eli Lehrer Frum Forum post illustrates that Eric Cantor gets rewarded for being a jerk.
I’m not the first to make this comment, but the current debt limit debate shows what the Tea Party movement (which I once basically supported) really values: being a jerk. Speaker Boehner has a close-to-perfect voting record on conservative issues, is not terribly warm in person (heck, Newt comes across better) and has proposed a good, tough spending cut plan. But he has also demonstrated a modicum of willingness to work with the president and appears to want to bring the debt ceiling crisis to a close.
Eric Cantor—who may well become speaker before the end of the year—does not disagree with Boehner on any major issue including the debt plan but, unlike Boehner, Cantor is basically a jerk who is willing to work against his own Speaker, the President, the financial interests that have traditionally supported his party and, indeed, just about everyone else so long as it keeps him in the media. I’m disgusted.
Cantor apparently is proud of jerk bona fides or stubborn.  From this Talking Points Memo post,
Will S&P's controversial decision to downgrade the country's bond rating -- and its explicit citation of GOP intransigence on tax revenue -- be enough to break the Republicans' broad opposition to tax increases in future deficit reduction legislation?
Not if House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) can help it.

In a Monday memo to the House GOP caucus, he candidly acknowledged that S&P faulted the party's unyielding stance on tax revenues for the downgrade. But he encourages members not to erase this bright line.
"Over the next several months, there will be tremendous pressure on Congress to prove that S&P's analysis of the inability of the political parties to bridge our differences is wrong," Cantor wrote. " In short, there will be pressure to compromise on tax increases. We will be told that there is no other way forward. I respectfully disagree.... I firmly believe we can find bipartisan agreement on savings from mandatory programs that can be agreed to without tax increases. I believe this is what we must demand from the Joint Committee as it begins its work."
In other words, House Republicans should unite against a plan that isn't dominated by Medicare cuts and contains no tax increases. There are 240 House Republicans, and during the debt limit fight, they followed Cantor's lead on this score.
Finally, there's this remarkable big lie that otherizes an entire political movement from Tea Party Nation CEO Judson Phillips.
"I will tell you ladies and gentlemen, I detest and despise everything the left stands for. How anybody can endorse and embrace an ideology that has killed a billion people in the last century is beyond me," (HT Andrew Sullivan)
Combine income disparity, belligerence, hubristic intransigence, and dangerous hyperbole, and one has a recipe for disaster.  I'm not predicting riots, but it seems as if the seeds of violent social unrest are being sown.

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Falling Union Membership Connected To Wage Inequality

According to an IO9.com post,
a new study points to the drop in union numbers to explain the growing wage inequality over the last 35 years. From 1973 to 2007, wage inequality increased 40% among men and 50% among women, while at the same time union participation dropped from 34% to 8% for the former, and 16% to 6% for the latter.
The post anticipates a key argument.
At this juncture, it's very easy to start yelling about correlation and causation, but researchers Bruce Western of Harvard University and Jake Rosenfeld of University of Washington think they can actually drill down, and ascribe this change to a multitude of factors, including falling union membership. By analyzing differences within labor groups and between them, the researchers found that the union decline was linked to as much as a third of the wage inequality for men, and a fifth for women.
The post notes that major league sports leagues seem to be the only social institutions with successful or well-received unions.  This fact illustrates that unions do not necessarily reward mediocrity at the expense of greatness.  Baseball, football, and basketball superstars earn tremendous sums of money, but average players are still adequately compensated.  Contrast that with the rest of the current economic system that allows a few to become obscenely rich while the average worker has seen wages stagnate since the 1970s.

IO9 also reports,
The paper will be published in the American Sociological Review in August, at which point you'll be able to find it here. Until then, there are a few more details here.
By the way, why do I read about studies like this on a site that covers comic books, science fiction, and weird science, but not other media.

Related Update:


Saturday, July 9, 2011

Plains Pops: Income Inequality Edition

The Madville Times highlights this An Inland Voyage post about CEO pay and this Republic Insider post about jobs.  Both illustrate the dangers of income inequality.

In addition to the immediate risks of income inequality, I have been fascinated by this Paul Glastris Washington Monthly editorial.  Glastris observes,
As it happens, the willingness of the rich to defend their wealth from taxation to the point of national ruin is nothing new in world history, as Francis Fukuyama recounts in his magisterial new book The Origins of Political Order. The Han dynasty in China fell in the third century AD after aristocratic families with government connections became increasingly able to shield their ever-larger land holdings from taxation, which helped precipitate the bloody Yellow Turban peasant revolt. Nearly a millennium and a half later, the great Ming dynasty went into protracted decline in part for similar reasons: unable or unwilling to raise taxes on the landed gentry, the government couldn’t pay its soldiers and was overrun by Manchu invaders.

In the fifteenth century, the Hungarian King Matthias Corvinus persuaded his reluctant nobles to accept higher taxes, with which he built a professional military that beat back the invading Ottomans. But after his death the resentful barons placed a weak foreign prince on the throne and got their taxes cut 70 to 80 percent. When their undisciplined army lost to Suleiman the Magnificent, Hungary lost its independence.

Similarly, the cash-strapped sixteenth-century Spanish monarchy sold municipal and state offices off to wealthy elites rather than raise their taxes—giving them the right to collect public revenues. The elites, in turn, raised taxes on commerce, immiserating peasants and artisans and putting Spain on a path of long-term economic decline. This same practice of exempting the wealthy from taxation and selling them government offices while transferring the tax burden onto the poor reached its apogee in ancien regime France and ended with the guillotine. [emphasis mine]
In short, some rich elites have been willing to destroy nations to protect their interests by keeping taxes low.

I've quoted this Thomas Ferguson and Robert Johnson information yesterday:
Between 2002 and 2007, for example, the richest 1 percent of Americans garnered 62 percent of all income gains, while the bottom 90 percent of the population saw their incomes grow by 4 percent. At the same time, thanks to the Bush tax cuts, the rich were also paying proportionately fewer taxes.
In addition, Political Animal Steve Benen contrasts the historical facts with current political realities.
You’ll notice, of course, that all of these measures have something in common: we’re talking about tax giveaways that benefit some very wealthy Americans. It puts Republicans into the familiar role of being a Reverse Robin Hood — they’re desperate to cut spending that favors working families, and equally eager to protect tax breaks that go exclusively to the richest of the rich. The GOP wants to lower the deficit, they say, but not if it means asking their wealthy benefactors to sacrifice even a little. Indeed, asking the rich to pay even a little more would be a disaster, Republicans assure us.
One wonders which disaster is more likely to occur or be more devastating.  Given the small number of people who have received the lion's share of recent benefits, I'm worried that America's top 1 percent live in an echo chamber that makes them to risk ignoring history's lessons.

Update:  Given this Bob Ellis comment on the Madville Times, I'll side with  Fukuyama.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Economic Comparisons between U.S. AndGermany

Writing about German Chancellor Angela Merkel's visit to Washington, the New York Times's David Leonhardt writes, "Yet for all the strengths of the United States, almost nobody claims that the economy is in especially good shape. It so happens that our current out-of-town guests could teach us a few things."  Leonhardt asserts, ". . . .the American economy’s strengths may still be greater than the German economy’s. But Germany sure does seem more serious about dealing with its weaknesses."  That seriousness includes both spending cuts through efficient government and careful stimulus.

The most telling contrast may be between average workers.  Leonhardt reports,
Inflation-adjusted average hourly pay has risen almost 30 percent since 1985 in Germany, the kind of gains American workers have not enjoyed since the ’50s and ’60s. In this country, hourly pay has risen a scant 6 percent since 1985.
Conversely, American workers work more hours.  An Inland Voyage quotes Robert Reich to show that American workers must work increased hours to maintain a middle class life style.
Coping mechanism No. 2: Everyone works longer hours. By the mid 2000s it was not uncommon for men to work more than 60 hours a week and women to work more than 50. A growing number of people took on two or three jobs. All told, by the 2000s, the typical American worker worked more than 2,200 hours a year — 350 hours more than the average European worked, more hours even than the typically industrious Japanese put in. It was many more hours than the typical American middle-class family had worked in 1979 — 500 hours longer, a full 12 weeks more.
Most importantly, income inequality has not increased in Germany as it has here.
The top 1 percent of German households earns about 11 percent of all income, virtually unchanged relative to 1970, according to recent estimates. In the United States, the top 1 percent makes more than 20 percent of all income, up from 9 percent in 1970. That’s right: only 40 years ago, Germany was more unequal than this country.
"In fact," Leonhardt writes,"[in Germany] middle-class pay has risen at roughly the same rate as top incomes."

Yesterday's taxation quotations, especially the statement "According to the Norquistian theology, a good small-government conservative can’t agree to close a tax loophole that’s bad public policy in order to entice Democrats into agreeing to spending cuts" produced sobering displeasure. Leonhardt adds to the discontent:
Some Democrats say Social Security and Medicare must remain unchanged. Most Republicans refuse to consider returning tax rates even to their 1990s levels. Republican leaders also want to make deep cuts in the sort of antipoverty programs that have helped Germany withstand the recession even in the absence of big new stimulus legislation.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

A Pox on Both Your Houses

Writing in Salon, Allyssa Battistoni points out,
Jamelle Bouie writes, "vanishingly few elected Republicans are interested in anything approaching egalitarianism, but a non-trivial number of Democrats support deep spending cuts and oppose tax increases"?

A study by Princeton political scientist Larry Bartels provides some insight. Bartels found that senators are "very responsive" to the views of the wealthiest third of their constituents, "somewhat responsive" to the middle third, and not responsive at all to the third with the lowest incomes (to the extent that the opinions of the wealthiest constituents can outweigh senators' party affiliations in determining their voting records). It's true that Republicans are nearly twice as attentive as Democrats to the preferences of the wealthy, but both parties are equally indifferent to the opinions of their lower-income constituents. [emphasis mine]
It's horrible that both parties seem willing to sell out their principles to serve the rich but that fact explains why banks got to big to fail and why no one has been prosecuted for actions the nearly destroyed the economy.

Bartels' study has some even more depressing details.  For example, "These results provide surprisingly strong and consistent evidence that the biases I have identified in senators’ responsiveness to rich and poor constituents are not primarily due to differences between rich and poor constituents in turnout, political knowledge, or contacting" (28).  In short, the poor and middle class are underserved because they are poor not because they don't vote or make an effort to contact a senator.

Bartel's results are brought into sharp contrast when Battistoni points out "relatively well-off people who believe the government favors the poor."

The irony and the facts lead a clear conclusion that Battistoni effectively points out.
. . . in unequal societies, "social insurance is perceived as redistributing income over the population, rather than across time." In European countries, which have much lower income inequality and largely depend on broad-based tax systems, people expect to utilize the services they're funding at some point; in America, people think they're writing checks to some deadbeat. . . .
Funding social programs largely through high taxes on high earners isn't a problem because higher taxes are inefficient, job-killing or unfair, as conservatives often claim. It's a problem because, with money and power concentrated the way they are now, the functioning of the government is essentially dependent on the acquiescence of the rich to higher taxes.
I don't want huge government or huge taxes.  I think both are dangerous.  In fact, the only thing that I think is more dangerous is the current situation that gives the rich control of both the economy and the political system.  We're seeing the result of that control and will soon have to live without the social safety net that has been available since 1965.

Sunday, April 3, 2011

Has The Invisible Backhand Become A Visible Fist?

The recent jobs report and a USA Today article about executive pay prompted a bit of musing, anger, and despair.  This Vanity Fair article adds to the anger and despair, especially since the article is penned by Joseph E. Stiglitz, an economist with in impressive curriculum vitae.

The article begins
The upper 1 percent of Americans are now taking in nearly a quarter of the nation’s income every year. In terms of wealth rather than income, the top 1 percent control 40 percent. Their lot in life has improved considerably. Twenty-five years ago, the corresponding figures were 12 percent and 33 percent. One response might be to celebrate the ingenuity and drive that brought good fortune to these people, and to contend that a rising tide lifts all boats. That response would be misguided. While the top 1 percent have seen their incomes rise 18 percent over the past decade, those in the middle have actually seen their incomes fall.
Americans have long been told that we live in a land of opportunity far better that Europe or other parts of the world.  Unfortunately,
In terms of income equality, America lags behind any country in the old, ossified Europe that President George W. Bush used to deride. Among our closest counterparts are Russia with its oligarchs and Iran. While many of the old centers of inequality in Latin America, such as Brazil, have been striving in recent years, rather successfully, to improve the plight of the poor and reduce gaps in income, America has allowed inequality to grow.
Stiglitz takes on those who say that the United States' economy is large enough that the inequality doesn't matter.  After all, nearly everyone has cable TV, cell phones, and computers.  He demolishes that idea with several cogent points.
First, growing inequality is the flip side of something else: shrinking opportunity. Whenever we diminish equality of opportunity, it means that we are not using some of our most valuable assets—our people—in the most productive way possible.

Second, many of the distortions that lead to inequality—such as those associated with monopoly power and preferential tax treatment for special interests—undermine the efficiency of the economy. . . .

Third, and perhaps most important, a modern economy requires “collective action”—it needs government to invest in infrastructure, education, and technology.
 Stiglitz contends that the main reason for the inequality is relatively simple:
But one big part of the reason we have so much inequality is that the top 1 percent want it that way. The most obvious example involves tax policy. Lowering tax rates on capital gains, which is how the rich receive a large portion of their income, has given the wealthiest Americans close to a free ride. . . . Much of today’s inequality is due to manipulation of the financial system, enabled by changes in the rules that have been bought and paid for by the financial industry itself—one of its best investment.
 The results are easy to predict as well.
America’s inequality distorts our society in every conceivable way. There is, for one thing, a well-documented lifestyle effect—people outside the top 1 percent increasingly live beyond their means. Trickle-down economics may be a chimera, but trickle-down behaviorism is very real. . .
The changed behavior damages the American social fabric.
Of all the costs imposed on our society by the top 1 percent, perhaps the greatest is this: the erosion of our sense of identity, in which fair play, equality of opportunity, and a sense of community are so important. America has long prided itself on being a fair society, where everyone has an equal chance of getting ahead, but the statistics suggest otherwise: the chances of a poor citizen, or even a middle-class citizen, making it to the top in America are smaller than in many countries of Europe.
 The results of the damaged social fabric can already be seen.
With youth unemployment in America at around 20 percent (and in some locations, and among some socio-demographic groups, at twice that); with one out of six Americans desiring a full-time job not able to get one; with one out of seven Americans on food stamps (and about the same number suffering from “food insecurity”)—given all this, there is ample evidence that something has blocked the vaunted “trickling down” from the top 1 percent to everyone else. All of this is having the predictable effect of creating alienation—voter turnout among those in their 20s in the last election stood at 21 percent, comparable to the unemployment rate.
Stiglitz contends repeatedly that the one percent don't seem to care, and he closes with an appropriate warning:
The top 1 percent have the best houses, the best educations, the best doctors, and the best lifestyles, but there is one thing that money doesn’t seem to have bought: an understanding that their fate is bound up with how the other 99 percent live. Throughout history, this is something that the top 1 percent eventually do learn. Too late.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

"Mirror, Mirror" in America

For the young or non-Trek literate readers, "Mirror Mirror" is a classic episode of the original Star Trek series.  The plot featured an alternate universe with a tyrannical Empire instead of a benevolent Federation, a bearded Spock, and a Tantalus Field that the Department of Homeland Security is probably trying to develop at this very moment.  As with all Star Trek episodes, good triumphed and everyone had a laugh on the bridge.  I'm not so sure the episode Americans are experiencing now will have such a happy ending.

First, a tweet by Peter Daou points to this article that confirms that 400 Americans have more wealth than the 155 million poorest Americans. For the purposes of comparison, Irene, South Dakota, would have more economic power than the states of California, Texas, New York, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, the nine US states with the largest populations.

Second, the US military is actively torturing an American citizen who has been convicted of nothing.  I naively believed that the US believed that one was innocent until proven guilty.  I also thought Obama condemned torture, but I guess that was when it didn't apply to Bradley Manning who is alleged to have turned over documents to Wikileaks.  To make matters worse, the White House has apparently decided to fire P.J. Crowley who was perceptive enough to call the government's treatment of Manning "ridiculous, counterproductive and stupid."  I guess that the prohibitions against cruel and unusual punishment and the protection of free speech can be selectively applied.

Third, via The Madville Times, I discover that South Dakota's budget is twice as large as it was in 1996 but it spends half as much on tax relief for the the elderly poor.

One of the running jokes about the original Star Trek series was that characters who appeared in a red uniform would die by the end of the episode.  Somehow, it seems as if a large portion of America just got beamed down wearing a red shirt.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

The End Of The World As We Know It

The "we" in question is the American middle class.  Offered without comment because the content is self explanatory and too depressing: a Financial Times article, big boy blogger Rod Dreher's comments about the FT article, and this income inequality graph.