On January 1, 2019, I resolved to start a commonplace book wherein I would write quotations from my reading. These quotations must meet the simple criterion of striking my fancy at the moment I am reading them. They need not be inspirational, profound, or examples of great writing.
Shortly, thereafter people who should know better asked me to teach an adolescent literature course. Were I a person who followed through on my resolutions, I would have filled two or three notebooks with quotations from the books I used in class or the supplemental materials I read to prepare to teach, but I frequently fail at following through on my New Year's resolutions.
Looking through the quotations I copied in the commonplace book, three stick out as valuable reminders for the last days of 2019.
First, Wendell Berry's essay "In Defense of Literacy" contains a line that needs no context or explanation. Berry reminds readers, "Short-term practicality is long-term idiocy." This fact is ignored constantly, most dangerously by our political and corporate leaders.
The other two quotations require a bit of context. The first comes from Patrick Ness's The Knife of Never Letting Go, the first book in his Chaos Walking trilogy. A central conceit of the series is that men and animals project their thoughts audibly for all to hear; women do not. The book was first published in 2008, so Ness must be given credit for presciently creating an extended metaphor to illustrate the effects of 24/7 news cycles and social media. The fact that he calls phenomenon "Noise" throughout the series earns him extra prescience points.
Early in The Knife of Never Letting Go, Todd Hewitt, the novel's protagonist and narrator, says, "Noise ain't truth. Noise is what men want to be true, and there's a difference 'twixt those two things so big that it could ruddy well kill you if don't watch out." Listening to and reading about the impeachment debate makes it clear that "Noise ain't truth" and individual Americans are hearing what they want to be true based on the "Noise" that reaches them but there's a wide, dangerous divide between what people want to be true and the truth.
Finally, news that a United States government website listed the fictional nation of Wakanda as a free- trade partner brings to mind a statement made by Changamire, who in the first four issues of the "A Nation Under Our Feet" arc is a scholar guilty of little more than a few radical ideas about the proper role of government. When he speaks to Wakanda's Queen Mother, Changamire says, "Wakanda is science and wonder, all of it achieved by ensuring your subjects do not ask too many questions. Wakanda has all the intelligence any advanced society would want and none of the wisdom any free society needs."
In 2019, political leaders in South Dakota and the nation as a whole doubled down on their emphasis on short-term practicality, amplified their idiocy through the Noise of social media echo chambers, worked diligently to prevent citizens from asking hard questions, and, thereby, ensured that country will continue to lack wisdom free societies need.
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Thursday, December 19, 2019
Sunday, May 12, 2019
South Dakota Democrats And Evangelicals Should Drink More Whisky And Listen To Mayor Pete
It's Mother's Day, so the best thing one should do is discuss whisky, politics, and religion. What bad can happen?
This morning, I watched two YouTube videos that I would urge every South Dakota Democrat and evangelical to watch.
One was Mayor Pete Buttigieg's speech at the Las Vegas Human Rights Campaign Dinner. It was an excellent speech. He discussed what he calls "a crisis of belonging." He alluded to the fact that many of the nation's excluded citizens are being divided by metaphoric walls that allow them to "get divided and carved up." In order to prevent divisions from continuing, Buttigieg asked the audience to be willing "to stand hand in hand with people just like you and people not at all like you." In short Buttigieg reminded people to tell person stories that welcomed rather than excluded.
Buttigieg enunciated a simple truth; politics is personal and people want their stories heard. Serendipitously, the second YouTube video I watched feature two Whisky YouTubers, Erik Wait and Daniel Whittington, who discussed "Telling the Story of Whisky." Throughout their entertaining conversation about the need for story, Whittington made two important points. First, "story doesn't eliminate information; story gives information context." A little later Whittington said directly what Buttigieg alluded to: "No one cares about your story. They care about how you become part of their story." In short, tell stories that help people belong.
During this century, I recall only a handful of South Dakota Democratic candidates who were decent story tellers There have been some good policy wonks who had a great command of the facts and some good policy positions. There were a few entertainers who could cleverly turn a phrase, but storytellers have been rare. Meanwhile, Kristi Noem et al. were going full Horatio Alger. Maybe it's because Democrats apparently prefer clear spirits, but if they want to reverse their fortunes in the state, they need to start telling better stories that gives information context.
It is a Sunday, and and any discussion of story makes me think of two old hymns: "Tell Me the Story of Jesus" and "I Love to Tell the Story." I do wish the evangelical folk who used to sing those songs regularly would get back to telling the story of Jesus and recognizing that Trump's lies are not coherent stories. I also wish they's recognize that every time they tell the story of Trump, people who seek to be part of Christ's story are driven away from grace.
Everybody else who is sick of politics and religion, go watch this video of the greatest whisky speech ever.
This morning, I watched two YouTube videos that I would urge every South Dakota Democrat and evangelical to watch.
One was Mayor Pete Buttigieg's speech at the Las Vegas Human Rights Campaign Dinner. It was an excellent speech. He discussed what he calls "a crisis of belonging." He alluded to the fact that many of the nation's excluded citizens are being divided by metaphoric walls that allow them to "get divided and carved up." In order to prevent divisions from continuing, Buttigieg asked the audience to be willing "to stand hand in hand with people just like you and people not at all like you." In short Buttigieg reminded people to tell person stories that welcomed rather than excluded.
Buttigieg enunciated a simple truth; politics is personal and people want their stories heard. Serendipitously, the second YouTube video I watched feature two Whisky YouTubers, Erik Wait and Daniel Whittington, who discussed "Telling the Story of Whisky." Throughout their entertaining conversation about the need for story, Whittington made two important points. First, "story doesn't eliminate information; story gives information context." A little later Whittington said directly what Buttigieg alluded to: "No one cares about your story. They care about how you become part of their story." In short, tell stories that help people belong.
During this century, I recall only a handful of South Dakota Democratic candidates who were decent story tellers There have been some good policy wonks who had a great command of the facts and some good policy positions. There were a few entertainers who could cleverly turn a phrase, but storytellers have been rare. Meanwhile, Kristi Noem et al. were going full Horatio Alger. Maybe it's because Democrats apparently prefer clear spirits, but if they want to reverse their fortunes in the state, they need to start telling better stories that gives information context.
It is a Sunday, and and any discussion of story makes me think of two old hymns: "Tell Me the Story of Jesus" and "I Love to Tell the Story." I do wish the evangelical folk who used to sing those songs regularly would get back to telling the story of Jesus and recognizing that Trump's lies are not coherent stories. I also wish they's recognize that every time they tell the story of Trump, people who seek to be part of Christ's story are driven away from grace.
Everybody else who is sick of politics and religion, go watch this video of the greatest whisky speech ever.
Wednesday, July 25, 2018
A Minor Musing On Politics, Literature, And Unquiet Minds
As an English teacher I spent a lot of time thinking about the "usefulness" of literature especially novels and myths. Too many Americans seemingly equate use with "being able to make a profit." Unless one is saying "'Myths and Novels' for $1000, Alex" literature may not have a financial use.
Others may be more high minded and look to novels to somehow fill a faith void created as America's religious institutions fail to provide spiritual insight. The idea that novels can replace the god that Nietzsche claims we have all killed, however, seems specious.
While literature may not provide "the truth that shall set you free," it may provide a frame that allows readers to understand a confusing world. Elizabeth Bruenig illustrates that point with this Washington Post column that uses Conrad's Heart of Darkness to explain the damage being done to America's civic institutions.
I have long maintained that Trump and his enablers use Orwell's 1984 as a road map. Yesterday, Trump became a walking caricature of Orwell's Big Brother when he asserted, “Just remember, what you are seeing and what you are reading is not what’s happening, . . . Just stick with us, don’t believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news.” This post is far from the first to point out that Orwell's dystopian state rested on an "essential command": "The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears."
I also wonder if America is approaching the tribalism illustrated in Lord of the Flies where one group rejected the evidence of their eyes and accepts that a pig's head on stick is somehow a talisman able to keep evil at bay. The boys were eventually rescued and novel leaves unanswered what happens when they return to "civilization." Like the questions that arise from the applying the Heart of Darkness to today's politics, this question should also cause disquiet because it implies there may be no true return from a descent into tribalism.
Because novels like Shakespeare's greatest works or ancient Greek tragedies offer questions without pat answers, we should encourage more reading and be more skeptical when a politician tells us "I alone can fix it." That we were not skeptical does not indicate that literature lacks value. Rather, it demonstrates that too few understand the value of the questions literature asks.
Others may be more high minded and look to novels to somehow fill a faith void created as America's religious institutions fail to provide spiritual insight. The idea that novels can replace the god that Nietzsche claims we have all killed, however, seems specious.
While literature may not provide "the truth that shall set you free," it may provide a frame that allows readers to understand a confusing world. Elizabeth Bruenig illustrates that point with this Washington Post column that uses Conrad's Heart of Darkness to explain the damage being done to America's civic institutions.
Marlow’s is a civic kind of going mad, where the veil is lifted from politics and what lies beneath makes participation in ordinary political life with a quiet mind impossible. By the time he returns, what once seemed placid and unremarkable seems sinister and false — and it is.
We’re about there, I think — perhaps not every single one of us, perhaps not just yet, but the conditions are right and the summer is long. The entire 2016 episode has been, in some sense, an introspective journey into America’s own innermost parts, with Donald Trump’s victory prompting a nervous self-inventory of what we value, whether our institutions work and to what degree we ought to trust one another. The full contents of that inward odyssey have yet to unfold. But on the question of institutional functioning, the news is unequivocally grim. Like Marlow, even after this particular chapter has ended, we are likely to find ourselves changed by what we’ve seen.Bruenig concludes that the change we undergo will be long lasting,
. . . It has gone this way before. It took several incidents, from Vietnam to Watergate to scattered episodes of civil unrest, to permanently damage American trust in government; but as distinct as each event was, they all fractured the same essential faith. We haven’t returned to consistent levels of pre-’70s levels of trust in 40 years, and I doubt this current civic unease will fade much sooner.
This particular horror — Trump and his failures, whatever ridiculous thing he has said or done today, whatever international incident he causes on Twitter tomorrow, however authentic the next panic is — will pass. What will last is the frank revelation of a point that, while ugly and dark, is at least true: You really don’t have the choices you ought to in American democracy, because of decisions made without your consent by people of wealth and power behind closed doors. It’s possible to continue to participate in a democracy after that. But not with a quiet mind.Many have rightfully referenced Orwell's fable Animal Farm as an analogy for the current political situation. In Animal Farm, the men and pigs become indistinguishable. Likewise, as Bruenig points out, Heart of Darkness shows both the demagogue and the a dictator, can achieve similar ends: the destruction of faith in civil institutions.
I have long maintained that Trump and his enablers use Orwell's 1984 as a road map. Yesterday, Trump became a walking caricature of Orwell's Big Brother when he asserted, “Just remember, what you are seeing and what you are reading is not what’s happening, . . . Just stick with us, don’t believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news.” This post is far from the first to point out that Orwell's dystopian state rested on an "essential command": "The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears."
I also wonder if America is approaching the tribalism illustrated in Lord of the Flies where one group rejected the evidence of their eyes and accepts that a pig's head on stick is somehow a talisman able to keep evil at bay. The boys were eventually rescued and novel leaves unanswered what happens when they return to "civilization." Like the questions that arise from the applying the Heart of Darkness to today's politics, this question should also cause disquiet because it implies there may be no true return from a descent into tribalism.
Because novels like Shakespeare's greatest works or ancient Greek tragedies offer questions without pat answers, we should encourage more reading and be more skeptical when a politician tells us "I alone can fix it." That we were not skeptical does not indicate that literature lacks value. Rather, it demonstrates that too few understand the value of the questions literature asks.
Labels:
Literature,
Politics
Monday, July 16, 2018
It's Tough To Make Sense Of The World When People React As If They're In A Comic Book Multiverse
President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin held their summit today. Following their one on one meeting, they held a joint press conference. Reactions to the press conference were fairly uniform. CNN called it "The most shameful, stunning moment of the Trump presidency." Senator John McCain said,
The only analogy I have is the DC Comics multiverse. On one Earth-1, there's the Justice League; Earth-X is populated by evil doppelgangers known as the Crime Syndicate of America. I am not trying to make light of the situation or hype today's events. I am trying to underscore the fact that it seems as if it will soon be impossible for Americans to discuss any event because they they won't be seeing the same facts. The Republic works when people argue interpretations of agreed on facts. I don't know if it works when groups of citizens live in two different universes and refuse to agree on both facts and interpretation.
“No prior president has ever abased himself more abjectly before a tyrant. Not only did President Trump fail to speak the truth about an adversary; but speaking for America to the world, our president failed to defend all that makes us who we are—a republic of free people dedicated to the cause of liberty at home and abroad. American presidents must be the champions of that cause if it is to succeed. Americans are waiting and hoping for President Trump to embrace that sacred responsibility. One can only hope they are not waiting totally in vain.”Even folks who should be reliable Trump supporters like the daughter of the U.S. Ambassador to Russia and a Fox News Anchor are outraged.
CBN's David Brody calls it "plain bad."No negotiation is worth throwing your own people and country under the bus.— Abby Huntsman (@HuntsmanAbby) July 16, 2018
And yet, there is one political group that can praise Trump's performance, the leaders of religious right.Conservatives defending @realDonaldTrump after his press conference w/ Vladimir Putin are not being intellectually honest. It was just plain bad. “Both countries responsible” on election meddling? That’s the moral equivalence stuff they hit @BarackObama on...— David Brody (@TheBrodyFile) July 16, 2018
— Franklin Graham (@Franklin_Graham) July 16, 2018Graham doesn't seem to be alone. As Brody notes, there are other religious conservatives defending Trump's performance.
The only analogy I have is the DC Comics multiverse. On one Earth-1, there's the Justice League; Earth-X is populated by evil doppelgangers known as the Crime Syndicate of America. I am not trying to make light of the situation or hype today's events. I am trying to underscore the fact that it seems as if it will soon be impossible for Americans to discuss any event because they they won't be seeing the same facts. The Republic works when people argue interpretations of agreed on facts. I don't know if it works when groups of citizens live in two different universes and refuse to agree on both facts and interpretation.
Wednesday, July 11, 2018
A Musing About Perspective, Kavanaugh, Summits, And Normality
It may be a week for the history books. On Monday, President Trump nominated Brett Kavanaugh to to be the next justice on the Supreme Court. Today, he's at the NATO Summit, and later this week he'll meet with Russian leader Vladimir Putin.
The following tweets may provide some prospective on Kavanaugh and provide some guidance for what promises to be a week and summer of sturm und drang.
First, there's this portion of a Susan Hennessey thread.
Second, there's this Leon Wood tweet
What's not politically usual, however is a President strongly criticizing allies on the eve of a summit, praising a dictator NATO was designed to confront, and imposing tariffs at a whim. It is also highly unusual to randomly pardon people for arson and occupying government property so soon after they have been sentenced.
I don't know if Republicans in the House and Senate will ever develop a spine let alone the adamantium infused one necessary to confront Trump, a juvenile, stubborn, vile man who has the hubris of a tragic hero. I know the Democrats want to pick up every gauntlet Trump throws down. There may be some political genius who knows how to fight all of these fights at once, but he or she is remaining quiet. Absent expert leadership, it might be best to fight to keep the abnormal from becoming normal and allowing the normal, no matter how bad, to remain a fight for another time.
During this week and the rest of the summer Putin may well back the United States into a corner as the American and world's economies begin a dangerous downward spiral because of Trump's foolish trade war. Returning to normal may not be possible if those events transpire; normality may be possible if the worst event of the summer is Kavanaugh's confirmation.
The following tweets may provide some prospective on Kavanaugh and provide some guidance for what promises to be a week and summer of sturm und drang.
First, there's this portion of a Susan Hennessey thread.
It can be hard for me to disentangle Trump as a true threat to the Republic from the Republican party with which I often strenuously disagree. I try to ask myself what Jeb or Mitt would do. If answer is same, then it’s just politics. /1— Susan Hennessey (@Susan_Hennessey) July 10, 2018
Any ordinary Republican president would be nominating Kavanaugh or Hardiman (or someone similar). Both are decent people who respect the rule of law. Both are significantly right of Kennedy and will reshape the court, I believe for the worse. /2— Susan Hennessey (@Susan_Hennessey) July 10, 2018
I wish a different president were picking someone else. I think what happened to Garland is deeply unjust. But I think it’s worth acknowledging—absurd Trumpian pageantry aside—tonight is politics as usual. /3— Susan Hennessey (@Susan_Hennessey) July 10, 2018
Second, there's this Leon Wood tweet
While Hennessey and Wood disagree about whether Kavanaugh is a good pick, they agree that Trump is a deleterious influence on the Republic. They also agree that Kavanaugh is a pick any Republican President would have made. As Hennessy succinctly puts it, the Kavanaugh nomination "is politics as usual."Any one of the republicans realistically running for president would have made two equally good picks for SCOTUS, without all the crap that makes Trump and Trumpism a cancer. https://t.co/tTYHuZNOHb— Leon Wolf (@LeonHWolf) July 10, 2018
What's not politically usual, however is a President strongly criticizing allies on the eve of a summit, praising a dictator NATO was designed to confront, and imposing tariffs at a whim. It is also highly unusual to randomly pardon people for arson and occupying government property so soon after they have been sentenced.
I don't know if Republicans in the House and Senate will ever develop a spine let alone the adamantium infused one necessary to confront Trump, a juvenile, stubborn, vile man who has the hubris of a tragic hero. I know the Democrats want to pick up every gauntlet Trump throws down. There may be some political genius who knows how to fight all of these fights at once, but he or she is remaining quiet. Absent expert leadership, it might be best to fight to keep the abnormal from becoming normal and allowing the normal, no matter how bad, to remain a fight for another time.
During this week and the rest of the summer Putin may well back the United States into a corner as the American and world's economies begin a dangerous downward spiral because of Trump's foolish trade war. Returning to normal may not be possible if those events transpire; normality may be possible if the worst event of the summer is Kavanaugh's confirmation.
Labels:
#neverTrump,
Politics,
Supreme Court
Monday, July 2, 2018
A Minor Musing About The Absence Of Art In Trump's White House
Over the weekend my long-suffering wife accompanied me to the inaugural St. Louis Pen Show. I met some friendly, helpful vendors, ate some great barbecue, and was taken care of by a kind, soft-spoken waitress at the restaurant in the St. Louis Sheraton Westport Plaza Hotel. I spent too much money and saw a gorgeous scrimshaw pen made by Ryan Krusac. Thankfully, South Dakota's Attorney General Marty Jackley did not station South Dakota Highway Patrol officers at the border to pull us over to ensure we had paid the proper amount of sales tax.
In addition to spending money, I fell further behind on blogging. During a brief hiatus from shopping, I stumbled upon this editorial, "A Cultural Vacuum in Trump's White House." Cory has already made many of the points I wanted to comment on here and here.
Something about the Eggers' editorial and the Krusac pens reminded me of two other reads. The first is this Ross Douthat column in which Douthat opines that a certain "kind of cycle of incomprehension and aggression tends to destroy republics if it isn’t broken, if leaders can’t compromise ideological principles to maintain civic peace, if partisans can’t imagine how the world looks in communities vastly different from their own." He goes on to assert that the nation needs a president "who acts to reassure threatened-feeling out-groups in a way that Obama failed to do and Trump is incapable of even attempting."
The second work is Raymond Chandler's "The Simple Art of Murder," an essay in which Chandler describes a world that is "not. . . very fragrant" before proclaiming that "[i]n everything that can be called art there is a quality of redemption."
The fact that Trump is not capable of attempting to reassure those who feel threatened or that his partisans can't or won't imagine how the world looks to those living in a world that differs from their own may well be that they never seek the cultural redemption that art provides.
In addition to spending money, I fell further behind on blogging. During a brief hiatus from shopping, I stumbled upon this editorial, "A Cultural Vacuum in Trump's White House." Cory has already made many of the points I wanted to comment on here and here.
Something about the Eggers' editorial and the Krusac pens reminded me of two other reads. The first is this Ross Douthat column in which Douthat opines that a certain "kind of cycle of incomprehension and aggression tends to destroy republics if it isn’t broken, if leaders can’t compromise ideological principles to maintain civic peace, if partisans can’t imagine how the world looks in communities vastly different from their own." He goes on to assert that the nation needs a president "who acts to reassure threatened-feeling out-groups in a way that Obama failed to do and Trump is incapable of even attempting."
The second work is Raymond Chandler's "The Simple Art of Murder," an essay in which Chandler describes a world that is "not. . . very fragrant" before proclaiming that "[i]n everything that can be called art there is a quality of redemption."
The fact that Trump is not capable of attempting to reassure those who feel threatened or that his partisans can't or won't imagine how the world looks to those living in a world that differs from their own may well be that they never seek the cultural redemption that art provides.
Labels:
Art,
Literature,
Politics
Saturday, June 2, 2018
When Bad Religion And Bad Politics Meet...
The result is--please forgive the trite phrasing--God Awful!
At about 48 seconds into the video below, Franklin Graham says, "Look for the candidates that best support Biblical principles. That doesn't mean the candidates necessarily live Biblical principles . . ."
Seriously? I must be reading the wrong Bible. For your edification, enrichment, and enjoyment, James 2: 14-26
At about 48 seconds into the video below, Franklin Graham says, "Look for the candidates that best support Biblical principles. That doesn't mean the candidates necessarily live Biblical principles . . ."
Seriously? I must be reading the wrong Bible. For your edification, enrichment, and enjoyment, James 2: 14-26
4 What does it profit, my brethren, if someone says he has faith but does not have works? Can faith save him? 15 If a brother or sister is naked and destitute of daily food, 16 and one of you says to them, “Depart in peace, be warmed and filled,” but you do not give them the things which are needed for the body, what does it profit? 17 Thus also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead.
18 But someone will say, “You have faith, and I have works.” Show me your faith without [a]your works, and I will show you my faith by [b]my works. 19 You believe that there is one God. You do well. Even the demons believe—and tremble! 20 But do you want to know, O foolish man, that faith without works is [c]dead? 21 Was not Abraham our father justified by works when he offered Isaac his son on the altar? 22 Do you see that faith was working together with his works, and by works faith was made [d]perfect? 23 And the Scripture was fulfilled which says, “Abraham believed God, and it was [e]accounted to him for righteousness.” And he was called the friend of God. 24 You see then that a man is justified by works, and not by faith only.
25 Likewise, was not Rahab the harlot also justified by works when she received the messengers and sent them out another way?
26 For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
A Minor Musing About The Last 3 Novels I Taught And Politics
In my excitement to discuss my new party affiliation, I forgot to mention that I have become a retiree. I may pick up a part-time job, but I am pretty sure I have corrected my last high school assignments.
As I was preparing notes about theme and characterization, it struck me how Wuthering Heights published in 1847, Things Fall Apart published in 1958, and All the Pretty Horses published in 1992 help explain the current zeitgeist. None of the musings made it into my lecture notes, but this is a blog not a classroom, so one can express musings that may not be classroom appropriate.
Heathcliff, the brooding protagonist, of Emily Bronte's novel, exclaims, "'I shall not stand to be laughed at. I shall not bear it!' By the novel's conclusion, Heathcliff has caused the death of Hindley, his adopted brother; ruined the life of Edgar, his rival; and indirectly murdered his son by denying him necessary medical care. At the conclusion of his life, Heathcliff says,
My old enemies have not beaten me; now would be the precise time to revenge myself on their representatives: I could do it; and none could hinder me. But where is the use? I don't care for striking: I can't take the trouble to raise my hand! That sounds as if I had been labouring the whole time only to exhibit a fine trait of magnanimity. It is far from being the case: I have lost the faculty of enjoying their destruction, and I am too idle to destroy for nothing.Like Heathcliff the populists who fueled Trump's ascent seem motivated in part by the belief that "coastal elites" frequently disparaged them as denizens of "flyover country." In short, they don't want to be laughed at.
Further, they seem to view the other party as dangerous and a "threat." A 2016 poll found,
For the first time in surveys dating to 1992, majorities in both parties express not just unfavorable but very unfavorable views of the other party. Today, 58% of Republicans have a very unfavorable impression of the Democratic Party, up from 46% in 2014 and just 32% during the 2008 election year. Among Democrats, highly negative views of the GOP have followed a similar trajectory – from 37% in 2008 to 43% in 2014 and 55% currently.
An overwhelming share of those who hold highly negative views of the opposing party say that its policies “are so misguided that they threaten the nation’s well-being.”
Currently, 45% of Republicans view the Democratic Party’s policies as a threat, up from 37% in Pew Research Center’s 2014 study of political polarization. The share of Democrats regarding GOP policies as a threat has risen 10 percentage points (41% now, 31% then).In the current climate, there seem to be enemies aplenty and proposed policies are seen as efficacious if they produce "liberal tears." Had the Bernie Bros been successful, efficacy would likely have been measured in "conservative angst." More importantly, it's unclear if or when the angriest of the populists will lose "the faculty of enjoying . . .destruction" or if they are "too idle to destroy for nothing." If they are not, the 1960s may seem like a time of peace and tranquility.
Like Heathcliff, Okonkwo, the protagonist of Chinua Achebe's Things Fall Apart, had obsessions: Okonkwo's "life was dominated by fear, the fear of failure and weakness." Okonkwo, therefore, "was ruled by one passion--to hate everything his father Unoka had loved. One of those things was gentleness . . ." In 1988, George H. W. Bush sought a "kinder and gentler nation." Given the current state of public discourse, we've lost a lot of ground in the past two decades.
Achebe took the novel's title from William Butler Yeats's poem "The Second Coming." The following lines from the poem need no explication.
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;After having his innocence "drowned" in a series of violent picaresque adventures, John Grady Cole, the protagonist of Cormac McCarthy's All the Pretty Horses, returns home and engages in this brief exchange with his friend Rawlins. Cole begins the conversation,
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
I think I'm goin to move on.Like John Grady Cole, I don't know what "happens to country." I do worry that we are nearing the time when our country be a place where "[t]he best lack all conviction, while the worst [a]re full of passionate intensity." If that event takes place, this won't be anyone's country.
This is still good country.
Yeah. I know it is. But it ain't my country. . . .
Where is your country? he said
I don't know, said John Grady. I don't know where it is. I don't know what happens to country.
Labels:
Literature,
Politics
Tuesday, November 15, 2016
Quotation Of The Day: The Future Of American Evangelicalism Edition
From Alan Jacobs:
There’s a lot of talk about Trump dominating the evangelical vote, but most of the enthusiasm for him came from people who call themselves evangelicals but don’t go to church. Church-going evangelicals stayed home in large numbers. However: people who call themselves evangelicals but don’t go to church are the future of American evangelicalism.
Sunday, August 9, 2015
Tweet And Quotation Of The Day: Reading As Soulcraft Edition
From John Merrow
"I'm not saying you have to be a reader to save your soul in the modern world. I'm saying it helps." Walter Mosley NYT Book Review 8/9/15
— John Merrow (@John_Merrow) August 10, 2015
Mosley's continuation is equally eloquent:
I’m not saying that you have to be a reader to save your soul in the modern world. I’m saying it helps. Artists, musicians, naturally empathetic children and people born to the beat of a different drum often embark on more original lives than the Company Store wants for us. They’re naturally more resistant to the forces of big business and big government.
But readers don’t have to be all that special. They have the guidance of a thousand stories to help them make their way. They are never alone. They are equipped to challenge (or ignore) the expectations laid down by standardized testing, fifth-grade bullies and parents that gaze upon the present-day world with eyes that only see the past. They can envision alternatives to economic and political systems that have no heart, art or true humanity.
Most readers stop here. They gather their ever-widening circle of favorite writers and read and reread their beloved books. But some are compelled to become writers. The stories they were told or read kindle an obsession that cries out to be heard. Like minor gods, they rummage in the mud looking to make characters with whom to explore their dreams, and nightmares.Paragraphs like these also likely explain why politicians like Governor Daugaard seek to ignore literature and focus on STEM.
Labels:
Literature,
Politics,
Reading
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
Some Minor Cynical Musings About The 2016 Presidential Race
First, Ohio Governor John Kasich will become the 16th Republican presidential candidate today, a fact that is basically irrelevant to South Dakota. Granted South Dakota's Republicans will conduct their fantasy politician drafts, create a few office betting pools, and make a few donations to their favorite candidate. South Dakota will, however, support the Republican nominee, whoever that may be, with about 63% of the vote.
Second, Hillary Clinton is the prohibitive favorite to win the Democratic nomination. To win the presidency, however, she faces several, for lack of a better phrase, demographic obstacles.
In my cynical moments, I wonder if the American electorate is willing to elect the nation's first female president immediately after electing the first African American president. Further, since 1952, there has been only one time when a two-term president was succeeded by a member of his party.
Finally, Hillary Clinton is nearly 14 years older than Barack Obama. The last time Americans elected new president of the same party who was that much older than the predecessor was prior to the Civil War when James Buchanan replaced Franklin Pierce. Both were Democrats. Since then, when Americans have elected someone more than a decade older than the previous president, the new president has been of a different party. By the way, Democrats who support Bernie Sanders need to remember that he is six years older than Hillary Clinton.
Labels:
2016,
Minor Musings,
Politics,
South Dakota Politics
Tuesday, August 19, 2014
South Dakota Has Turned A Deeper Shade Of Republican Red Over The Past 20 Years
IO9.com, one of my favorite sources of sci-fi and superhero geekery, posts this animated gif showing political polarization. In particular, the middle of the country seems to be turning a deeper shade of red. South Dakotans probably didn't need to see this gif to discern that fact.
Although red seems to be expanding geographically, one needs to remember that the major population centers are blue.
For South Dakota's Democrats, it seems to show a trend that will be difficult to overcome. Certainly, the normal political combination of message and smart candidates not seems as if it will not be enough.to overcome the past 20 years.
Although red seems to be expanding geographically, one needs to remember that the major population centers are blue.
For South Dakota's Democrats, it seems to show a trend that will be difficult to overcome. Certainly, the normal political combination of message and smart candidates not seems as if it will not be enough.to overcome the past 20 years.
![]() |
| Political Polarization From Washington Post Originally |
Labels:
Demographics,
Politics
Friday, August 8, 2014
Quotations Of The Day: Ebola and Electrocution Edition
Raw Story reports that a radio talk show host wants people who do things he doesn't like or believe things he doesn't believe to contract the Ebola virus
A Christian radio host who enthusiastically looks for signs the world will end welcomed the Ebola virus as a cleansing force.
“This Ebola epidemic could become a global pandemic and that’s another name for plague,” said broadcaster Rick Wiles on his “Trunews” program.
“It may be the great attitude adjustment that I believe is coming,” Wiles continued. “Ebola could solve America’s problems with atheism, homosexuality, sexual promiscuity, pornography, and abortion.”Meanwhile, Charlie Brown, who is the Democratic candidate for governor of Tennessee and who may very well be a blockhead, wants to electrocute the incumbent Republican.
But if Brown were just some random guy who paid the filing fee and happened to win, we wouldn't be writing this. No, rather it seems what little we know about Brown's platform includes his desire to electrocute the man he's facing off against in November.
Here's a screenshot of what Brown apparently submitted to the Blount County Democratic Party in lieu of a candidate questionnaire. You'll notice toward the top, Brown says he would like to sit Gov. Bill Haslam (R) in an electric chair and give him "half the jolt."
Labels:
Politics,
Quotation of the Day
Saturday, August 2, 2014
Why Don't South Dakota Television News Personalities Do Something Like This When Political Leaders Mess Up?
I hope that before I die I will have the opportunity to see one, just one, South Dakota television news reader expose a South Dakota politician the way Olbermann illustrates the inadequacies of Roger Goodell's two game suspension of Ray Rice after Rice knocked out his fiance and dragged her from an elevator.
Thursday, July 17, 2014
Will Republicans Give A Warm Fuzzy To An Atheist Who Drinks Welch's?
Scoff if you will, but the question posed in this post's title may decide how every political question is answered during the next year.
These two totally different surveys do point to a way out of gridlock. To the best of my knowledge there are no avowed atheists or Muslims in the Republican leadership. President Obama is a Christian. If the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives and the President would all go to Home Depot, stock their carts with everyone's favorite tools, bleach, and dish soap, go to the checkout lane staffed by a Hindu clerk, and then break open a communal box of Cheerios, some issues might not seem so intractable.
I suspect, however, the political atmosphere has become so noxious that the politicians would soon begin to argue about who had purchased the biggest hammer and whether skim milk is un-American.
Bonus charts for visual learners.
According to a recent Pew Research poll, Jews, Catholics and Evangelicals earn warm rankings from Americans.
Jews, Catholics and evangelical Christians are viewed warmly by the American public. When asked to rate each group on a “feeling thermometer” ranging from 0 to 100 – where 0 reflects the coldest, most negative possible rating and 100 the warmest, most positive rating – all three groups receive an average rating of 60 or higher (63 for Jews, 62 for Catholics and 61 for evangelical Christians). And 44% of the public rates all three groups in the warmest part of the scale (67 or higher).Hindus and Buddhists are viewed neutrally, but atheists and Muslims don't fare as well.
The public views atheists and Muslims more coldly; atheists receive an average rating of 41, and Muslims an average rating of 40. Fully 41% of the public rates Muslims in the coldest part of the thermometer (33 or below), and 40% rate atheists in the coldest part.Meanwhile, BrandIndex finds that Americans are united by an inexplicable common affection for some popular brands.
The brands that feature in the top ten for all three political affiliations seem mostly to relate to house and home. Craftsman, Clorox, Dawn, Johnson and Johnson, Home Depot and Cheerios appear in all three lists as well as online mega-retailer Amazon. Home Depot was a new entry for all three lists.The BrandIndex report, however, shows that Democrats are alone in having Google, PBS, and Dove as part of their top 10 brands. Independents are alone in their top 10 love for the Discovery Channel while Republicans are alone in their newly discovered top 10 taste for Welch's. (It is a positive sign for the American Republic that Fox News has dropped out the Republican top 10.)
These two totally different surveys do point to a way out of gridlock. To the best of my knowledge there are no avowed atheists or Muslims in the Republican leadership. President Obama is a Christian. If the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives and the President would all go to Home Depot, stock their carts with everyone's favorite tools, bleach, and dish soap, go to the checkout lane staffed by a Hindu clerk, and then break open a communal box of Cheerios, some issues might not seem so intractable.
I suspect, however, the political atmosphere has become so noxious that the politicians would soon begin to argue about who had purchased the biggest hammer and whether skim milk is un-American.
Bonus charts for visual learners.
![]() |
| Original Found Here |
![]() |
| Original Found Here |
Labels:
America Divided,
Politics,
Religion
Saturday, May 31, 2014
Quotation Of The Day: How The Ultra Rich Are Changing Politics Edition
Politico reporter Kenneth Vogel infiltrates a Koch brothers event and offers this summation:
[The event] was a snapshot of an extraordinary shift: the reordering of the political system by an elite fraternity of the superrich and a small brain trust of consultants who cater to them. Starting in 2010, a few dozen of the wealthiest donors turned on a gusher of mega-checks that have made them more important than the thousands of grassroots activists, small individual donors and even party leaders put together. Together, these donors have injected into campaigns sums that were once unimaginable, even as recently as the 2008 presidential election.
Intentionally or not, this new system has eroded the power of the official parties that have rigidly controlled modern politics for decades by doling out or withholding pork-barrel spending earmarks and campaign cash. Suddenly, party leaders have none of the former to offer (the result of symbolic belt-tightening reforms), and far less of the latter than big donors operating outside the party system. The result—the one Obama lamented on that rainy day in Washington state—is the privatization of a system that we’d always thought of as public. It amounts to the takeover—hostile or not—of American politics by the ultra-rich.
Labels:
Politics,
Quotation of the Day,
the rich
Tuesday, March 25, 2014
What Happens If Nate Silver Is Correct?
Over the weekend Nate Silver, a statistician who has taken on Delphic significance in the political world, launched the political page on his 538 blog with the announcement that the Republicans are slight favorites to take the United States Senate. On ABC's This Week, Silver gave the Republicans a chance to pick up 11 seats.
Locally, the statistically minded Messrs Montgomery and Heidelberger have given their takes. Nationally Republicans have a new found respect for Silver whereas Democrats are suddenly challenging his statistical acumen.
I have seen little speculation about what happens if Silver is correct and Republicans get 52 or 54 Senate seats and keep the House. I'll go out on a limb with a single word: impeachment.
I have two likely scenarios. In one, the fire-breathers in the House will scream Benghazi and cover-up, IRS harassment and cover-up, executive orders were issued that we didn't like and cover-up, "we didn't get Clinton" and cover-up.
The other scenario involves a long game. Republicans will have repeated successful votes to repeal Obamacare followed by repeated vetoes. (There will be a few filibusters in the Senate, those efforts will not be serious because the Obama holds the veto pen.) Republicans will then attach repeal to a debt ceiling vote; Obama will invoke the full faith and credit clause, and Republicans will impeach.
I know Rush Limbaugh says impeachment will never happen, but that proclamation is issues in the form of a challenge; Republicans according to Limbaugh lack "political will." even as everything gets "screwed-up." There are too many safe blood-red districts. There is also an understanding, even among those who would rather breathe fire than think, that demographics and the electoral map favors Democrats or at least a Republican far too moderate for their tastes. Besides, impeachment will be much easier that trying to think up policy solutions.
Locally, the statistically minded Messrs Montgomery and Heidelberger have given their takes. Nationally Republicans have a new found respect for Silver whereas Democrats are suddenly challenging his statistical acumen.
I have seen little speculation about what happens if Silver is correct and Republicans get 52 or 54 Senate seats and keep the House. I'll go out on a limb with a single word: impeachment.
I have two likely scenarios. In one, the fire-breathers in the House will scream Benghazi and cover-up, IRS harassment and cover-up, executive orders were issued that we didn't like and cover-up, "we didn't get Clinton" and cover-up.
The other scenario involves a long game. Republicans will have repeated successful votes to repeal Obamacare followed by repeated vetoes. (There will be a few filibusters in the Senate, those efforts will not be serious because the Obama holds the veto pen.) Republicans will then attach repeal to a debt ceiling vote; Obama will invoke the full faith and credit clause, and Republicans will impeach.
I know Rush Limbaugh says impeachment will never happen, but that proclamation is issues in the form of a challenge; Republicans according to Limbaugh lack "political will." even as everything gets "screwed-up." There are too many safe blood-red districts. There is also an understanding, even among those who would rather breathe fire than think, that demographics and the electoral map favors Democrats or at least a Republican far too moderate for their tastes. Besides, impeachment will be much easier that trying to think up policy solutions.
Labels:
Politics
Tuesday, March 18, 2014
Quotation Of The Day: Christians And Politics Edition
Pascal-Emmanuel Gobrey succinctly points out something I have believed for a long time.
Because if you believe that the person of Jesus Christ is "the Truth," then the corollary that logically follows is that everything that is not Jesus Christ is not "the Truth."
To put it more practically: To be a Christian is to believe that all political ideologies are suspect. And wrong. It doesn't mean that Christians should retreat from all political ideologies — as that would also be a political ideology, and also wrong. By all means, be a Christian liberal. Be a Christian conservative. But if you are a Christian liberal, if you are a Christian conservative, then by definition there will be tensions between your Christianity and your political ideology. It's axiomatic. And if you are a Christian first and an ideologue second, you should confront those tensions instead of papering over them.
Let's take my own tent of Christian conservatism, since this is about us.
Yes, it is absolutely possible to be a Christian and believe that limited government and free markets are the best ways to advance the prospects of the poor. But when conservatives portray the poor as moochers and divide the world into "Makers" and "Takers," and hold up those "Takers" quite clearly as objects of contempt, the Christian has to recoil. And not just recoil, but cry injustice.
Labels:
Christianity,
Politics,
Quotation of the Day
Wednesday, January 1, 2014
Booze As Politics
Those reaching for a bit of hair of the dog this morning will probably reveal their political leanings. Someone reaching for Wild Turkey likely leans Republican; someone who leans Democrat may be looking for Absolut. The Washington Post provides the following useful chart.
Labels:
Is it Weird Enough?,
Politics
Tuesday, October 22, 2013
Let's Stop Playing What's The Politician's Faith?
Via Madville, I see that Reverend Hickey unable to "detect" any "evidence" of President Obama's "Christian faith." I have no idea whether Reverend Hickey claims to possess the gift of discernment or how one discerns the sincerity of the faith of a politician one has never met.
I can remember more than a few good Christian folk who were upset that Jimmy Carter lusted in his heart and had an evening glass of scotch even though he taught Sunday school. Many of those same folks loved Ronald Reagan who rarely darkened a church door.
Bill Clinton broke both the adultery and false witness commandments. The second Bush took the nation to war under dubious pretenses. Obama is far from perfect, but I haven't seen any evidence of his committing similar, shall we agree to call them, errors.
I didn't vote for Obama in 2012; I haven't been satisfied with a President since Eisenhower, and I was three when he left office. I'm, therefore, not going to trust my personal memory on his second term.
From my displaced point of view, it seems that one's view of a public figure's faith is colored not by the public figure's faith and works but by beholder's political views.
When I was a young'un my mother used to read me the story of Samuel coming to Jesse to anoint one of Jesse's sons the new king of Israel. That son was the future King David who at the time was a runty, ruddy youth. The key verse of the story was I Samuel 16:7
I can remember more than a few good Christian folk who were upset that Jimmy Carter lusted in his heart and had an evening glass of scotch even though he taught Sunday school. Many of those same folks loved Ronald Reagan who rarely darkened a church door.
Bill Clinton broke both the adultery and false witness commandments. The second Bush took the nation to war under dubious pretenses. Obama is far from perfect, but I haven't seen any evidence of his committing similar, shall we agree to call them, errors.
I didn't vote for Obama in 2012; I haven't been satisfied with a President since Eisenhower, and I was three when he left office. I'm, therefore, not going to trust my personal memory on his second term.
From my displaced point of view, it seems that one's view of a public figure's faith is colored not by the public figure's faith and works but by beholder's political views.
When I was a young'un my mother used to read me the story of Samuel coming to Jesse to anoint one of Jesse's sons the new king of Israel. That son was the future King David who at the time was a runty, ruddy youth. The key verse of the story was I Samuel 16:7
But the Lord said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature; because I have refused him: for the Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the Lord looketh on the heart.I'm fairly certain that no human can can see another's heart. Perhaps, it would serve us all to refrain from commenting on the faith of public figures be they Presidents, U.S. Senators, or Popes. Those comments reveal more about the speaker than the public figure, and they rarely reflect well on the speaker.
Labels:
Faith,
Political Labels,
Politics
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.gif)



