Showing posts with label South Dakota Blogosphere. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Dakota Blogosphere. Show all posts

Thursday, January 3, 2019

A Musing About State Senator Stace Nelson's Wall Resolution, Facts, Lies, Truth, And Politics


I thought of Moynihan this morning when I read this Stace Nelson's comment on Dakota Free Press.
35+ posts of personal attacks and absolute rubbish with not one intelligent comment about the actual bill. Who does that? The Trump Derangement Syndrome is alive and well. Ranting and raving and not one of you have read the actual bill.. If you can’t debate the issues? Make things up and lie, lie, lie.
Nelson's outburst was in response to comments about his proposed resolution supporting Trump's border wall. His comment also contains a draft of his own resolution. My comment which contained a link to a Washington Post article and used numbers that come from various media sources was apparently one of those pieces of "rubbish."

Perhaps I am being nostalgic and naive, but the Moynihan assertion was made a time when people agreed what the facts were and political arguments were about the implications of those facts. Granted, I can't remember a time in my life when someone didn't mutter something about lies, damned lies and statistics or utter the phrase "figures don't lie, but liars sure do figure." Even with those caveats, it seems that people used to agreed about what the facts were. The political arguments were about the best way to deal with those facts.

In 2019 no one seems willing to agree what the facts are. I believe that Trump has said 3924 false things as president as of this writing. Based on his comment cited above, Nelson may accuse me of having Trump Derangement Syndrome. Nelson's proposed resolution contains a copious amount of numbers, many of which Nelson claims he found in congressional records. I recognize some of them as numbers originating from sources that I believe to be biased. As I did at Dakota Free Press, I will point out that Trump seems to have made up the number about the cost of illegal immigration. Many supporters of the wall will claim the article is an example of mainstream media bias.

A few years back, Chris Mooney wrote an article "The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science." These conclusions seem relevant to the point at hand.

In other words, people rejected the validity of a scientific source because its conclusion contradicted their deeply held views. . . . The study subjects weren’t “anti-science”—not in their own minds, anyway. It’s just that “science” was whatever they wanted it to be. “We’ve come to a misadventure, a bad situation where diverse citizens, who rely on diverse systems of cultural certification, are in conflict,” says Kahan. 

And that undercuts the standard notion that the way to persuade people is via evidence and argument. In fact, head-on attempts to persuade can sometimes trigger a backfire effect, where people not only fail to change their minds when confronted with the facts—they may hold their wrong views more tenaciously than ever.

Were this post a high schooler's original oratory, I would expect a solution at this point in the composition. I don't have one. I'm going to try to approach issues like I approached judging a debate round and look for the best evidence and the best arguments. Nelson and other supporters of Trump's wall will likely claim they're doing the same thing.

If we can't agree about facts and Mooney is correct that evidence and argument only cause people to hold their views more firmly, the political climate will get more charged and angry. To apply an overused Thomas Hobbes statement, it will be nasty and brutish, a war of everyone against everyone. Welcome to post-truth America.

Wednesday, July 18, 2018

Are South Dakota's Republican Leaders Running A Caucus, A Kids Club, Or A Cult?

Dakota Free Press, Dakota War College, and Right Side South Dakota all cover a letter Republican cause leaders sent to Republican legislative candidates. (Given how Blogger seems to load slowly, I am not going to paste images of the letter which one can find at all three sites.)

I really don't know if the letter is recruiting people to a meeting to indoctrinate them into a cult or is an adult version of "Do you like me? Please check yes or no."

The letter begins, "As we just celebrated the birthday of our great country, we take time to pause and reflect how important it is for our great state of South Dakota to have a strong and united  Republican caucus. We have all agreed and wish to share the following points . . . "

Translation: We're the cool kids and we want you to be cool kids to. Nothing cool has happened without us. If you want to be a cool kid, we have decided you have to do everything we say.

Later, the letter says , "All members will be expected to maintain the highest degree of confidentiality within the caucus."

Translation: Don't tell anyone our secret passwords or show anyone our secret handshake. Whatever you do, don't mention that thing with the pocketknife and candle! (I'll leave the rant about transparency for another post.)

The letter continues, "History dictates that members of the Senate and House Republican Majority Caucuses, respectively, have been considered and assigned for positions of chair and vice chair of committees.  Members of minority caucuses are not considered for these positions."

Translation: Did we tell you we're the cool kids? Yeah, just remember, we're really freakin' cool!

Later, the caucus leaders pour on the charm: "We consider the Senate and House Republican Majority Caucuses to be a family of Republicans working together to ensure that conservative Republican principles are protected and preserved in South Dakota."

Translation: We love you. You need our love to be whole. We'll be just like mommy and daddy but without the vegetables. If you accept our love everything will be great all over. Remember, mommy and daddy make you eat yucky stuff, but we love you.

The charm ends with the next sentence, however. "Therefore it requires you to be a sole member of the Senate or House Republican Majority Cause, respectively.

Translation: We have the only good ideas and a monopoly on all that is right. We're like that Joshua guy in the Bible, and you have to choose us or nothing. Remember we're on the side of freedom and good stuff. Also, you won't be one of the cool kids if talk to anyone isn't one of us.

I would prefer my legislators to be adults who are able to think independently not members of a kids club or a cult. Republican leaders, however, seem to value conformity, secrecy, and a forced show of unity.

Saturday, July 14, 2018

And The Dog Whistles Yet Remain

According to the counter on my sidebar, I have written more posts in June and July than I did in the years 2016 and 2017 combined.  I should match my 2015 yearly total in a few days.

Honesty compels me to admit that in addition to not writing posts, I didn't read South Dakota blogs as much as I should have the past few years. That lack of reading was especially pronounced from October through March and during May and June when debate season or nationals preparation was in full swing. There was not enough caffeine in the world to provide enough energy to get me past teaching and coaching.

While reacquainting myself with the South Dakota blogosphere, I've learned Bob Ellis has stopped blogging, seen that Sibby is still obsessed with Cory Heidelberger but hasn't posted anything in a few months, and noticed what I believe is a decrease in the number of regular commenters on Dakota War College and Dakota Free Press. The latter observation may be a function of age and not actually be fact.

On Right Side South Dakota, however, Brad Ford remains unchanged. He still tosses out dog whistles like this insinuation that, despite libraries worth of evidence to the contrary, slaves must have been well cared for.
The family’s workhorse (“Old Doc”) seems to symbolize the difference between then and now.  Cash outlay was minimal over the 34 years of the horse’s life.  Food was free from the harvests. There were no veterinary bills or insurance policies needed:  “Since the horses had the hard work to do, and would as busy as the men all summer, simple wisdom demanded that they be treated considerately.  During the first week or so of plowing days they were permitted to stop for frequent rests, because their muscles were soft from the comparative idleness of winter. On warm days, when their breathing become fast, the plow was stopped to allow them to cool off.” 
Of course, farmers today are just as motivated to care for their expensive machinery to prevent breakdowns.  It seems just as likely that plantation farmers in the Old South would have done likewise.  McMillen suggests that such practicality is built right into the natural order: “The cow permits herself to be milked, and the sheep yields up her wool.  The horse, despite his great strength, stupidly lets man make him into a slave laborer” in exchange for ample food, comfortable housing, and parent-like care. [emphasis mine]
Ford's ignoring the horrors of slavery are bad enough, but the paragraph's structure and the placing of the quotation not only furthers the idea that "plantation owners in the Old South" not only provided "ample food, comfortable housing, and parent-like care" but also that slave labor is part of "the natural order." More importantly, Ford's placement of the quotation likens humans to horses and impugns the intelligence of a whole race.

Perhaps the South Dakota blogosphere made the collective decision to ignore Ford while I wasn't looking. Perhaps I should ignore him too. That decision would certainly keep my blood pressure in check. I retain, however, a silly notion that humans are created equal and that it might be better for the world if one points out that no natural order exists where humans should be treated like animals.

Friday, July 13, 2018

The Blogger Doth Protest Too Much Methinks

It likely reflects poorly on my character that I enjoy using literary allusions to refer to everyday occurrences. In the case, this post's title refers to the fact that South Dakota War College has posted at least  6 posts referencing the fact that the Democrats must reconvene in August to properly certify their candidates for constitutional offices in South Dakota.

Were I a Republican insider, I would chortle a bit at a major unforced error. I don't believe that this incident is worth six posts worth of pointing and giggling. Further, Dakota War College's latest post, implies that Republicans presented Democrats with a gift and states that "Democrats should be thanking the GOP" for pointing out the error "in the interest of transparency."

Transparency is not a term I would use to describe a party that dominates the legislature but keeps its caucus closed. Also, I have never associated the South Dakota Republicans with benevolence. If anything, they are ruthlessly efficient.

That nature reminds me of a few classics, chiefly The Iliad which features the ruthlessly efficient killing machine Achilles and The Aeneid which contains the story of the Trojan Horse. South Dakota Democrats would do well to remember one of the key lines from The Aeneid, "I fear the Greeks even when they bring gifts." This "gift," like that famous giant wooden horse may not be given with good intent and Democrats should exercise due caution.

Preparing For Our Robot Overlords

I may be committing nostalgia without a licence but I seem to remember a distant golden age of blogging when bloggers used some of their posts to engage in conversation that involved agreement or disagreement but not sniping. This morning Cory at Dakota Free Press was kind enough to mention this post about AI and truth and elaborate on his efforts at "preparation for and resistance to robopropaganda" His list includes not allowing anonymous comments and a healthy dose of Asimov.

I'd like to add four other preparations as we await the coming of our robot overlords

1. Read books.

2. Read old books. I'll defer to C.S. Lewis for rationale.

It is a good rule, after reading a new book, never to allow yourself another new one till you have read an old one in between. If that is too much for you, you should at least read one old one to every three new ones. 

Every age has its own outlook. It is specially good at seeing certain truths and specially liable to make certain mistakes. We all, therefore, need the books that will correct the characteristic mistakes of our own period. And that means the old books. 

All contemporary writers share to some extent the contemporary outlook—even those, like myself, who seem most opposed to it. Nothing strikes me more when I read the controversies of past ages than the fact that both sides were usually assuming without question a good deal which we should now absolutely deny. They thought that they were as completely opposed as two sides could be, but in fact they were all the time secretly united—united with each other and against earlier and later ages—by a great mass of common assumptions.

3. Memorize Orwell's "Politics and the English Language." 

4. Finally, just think. Heck, that advice is even in the Bible.
Finally, brethren, whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report; if there be any virtue, and if there be any praise, think on these things.
 
 

Sunday, July 8, 2018

Some Musings About Guns, Unlocked Cars, And Responsibility

A quick search of the blog will find posts opposing South Dakota's school sentinel plan, musings about guns being a fetish, and implications, if not direct statements, that the nation has too many guns.

I haven't changed any of those opinions during the past few years when this blog was relatively dormant. The best case scenario for a school sentinel involves gunshot wounds with nary a tourniquet in sight. I continue to be befuddled by straight white males whose fetishes involve guns rather than a red-headed dominatrix. The United States has at least 265 million guns, more than enough for every adult to own one.

I try to understand other viewpoints. Many of the everyday carry gear folk that I follow on YouTube do gun videos. A few months ago, after one the mass shootings, YouTube began limiting some gun content. One of the people I follow, The Last Boy Scout, published this short video in response:



At about 31 seconds in, Lane says, "I don't carry a gun because I hate the government. I carry a gun because governing myself is my first responsibility." At 53 seconds in he says, "I don't carry a gun to feel like a man. I carry a gun because I am a man and because men take care of themselves and the people they love." Finally, at 1:10, he concludes, "I don't carry a gun because I love guns; I carry a gun because I love life, and I love the people who make my life worth living."

In short, the video asserts that people carry guns because it's the responsible thing to do.

I thought about this video a few weeks ago when Dakota War College took issue with a proposed Sioux Falls City ordinance designed to "penalize gun owners who don't keep their firearms locked up." I was reminded of it again when reading this South DaCola post. 

South DaCola links to this Keloland report that quotes Minnehaha County Sheriff Mike Milstead:
"You know, because you would be taking legit, lawful gun owners and making them criminals because we're trying to prevent other criminals from stealing their guns. I hate to make lawful gun owners into criminals," said Milstead.  
Milstead says he would much prefer gun owners just do what they're supposed to; which is lock up the dangerous weapon they don't want being used to hurt others. 
"You'd feel horrible if your gun was stolen out of your car, where you'd left it unlocked. And ultimately it ends up being used by somebody to kill somebody, to rob somebody, to commit a violent crime," said Milstead.
Logic would dictate that loving "the people who make make . . . life worth living," "taking care of themselves and the people they love," and accepting that "governing myself is my first responsibility" implies locking up guns safely when the weapons are not in use. And yet, if gun owners fail to fulfill their responsibility, the only recourse their fellow citizens have is to hope the irresponsible party feels "horrible" if the gun is "stolen from an unlocked car" and "ultimately it ends up being used by somebody to kill somebody, to rob somebody, to commit a violent crime."

"Feeling horrible" is an emotion that ought to accompany accidentally spilling a glass of red wine on a woman's white dress. In that situation, the emotion should be accompanied by the responsible action of paying to clean or replace the dress. Making it easier to "kill somebody, to rob somebody, [and] to commit a violent crime" should have a  consequence beyond one that comes with ruining a dress, but apparently in South Dakota, gun ownership is only about rights not responsibility.

Thursday, July 5, 2018

South Dakota Republican Blog Tells South Dakota Democratic Party Executive Director That It's Not Ok To Sound Like Trump

South Dakota War College takes issue with South Dakota Democratic Party Executive Director Sam Parkinson's Fourth of July tweet in which Parkinson writes that July 4th commemorates "the fact that a bunch of slave-owning aristocratic white males did'nt [sic] want to pay their taxes."

The tweet is a reminder to the young'uns that even if one's account is "protected," as Parkinson's is, social media means that nothing is private. It may also be the case that the situation should remind the young'uns that beer and irony rarely mix well.

That said, I thought Republicans were past considering criticisms of the country as signs of unpatriotic activity. Just last year, President Trump had the following exchange with Bill O'Reilly.
O'Reilly pressed Trump on his statement, saying, "But he's a killer though. Putin's a killer." 
"There are a lot of killers. We've got a lot of killers. What, you think our country is so innocent?" Trump responded.



I don't know how one wins a debate affirming Resolved: Being a nation with a lot of killers is better than being a nation founded by slave-owners. Heck, I'm not sure one can win on the negative either. Perhaps, the young'uns should be cut some slack when their elders can't control their tongues.

Saturday, June 9, 2018

When Blog Comments Meet Hollywood

Over at Dakota Free Press, one Cory's one of his frequent interlocutors has taken to making numerous comments that follow the same theme.
It doesn’t matter. So long as the democrats align themselves with change the constitution, baby killing, open borders, islamist worshiping, MS-13 honoring, drug riddled, spies in the presidential election, raise the taxes, forced health insurance, IRS prosecuting conservatives and russian colluding left they do not have a chance.Listen to what I am telling you: . . . You are being ANTI-CULTURE against your neighbors who will not vote to destroy their way of life. . . .  . .” 
In another comment, he expresses the idea that women need protection because they are "venerable."
. . . They are animals and you know he was speaking specifically about the members of MS-13. . . . You don’t care . . .  any . . . woman nor do you care if they had any rights at all. It’s an act. I’ve seen it a thousand times. A male claims to support women’s rights. Acts as if he is in support of the feminist movement. Attends the rally, events and protests and then when the unsuspecting woman is venerable they strike. It’s been all over the news lately and in almost every case it is an ugly male, in poor physical condition, normally a loner. . . . 
It's probably just me, but these sorts of pronouncements always remind me of this speech from the Coen brother's classic O Brother Where Art Thou?. (If this doesn't post properly, the speech begins about 50 seconds in and ends at about 1:54)


Thursday, July 9, 2015

South Dakota Politics And Debate Camp: I Love It When A Plan Comes Together

Via Mr. Heidelberger, I note that the ACLU has challenged Attorney General Marty Jackley on his assertion that county clerks could refuse to issue marriage licences to same sex couples if the official's conscience or religious convictions so dictated, the recent Obergefell decision not withstanding. Jackley, who will almost certainly run for governor in 2018, likely anticipated this challenge and is probably planning campaign commercials  touting his quixotic effort, alleging that it was thwarted by a leftist, liberal, progressive, socialist, cabal of atheistic lawyers. (I hope I didn't leave out any current dog whistles.)

Meanwhile, at debate camp in beautiful Brookings, South Dakota, the young Lincoln-Douglas debaters are preparing cases on Resolved: In the United States criminal justice system, jury nullification ought to be used in the face of perceived injustice. The cynic in me wonders if Jackley will now appeal to the South Dakota Republicans of a more libertarian bent and advocate that juries be informed that they are judges of both the law and fact, at least in court cases involving weddings.

In other political news, Reverend Steve Hickey has announced he will be leaving the legislature and his pulpit to "study Christian ethics with an emphasis on surveillance in the modern world in the Bonhoeffer Studies program at the University of Aberdeen." In a serendipitous coincidence, the policy debaters are preparing to spend the next season debating Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially curtail its domestic surveillance.  My knowledge of Bonhoeffer is limited to knowing that he prophetically spoke against "cheap grace." If Reverend Hickey stumbles upon this blog, my students and I would appreciate his forwarding any reading lists about both Bonhoeffer and surveillance.

Finally, in one other debate camp and politics connection, I notice that Cory has created a debate tournament for the Republican Presidential candidates. I look forward to his format for quarters, semis, and finals.

Saturday, January 3, 2015

Quotation Of The Day: Courage In The Political Lions' Den Edition

From Representive Reverend Steve Hickey in the comments section at Dakota War College:
We blew through our 125th anniversary year with no acknowledgement that 10% of our population resents we are even here. It’s not okay native families are struggling in third world conditions within a couple hundred miles of our hundred million dollar sportsplexes and entertainment centers. It’s not okay native kids are killing themselves. If a similar suicide rate was for white kids it’d be front page news. A 15 year old native girl in our state hung her self in her own home and no one even noticed for two weeks. Spare me the decades old excuses why these are their problems not ours. Time for a South African style truth and reconciliation to commission lead the way out of the past into the future. We brag about our low unemployment rate but ignore it nearly triples when natives are factored in. It’s not okay we have states attorneys who brag openly how many natives they’ve put on the hill. We create criminals and then wonder why there are more of them.

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Wars And Rumors Of Wars: It's Still The Economy

I've just finished teaching a short Norse myth unit. Ragnarok is fresh on my mind. Coincidentally, PNR has an interesting post contending that Obama's foreign policy ensures a 21st Century World War. I have little doubt that there will be another war before my 80th birthday. Laying the blame on Obama's foreign policy which, by and large, is a continuation of the policies of previous administrations means that one should also blame every post Cold War President including Bush I, Bush II, and Clinton.

The reason for war will not be foreign policy. Writing a short post for The Week, William Falk sums it up well:
Wage stagnation — and the resulting erosion of the middle class — is this country's biggest problem. When hard work no longer produces upward mobility for workers who lack elite skills, America's implicit promise is broken. At National Review, conservative Maggie Gallagher complains that "for more than a decade Americans have been losing ground financially, and the GOP has yet to address the issue." In The Washington Post, liberal Harold Meyerson grouses that "the Democrats have had precious little to say about how to re-create…widely shared prosperity." Perhaps that's because the standard liberal and conservative nostrums (Tax the rich! Eliminate regulations!) won't address the fundamental problem: Globalization and technology have devalued both labor and workers, and made companies more ruthlessly competitive. Here's a scary thought: Neither party is offering a remedy because there isn't one.
When hard work produces disillusionment not advancement, governments will distract the populace with foreign adventures. Given that nations' economies are becoming entwined in a Gordian Knot, the distraction will be monstrous.

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

The First C Of Political Survival: Campaign

I have become quite fascinated with the 5 Cs of survival: cutting tool, cover, container, cordage, and combustion. The idea of 5 alliterative essentials is an excellent mnemonic device and, dare I say, a workable organizing principle.

It with that spirit in mind that I offer Democrats the first C of political survival, campaign.

Professor Jon Schaff believes "Weiland has run an almost perfect campaign," and "Rounds is in trouble." I agree with Schaff that Rounds is merely bruised not bloodied. Further, in blood red South Dakota, Weiland needs a knockout not merely a knockdown to win. Those caveats aside, Weiland still has a chance because he is running a campaign.

It is difficult to imagine every Democrat running for statewide office having the energy to do Weiland's statewide tours. In addition Rounds may have bigger flaws and have more negative baggage than most other Republicans seeking statewide office. That said, Susan Wismer's campaign has provoked skirmishes but falls far short of full scale political guerrilla warfare necessary to win. There's little evidence than any other Democrats are running for statewide office.

Campaigns matter and only one Democrat running statewide seems to be running a complete one.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

I Left For A Week And Nothing Changed

I had to take a week to learn more about oceans for the policy debate topic, read Things Fall Apart as a teacher rather than a reader, survive homecoming activities and few other real life nuisances, so I maintained blog absence for most of the past week.

I was worried that I may have missed something, but a quick scan of Madville Times shows that Democrats are still trying to hang the EB-5 albatross around Mike Rounds neck. Meanwhile, Dakota War College continues it efforts to show Democrats to be incompetent or duplicitous or both.

Other stories of interest remained stable Attorney General candidate Chad Haber still does weird stuff and Brad Ford continues to write the weirdest posts in the South Dakota blogosphere. Oh yeah, South Dakota teacher pay is still the worst in the nation.

Regular blogging here will hopefully soon resume

Monday, August 18, 2014

A Musing About The Minor But Predictable Gordon Howie Civil Unions (Or Not) Imbroglio

On Saturday, Pat Powers published two posts about United States Senate candidate Gordon Howie's views on same-gender marriage. In the first post, he does his best to place Mike Rounds, Powers's preferred candidate, to Howie's right.
"Apparently Gordon Howie is closer to RIck Weiland and Larry Pressler on the issue of gay marriage than Mike Rounds."
Getting to Howie's right on anything requires political maneuvering that, were it a military effort, would require the combined military genius of Sun Tzu, Alexander the Great, Napoleon, and George Patton. As a political matter, one should question the efficacy of attempting to move to Howie's right, but that's a subject for a different post.

Perpetually angry Bob Ellis gave his obligatory angry retort: the "liberal media" and RINOs have written "defamation articles" "to distort what they hate," which involves marriage, family, and apparently, although Ellis doesn't write about them in the post, puppies, angels, and apple pie.

Ellis then gets to the matter at hand.
Sure enough, when I read the articles and carefully separate the quotes from the author’s “interpretation” of what was said, I find that nowhere in the article was Gordon Howie quoted saying he supported “civil unions” (which are nothing more than mimicry of marriage), much less supporting “gay marriage” (i.e. counterfeit marriage)....
...
Howie supports–as I do–allowing homosexuals continued access to the same rights that every American enjoys regardless of sexual practice and proclivity.  In other words, if a homosexual wants to leave his property to his homosexual partner upon his death, that is a legal right any American enjoys, so why should the same right be denied to the homosexual?  If a homosexual wants his homosexual partner to be able to visit him in the hospital, and he makes prior legal notice of that–just as any American can do–then why should he be denied that right?
Coincidentally, Rod Dreher has a post this morning on the American Conservative website that is more thoughtful than Ellis's and points to some major problems with Ellis's conservative agenda that purports to mix Christianity with political action. Dreher writes,
1. Traditional Christians should quit lying to themselves (ourselves) about the possibility that politics can adequately address the core problems we identify in American culture. It’s not that politics are inconsequential, but rather that what can be achieved through politics is limited. It always was, of course, but now it is especially so. . . .
Do we think we are Christians because God has blessed us with material things and liberty? What use have we made of these blessings? Because we build megachurches, bishops’ palaces, McMansions for our own homes? Is it possible that God is judging us? I ask of all Christians, not just traditional ones? I ask it of myself.
2. If the core of our problems are moral and spiritual, then we must build the institutions and communal structures that will address those problems, and attempt to solve them. No politician, Republican or Democrat, saved anyone’s soul. Again, this is not to say that our religious beliefs do not have political consequences. They do. But it is to say that we have to keep straight in our minds what our goals are, and what the means to reach them are.
3. As a Christian and conservative, I have become interested in voting for the candidate who can most be trusted to work for the maximal protection of religious liberty and an autonomous sphere within which traditionalist Christians (and others) can work to build our own institutions (churches, schools, voluntary associations) that enable us to live out in common our conception of the moral life. This means that I will support a candidate who favors gay marriage rights if I believe that that candidate can be trusted to fight for religious liberty, and if that candidate is the most viable rightward candidate.
Dreher, I think points to three things that all voters need to think about as we enter the campaign season that will be full of short TV ads and charges and counter-charges of lying, defamation, and despising all that is good and holy.

First, Americans over most of my lifetime have done a rather poor job of "adequately address[ing] the core problems we identify in American culture" and have lived under the mantra, spoken or unspoken: "It's the economy, Stupid.". Since Madonna sang about  being a material girl in a material world in the 1980s, we haven't even bothered to mock ourselves and our emphasis on securing the material at the expense of nearly everything else.

Second, politicians have really lost the ability to think long term. Everything is about issues, tactics, and the horse race. Voters trust them to deliver on their promises at the voters' peril. More importantly, the difficulty Madison enunciated the Federalist 51 remains: humans are not angels.

Third, focusing on the hot button issues at the expense of the bigger issue, in this case preserving religious liberty, is counterproductive. Also, going for an all or nothing political approach is likely to gain the latter.

One wonders what the political and social landscape would look like now if, in the 1990s, Ellis and his conservative cohorts had pushed for a law that extends to gay and lesbian couples the civil benefits he claims to support with the caveat that churches could marry or not marry anyone they chose.

I don't have the answers, and I don't know where the lines should be drawn, but Dreher's approach makes a lot more sense than Ellis's

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

A Naive Organizing Principle For Foreign Policy

PNR asks an important question:
The world needs a cop quite often.  What should dictate when we answer the call and when we leave it ringing?  What should principles should set the priorities among the competing calls that come in?
He has proclaimed "don't do stupid stuff" as insufficient. (I'm going to be in the first day of faculty meetings in an hour, so I'm trying to cut back on summer language.) One could contend that the aphorism is still a necessary element in any foreign policy principle or set of principles. The Princess Bride offered two pithy phrases, one of which the United States frequently ignores: "Never get involved in a land war in Asia" and "Never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line." Those principles also seem  insufficient even though following the former might have have dramatically altered the history that has occurred during my lifetime

In light of the fact that most aphorisms, including "first, do no harm" will be found wanting, I humbly offer a rather naive principle with the accompanying plan.

Every time a foreign policy is presented to the President, he or she should ask the presenter(s) two simple questions.

First, will proposal x, plan y, act z help provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our posterity? (The phrases "form a more perfect union, establish justice, [and] insure domestic tranquility," seem better suited to domestic policy.)

Second, can you explain how it will do so in a manner that an 8 year old can understand?

Granted, Barack Obama and John McCain might answer the questions differently, but neither of them would agree about what constitutes stupid stuff.

Tuesday, August 12, 2014

Does Bob Ellis Have Political Porphyria?

Porphyria is sometimes known as vampire disease.
One of the most interesting "vampire diseases" is porphyria. Porphyria is a rare disease characterized by irregularities in production of heme, an iron-rich pigment in blood. People with the more severe forms of porphyria are highly sensitive to sunlight, experience severe abdominal pain and may suffer from acute delirium. One possible treatment for porphyria in the past might have been to drink blood, to correct the imbalance in the body (though there's no clear evidence of this). Some porphyria sufferers do have reddish mouths and teeth, due to irregular production of the heme pigment. Porphyria is hereditary, so there may have been concentrations of sufferers in certain areas throughout history.
Bob Ellis, the angriest man in the South Dakota blogosphere, loves to toss out the blood red political meat to defend Gordon Howie.
Of course, there’s a whole lot of anti-conservatism and smearing of conservatives from liberals in the Republican Party these days.
This is far from the first time the pro-Rounds liberals have tried to smear Howie as “racist.” And Howie isn’t the only conservative to earn the “race card” from the liberals infesting the Republican Party. You may recall that they lied about South Dakota Senator Phil Jensen several months ago for trying to protect religious liberty from homosexual activists, like some of them smeared South Dakota Rep. Manny Steele as a “racist” a few years ago for trying to deal with illegal immigration.
And let’s not forget that the RINO establishment tried to smear Tea Party-supported Chris McDaniel in Mississippi as a racist recently, jumping into bed with Democrats in gross vote fraud. Liberals have long enjoyed repeating the lie of Tea Party racism.
Like typical liberals, they have no interest in the truth. Lacking any substantive defense of their liberal betrayals, they just keep repeating the same lies, trusting that people too busy or shallow to seek out the truth will buy their snake oil. Whether they are in the Democrat Party or the “Republican” Party, liberals are all the same: scorched earth politics, with no lie too low.
Those paragraphs have a lot of red blood cells: "smear," "lie," "race card," "liberals infest," "homosexual activists," "RINO establishment," "jumping into bed with Democrats," "typical liberals," "liberal betrayals" "people too . . . shallow to seek out the truth will buy their snake oil," "same scorched earth politics," "no lie too low."

If all of that blood red political ranting helps Ellis deal with his political porphyria symptoms, more power to him. The rants won't explain away Brad Ford.

Sunday, August 3, 2014

A Modest Proposal For Meet The Press South Dakota

John Thune was apparently on Meet the Press this morning. Coincidently, a Ryan Cooper column at The Week asserts that a typical Meet the Press segment is "short, dull, clichéd, and barely touch[es] the subject on hand." According to Cooper, the long running Sunday morning staple "has become completely worthless. Further, the program is "neither informative nor interesting." Regular viewers  "find the same dozen or so tired D.C. insiders [who] blithely opine on stuff they know little or nothing about." The opportunities for snark abound, but I will forego all of them because Cooper has an interesting proposal to improve the program that a South Dakota television program could adapt for the state.

In short Cooper suggests having half-hour conversations between writers interested in the subject, experts, and public officials. He offers several examples like this one: "journalist Ta-Nehisi Coates and economist Jared Bernstein interview Paul Ryan on his poverty plan."

Off the top of my head, I can think of four or five segments that would be worthwhile. I prefer a bit more of a lion's den approach rather than the standard interviewer from the left and interviewer from the right approach. The format would be a table, comfortable chairs, and coffee for everyone but Heidelberger who would wave his arms too much if caffeinated.
Mike Rounds interviewed by Cory Heidelberger and Representative Bernie Hunhoff.
Rick Wieland interviewed by Pat Powers and Representative Rev. Steve Hickey
Rapid City Mayor Sam Kookier and Sioux Falls Mayor Mike Huether interviewed by John Tsitrian and Scott Ehrisman.
Secretary of Education Melody Schopp interviewed by Associated School Boards of South Dakota Executive Director Wade Pogany and me (provided the camera were kept on the other two so as the good children of South Dakota did not suffer nightmares. If they won't agree to that condition, Representative Jim Bolin or Mike Larson would be more telegenic than I.)
It would be an important public service to have Governor Daugaard interviewed about Native American policy. I have to confess I'm unsure whom the Native American community would deem able to best ask questions that advocated their interests.
Quite frankly, I would love to see Libertarian blogger Ken Santema interview anyone in South Dakota politics.
If the television station airing the program would demand an official journalist to moderate, David Montgomery or Kevin Woster strike me as able to do the job. If nothing else this program would allow South Dakota voters and television viewers to see officials questioned by folks a less willing to accept press releases as the final word on a matter.

Friday, August 1, 2014

A Minor Musing About Religion In The Public Square

Cory wrote a post about the ACLU, the Miller School Board, and Gideon Bibles. Because Steve Sibson, as is his wont, took over the comment section, the comments took a turn for the worse rather quickly, so I decided to electronically scribble my thoughts here.

First, teachers should teach subject matter not proselytize.

That said, I don't know how one talks about Salem without mentioning religion. It's pretty difficult to discuss slave narratives without providing background information on Old Testament symbolism. One should at least mention that Thomas Jefferson spent a number of nights in the White House using a razor to excise the miraculous elements of the New Testament. When teaching the 1890s, explaining William Jennings Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech is tough if one doesn't explain the allusion. So is discussing Theodore Roosevelt without mentioning his "We Stand at Armageddon and We Battle for the Lord" speech. One should probably mention Sitting Bull's importance as a spiritual leader before mentioning Battle of The Little Big Horn. The last history book I looked at was woefully inadequate on both The Sun Dance and The Ghost Dance.

Further, it's impossible to teach world literature without covering the Bible, Lao Tzu, Confucius, Plato, Socrates, Gandhi, Tolstoy, Dante, or a bunch of wonderful pagan stories. In American literature, those who fear Flannery O'Connor's Catholicism should know that Mark Twain provides a cynical balance. Lest I forget, The Life of Pi should make all moral therapeutic deists happy.

My fellow believers need to own that Christianity has been used as a tool to enslave and kill countless people. Atheists need to acknowledge that Pol Pot, Stalin, and Mao headed murderous regimes that were officially atheistic. Evil people will use any tool at hand to accomplish their ends. On a more benign note, Christians need to acknowledge that the Bible is not a science book while secularists ought to acknowledge that science is an inadequate tool for explaining why the universe should go through trouble of existing.

To move this from the classroom to the full public square, all should try to avoid being deliberately offensive. Everyone needs to realize, however, that there is no God given/Constitutional/civil/human right to go through life without being offended by an idea that differs from one's own. That offense is necessary to build one's mind or soul or both.

The public square needs to look at this clip from an old science fiction series Babylon 5. (The important part starts 15 seconds in. It's American television so there may be a cringeworthy stereotype used to make a broader point.)

Tuesday, July 29, 2014

In South Dakota Politics The Enemy Of My Enemy Is Likely My Enemy's Enemy

Tara Volesky hopes that I and everyone else will support Independent candidate for lieutenant-governor Lora Hubbel because Hubbel fights the GOP establishment. I don't like established churches or political oligarchies. I'm not sanguine about South Dakota being a single-party state. The ruling clique has far too many Mayberry Machiavellis in its number. More importantly, South Dakota gets an F from the Center for Public Integrity and is the eighth most corrupt state according to an Indiana University study.

Lee Stranahan has promised South Dakotans "better media." Stranahan claims the improved coverage will happen because he is "going to keep it real about the REAL ISSUES facing South Dakota." It's disheartening to know that South Dakota has fewer statehouse reporters.than any other state. Further, South Dakota's television news departments do more press release reading than actual journalism.

I should, therefore, wholeheartedly rejoice because an "advocate" like Hubbel and an intrepid "reporter" like Stranahan are in South Dakota. And yet, there exists a strong feeling that, in this case, the enemy of my enemy is . . . something other than an ally.

To date, Stranahan seems to write about only two subjects; neither involve improving South Dakota's political news coverage. First, he serves as the chief apologist for Chad Haber's and Annette Bosworth's efforts to lead as many as possible down a political rabbit hole to a bizarre wonderland that makes Lewis Carroll's look pedestrian. (Much of Stranahan's concern in the Mette rape case has been connected to Attorney General Marty Jackley's prosecution of Annette Bosworth.) Second, he reprimands the two leading South Dakota political blogs, Madville Times and Dakota War College, for criticizing Haber and Bosworth. Like Sibby before him, Stranahan seems particularly fixated on Madville's Cory Heidelberger. With all due respect to DWC's Pat Powers and Heidelberger, far more South Dakotas get their political news from KELO or KSFY than from Madville and DWC, a fact Stranahan blithely ignores.

A single-party state that is gaining infamy for having too few reporters and too much corruption is hardly on its way to becoming Utopia. The political leadership and those who have failed in their watchdog capacity deserve censure. On the other hand, Hubbel has a history of being a political bomb thrower with an uncertain aim, and Stranahan seems to share that tendency. Their histrionics will only cause collateral damage and damn by association those who expose corruption and champion carefully formulated reform efforts.

Giving someone the choice of supporting the political status quo or supporting a political reality envisioned by Stranahan or Hubbel, is like giving someone the choice to killed by a firing squad or lethal injection. The end result is the same. Given the available options, I'll opt for remaining politically displaced.

Thursday, June 26, 2014

Is Bob Ellis The Love Child Of Darth Vader And Al Gore?

I ask because Ellis, the angriest man in the South Dakota blogosphere, favorably quotes interesting phrasing in his latest diatribe. It's not his conclusion:
As is always the case with liberals (in both parties), all the burden is on conservatives.  “Compromise” means “conservatives do what liberals want.” “Tolerance” means shut up and agree with liberals.” And “unity” means get behind the most liberal candidate available, regardless of party.
That's standard Ellis fare: "Liberals hate all that's good. Everyone who disagrees with me is a liberal because I am all that's good." Every time I read an Ellis column, I wonder what would happen if he were in a room with a dozen real liberals. I'm betting on spontaneous human combustion, but I digress.

The part of Ellis's post that prompted the question in the post's title was his use of this Steven Deace statement:
This will be a day long remembered. The day eyes were opened to the inconvenient truth . . . [italics in original]
It struck me as odd that a conservative crusader wouldn't recognize a quote from a Hollywood classic, conservatives believing Hollywood to be a liberal bastion of scum and villainy. It doesn't take a pop culture nerd to recognize that the first sentence was most famously uttered by Star Wars uber villian Darth Vader: "This will be a day long remembered. It has seen the end of Kenobi, it will soon see the end of the Rebellion."

As to the second part, surely all true conservatives remember An Inconvenient Truth was the documentary about Al Gore and his efforts to make climate change a major policy issue.

Maybe, I went too far with the love child question. It would take some weird cloning to create a love child from Gore and Vader. It's just as likely that Ellis is a closet RINO. Hollywood and Gore sure sound liberal to me.