Showing posts with label #neverTrump. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #neverTrump. Show all posts

Thursday, July 2, 2020

A Minor Musing About Trump's Visit To Mount Rushmore

In two days, the forty-fifth president of the United States will use Mount Rushmore as a backdrop for a political dog and pony show.

Some easy contrasts between the current president and those whose faces are chiseled into the mountain exist. George Washington led America's fight for independence from Great Britain. A young Donald Trump sought deferments from military service claiming he had bone spurs. Further, the myths surrounding Washington have him eschewing lies. Trump's lies are legion.

Theodore Roosevelt provides another easy comparison. He was shot while he giving a speech. Roosevelt told the crowd not to harm the man who attempted to assassinate him. While a candidate, Trump promised to pay legal fees for those who physically attacked people who protested at his rallies. (Protesters who exchange high fives seem to anger Trump more than others.)

More importantly, it is one history's of great ironies that Thomas Jefferson, a lifelong slave owner, could pen "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." Eighty-seven years later, Abraham Lincoln would declare that the nation was "conceived" and "dedicated to the proposition" that all men are created equal." 

No evidence exists that the current president has the cognitive or rhetorical skills to use language the way that Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln did. Distressingly there's a similar dearth of evidence that he believes all are created equal or that the nation is dedicated to the proposition supporting that fact.

Finally, Trump seems totally incapable of asking Americans to convincingly appeal to the "better angels of their nature" or to adequately copy Lincoln's call at a time our nation needs to hear it:
With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up the nation's wounds, to care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan, to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace among ourselves and with all nations.
Current discussions about monuments and their significance are politically and morally fraught, and those around Mount Rushmore will continue to be so. For the purposes of this post, however, the mythos surrounding the four presidents on Mt. Rushmore illustrate a vital reminder about the failings of the current occupant of the Oval Office. 
 

Monday, February 3, 2020

As Iowa Democrats Caucus, I Worry

Democrats will caucus in Iowa tonight to begin the process of nominating their 2020 candidate for president.

I have numerous fears, but I will list only a few here.

First, the two front runners, Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden are too old. One hopes that with age comes wisdom, but tech has changed the world in ways that make it difficult for folks over 60, let alone folks approaching 80, to adapt.

Second, and much more importantly, both of the front runners have a cult problem. Trumpism has illustrated many faults in America's current system, but none may be more dangerous than the tribalism fueled by the cult of personality.

The Bernie Bros of 2016 have not gone away. If Sanders in the nominee, their fervor will ratchet up exponentially and promote an overblown Trumpist response that will take fear mongering to unprecedented heights. The McCarthy era will seem tame and civilized in comparison. (If he is not the nominee their fervor may still ratchet up exponentially but their target will be the Democrats' nominee.)

Whenever one points out that Trumpism is a cult, one is faced with the response that Obama's popularity also fueled cult-like behavior. Whether the charge is true or not, Republicans will turn out the base by contending that Biden is trading on or attempting to revive Obama's legacy and, therefore, Obama's cult of personality.

In either instance, the fear their "chosen one" will be replaced by someone they fear has a personality cult will elevate Trumpists' zeal to new, more dangerous, and insane levels. (As a side note, Democrats do not seem to understand how much fear motivates Trump's most fervent supporters.)

Third, Democrats are looking at the fact that Trump "is the only president in the history of Gallup polling who has never had the support of a majority of Americans for even a single day" as a reason to believe that they have an easy path to win the popular. If 2016 showed anything, it's that the popular vote doesn't matter. Trump's election team is likely targeting key precincts in swing states and charting a path to another minority victory. Democrats seem blissfully and dangerously oblivious to the electoral map.

Finally and most importantly, Democrats seem focused on purity rather than defeating Trump. Defeating Trump and his authoritarian tendencies should be a primary goal; it should be the only goal.

Thursday, January 23, 2020

Republicans In United States Senate Prove South Dakota Republicans Fail Self-Reliance Test

Over at Dakota Free Press, Cory posted about Senate Bill 54, legislation written to prevent South Dakota communities from banning plastic bags and straws. I commented on his post that South Dakota Republicans, some of whom must be part of the every day carry (EDC) community, should show their dedication to preparedness supporting the carrying of metal straws and reusable grocery bags.

Today, Republicans in United States Senate have shown South Dakota Republicans the error of their ways. North Carolina Senator Richard Burr handed out fidget spinners to some of his colleagues for their edification, enrichment, and enjoyment during the Donald Trump Impeachment Trial.

Let's leave aside for the nonce the worry that these spinners may violate the rules the Senate established for the trial. Let's ignore the fact that that these spinners may be a not so subtle message that the Senators using them are not taking seriously their oath to be impartial jurors. Instead, in a spirit of bipartisanship, let's celebrate the fact that Republicans in the United States Senate are demonstrated their dedication to preparedness, albeit belatedly, by making fidget spinners part of their EDC.

Maybe South Dakota Republicans can follow that example and drop their opposition to individuals making metal straws and reusable grocery bags part of their everyday carry.

Sunday, January 19, 2020

The MAGA Church Ad: A Minor Musing

It's Sunday morning, so let's mix politics and religion.

During the 2016 campaign, some American Christians voted for Donald Trump because they believed him to be a King Cyrus figure. In the Bible, Cyrus is the Persian king who ended the Babylonian captivity. These same people likely saw Hillary Clinton as a Jezebel analogue. At the time, I saw Trump to be closer to Rehoboam, the king of Israel whose actions literally divided the kingdom. Trump's actions as president have intensified my belief.

Recently, the Lincoln Project, a group of anti-Trump Republicans, has released a campaign video entitled "The MAGA Church." The video begins with the scriptural reminder to beware wolves in sheep's clothing and closes with the tagline "If this is the best American Christians can do? Then God help us all." The ad juxtaposes statements by prosperity gospel preachers and sons of famous preachers with some of Trump's more hubristic  or outlandish comments. It is a powerful well-done ad that will matter not a whit.


First, the ad demonstrates Trump's hypocrisy. Trump's religious base has made peace with that hypocrisy and now sees it as a mark of faith. They did not need Jim Bakker to tell them that supporting Trump was a sign that one is saved. They already believed it. (The ad has a clip of Bakker's utterance, so I am not going to provide a link.)

Second, the ad shows many of the prosperity preachers laying hands on Trump in the Oval Office. Those unfamiliar with charismatic, Pentecostal, or full gospel churches will find the act peculiar at best. Members of those churches who are full-throated Trumpists will take pride in being a "peculiar people." More importantly, they will see the ad as evidence that the wisdom of the world is foolishness to God.

In short, the ad will merely reinforce existing beliefs. Those who believe Trump is a B.S. artist conning the faithful will have a lot of evidence in one place. On the other hand, the ad will likely deepen Trumpists' belief that American Christians are a persecuted minority and that Trump is indeed a modern day Cyrus sent by God to protect them from worse persecution.

Saturday, December 28, 2019

On Trumpists And Zeal: A Minor Musing

Last summer events conspired to cause me to realize that I needed to settle myself down a bit, so I began reading entries from A Year with Thomas Merton: Daily Meditations from His Journals every morning and entries from A Year with G. K. Chesterton: 365 Days of Wisdom, Wit, and Wonder every evening. 

I picked the Chesterton book because I like Chesterton's Father Brown mysteries and the title seemed timely. If the Trump era has revealed anything about America, it's illustrated that Americans as a whole exhibit a profound lack of both wisdom and wit. That lack likely exists because of a collective inability to experience or express wonder in either its common or spiritual definition.

I'm not but sure why I picked the Merton book, but I have found many of the entries beneficial. It is the December 22 entry of the Merton devotional, however, that expresses the root of the problem and the error of believers who have sold their political soul to Trumpism:
Yesterday, day of recollection, realized again above all my need for profound and total humility--especially in any work I may do for peace. Humility is more important than zeal. Descent into nothingness and dependence on God. Otherwise I am just fighting the world with its own weapons and there the world is unbeatable. Indeed it does not even have to fight back, for I will exhaust myself and that will be the end of my stupid efforts. [Emphasis mine]
I am more than willing to accept that many of the country's current problems began because wealthy, well-educated elites developed a sense of hubris that rivals that of every tragic hero in literature. Answering that hubris with the populist zeal that Trump fans possess will correct none of those errors. It will, as Merton correctly observes, burn itself out and accomplish nothing permanent.

I suspect that the populists who use Christianity to further their efforts to avenge perceived slights from those they view as out-of-touch elites will not take advice from a Trappist monk or a British Catholic, so they will continue to privilege zeal over humility and the exhaust themselves and the rest of us in the process.
 

Sunday, July 21, 2019

A Minor Musing About Libertarians In The Age Of Trump

This Dakota Free Press post about Bob Newland's speech to the 2019 Libertarian Party Convention caused a few ideas to gel for me. (As a quick aside, I believe I have met Mr. Newland only once and he struck me as an affable gentleman.)

First, it's refreshing to see a Libertarian discuss a role for government in infrastructure. I would like to hear Libertarians also espouse Hayek's view of social insurance:
There is no reason why, in a society which has reached the general level of wealth which ours has attained , the first kind of security should not be guaranteed to all without endangering general freedom. . . .there can be no doubt that some minimum of food, shelter and clothing, sufficient to preserve health and the capacity to work, can be assured to everybody. . . . 
Nor is there any reason why the state should not help to organize a comprehensive system of social insurance in providing for those common hazards of life against which few can make adequate provision.
Hayek goes on to say, ". . . there is no incompatibility in principle between the state's providing greater security in this way and the preservation of individual freedom."

Libertarians' unwillingness to support a social safety net might have something to do with their view of socialism, a political theory Newland took time to attack. In 2019, however, the biggest threat to classic liberalism is not socialism but the new toxic mix of nationalism, populism, and Trumpism. 

Earlier this summer members of the conservative intelligentsia engaged in a rather heated argument about liberalism. Writing in First Things, Sohrab Ahmari attacked Never-Trumper David French because French, a cultural conservative,  "has individual autonomy [as] his lodestar: He sees 'protecting individual liberty' as the main, if not sole, purpose of government." In short, Ahmari is attacking French for being too Libertarian.

More importantly, Ahmari uses Trump, a man whose only political philosophy is an "I alone can fix it" narcissism as a blank slate. According to Ahmari,
[Trump's] instinct has been to shift the cultural and political mix, ever so slightly, away from autonomy-above-all toward order, continuity, and social cohesion. He believes that the political community—and not just the church, family, and individual—has its own legitimate scope for action. He believes it can help protect the citizen from transnational forces beyond his control.
Trump's recent "go back" to "crime infested places from which they came" tweets put the lie to any claims that he seeks "social cohesion." However, it seems clear that Ahmari wants to use Trump's followers to impose a form of "order" that will, unironically, attempt to force people to be autonomous and virtuous in ways that bend the terms "autonomy" and "virtue" beyond recognition. In short, government will exist to force citizens to relinquish rights to achieve the nationalists' or Trumpists' order.

Finally, the Ahmari article coincides with Newland's apprehension about what he calls an "insidious threat," "squincthy-eyed evangelicals" who attempt to impose "their version of God's will" on others. Ahmari is not an evangelical. He will, however, give intellectual heft to some social conservatives' desires to quell their inchoate fears with government imposed puritanical security. That threat should have all of us keeping one foot in the Libertarian camp.


Tuesday, April 23, 2019

A Minor Musing About Trump And Tech Giants With A Dash Of Orwell

I don't know if it's the fact that I'm getting older or the fact that we're cursed to live in interesting times, but I seem to re-read and cogitate over things more than I used to.

One such piece is this Rod Dreher post on The American Conservative site. Dreher wonders at conservative's gleeful reaction to the Mueller Report. He favorably quotes a David Brooks column wherein Brooks opines,
And today, across society, two things are happening: Referees are being undermined, and many are abandoning their own impartiality. (Think of the Wall Street regulators, the Supreme Court, the Senate committee chairmen, even many of us in the blessed media.) Things begin to topple. 
… Trump doesn’t seem to have any notion of loyalty to an office. All power in his eye is personal power, and the government is there to serve his Sun God self. He’ll continue to trample the proper systems of government. 
It’s easy to recognize when you are attacked head-on. But the U.S. is being attacked from below, at the level of the foundations we take for granted.
Dreher also writes,
The center is not holding, and technological changes (as well as cultural evolution) are rendering us unable to recreate a sustainable center.  Whether he leaves the White House in 2021, or 2025, after Trump, I believe that the US will be more or less in a Spain 1931 situation. Trump has done nothing to prevent that, and much to hasten its arrival.
Although Dreher writes, "I fully endorse David Brooks’s take on the corruption of the system, and his judgment on Donald Trump as a moral catastrophe," he does not proclaim himself a #NeverTrump club member. Instead, Dreher concludes,
. . . if you want to talk about the foundations of society being attacked, believe me, we should all worry about Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Silicon Valley on the whole a lot more than we worry about our buffoonish president. What the surveillance capitalists have done, and are doing, matters far more to the future of our democracy and its legitimacy than does Trump.
In fact, he doubles down on this conclusion:
I just know that I’m a lot more worried about Sergey Brin, Larry Page, and Mark Zuckerberg, and the class that they embody, than I am of a crooked real estate magnate from New York who is the weakest and least effective president since Jimmy Carter.
Dreher butters his bread by thinking and writing. Although he calls himself a "Bible-thumping troglodyte," Dreher thinks deeply, comes at the world from an Orthodox perspective, and talks about good food and drink frequentl, so he likely makes many conservative evangelical folk uncomfortable. 

I share Dreher's fears about Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple. The tech giants threaten Americans' privacy and possess a near totalitarian power to control public opinion.They cannot, however, send a person to Guantanamo or launch nuclear weapons. Further, I cannot share Dreher's confidence that Trump "stands, however uncertainly, in the way of the Controllers." Trump's admiration of despots indicates that he would give Bezos et al. free rein were they to offer him just a little flattery. In short, I remain a firm member of the #NeverTrump club.

That said, I worry that Dreher and I are both wrong. Americans seem to possess a certain optimism. The current crop of religious populists claim to be on God's side and view Trump as a savior from the evil liberals. Progressives proclaim that they are on the right side of history's long march toward justice for all. It is, however, likely that such optimism is misplaced and America has reached an Orwellian moment. Not the moment when we all loudly admit to loving big brother, although that moment is certainly possible; rather, we have come to the Animal Farm climax when conservatives, liberals, and displaced folks like myself stand outside the window and look "from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but [find it] impossible to say which was which. "

Saturday, March 16, 2019

A Minor Musing On Justice And Power And Implied Threats Of Violence

I was fortunate to coach some excellent Lincoln-Douglas debaters. (Whether they succeeded with my coaching or in spite of my coaching is an open question.) Lincoln-Douglas debaters debate propositions of value and frequently open their cases with the phrase "I will be upholding the value of justice. . . " The young'uns I coached and those they debated against would frequently argue whether justice meant rendering each their due or a more Rawlsian concept which aregued justice as fairness

Donald Trump swore to uphold a Constitutions designed to "form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity. . . " Trump, however, doesn't see justice as rendering each his or her due or fairness. Instead, he relies on a Sophist argument: "Justice is nothing but the advantage of the stronger." Earlier this week, he told Breitbart News:
. . . I can tell you I have the support of the police, the support of the military, the support of the Bikers for Trump – I have the tough people, but they don’t play it tough — until they go to a certain point, and then it would be very bad, very bad....
These words are a not-so-veiled threat premised on the idea that might makes right. It's unlikely that those who drafted the Constitution understood justice in those terms nor is it clear how the threat of violence promotes the general welfare or insures domestic tranquility. (If I may be forgiven a bit of snark, one wonders if those words constitute "riot boosting" in South Dakota under the recently passed SB 189 and 190.)

This recent rhetoric is just another example of Trump attempting to obliterate political norms. This particular violation moves politics one step further from debate and one step closer to angry confrontation and reveals Trump once again to be a weak man posing as a strong one. More importantly, it confuses the debate about what justice is or should be and returns the debate to what do the strongest and richest want it to be.

For those interested, John Tristan posts what may be a more coherent take.

Saturday, January 19, 2019

Quotation Of The Day: Is Donald Trump Trying To Make The Rest Of Us As Miserable As He Is?

I have to ask because this George Will analysis resonates with me.

By his comportment, the president benefits his media detractors with serial vindications of their disparagements. They, however, have sunk to his level of insufferable self-satisfaction by preening about their superiority to someone they consider morally horrifying and intellectually cretinous. For most Americans, President Trump’s expostulations are audible wallpaper, always there but not really noticed. Still, the ubiquity of his outpourings in the media’s outpourings gives American life its current claustrophobic feel. This results from many journalists considering him an excuse for a four-year sabbatical from thinking about anything other than the shiny thing that mesmerizes them by dangling himself in front of them.

Dislike of him should be tempered by this consideration: He is an almost inexpressibly sad specimen. It must be misery to awaken to another day of being Donald Trump. He seems to have as many friends as his pluperfect self-centeredness allows, and as he has earned in an entirely transactional life. His historical ignorance deprives him of the satisfaction of working in a house where much magnificent history has been made. His childlike ignorance — preserved by a lifetime of single-minded self-promotion — concerning governance and economics guarantees that whenever he must interact with experienced and accomplished people, he is as bewildered as a kindergartener at a seminar on string theory.

I'm never going to turn a phrase as well as George Will, so I won't try. I don't know about Trump's personal friendships and I don't really care. I know that all of us seem to think less and yell more whenever we discuss political issues. In short, Trump has brought us down to his level. I certainly feel suffocated by the oxygen that he takes out of the room, but ignoring him, a action that most other politicians make easy, is nearly impossible. He's driving a bulldozer through a china shop without worrying about the damage he's doing or those who will have to clean it up.

Monday, January 14, 2019

I Am Pleasantly Surprised ....

Even if the statement is late, Senator Rounds has demonstrated the ability to point out one of Trump's racist comments when Trump takes aim at something South Dakota specific.
Senator Thune and Representative Johnson have apparently given their social media team the night off.

Saturday, January 12, 2019

South Dakota Senate Acts Like An Abuse Victim

Per Axios, six of the ten states hardest hit by the shutdown voted for Trump. South Dakota is one of those states. Axios points out that "[o]ffices of the USDA's Farm Service Agency, which help farmers affected by China's soybean tariffs, are closed due to the shutdown. Further, agencies including the Indian Health Service and Small Business Administration are shuttered.

Meanwhile, the South Dakota Senate passed a resolution supporting Trump's monument to his own narcissism. Although Senator Stace Nelson's hyperbolic "black wind of death to race across this nation from coast to coast" will likely garner the most attention, it's Senator Lance Russell's plaintive desire to protect Trump from those with "nefarious motives" that indicates the need for an intervention.

After the original resolution was amended to reflect the historically accurate fact that nearly all walls including the Great Wall of China, Hadrian's Wall, and the Berlin Wall fail, Senator Lance Russel worried about Trump's feelings:

Lance Russell, R-Hot Springs, saw the amended version as a watered down version of the original resolution. He said that amending the resolution is on par with "the games that get played in Washington." He said he hopes the amended version doesn't send a message that South Dakota doesn't support Trump. 

The Senate needs to support Trump in constructing a wall across the entire southern U.S. border because the problems Trump is describing aren't "a manufactured crisis," Russell said. Trump is "trying to elevate all of us" by taking on the border issues, he said, adding that the South Dakota Senate needs to support Trump and the amended version of the resolution doesn't do that.
 

"It is a crisis, and Trump didn't manufacture it," Russell said. "It's been around for a while. ... When we are watering down what we're doing here, I understand the politics of the situation, but this gives people with nefarious motives to question what the president is doing and what he was elected to do."

Let's be clear. If the wall were that important, Trump had a Republican House and Senate for two years. They could have passed the funding, gone to reconciliation to avoid the filibuster, and started construction. Instead, South Dakotans are being hurt and the legislature is looking to protect the person responsible for causing the pain.

According to Russell, South Dakotans need to support Trump even when he creates policies such as tariffs and shutdowns that adversely affect South Dakotans. It doesn't take any reading between the lines to get to abuse victim phrasing: "Trumpie just wants what's best for me; my Trumpie doesn't want to hurt me; he just gets angry sometimes. It's my fault really."

Wednesday, January 2, 2019

A Minor Musing On Idolatry And Trump

If it were possible to boil the problems with the Trump reign into three words, one could do worse than character, competence, and corruption. Yesterday, Mitt Romney succinctly explained Trump's character problem:
To a great degree, a presidency shapes the public character of the nation. A president should unite us and inspire us to follow “our better angels.” A president should demonstrate the essential qualities of honesty and integrity, and elevate the national discourse with comity and mutual respect. As a nation, we have been blessed with presidents who have called on the greatness of the American spirit. With the nation so divided, resentful and angry, presidential leadership in qualities of character is indispensable. And it is in this province where the incumbent’s shortfall has been most glaring.
The other problem, however, is that Trump's followers, even those who should know better, deify him.  For example, Jerry Falwell Jr. asserts he can see no circumstance that would lead him to not supporting Trump.

Is there anything President Trump could do that would endanger that support from you or other evangelical leaders? 

No.
 

That’s the shortest answer we’ve had so far.
Only because I know that he only wants what’s best for this country, and I know anything he does, it may not be ideologically “conservative,” but it’s going to be what’s best for this country, and I can’t imagine him doing anything that’s not good for the country. [Emphasis in original]

In response to Romney's op-ed, Trump's campaign manager, Brad Parscale doubled down on deification
That tweet, which borders on idolatry, certainly goes against scriptural injunction found in Psalm 146: 3-4.

Do not put your trust in princes,in human beings, who cannot save.When their spirit departs, they return to the ground;on that very day their plans come to nothing.

The more secular and mundane problem with deification and the belief that Trump or any other human will save the nation is the fact that the "savior" needs a threat to save the nation from. That fact creates an illogical conundrum: there's a threat and the nation needs a savior; the savior has saved the nation, but now there's a bigger threat and the nation needs to be saved again.

Trump will not save the nation; he is incapable of saving the nation. That's not an insult or a political judgement. No human can save any nation. The danger is believing a human can do no wrong or singlehandedly save one. Deifying a human rarely works well.

Saturday, October 6, 2018

Trump, Kavanaugh, and Justice: A Minor Musing

Sometime today, the Senate will vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh as a justice on the United States Supreme Court. His self-righteous outburst last week should have disqualified him because it demonstrated his lack of judicious restraint and sense of entitlement.  All Supreme Court justices ought to be judicious and restrained when their every word affects the course of history. No one should be entitled to a lifetime appointment. Apparently, a Wall Street Journal apology covers multitude of sins.

In the past few days, Donald Trump has taken to mocking Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, the woman who accused Kavanaugh of assaulting her decades ago. He has also mocked former Senator Al Franken for resigning from the United States Senate when Franken was accused of sexual impropriety.

It's impossible to know what cases will come before the Supreme Court two, five, or ten years from now. Three certainties exist, however. First, Republicans may have had cause to accuse the Democrats of falling prey to relativism and postmodernism over the past twenty or thirty years, but the events of the Kavanaugh hearings and the aftermath show Republicans, like all postmodernists, returning to the Sophists and giving full throat to relativistic arguments. The idea that justice is the rendering of due is no longer an operative principle for Republicans or this allegedly conservative court. Both are acting and will continue to act on Thrasymacus's argument that justice is "nothing else than the interest of the stronger." Only those with wealth and connections need seek relief in the courts or the legislatures.

Second, Trumpists will continue to confuse bellicosity with strength. President George H.W. Bush sought "a kinder, gentler nation." President Abraham Lincoln believed Americans would be governed "by the better angels of our nature." Trump throws tantrums and urges his base to throw them as well. Kavanaugh's contempt and anger was nothing but a tantrum without profanity. The fact that the tactic was successful presages more of the same

Third, public discourse will resemble Flint's water supply for the foreseeable future. Democrats are enraged at how Republicans treated Dr. Ford. Republicans are enraged at how Democrats treated Kavanaugh. Even if senators from both parties are merely posturing for the cameras and their respective bases, the rhetoric has reached a level where comity and reasoned political debate have become impossible at the national level.

Throughout the entire 2016 election season and on a weekly basis since, I have thought about the first stanza of Yeats's "The Second Coming." The following lines capture the current cultural climate:
Turning and turning in the widening gyre 
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere 
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst 
Are full of passionate intensity.
Yeats concluded by wondering
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, 
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Whatever curiosity I may have had about the answer to that question has given way to dread.

Thursday, September 13, 2018

Sound, Fury, And The Signifying Of Nothing

I had seriously considered voting for Dusty Johnson. People I deeply respect support him. Further, in the 2018 primary he did not appear to be a Trump sycophant.

Recently, Johnson seems to have lost his ability to exercise any sort of judgement and has veered toward being a Trump cultist. Johnson asserts that Trump came to Sioux Falls and seemed "well-versed . . . in the nuances of the issues." (HT Dakota Free Press)

Yeah, about that. Last night, Daniel Dale tweeted this image of a partial transcript of Trump's remarks in Sioux Falls.

Click to enlarge. No amount of enlarging will enable one to see nuance

Asserting that China and India are big doesn't reflect nuance. Neither does asserting that Japan and India "called." Conflating the size of a country's population with the size of it's economy is hardly nuanced analysis.

By far my favorite part of this "nuanced" analysis is Trump's view of the miraculous.
What's happened has been very much a miracle, but they haven't seen the miracle yet. The miracle is going to start , because now we're getting things ready.
So, there's a miracle that "has happened" but no one "has seen the miracle yet" because it "is going to start." That language may work for a cult leader but let's not call it nuanced.

We've all heard the silly question "If a tree falls in the forest, but there's no one who hears it, does it make any noise?" With Trump, one can adapt the question about noise to a statement: When Trump talks about miracles that have happened but are going to start, one can be certain it's only noise. In fact, one can adapt a famous Shakespearean quotation to all of Trump's utterances: they are "full of sound and fury signifying nothing."

Monday, August 6, 2018

This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things

I am so old I can remember that people of the generation of the men pictured here vilified young folk for wearing Che Guevara T shirts, wouldn't support anyone who was "soft on Russia," and loved freedom fighters who fought murderous dictators.

I'm also old enough to remember when folks like these gentlemen would scream "America, love it or leave it!" at anyone who wore a t-shirt like those worn in the picture. In 2018, however, these gentlemen seem to believe that "owning the libs"  means that people old enough to know better indicate that they prefer a corrupt dictator propped up by corrupt oligarchs over an American political party.

I can even remember when age connoted a bit of wisdom. That's no longer the case either. We were promised a republic if we could keep. With reasoning skills like this, we may not keep it much longer.

People who are stupid an proud of it are a chief reason we can't have nice things.
Photo from here.




Tuesday, July 31, 2018

A Minor Musing On The Cult Of Trump

Trying to compare Donald Trump to his predecessors is always a difficult task. I have preferred comparisons to Richard Nixon or Warren Harding, usually the latter. Others prefer to group him with impeached Presidents Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton.

Recently, comparisons have gone beyond former Presidents. For example,  some have taken to likening him to Joseph McCarthy.

A recent CBS News poll, however, has a new statistic that prompts a new comparison. According to the poll "strong Trump supporters" trust Trump more than their family to deliver the accurate information. The margin is not even close. Among his "strong' supporters Trump has a 28% advantage over friends and family when it comes to "who do you trust for accurate information?'

From CBS News poll.
These results are not partisanship; they're cult like. True believers trusting their leader or irrationally revering their leader is one of the first identifiers of a cult. Trusting a distant leader who communicates without speaking in complete sentences more than one's friends or family fits that category.

This is hardly the first sign that Trump's true believers venerate Trump as others have venerated cult leaders. Salena Zito who is one of the main apologists for Trump supporters has co-authored The Great Revolt: Inside the Populist Coalition Reshaping American Politics. (I will buy the paperback and try to review it.)  Zito also writes a regular opinion column for The Washington Examiner. Several weeks ago, she published "'Not a morally upstanding guy,' yet Trump has the love of millions of Christian conservatives," a piece which profiles Jill Gilmore, "a college-educated, gun-owning female conservative Republican who voted for Donald Trump"  Gilmore "is also a devout Evangelical Christian" whom Zito views as a "King Cyrus Conservative." Cyrus was the Persian king who allowed the Jews to return Jerusalem.

In short, Trump's true believers assign him a prophetic role beyond that of regular mortals. Therein lies the cliched rub; no debate is now possible. If 91% of his strongest supporters trust him for accurate information above anyone else, then my argument that he's like a cult leader will be dismissed. So will the possibility that North Korea is building new missiles; Russia has the potential to take down the U.S power grid, or that nations are signing trade deals without the US. Trump after all has said that North Korea is no longer a threat, that he trusts Putin, and that trade wars are easy. Trump has already said that his supporters shouldn't "believe what you're seeing," so they no other choice but to believe their cult leader.


Sunday, July 15, 2018

Inflation Wipes Out Wage Gains: So Much Winning

The Chicago Tribune points to the fact that workers like farmers are feeling the brunt of the trade war.
The cost of food, shelter and gas have all risen significantly in the past year. Gas skyrocketed more than 24 percent, rent for a primary residence jumped 3.6 percent and meals at restaurants and cafeterias rose 2.8 percent. 
Prices have risen roughly at the same rate as wages, erasing any gains workers may have hoped to realize via bigger paychecks. 
"While the labor market remains historically tight, the pace of U.S. inflation is now outpacing wage gains late in the business cycle," said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at RSM, an audit and advisory firm. "The U.S. is now ensnared in a three front trade war which will in the near to medium term result in higher prices." 
For workers, more pain may be coming, as economists are concerned that prices could rise further due to President Trumps tariffs on many foreign imports. Trump put a 20 tariff on foreign washing machines earlier this year, and the inflation report Thursday showed more than a 13 percent spike in laundry equipment over the same period last year. 
"Expect rising transportation costs to start getting passed on to us, along with the tariff induced jump in costs," said Peter Boockvar, chief investment officer of Bleakley Advisory Group.
This article reminded me of another time WIN was a key part of the political discussion. During the 70s, it stood for "whip inflation now." There were even pins.

Whip Inflation Now pin circa 1974
From Wikipedia
We're nowhere near the levels of inflation that existed in the 1970s. Trump's policies may, however, be creating the conditions that will produce double digit inflation. Trump stole "Make America Great" from Reagan. With his love of "winning," he has a ready made slogan used during the Ford administration.

Wednesday, July 11, 2018

A Musing About Perspective, Kavanaugh, Summits, And Normality

It may be a week for the history books. On Monday, President Trump nominated Brett Kavanaugh to to be the next justice on the Supreme Court. Today, he's at the NATO Summit, and later this week he'll meet with Russian leader Vladimir Putin.

The following tweets may provide some prospective on Kavanaugh and provide some guidance for what promises to be a week and summer of sturm und drang.

First, there's this portion of a Susan Hennessey thread.


Second, there's this Leon Wood tweet
While Hennessey and Wood disagree about whether Kavanaugh is a good pick, they agree that Trump is a deleterious influence on the Republic. They also agree that Kavanaugh is a pick any Republican President would have made. As Hennessy succinctly puts it, the Kavanaugh nomination "is politics as usual."

What's not politically usual, however is a President strongly criticizing allies on the eve of a summit, praising a dictator NATO was designed to confront, and imposing tariffs at a whim. It is also highly unusual to randomly pardon people for arson and occupying government property so soon after they have been sentenced.

I don't know if Republicans in the House and Senate will ever develop a spine let alone the adamantium infused one necessary to confront Trump, a juvenile, stubborn, vile man who has the hubris of a tragic hero. I know the Democrats want to pick up every gauntlet Trump throws down. There may be some political genius who knows how to fight all of these fights at once, but he or she is remaining quiet. Absent expert leadership, it might be best to fight to keep the abnormal from becoming normal and allowing the normal, no matter how bad, to remain a fight for another time.

During this week and the rest of the summer Putin may well back the United States into a corner as the American and world's economies begin a dangerous downward spiral because of Trump's foolish trade war. Returning to normal may not be possible if those events transpire; normality may be possible if the worst event of the summer is Kavanaugh's confirmation.

Friday, July 6, 2018

Can Communities Survive The World of Trump?

I don't get out much. I'm not sure if it's because I took perverse pride in a report card that said "does not play well with others" or because I accepted as a gospel-like injunction Groucho Marx's statement "I don't want to belong to any club that would accept me as one of its members" without knowing that it was a letter of resignation from a club.

Instead of going out, I spend too much time watching YouTube videos about fountain pens, folding knives, other everyday carry gear, comic books, and books. Many content producers discuss their own wonderful communities. There is apparently, a "fountain pen community," a "gear community," and a "BookTube community." It's unclear whether my buying more than a few pens or pocket knives and my leaving a few comments on random videos makes me a member of any of these communities, so I muse about the term community while I drink too much Koffee Kult coffee, a product that a member of the gear community introduced to me.

As the country has had a month of discussions about bakers baking or not baking cakes for same sex couples' weddings and whether a restaurant should have served Sarah Sanders, I have mused a bit more about flesh and blood communities.

That musing is why this Donald Trump tweet alarms me more than his usual bluster.
If one takes this 280 character missive seriously, then my neighbor who puts a sign for a Democratic candidate for the state legislature in his yard wants to take away my Republican neighbor's job and usher in anarchy. If my Republican neighbors truly desire justice and order, can they break bread at the church potluck with someone who wants to "let drugs pour into our cities"? Is it truly safe to let Democrat who will "let MS-13 run wild in our communities" coach little league or youth soccer? Won't they actively recruit the young'uns into gang activity?

I'm sure good Republicans will tell me this tweet is just campaign rhetoric meant to produce a few liberal tears and nothing more. Hyperbole is, after all, an accepted device for times when an author wants to nothing more than tell a big lie. Yet history is replete with examples of humans accepting and acting upon a big lie about other ethnic groups, religions, or political parties. None of those examples produced law, order, or justice.

Perhaps I have taken to heart too deeply the line from Men in Black "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals . . ." and should trust others more. However, if one reverses the line and decides that a person may become a panicky dangerous animal but people are smart, it took only one person to decide that a pizza parlor was a base for pedophiles to fire his gun inside the restaurant. I am sufficiently pessimistic to believe the next person who acts on hot rhetoric will be a better shot.

There's probably some bad joke about the fountain pen, or in this case keyboard, being mightier than the sword or watching more gear community videos to get my bugout bag or bug-in preps in order, but I'm just going to state I've start worrying that small town or large city community may not be possible when one political party sees itself as the sole protector of law order and justice and believes the other side is actively producing anarchy and chaos.

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

I Rise To The Bait And Respond To A Trump Tweet

I get it. The 45th President of the United States likes creating kerfuffles by tweeting things that outrage his opponents who then provide responses that give him fodder to use at his rallies. It's a tried and true propaganda technique. That said, this tweet goes too far even for the low standards the nation has set for Trump.

Let's leave aside for the moment that this deal is more vague and less enforceable than the one struck by the Clinton administration and that Trump himself began the war rhetoric with "fire and fury" tweets.

"Our Country’s biggest enemy is the Fake News so easily promulgated by fools!" is a direct assault on the First Amendment. Pointing out that something the President considers an accomplishment may indeed be flawed makes one the nation's "biggest enemy"? Bigger than Russia? China? Iran? By the way even if North Korea does give up its nuclear program, that doesn't mean it won't have offensive cyber warfare program and there are plenty of vulnerabilities.

We were given a republic and told it was our duty to keep it. Pointing out a leader's flaws is part of that duty and doesn't make one an "enemy."