Showing posts with label Guns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guns. Show all posts

Sunday, January 26, 2020

HB 1078 And Exempting Guns From The Sales Tax: A Minor Musing

It's difficult to take  HB 1078, a bill to exempt guns, bullets, and gunpowder from sales tax seriously.

First, some of its sponsors frequently seem more interested in triggering the libs than they are in passing productive legislation.

Second, it's entirely possible the bill is merely a vehicle for a scorecard issuing group with a name like People Perpetuating Pistoliers into Perpetuity to point out someone they deem a Republican in Name Only (RINO) lacks perfect fealty to the Second Amendment.

For this post, let's stipulate that Representatives Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, and Weis along with Senators (Phil)  Jensen and Monroe have every intention of passing this legislation.

Their argument likely proceeds as follows.
  1. The right to self-defense is a human right.

  2. That right is enshrined in the Second Amendment.

  3. With rights come responsibilities and citizens have a duty to carry firearms to protect themselves.

  4. When South Dakota taxes guns and ammunition, the state places an onerous burden on citizens' efforts to exercise that right and fulfill their duty.

  5. No state should place onerous burdens on the exercising of rights; therefore, items necessary to exercise a right, in this case guns and ammunition, should be exempt from the sales tax.
One wonders if sponsors Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, Weis, (Phil)  Jensen, and Monroe have thought through the ramifications of the argument because points 4 and 5 tacitly admit that South Dakota's sales tax is regressive.

Further, if humans indeed have an inalienable right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness," it follows that they have a right to items, like food,  that are necessary to exercise the right to life. If the solution to solve regression is exempting items from the sales tax, then there shouldn't be any argument against exempting groceries

I haven't heard the the bill's sponsors speak on the issue, but they may believe guns are more necessary than groceries. That's a tough argument to win. People need to eat more frequently than they need to use a gun for self-defense or any other reason. I'd wager that they and everyone who reads this post has eaten more often than they have used a gun in self-defense.

Perhaps their argument is that states as an entity should protect guns and not protect butter. That analogy has a fraught history.

In short, legislators Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, Weis, (Phil)  Jensen, and Monroe seem to have been too clever by half. In creating legislation that tacitly admits that South Dakota's tax structure is regressive, they are laying the groundwork necessary to eliminate the sales tax on food. I doubt that was their intention.

Sunday, January 13, 2019

A Modest Proposal To Amend HB 1041

Last year, I wrote a post about my Republicanism. Since then, I have read a good number of conservative authors at places like The National Review and The American Conservative. These articles repeatedly pointed out that conservatives and Republicans believe in freedom and responsibility, Further, Republicans and conservatives understand, in ways that other mammals cannot, that the world is filled with bad actors.

HB 1041 is a bill to "provide for the carrying of a concealed pistol without a permit." The legislation's sponsors certainly will contend that they proposed the legislation because they realize that freedom to carry pistols without a permit is the only available method to stop unabated wickedness wherever a good conservative or Republican  may find it.

According to the Argus Leader,
Republican Rep. Drew Dennert is sponsoring a constitutional carry bill in the House. He says backers have the promise of the governor and support from the public and both legislative chambers.
Given that Governor Noem seems supportive, one hates to temper the enthusiasm of "constitutional carry" advocates. Obviously every Republican or conservative who carries a pistol under HB 1041 will train weekly to become as proficient with a pistol as Wild Bill Hickok, Such people will, of course, never crack under pressure nor will they ever miss their intended target.

That said, South Dakota still retains a few Democrats. Some have even been elected to the legislature. The state also has a university system, and these educational institutions are known to be the last bastions of socialists and other nefarious scoundrels. It is, therefore, not beyond the realm of possibility that an irresponsible person might take unfair advantage of the "constitutional carry" freedom provision and carry a concealed pistol or several concealed pistols. Because South Dakota is home to 800,000 resident, it is not unlikely that several thousand feckless folk may abuse the the "constitutional carry" freedom. These capricious citizens may accidentally wound themselves or others.

It, therefore, becomes one's duty to offer a modest proposal, with all due apologies to Jonathan Swift, in the form of an amendment to rectify the situation.

The amendment would require every person carrying a concealed pistol also carry a trauma kit. The kit would contain gauze with a clotting agent, a chest seal, a trauma bandage, medical tape, a tourniquet, and heavy duty medical gloves. It would also require that the person carrying the concealed pistol and trauma kit should be able to show proof of competency with the medical items being carried. This proof could be demonstrated either by certificate of training or a field test consisting of properly applying the tourniquet and other items in the kit.

Some conservatives or Republicans may contend that this proposal springs from some hidden liberal bias. In an effort to allay such fears, prudence moves me to point out that a Blue Force Gear Micro Trauma Kit NOW won the 2018 NRA Golden Bullseye Award for "Accessory of The Year." If it as an approved NRA accessory, surely conservatives and Republicans cannot object to making it part of a "constitutional carry" law. (Neither the NRA nor Blue Force Gear sponsor this blog.)

I cannot conceive of a Republican or conservative legislature not wanting to ensure that freedom is accompanied with responsibility, so I eagerly anticipate sponsorship, debate, and passage of the amendments proposed above.

Saturday, July 28, 2018

Chart Of The Day: When It Comes To Killing People . . .

Americans increasingly take the easy way out.

The Centers for Disease Control documented a 31% increase in gun related homicides from 2014-2016. The use of the two next most used homicide methods, cutting and suffocation, has remained stable.

From CDC
Click to enlarge.

Sunday, July 8, 2018

Some Musings About Guns, Unlocked Cars, And Responsibility

A quick search of the blog will find posts opposing South Dakota's school sentinel plan, musings about guns being a fetish, and implications, if not direct statements, that the nation has too many guns.

I haven't changed any of those opinions during the past few years when this blog was relatively dormant. The best case scenario for a school sentinel involves gunshot wounds with nary a tourniquet in sight. I continue to be befuddled by straight white males whose fetishes involve guns rather than a red-headed dominatrix. The United States has at least 265 million guns, more than enough for every adult to own one.

I try to understand other viewpoints. Many of the everyday carry gear folk that I follow on YouTube do gun videos. A few months ago, after one the mass shootings, YouTube began limiting some gun content. One of the people I follow, The Last Boy Scout, published this short video in response:



At about 31 seconds in, Lane says, "I don't carry a gun because I hate the government. I carry a gun because governing myself is my first responsibility." At 53 seconds in he says, "I don't carry a gun to feel like a man. I carry a gun because I am a man and because men take care of themselves and the people they love." Finally, at 1:10, he concludes, "I don't carry a gun because I love guns; I carry a gun because I love life, and I love the people who make my life worth living."

In short, the video asserts that people carry guns because it's the responsible thing to do.

I thought about this video a few weeks ago when Dakota War College took issue with a proposed Sioux Falls City ordinance designed to "penalize gun owners who don't keep their firearms locked up." I was reminded of it again when reading this South DaCola post. 

South DaCola links to this Keloland report that quotes Minnehaha County Sheriff Mike Milstead:
"You know, because you would be taking legit, lawful gun owners and making them criminals because we're trying to prevent other criminals from stealing their guns. I hate to make lawful gun owners into criminals," said Milstead.  
Milstead says he would much prefer gun owners just do what they're supposed to; which is lock up the dangerous weapon they don't want being used to hurt others. 
"You'd feel horrible if your gun was stolen out of your car, where you'd left it unlocked. And ultimately it ends up being used by somebody to kill somebody, to rob somebody, to commit a violent crime," said Milstead.
Logic would dictate that loving "the people who make make . . . life worth living," "taking care of themselves and the people they love," and accepting that "governing myself is my first responsibility" implies locking up guns safely when the weapons are not in use. And yet, if gun owners fail to fulfill their responsibility, the only recourse their fellow citizens have is to hope the irresponsible party feels "horrible" if the gun is "stolen from an unlocked car" and "ultimately it ends up being used by somebody to kill somebody, to rob somebody, to commit a violent crime."

"Feeling horrible" is an emotion that ought to accompany accidentally spilling a glass of red wine on a woman's white dress. In that situation, the emotion should be accompanied by the responsible action of paying to clean or replace the dress. Making it easier to "kill somebody, to rob somebody, [and] to commit a violent crime" should have a  consequence beyond one that comes with ruining a dress, but apparently in South Dakota, gun ownership is only about rights not responsibility.

Monday, August 3, 2015

Another Angry Image Of The Day

This image came across my Twitter feed over the weekend.


Picture from here.
The man, carrying a rifle and who has his hand on his handgun, was part of a rally held at Stone Mountain, Georgia to support the Confederate flag. As I understand the story, the man in the white t-shirt burned a Confederate battle flag to protest the rally. Until the hand went to handgun, both men were engaging in provocative political speech that the First Amendment is designed to protect.

This image troubles leaves me with dozens of questions, but I'll ask just three.

First, is the police officer preternaturally calm or would his reaction have been different if an African American had had his hand on the gun?

Second, has the nation really come to the point that any political speech must be loud and any speech which violates one's sensibilities must be responded to with the threat of violence?

Most importantly, if the answer to the second question is "yes," what can citizens do to protect free speech rights?

Thursday, September 19, 2013

Guns Rights Advocates Willing To Throw Away Every Other Constitutional Right

John Stewart does the honors.

If forced to choose, I'd rank the First Amendment and the Fourth Amendment ahead of the Second. I believe that the rights protected by the former are much more fragile. On a snarky level, I believe that the right to proclaim faith in or deny faith in the Holy Trinity is more important than purchasing faith in Colt, Smith, and Wesson. That said, I would never want to eviscerate the Second Amendment the way Lindsey Graham (R-SC) and the others Stewart skewers in clip do.


If Abraham Lincoln had possessed the prophetic ability to foresee that South Carolina would one day elect Lindsey Graham to the United States Senate, I'm willing to bet he would have let the state secede.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

Have Guns Become a Religion?

I ask because actress Katee Sackhoff lost 100,000 followers for the following tweet:
Sackhoff has a bit of cult following because she played Starbuck in Battlestar Galactica and plays Vic Moretti on Longmire.* Her timeline has tweets about filming Longmire, hockey, and her Harley. None seem overtly political.

It seems odd that an admission that the U.S. has a strong gun culture and an admonition to practice gun safety is offensive to 100,000 people. It wasn't a call for political action to ban assault weapons, toughen background checks, create database of gun owners.

Twitter may not be conducive to rational, reasoned debate, but this reaction smacks of zealotry that one finds in true believers not an actress's casual fans who have been disappointed by scandal.

*For what it's worth, Craig Johnson's Longmire books are great reads.

Monday, May 6, 2013

The NRA And Decency: Two Things That Don't Go Together

Let's walk through this step by step.

First, Wayne LaPierre believes Hollywood produces too many violent movies::
“We have blood-soaked films out there, like ‘American Psycho,’ ‘Natural Born Killers’ that are aired like propaganda loops on splatter days.”
In addition, he also believes video games are too violent:
“There exists in this country, sadly, a callous, corrupt and corrupting shadow industry that sells and stows violence against its own people through vicious and violent video games.”
Further, the media glorifies mass murderers and this glorification produces copycat murderers
“How many more copycats are waiting in the wings for their moment of fame from a national media machine that rewards them with wall-to-wall attention and a sense of identity they crave?”
On the other hand, selling a "shoot it until it bleeds" zombie target that closely and intentionally resembles President Obama during the NRA convention doesn't seem to be a problem unless some liberals will complain. Buzzfeed provides the details about the target that was displayed for two days and sold during the duration of the NRA convention:

"Someone from the NRA came by and asked us to remove it" a Zombie Industries booth worker told BuzzFeed in hushed tones. "They thought it looked too much like President Obama."
When asked if the Obama likeness was intentional the worker said, "Let's just say I gave my Republican father one for Christmas."
"They are just scared some liberal reporter will come by and start bitching" another booth worker said to men gathered around the booth. "But ya know, he does look very familiar."
Shoot It Until It Bleeds Target
Of course, one can rename the target "Barry."


Let's review, according to the NRA violent films and video games are "callous" and "corrupt," but shooting a target designed to look like the President is just good clean fun.

As the group's spokesperson, LaPierre has a First Amendment right to be classless and hypocritical; I wish had a sense of shame.

Friday, May 3, 2013

Getting Ready For A Revolution?

Gordon Howie's hyperbole is usually good for a laugh, but this morning Gordon outdid himself. He issued the following blast implying that President Obama is on the road to exterminating Christians with Hitleresque precision:
It has always amazed me how Hitler could exterminate so many Jews with so little resistance.  I can’t help but wonder if Obama is being equally successful in the early stages of a “War on Christians”.
Will America’s Christian leaders PLEASE stand up and speak out?!!! 
If Obama is engaged in "the early stages of a war," one wonders how long it will be before Gordon goes calling on people to do more than speak out.

Some allegedly responsible folk already are. Jim Porter, the NRA's president, apparently wasn't satisfied with the results of the last one in the 1860s, so he's advocating people prepare for another one:
In a June speech, Porter noted the NRA was “started by some Yankee generals who didn’t like the way my Southern boys had the ability to shoot in what we call the ‘War of Northern Aggression.’ ”
“Now y’all might call it the Civil War, but we call it the ‘War of Northern Aggression’ down South,” Porter said to the New York State Rifle & Pistol Association.
He also advocates training all U.S. civilians to use standard military firearms so “they’re ready to fight tyranny.”
Porter apparently has a lot of company. A Fairleigh Dickinson University poll taken in late April finds a large sector of the Republican party believes armed revolution might be necessary with in the next few years.
Overall, the poll finds that 29 percent of Americans think that an armed revolution in order to protect liberties might be necessary in the next few years, with another five percent unsure. However, these beliefs are conditional on party. Just 18 percent of Democrats think an armed revolution may be necessary, as opposed to 44 percent of Republicans and 27 percent of independents.
 The poll might be flawed. It sampled only 863 people, but I have to agree with big boy blogger Ed Kilgore:
You can dismiss it for its sample size or its question order or its wording if you want, but I’m sorry: when nearly half the self-identified members of one of our two major political parties in any sample looks benignly on the possibility of “armed revolution”—particularly when it’s the supposedly conservative party—we’ve got real problems. If the actual percentage of Republicans thinking positively about armed revolution as a near-term necessity is 15%, we’ve got real problems. [italics in original] 
There's little logic in Howie's assertion that Obama is at war with Christians; Obama is a Christian, so he probably would not be attempting to engage in war against himself.  For his part, Porter is as illogical as Howie if he truly believes the Civil War was about Northern aggression rather than Southern efforts to preserve slavery.

It doesn't take much effort to see how people who believe a Hilteresque leader will lead an aggressive war against Americans because of their religious faith will see the need to prepare for an armed revolt "in the next few years." It's unclear how any of those beliefs are reasonable, conservative, or Christian.

Thursday, April 18, 2013

So What's Next?

"A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed"

It's unclear how a well regulated militia helps secure a free state if the members of the militia are criminals or mentally unstable. The army is dealing with the ramifications of inadequate background checks now:
In Irregular Army, Kennard documents a series of disturbing trends in the military: lowered standards, inadequately treated mental-health and substance-abuse problems, and the enlistment and retention of white supremacists, Nazis, and gang members.
It's also unclear why a senator who is viewed as a champion of freedom calls those petitioning government for the redress of grievances "props" and is saddened to see them there of their own free will.
With the fate of gun control legislation in doubt, Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) accused President Obama of using the victims of the Newtown elementary school shootings as “props” to advance an agenda that would have done nothing to prevent the massacre.
“I think gun control is a legitimate issue for our country to debate,” he said at a Christian Science Monitor breakfast Wednesday morning. But the Kentucky senator said that looking at the parents of Newtown victims who have spoken in favor of gun control legislation, ”I think in some cases the president has used them as props.”
“When I see the father and the mothers and them testifying — and I know they’re coming voluntarily, and they want to come and be part of this debate — but it still saddens me just to see them, and I think that in some cases the president has used them as props. And that disappoints me,” he said.
My guess is that those who support the Second Amendment over everything else will seek to weaken protections in the First, Fourth, and Fifth. God willing, they will be unsuccessful.

There have been 900,000 gun deaths since 1970. The violent crime trend seems to be lowering, so let's be optimistic and project 750,000 gun deaths between now and 2050. Are we to believe that background checks will not prevent thousands of those deaths?

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Proof Of The Debilitating Effects Of South Dakota's Brain Drain (Sort Of)

One has no choice but to be sorely disappointed in South Dakota's leading government officials. Unique among the 50 laboratories of democracy, the state has produced laws authorizing school districts to hire private pistoliers. Yet, no state official, not Governor Daugaard, not Attorney General Jackley, not Secretary of State Gant, not a single legislator has exhibited the creativity to come up with an a recruitment slogan to take advantage of South Dakota's unique accomplishment. No one has uttered a phrase that that can fit on a business card or bumper sticker to draw new residents

Texas, however, has produced a slogan: Texas, a state that talks big-- ". . . in Texas, the Second Amendment is right up there with mother, God and apple pie"--but in reality is all hat and no cattle:
Texas Rep. Dan Flynn, a Republican co-author of a bill allowing guns on college campuses, said opposition from public universities and big cities has so far kept the measure from coming to a vote. But the Legislature doesn't adjourn until Memorial Day.
 Texas has phrasing that can fit on a bumper sticker:
Bumper sticker from this Justin Green Post
If the state can't market its unique achievements poseurs like Texas successfully market their second-rate achievements,  perhaps South Dakota should consider fully funding the formula that determines state aid to schools instead of passing laws to fill the holsters of John Wayne wannabes.

Saturday, March 30, 2013

Defining Freedom Down

Earlier today, I mentioned this Bob Mercer post that points out that groups that grade government transparency aren't necessarily transparent. It turns out that groups that grade freedom have skewed version of freedom.

Constant Conservative points to the Mercatus Center study that finds that the Dakotas are the freest states in the United States and rejoices:
So, congratulations fellow citizens (and the government which you all helped to elect). We may not be doing everything right, but we are doing better than many
As with the transparency study, things are not what they seem. Mercatus sees economic freedom, especially a low tax burden, as the most important freedom. The ability to avail one's self of a prostitute while high and shoot a gun to celebrate seem to be the most important personal freedoms:
Fiscal Policy (35.3%)
The fiscal policy dimension consists of the following categories: Tax Burden (28.6%), Government Employment (2.8%), Government Spending (1.9%), Government Debt (1.2%), and Fiscal Decentralization (0.9%).
Regulatory Policy (32.0%)
The regulatory policy dimension consists of the following categories: Freedom from Tort Abuse (11.5%), Property Right Protection (7.6%), Health Insurance Freedom (5.4%), Labor Market Freedom (3.8%), Occupational Licensing Freedom (1.7%), Miscellaneous Regulatory Freedom (1.3%), and Cable and Telecom Freedom (0.8%).
Personal Freedom (32.7%)
Personal freedom dimension consists of the following categories: Victimless Crime Freedom (9.8%), Gun Control Freedom (6.6%), Tobacco Freedom (4.1%), Alcohol Freedom (2.8%), Marriage Freedom (2.1%), Marijuana and Salvia Freedom (2.1%), Gambling Freedom (2.0%), Education Policy (1.9%), Civil Liberties (0.6%), Travel Freedom (0.5%), Asset Forfeiture Freedom (0.1%), and Campaign Finance Freedom (0.02%).
The economic freedoms certainly dominate the results. Paul Waldman writes that "the factors that matter are things like low taxes, lack of gun control, and "freedom from tort abuse," i.e. laws that make it hard to sue when your surgeon cuts off the wrong leg."

As for civil liberties, Timothy Lee points out they aren't really considered:
The right to own a gun is given five times as much weight as the “civil liberties” category, described as a “grab bag of mostly unrelated policies, including raw milk laws, fireworks laws, prostitution laws, physician-assisted suicide laws, religious freedom restoration acts, rules on taking DNA samples from criminal suspects, trans-fat bans, and laws that can be used to prosecute people who audiorecord public officials in the performance of their duties.”
Alex Pareene adds:
“Economic freedom” is of course their most important freedom, and so it is weighted the heaviest, with fiscal and regulatory matters making up a bit more than two-thirds of each state’s score. Which is how their No. 1 freest state is ranked 39th on the “Civil Liberties” list. Though that list is fairly useless, as their definition of “civil liberties” is “unrelated policies, such as fireworks laws, prostitution laws, and trans-fat bans.” On the list taking into account “incarceration rates, non-drug crime arrests, and drug enforcement,” Freest State North Dakota is at 24. (Second-freest state South Dakota is 48.) And Arizona has climbed to No. 11 on the overall list, because at no point are the rights of immigrants or people whom the police may suspect are immigrants taken into account
Pareene concludes, "Almost any Liberty issue that wouldn’t concern a straight, white, male capitalist is wholly ignored."

Lee, Waldman, and Pareene all exhibit a bit of urban arrogance toward the rural lifestyle and they show little appreciation for winter. That being said, short lines at a Hy-Vee checkout along with relief from heat and humidity does not necessarily make one free. Neither does emphasizing wealth  over civil liberties. In fact the latter situation makes Janis Joplin's lyrics more relevant. (I know it's a trite thing to do, but hearing Janis on a Saturday afternoon makes me feel good.)


Friday, March 15, 2013

A Minor Musing About Pistol Packing Preachers, Wish Fulfillment, And South Dakota Politics

I really want to move on from the school pistolier issue. Until proven otherwise, I hope the conventional wisdom expressed by Pat Powers and others that few schools will choose to arm school personnel will be proven correct:
I suspect it will be fewer than five. But – they’re going to be in the middle of nowhere, and have a long response time from law enforcement.
Bob Mercer, however, has caused me to have a mustard seed size bit of doubt in that conventional wisdom. In responding to a Madville Times post about a Yankton Press & Dakotan editorial that had the temerity to disagree with his rosy assessment of the past session, Mercer writes:
The nucleus of support for that bill, by the way, came out of Rapid City, Sioux Falls and the Sioux Falls suburbs.
Mercer, a wordsmith of no meager skill, does not say from "representatives of" those cities and suburbs. The omission seems telling, and makes me wonder if there may be efforts to implement school pistoliers in areas other than rural West River.

On the other hand, it's entirely possible that the pistol packing promoting preachers, Representatives Hickey and Craig weren't doing the will of a large segment of their constituency. They may have just been engaging in their desire to go Hollywood and rewrite the ending of the under-appreciated Five Card Stud. For those who don't have 4 minutes 27 seconds, the real action begins at about 2:20


Update: I have learned a valuable lesson about writing a post and scheduling it to publish the next morning. I miss the news in the morning papers.. Nathan Johnson has an article about about Yankton 's city and county law enforcement officials' responses to the school pisotlier bill. Pat Powers responds and notes a Brookings Register article.

My doubts about the conventional wisdom being correct are increasing.

Monday, March 11, 2013

A Minor Musing About What Would Happen If Hollywood Reduced Gun Violence

It seems as if people of all political stripes are willing to condemn Hollywood gun violence.

I have a modest proposal. Let's have Hollywood remake two of my favorite television programs and one of my favorite films: The Andy Griffith Show, The Rockford Files, and The Maltese Falcon. The producers should follow the original scripts.

Andy Taylor, Griffith's character famously did not carry gun. Barney Fife, the character that defined Don Knotts's career, infamously was allowed only one bullet for his revolver which he repeatedly discharged accidentally and humorously.

Jim Rockford, played by James Garner, hid his gun in a cookie jar and would only "reluctantly retrieve the gun he stored there." He seldom shot the gun even when he did point it.

In The Maltese Falcon, Samuel Spade, played by Humphrey Bogart, didn't carry a gun because he didn't like them. He did, however, get a lot of practice taking guns away from Wilmer and Joel Cairo. Neither armed man could handle the unarmed Spade unless he kicked Spade while the detective was down after drinking a drugged glass of scotch..

I'll bet a tub of movie theater popcorn with extra butter that the pro-gun crowd would loudly scream liberal bias if Hollywood remade these programs and movie exactly as they were originally made. After all the gun loving characters are inept and the good guys who are competent want to avoid guns. They would contend that the series and movies illustrate and obvious liberal effort to make to make gun users look ridiculous.

By the way, law-abiding liberals might be angry that Rockford carries an unregistered gun. Good people would always follow registration laws after all.

I'll go double or nothing that the NRA would be angry because they wouldn't have any new Hollywood guns to add to their museum.

Saturday, March 9, 2013

Saturday Morning Reads: March 9 Edition

Nathan Johnson delves into the details that South Dakota has 3rd most regressive tax structure in the nation.
According to a recent study by the Institute on Taxation & Economic Policy (ITEP), South Dakota had the third-most regressive tax system in the United States as of the beginning of 2013. The bottom 20 percent of the state’s earners pay 11.6 percent of their income in taxes. The top 1 percent pay 2.1 percent.
“One could rightly say that the rate on poor people in South Dakota is 552 percent higher than the rate on those in the top 1 percent,” said Reynold Nesiba, an associate professor of economics at Augustana College. “I think most outside of the top 1 percent of the population would agree that this is grossly unfair and by no stretch of the imagination equitable.”
A self-described liberal gun guy is shilling his book. My take-away doesn't fit the general tone of the interview, so read it for yourself. My take-away:
"The people who buy most of the guns are middle-aged white men who have not finished college.. . [because] gun guys derive [self-esteem] from their guns"
The title alone makes it worth the read: The Professor, the Bikini Model and the Suitcase Full of Trouble

Brew another cup of coffee and enjoy.

Friday, March 8, 2013

Governor Daugaard Signs Another School Bill

Something's missing, but I can't quite put my finger on it.

Teachers? We don't need no stinkin' teachers. We got guns.

Monday, March 4, 2013

South Dakota Legislature Weighs In On Infallibility

I am a Protestant by temperament and tradition, but I am watching the events surrounding Pope Benedict's abdication and the search for his replacement with interest. The Protestant churches have much to learn from their Catholic brothers and sisters when it comes to combining the power of the Holy Spirit with the power of tradition and ritual.

When my Catholic wife and I discuss faith and practice, I save my best debate coach cross-examination questions to ask about the Assumption of Mary and papal infallibility. On the latter, I find no scriptural evidence that anyone can be seen to be infallible on any matter let alone matters of faith and doctrine.

Today, it seems more than a few South Dakota legislators want to extend the doctrine of infallibility to more than one man occupying the office of the Bishop of Rome.  The South Dakota House of Representatives concurred with the school pistolier bill  as passed by the South Dakota Senate. The bill will now be sent to Governor Daugaard.

In effect, the South Dakota Legislature has decided that some people with little formal training will be infallible in matters of guns and school shootings. Inherent in the logic behind putting more guns in schools is the belief that pistoliers will never err. They will never mistakenly shoot a student who is not armed. They will never miss if they confront an actual shooter. According to the logic behind this bill, the pistoliers will be infallible in matters of life and death.

I'm just a farm boy. I do my best to work out my salvation with fear and trembling. I don't claim to be infallible on matters of doctrine. I also don't trust those who have the hubris to believe that they will be infallible when confronting a school shooter.



Thursday, February 14, 2013

CISPA Proves Guns Never Will Be The Answer

PNR points to a story about an Amish farmer who was arrested by a SWAT team of federal agents because he dared sell raw milk. I must confess that I had no idea consuming raw milk was a crime nor do I know if I am a wanted criminal because I consumed thousands of gallons of raw milk from 1957 until 1975. I may have even delivered some raw cream for my mother who sold the dangerous product for the obscene sum of 50 cents a quart. I feel pretty healthy for a 55 year old. At any rate, I hope the statute of limitations has lapsed.

PNR uses the story not to extol the virtues of raw milk but to illustrate the need for the 2nd Amendment. According to PNR, the incident illustrates that citizens need guns to defend themselves from overzealous government officials.

Let's begin with some basics. the government doesn't need a SWAT team to take down Amish farmers. Armed citizens who shoot at federal agents will not fare well. I hope both statements are uncontroversial

More importantly, no gun will defend a citizen from agents acting under the ridiculously broad guidelines of CISPA, the Cyber Intelligence Sharing And Protection Act. When CISPA first came on the scene last year, Lifehacker reported:
Essentially, CISPA makes it possible for private companies to share potential cyber threat information with the government if the government concludes it needs it for cyber security information (and vice versa) immediately, without a complicated process.
That "complicated process" involves a minor thing called a warrant, something the SWAT team had, although the "no knock" component of the warrant in the Amish farmer incident is ludicrious. Lifehacker continues:
The privacy implications of the broadly defined "cybersecurity threat" is the cause for concern among CISPA's opposition. It's feared the information gathered would be released too easily and would violate the Fourth Amendment because it offers a simple, warrantless means to acquire personal data.
Several other advocacy groups echo this sentiment, including the American Library Association, which has this to say:
The ALA is concerned that all private electronic communications could be obtained by the government and used for many purposes–and not just for cybersecurity activities. H.R.3523 would permit, and sometimes even require, Internet service providers and other entities to monitor all electronic communications and share personal information with the government without effective oversight by claiming the sharing is for "cybersecurity purposes."
Today Computerworld reports that the legislation which was stopped last year has been re-introduced and reminds readers that the law protects both the government and Internet giants like Facebook:
CISPA also overrides existing privacy law and would grant broad immunities against lawsuits and liabilities to participating companies, EFF policy analyst Mark Jaycox wrote in a blog post Wednesday.

Importantly, there are few transparency provisions in the legislation, Jaycox wrote. Information collected by private companies and provided to the government would be exempt from Freedom of Information Act requests, he noted. There is also nothing in the bill that would require companies to inform users if their information is shared with the government, he said.
There are 310 million guns in the US. There's not a single one of them that will protect anyone from governmental overreach like CISPA. Of course the 2nd Amendment only crowd will continue to ignore encroachments on the 4th Amendment so they can protect themselves from roaming Latino gangs, an assertion that causes one to wonder if Wayne Lapierre could pass a background check.

Monday, February 11, 2013

Tweets Of The Day: Barbarism Edition

Tweets of the day:

Sunday, February 10, 2013

A Minor Musing About Fear And Normativity

Over at The Madville Times, PNR offers the following bit of wisdom: It's always easy to say my fears are realistic and yours aren't."

He's speaking about South Dakota's proposed school pistolier bill and other gun laws. Although I am positive that some bean counter buried deep within the catacombs of some insurance company can provide a statistical certainty that additional guns in school increase the risk of innocents being killed, PNR rightfully asserts likelihood of a school shooter or a sanctioned pistolier in South Dakota killing someone are relatively small.

If one goes a level deeper, the real fear is that cherished norms may soon be violated. Professor Terry Eagleton in After Theory presents one of my favorite analyses of normativity:
It is a mistake, however, to believe that norms are always restrictive.  In fact it is a crass Romantic delusion.  It is normative in our kind of society that people do not throw themselves with a hoarse cry on total strangers and amputate their legs.  It is conventional that child murderers are punished, that working men and women may withdraw their labour, and that ambulances speeding to a traffic accident should not be impeded just for the hell of it.  Anyone who fells oppressed by all this must be seriously oversensitive.  Only an intellectual who has overdosed on abstraction could be dim enough to imagine that whatever bends a norm is potentially radical.Eagleton, AfterTheory 15
A similar norm would be that first graders are not to be shot in cold blood. I had always believed that norm provided the reason that guns stayed out of a school building. For as long as I can remember, those who wanted to hunt after school locked their guns in their vehicle before coming inside.

Further, I had always thought it a norm that the freedoms enshrined in the Bill of Rights had a few limits. One cannot shout fire in a crowded theater if there's no fire. The longer the school pistolier bill discussion goes on the more I'm beginning to believe that the bill's supporters don't see any limits to the second amendment except the size of one's wallet. In short, the only thing preventing one from owning a predator drone is the damned drone is expensive.

Perhaps I've lived in my own personal echo chamber. I don't recall ever having a discussion with anyone about the priorities within the Bill of Rights, but threats to Amendments 1, 9, 4, 5, 6, and 8 worry me far more that real or perceived threats to Amendment 2. (For the record, I have never seriously thought about Amendment 3 and probably couldn't state its subject if I hadn't just looked it up. For the curious but lazy, it forbids housing soldiers in citizens' home without the citizen's consent.) I have also always believed that one should not sacrifice one of the enshrined freedoms to preserve another

I'm guessing here, but it seems that my concern that putting guns in school irrevocably removes an essential norm may be similar to the concerns that opponents of gay marriage or opponents or legalizing marijuana or opponents of a fence across border the express: sanctioning gay marriage, legalizing marijuana, or building that fence somehow irrevocably violates a norm. Hence, the heat generated behind each issue.

Perhaps the discussion needs to move beyond guns, gay marriage, marijuana legalization or whatever the hot button issue is; instead, the discussion should begin by asking what norms should govern our living together.