Tuesday, July 31, 2018

A Minor Musing About Who Should Pay For Job Training

Governor Daugaard continues to insist that education's primary purpose is preparing one for the workplace over preparing one to participate in broader public square as a citizen. Over at Dakota Free Press, Cory does an excellent job of pointing out the error in that, dare I say, philosophy. Cory concludes,
Unaccounted for in the Governor’s argument is what those aspiring engineers, accountants, nurses, and welders will do with their job-specific high school curriculum twenty years from now when economic forces, experiences, and unforeseen changes of plan render the jobs they thought at age 15 they would do forever untenable, or what knowledge and skills they might find helpful in leading purposeful, fulfilling lives during the two thirds of their working life and the three thirds of their retirement when they won’t be on the job. Those liberal arts still be darned; we’ve got cogs to mill for the economic machine!
If students are to be prepared solely to be chewed up by cogs of the economic machine, Libertarian gubernatorial candidate Kurt Evans throws the proverbial monkey wrench into those cogs by taking Daugaard's premises to their logical ultimate conclusion and then prompting a question that the Governor seems to ignore.
We may need a social consensus for state government to teach elementary students literacy and basic arithmetic, but if a vo-tech does things you don’t like, no government should force you to pay for it.
If the goal of education is to create citizens who can reason and knowledgeably participate in discussions in the public square, then the public should pay for education. If, however, the purpose is solely to prepare someone for a specific job, the public requires only basic literacy and arithmetic. After all, no one wants people holding up the line in the grocery store incorrectly arguing that the person behind the counter gave them the wrong change. In a world of economics uber alles, people still need to read the advertisement copy.

The question then becomes who should pay for the rest. Daugaard never entertains the question. Evans, the consistent Libertarian, hints that the duty should fall on the workplace. Instead of "Our Town Public School" we could have "Fast Food High School" or "Welders and Assemblers Private Institute." A chain of entities called "The Walmart Superschools" could dot the landscape. Whether Daugaard admits it or not, his educational philosophy will eventually lead to the same result only with public funding. It seems reminiscent of the medieval guild system rather than a system to take on 21st Century challenges.

The purpose of education should remain developing citizens who can think creatively and communicate effectively. Schools can improve, but turning them into institutions that create workers prepared for a job that will disappear in 10 years is not going to provide that improvement.

A Minor Musing On The Cult Of Trump

Trying to compare Donald Trump to his predecessors is always a difficult task. I have preferred comparisons to Richard Nixon or Warren Harding, usually the latter. Others prefer to group him with impeached Presidents Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton.

Recently, comparisons have gone beyond former Presidents. For example,  some have taken to likening him to Joseph McCarthy.

A recent CBS News poll, however, has a new statistic that prompts a new comparison. According to the poll "strong Trump supporters" trust Trump more than their family to deliver the accurate information. The margin is not even close. Among his "strong' supporters Trump has a 28% advantage over friends and family when it comes to "who do you trust for accurate information?'

From CBS News poll.
These results are not partisanship; they're cult like. True believers trusting their leader or irrationally revering their leader is one of the first identifiers of a cult. Trusting a distant leader who communicates without speaking in complete sentences more than one's friends or family fits that category.

This is hardly the first sign that Trump's true believers venerate Trump as others have venerated cult leaders. Salena Zito who is one of the main apologists for Trump supporters has co-authored The Great Revolt: Inside the Populist Coalition Reshaping American Politics. (I will buy the paperback and try to review it.)  Zito also writes a regular opinion column for The Washington Examiner. Several weeks ago, she published "'Not a morally upstanding guy,' yet Trump has the love of millions of Christian conservatives," a piece which profiles Jill Gilmore, "a college-educated, gun-owning female conservative Republican who voted for Donald Trump"  Gilmore "is also a devout Evangelical Christian" whom Zito views as a "King Cyrus Conservative." Cyrus was the Persian king who allowed the Jews to return Jerusalem.

In short, Trump's true believers assign him a prophetic role beyond that of regular mortals. Therein lies the cliched rub; no debate is now possible. If 91% of his strongest supporters trust him for accurate information above anyone else, then my argument that he's like a cult leader will be dismissed. So will the possibility that North Korea is building new missiles; Russia has the potential to take down the U.S power grid, or that nations are signing trade deals without the US. Trump after all has said that North Korea is no longer a threat, that he trusts Putin, and that trade wars are easy. Trump has already said that his supporters shouldn't "believe what you're seeing," so they no other choice but to believe their cult leader.


Sunday, July 29, 2018

Scripture And Song For The Week: Psalm 126 Edition

Psalm 126

1When the Lord turned again the captivity of Zion, we were like them that dream.

2 Then was our mouth filled with laughter, and our tongue with singing: then said they among the heathen, The Lord hath done great things for them.

3 The Lord hath done great things for us; whereof we are glad.

4 Turn again our captivity, O Lord, as the streams in the south.

5 They that sow in tears shall reap in joy.

6 He that goeth forth and weepeth, bearing precious seed, shall doubtless come again with rejoicing, bringing his sheaves with him.


Full lyrics of "Democracy"

What's Governor Daugaard's PARG?

When I was a young'un baseball had three offensive stats that mattered, batting average, home runs, and runs batted in (RBI). As time went on, stats like on-base percentage, on-base plus slugging (OPS), and wins above replacement (WAR) become central metrics. (Baseball nerds feel free to insert sabermetrics joke here.)

Politics has far fewer stats than baseball, popularity and elections won or lost might be the only two that matter. Nate Silver, however, has adapted baseball's WAR to develop PARG (popularity over replacement governor) which is computed "by measuring the distance between their net approval rating and their state’s partisan lean"

A couple of days ago, Dakota War College trumpeted a Morning Consult poll that showed Governor Daugaard was the nation's 5th most popular governor. According to the poll, 61% of the state's residents view Daugaard favorably while 24% view him unfavorably, a net 37 favorability.

Silver takes that +37 and compares it with South Dakota's partisan lean, a number developed by combining  the 2008, 2012, and 2016 Presidential election vote totals in the state along with the Cook PVI which "measures how each district performs at the presidential level compared to the nation as a whole. " According to Silver, South Dakota's partisan lean is +29 toward Republicans.

Taking the difference between Daugaard's +37 popularity and the state's partisan lean of +29 gives Daugaard a modest +8 PARG which ranks him number 20 among the nation's governors, hardly a hall of fame number.

Screenshot of PARG rankings
Original found here.



Saturday, July 28, 2018

Chart Of The Day: When It Comes To Killing People . . .

Americans increasingly take the easy way out.

The Centers for Disease Control documented a 31% increase in gun related homicides from 2014-2016. The use of the two next most used homicide methods, cutting and suffocation, has remained stable.

From CDC
Click to enlarge.

Friday, July 27, 2018

A Post Wherein I Offer Billie Sutton Some Unsolicited Advice

I used to tell my young policy debaters to be sure they got their opponents' sources and numbers. It was a central part of understanding an opponents case or disadvantage.

Billie Sutton doesn't need my assistance, but I offer him the same advice if he and Kristi Noem debate next fall.

Over the past few days Noem has hailed the  the trade agreement that Trump announced with the EU. Noem calls Trump "best negotiator we have" and asserts "[h]e's doing an incredible job fighting for our farmers." She claims that the Rose Garden announcement was "wonderful" and that the President will "continue to negotiate" to open more markets.

Let's start with a simple question that seems to have not been asked: when it comes to soybeans how much more will the European Union buy than it would have purchased before the tariff silliness began? Has anyone given a number in bushels or tons or a percentage increase? Heralding a trade deal with no numbers seems akin to celebrating the purchase of pig in a poke.

Sutton should also ask about other crops. The American negotiators claim that all agricultural trade is on the table in the future.

“It’s more than soybeans. All agricultural products are something that will be discussed [in the trade talks with the EU],” Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross told Fox News on late Wednesday. “Soybeans was simply a very timely example of those [agricultural products],” he added. 
Trump’s chief trade enforcer, U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, also demanded during a Senate hearing on Thursday that the EU deliver more. “Our view is we are negotiating about agriculture,” he told lawmakers. “That’s part of the project.”

On the other hand, the EU asserts that other agricultural products are not part of the agreement.

Brussels was quick to shoot down such suggestions. “Agriculture is not part of the scope of the talks,” an EU official told reporters on Thursday. 
“It’s clear that the U.S. side would’ve liked [it] but it has not been agreed, and Mr. Ross can say what he wishes but it doesn’t correspond” to the deal agreed, the official added. “There is no ambiguity in this regard.”

Given this conflict one day after the agreement was allegedly reached, Sutton can ask if Noem and Trump sold out wheat, corn, beef and every other ag producer just to get a photo op about an unspecified amount of soybeans.

My Lincoln-Douglas debaters used to work to capture their opponents' value and value criterion. Sutton can use this tactic as well. Republicans, in general, have one overarching value: hate Barack Obama. This trade deal, however, is an extension of Obama's policies.


European Commission boss Jean-Claude Juncker wouldn’t pitch it this way. But on Wednesday, he and U.S. President Donald Trump essentially revived trade goals dating from the Barack Obama era. The European Union will buy more American soybeans and liquefied natural gas, while U.S. tariffs on steel imports from that region may be eliminated if the parties can agree. Other goals featured in negotiations about the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership, or TTIP, under Trump’s predecessor.

Noem touts this deal which follows Obama's trade policy as wonderful. As a Democrat, Sutton has a better claim to Obama's successful policies that she does. He wins on the value level.

Policy debate rounds often close on impact calculation. What's the time frame, magnitude, and probability? Noem and Trump have not given a time frame, and they have no numbers to show the magnitude of the deal. Further, other ag products may not be subject to the deal. Finally, given Trump's erratic nature, the deal, no matter how good it may be, might be disavowed tomorrow, so even the probability is in question. When it comes to this trade deal, Sutton has the advantage on both the policy and value levels.

Thursday, July 26, 2018

A Minor Musing About The Possible Special Legislative Session To Collect Online Sales Tax

Bob Mercer and Cory Heidelberger both have posts  up this morning about the potential special legislative session, Mercer provided a link to the briefing legislators received.

There are a few interesting tidbits. First is the reminder that South Dakota still can't collect sales tax from online purchases despite the Wayfair decision.
Although the United States Supreme Court’s ruling was favorable to the state, the case was remanded back to the South Dakota court system for further legal proceedings. The case and the status of our law are not yet settled. Further, the trial court’s March 2017 order granting summary judgment in favor of Wayfair put in place an injunction that remains in effect today. The injunction prohibits the state from enforcing SB 106. Once the injunction is lifted, the state can begin to enforce SB 106, which will trigger SDCL 10-64-9.
My Amazon shopping cart tells me that I pay sales tax on every purchase. According to my PayPal receipts, two recent purchases from boutique retailers do not show sales tax collection. I'm not sure either retailer will meet the current legal criteria that will demand that they begin collecting South Dakota sales taxes.

Second, it seems odd that key provisions of of amendment to lower the sales tax one tenth of a percent for every $20 million raised from online sales tax collections did not include details for for how the net revenue would be calculated.


There are two ideas as to how “additional net revenue” could be calculated:

(1) additional net revenue is only that revenue that is collected from new licensees that obtain a sales tax license and begin collecting and remitting sales tax after the state can enforce the law, or
(2) additional net revenue is calculated based on the amount of additional money the state collects after the state can enforce its law regardless of whether the licensee had been licensed before or after the state could enforce the law.
Even more confusing is the fact that the law isn't clear about what to do if an extra $22 million or an extra $38 million is raised.
The law provides that sales tax “shall be reduced by one-tenth percent on July first following the calendar year for which each additional twenty million dollar increment of net revenue is collected and remitted by” remote sellers. It is not clear whether the $20M in additional net revenue calculation should be done by calendar year or on a rolling basis.  
This is best explained through an example. If, in a given year, the state collects $30M in additional net revenue, $20M of that total would trigger a reduction in the tax rate of 0.1%. How the remaining $10M should be treated is unclear.  
Under one interpretation, that $10M, being less than $20M, would not trigger a further tax rate reduction, but it would go into the base for sales tax collections upon which additional net revenue would be calculated for the following year.  
Under the other interpretation, that $10M “rolls over” into the following year, meaning that only another $10M in additional net revenue would trigger an additional 0.1% tax rate reduction.

These problems along with the question of whether any reduction in the sales tax rate is self-enforcing should have been foreseen and addressed when the legislation was being crafted so that no one would have to consider a special session.

Wednesday, July 25, 2018

Governor Daugaard Is Probably Glad She Didn't Mention Philosophy

It's about time for South Dakota's Governor Daugaard to issue one of his regular insults to philosophy majors. Because I believe there's always a place for philosophy and the humanities, I was pleased to listen to this WNAX report featuring University of South Dakota President Sheila Gestring defending the liberal arts.

Gestring makes several important points about the inherent value of the liberal arts. First, she rightfully points out that "there are jobs today we didn't even contemplate ten years ago." and "that will be true five years from now." She points out that a liberal arts education uniquely teaches students to meet the needs of jobs that don't exist now because the liberal arts teaches "students how to be problem solvers and how to think critically."

More importantly, she asserts that the creative thinking prompted by the liberal arts helps one "interpret what this job is evolving from and to" and gives employees an advantage in a world that changes quickly because of technology.

Finally, she points out that "communication skills are . . .very, very important and that's at the foundation of the liberal arts as well."

It's unfortunate that university heads have to defend the liberal arts from political leaders, but it's refreshing when they do so cogently.

A Minor Musing On Politics, Literature, And Unquiet Minds

As an English teacher I spent a lot of time thinking about the "usefulness" of literature especially novels and myths. Too many Americans seemingly equate use with  "being able to make a profit." Unless one is saying "'Myths and Novels' for $1000, Alex" literature may not have a financial use. 

Others may be more high minded and look to novels to somehow fill a faith void created as America's religious institutions fail to provide spiritual insight. The idea that novels can replace the god that Nietzsche claims we have all killed, however, seems specious.

While literature may not provide "the truth that shall set you free," it may provide a frame that allows readers to understand a confusing world. Elizabeth Bruenig illustrates that point with this Washington Post column that uses Conrad's Heart of Darkness to explain the damage being done to America's civic institutions.
Marlow’s is a civic kind of going mad, where the veil is lifted from politics and what lies beneath makes participation in ordinary political life with a quiet mind impossible. By the time he returns, what once seemed placid and unremarkable seems sinister and false — and it is. 
We’re about there, I think — perhaps not every single one of us, perhaps not just yet, but the conditions are right and the summer is long. The entire 2016 episode has been, in some sense, an introspective journey into America’s own innermost parts, with Donald Trump’s victory prompting a nervous self-inventory of what we value, whether our institutions work and to what degree we ought to trust one another. The full contents of that inward odyssey have yet to unfold. But on the question of institutional functioning, the news is unequivocally grim. Like Marlow, even after this particular chapter has ended, we are likely to find ourselves changed by what we’ve seen.
Bruenig concludes that the change we undergo will be long lasting,
. . . It has gone this way before. It took several incidents, from Vietnam to Watergate to scattered episodes of civil unrest, to permanently damage American trust in government; but as distinct as each event was, they all fractured the same essential faith. We haven’t returned to consistent levels of pre-’70s levels of trust in 40 years, and I doubt this current civic unease will fade much sooner. 
This particular horror — Trump and his failures, whatever ridiculous thing he has said or done today, whatever international incident he causes on Twitter tomorrow, however authentic the next panic is — will pass. What will last is the frank revelation of a point that, while ugly and dark, is at least true: You really don’t have the choices you ought to in American democracy, because of decisions made without your consent by people of wealth and power behind closed doors. It’s possible to continue to participate in a democracy after that. But not with a quiet mind.
Many have rightfully referenced Orwell's fable Animal Farm as an analogy for the current political situation.  In Animal Farm, the men and pigs become indistinguishable. Likewise, as Bruenig points out, Heart of Darkness shows both the demagogue and the a dictator, can achieve similar ends: the destruction of faith in civil institutions.

I have long maintained that Trump and his enablers use Orwell's 1984 as a road map. Yesterday, Trump became a walking caricature of Orwell's Big Brother when he asserted, “Just remember, what you are seeing and what you are reading is not what’s happening, . . . Just stick with us, don’t believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news.” This post is far from the first to point out that Orwell's dystopian state rested on an "essential command": "The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears."

I also wonder if America is approaching the tribalism illustrated in Lord of the Flies where one group rejected the evidence of their eyes and accepts that a pig's head on stick is somehow a talisman able to keep evil at bay. The boys were eventually rescued and novel leaves unanswered what happens when they return to "civilization." Like the questions that arise from the applying the Heart of Darkness to today's politics, this question should also cause disquiet because it implies there may be no true return from a descent into tribalism.

Because novels like Shakespeare's greatest works or ancient Greek tragedies offer questions without pat answers, we should encourage more reading and be more skeptical when a politician tells us "I alone can fix it." That we were not skeptical does not indicate that literature lacks value. Rather, it demonstrates that too few understand the value of the questions literature asks.

Tuesday, July 24, 2018

A Post Wherein I Compliment Republicans For Saying The Right Thing

Given that Donald Trump dominates the political discussion and that his utterances that are not vile, divisive, or dishonest are banal, it's refreshing to hear a few Republican politicians say the right thing.

WNAX posts clips of Republican congressional candidate Dusty Johnson asserting that a free media is important for American democracy. Johnson says, "...we absolutely have to have an independent media in this country...that is what makes the American experience work and an independent media is on a regular basis going to irritate the folks in power. That is a pretty big part of their job." Johnson goes on to say that he would tell President Trump "Mr. President, we don't have a free country without a free media." 

Granted there was a time when such statements would have been considered unnecessary but in the Age of Trump, they become refreshing and vital, especially when a Republican says them.

It's also refreshing to hear a Republican praise the use of reason. U.N. Ambassador Nikki Hayley also makes a statement that veers from the Trump playbook. After asking students at a young conservative conference if they had posted things on social media to "own the libs," she offered adult advice:


“I know that it’s fun and that it can feel good, but step back and think about what you’re accomplishing when you do this — are you persuading anyone? Who are you persuading?” Haley asked. “We’ve all been guilty of it at some point or another, but this kind of speech isn’t leadership — it’s the exact opposite.”
“Real leadership is about persuasion, it’s about movement, it’s bringing people around to your point of view,” she added. “Not by shouting them down, but by showing them how it is in their best interest to see things the way you do.”

Supporting the free press and using reason used to be givens. Now, we need to hope a few more Republicans to use facts presented by an independent media as part of their persuasive efforts instead of copying Trump's bombast, so that political debate can return to what used to be considered a a basic level of discourse.

Sunday, July 22, 2018

A Musing On D'Sousa's New Propaganda

I used to credit the South Dakota Republican establishment for controlling their extreme fringe. It seems those days have ended. South Dakota War College has posted that the Minnehaha County Republicans will host a showing of Dinesh D'Sousa's propaganda piece Death of a Nation.

The movie's title is a too obvious turn on Birth of a Nation, a silent film infamous for being sympathetic to the KKK. The film's poster merges Lincoln's and Trump's faces and implies that like Lincoln, Trump is uniquely able to save the union because both are opposed by Democrats. These comparisons are superficial. They ignore the fact that Lincoln was a man with virtues whereas Trump knows only excess. Lincoln was perhaps the nation's most eloquent President. As George Will has written, Trump "speaks English as though it is a second language that he learned from someone who learned English last week." Most importantly, Lincoln urged Americans to appeal to the better angels of our nature. Trump wants his followers to treat everyone who doesn't wear a MAGA hat as an enemy.

The film will no doubt claim that the conclusions it presents are historical fact. D'Sousa is to history what Satan is to truth. He claims, "the primary theme of the movie is racism and fascism," If this "theme" follows his other works, he will contend that Democrats are racists and assert as a new discovery that Southern Democrats were the party of slavery. Every high school American history book contains that fact, but why let facts get in the way of propaganda? 

What D'Sousa will ignore is that Dixiecrats and segregationists joined the Republican party in droves. Historian Kevin M. Kruse has provided a list that includes Strom Thurmond, John Tower, William C. Cramer, Iris Faircloth Blitch, James D. Martin, Bo Callaway and a host of others.

This propaganda piece will make it harder for the South Dakota GOP establishment to control its right fringe. It will instill or deepen the belief that one party has sole control of the truth and that those outside that party should be viewed with suspicion if not outright hatred. It will ignore the obvious fact that no party has a monopoly on truth.

I'm feeling a bit nostalgic lately, so I'll close with a song from my youth. I admit it's cheesy, but it makes me feel a little better after thinking about hatemongers.


Saturday, July 21, 2018

Some Musings About Article V Convention Silliness That Will Surely Occur In Pierre in January 2019

Last month, Bloomberg writer Noah Smith posted a tweetstorm that demonstrated the risks an Article V constitutional convention poses. Smith opined that one of those risks was an end to birthright citizenship. This week Michael Anton of Hillsdale College proved Smith prescient when he wrote a Washington Post opinion piece arguing for the end of birthright citizenship. 

Last year, the South Dakota Legislature debated two conflicting Article V resolutions. Thankfully, Senate Joint Resolution 3 died with 16 senators voting in favor and 18 opposing. House Resolution 1003 which which would have rescinded a 2015 resolution for an Article V convention to consider a balanced budget amendment was deferred to the 41st legislative day. There will no doubt be a 2019 Article V Resolution, so let's deal with the dangerous silliness now.

In addition to Smith's fear about the elimination of birthright citizenship, numerous reasons exist to oppose an Article V convention.

First, with all due respect to the 330 million people residing in the United States, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and Benjamin Franklin won't be there. If one wants to charge me with doubting my fellow citizens' ability to use their reason to govern their passions, I plead guilty.

Second, history proves it's impossible to prevent a runaway convention. The convention that Madison euphemistically called "the business of May next" was called to revise the Articles of Confederation not produce the current Constitution. (I willingly cheer the fact that the Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation; however, I refer readers to my first objection.)

Third, once the Article V convention gets out of hand, as it surely will, its targets will include the equal protection clause, long a project of 14th Amendment deniers, the 17th Amendment because Americans allegedly "have never had the right to elect their senators." and the 22nd Amendment because Donald Trump wants more than two terms. Of course, birthright citizenship will be a target as well.

Finally, both former Associate Justice Anton Scalia and former Chief Justice Warren Berger opposed an Article V convention. If two jurists who had diametrically opposed views of the limits of the Constitution could agree on that issue, then perhaps it's a really horrendous idea.

It's summer and the legislative election season, like baseball's pennant races, won't get serious until September. The resolutions won't be in the hopper until January, but voters should always be vigilant to protect themselves from dangerous ideas.

Friday, July 20, 2018

Kristi Noem: 20th Century Thinking For 21st Century Problems?

Russia's hacking of American elections may be the tip of the iceberg.
Now intelligence agencies and security companies have connected Russian hackers to the shutdown of a German steel mill, the cutting off of phone and Internet service to some 900,000 Germans, and most ominously, two disruptions of the power grid in Ukraine. The right takeaway from Russian interference in 2016 is not just that Washington needs to protect American elections; it’s also that what Russia does in cyberspace in its near abroad should be a warning about what can be done in the United States.
The job of protecting the the United States from foreign cyber aggression got a bit tougher. Yesterday, three people in charge of protecting the grid and the election infrastructure announced their retirement. They will be taking jobs in the private sector.
Three of the top cybersecurity officials at the Federal Bureau of Investigation are retiring from government service, according to people familiar with the matter—departures that come as cyberattacks are a major concern for the country’s security agencies. 
Senior U.S. intelligence officials warn that the country is at a “critical point” facing unprecedented cyberthreats, including Russia’s ongoing attacks on the American political system. They retirements also come as the FBI is facing regular criticism from President Donald Trump and his supporters, and is working to attract and retain top cyber talent.
Other that driving experienced people from the FBI to the private sector, Republicans seem to have no plan to deal with foreign cyber attacks. In May, the White House eliminated the position of cybersecurity coordinator. Yesterday, the House of Representatives voted against funding extra election security measures. The vote was a strict party line vote.

Instead of protecting the nation's election infrastructure, a Republican leader offered a 20th Century solution to a 21st Century problem.
Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), a leader of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, discounted the need for any new security spending. 
“I know what we need for safe and secure elections, and that’s voter ID,” Jordan said.
A laminated card with a photograph won't prevent voting machines from being hacked. Further, Republicans have not made protecting the country's power grid a priority. When it comes to digital infrastructure Congressional Republicans seem to maintaining a Commodore 64 mindset. 

Representative Kristi Noem joined her Republican cohorts and rejected extra funding for extra election security measures. I have not heard her criticize President Trump for his attacks on the FBI nor his decision to eliminate the office of cybersecurity coordinator. The energy section of her House of Representatives webpage promotes Keystone XL Pipeline and tax credits but says nothing about protecting the power grid. In short, she's advocating issues and policies that would have been at home in the Reagan administration, the era when the Commodore 64 was new.

The next governor of South Dakota will have to deal with economic, political, and cultural issues brought on by the digital age. Noem's candidate page mentions increasing rural broadband, but "the creation of  'a national, competitive, deregulatory telecommunications policy' to bring the promise of broadband communications networks and services 'to all Americans wherever they live'" was an issue in 1999. It's certainly not a cutting edge proposal. If Representative Noem has nothing to offer but 20th Century thinking, she is unprepared to serve as governor in the 21st Century.

Thursday, July 19, 2018

Charting Different Political Universes

I know!  I need to move on! The fact that political affiliation seemingly determines the color of the sky one sees fascinates and worries me. 

The following chart from Axios provides a solid visual of how Republicans see Trump far differently than independents or Democrats. I am not vouching for the poll's methodology, but the visual illustrates the diametrically opposed views of Trump I have been reading and deepens my belief that gap is widening dangerously.

Axios online poll conducted June 16-17.

Wednesday, July 18, 2018

Are South Dakota's Republican Leaders Running A Caucus, A Kids Club, Or A Cult?

Dakota Free Press, Dakota War College, and Right Side South Dakota all cover a letter Republican cause leaders sent to Republican legislative candidates. (Given how Blogger seems to load slowly, I am not going to paste images of the letter which one can find at all three sites.)

I really don't know if the letter is recruiting people to a meeting to indoctrinate them into a cult or is an adult version of "Do you like me? Please check yes or no."

The letter begins, "As we just celebrated the birthday of our great country, we take time to pause and reflect how important it is for our great state of South Dakota to have a strong and united  Republican caucus. We have all agreed and wish to share the following points . . . "

Translation: We're the cool kids and we want you to be cool kids to. Nothing cool has happened without us. If you want to be a cool kid, we have decided you have to do everything we say.

Later, the letter says , "All members will be expected to maintain the highest degree of confidentiality within the caucus."

Translation: Don't tell anyone our secret passwords or show anyone our secret handshake. Whatever you do, don't mention that thing with the pocketknife and candle! (I'll leave the rant about transparency for another post.)

The letter continues, "History dictates that members of the Senate and House Republican Majority Caucuses, respectively, have been considered and assigned for positions of chair and vice chair of committees.  Members of minority caucuses are not considered for these positions."

Translation: Did we tell you we're the cool kids? Yeah, just remember, we're really freakin' cool!

Later, the caucus leaders pour on the charm: "We consider the Senate and House Republican Majority Caucuses to be a family of Republicans working together to ensure that conservative Republican principles are protected and preserved in South Dakota."

Translation: We love you. You need our love to be whole. We'll be just like mommy and daddy but without the vegetables. If you accept our love everything will be great all over. Remember, mommy and daddy make you eat yucky stuff, but we love you.

The charm ends with the next sentence, however. "Therefore it requires you to be a sole member of the Senate or House Republican Majority Cause, respectively.

Translation: We have the only good ideas and a monopoly on all that is right. We're like that Joshua guy in the Bible, and you have to choose us or nothing. Remember we're on the side of freedom and good stuff. Also, you won't be one of the cool kids if talk to anyone isn't one of us.

I would prefer my legislators to be adults who are able to think independently not members of a kids club or a cult. Republican leaders, however, seem to value conformity, secrecy, and a forced show of unity.

A Minor Musing About The Loss Of Truth

Daniel Dale, Washington Bureau Chief of the Toronto Star, has taken upon himself the herculean effort of keeping track of every false claim President Donald Trump has made while in office. The total as of this writing is 2029. During the last week of June and the first week of July 2018 Trump made 100 false claims each week.

Let's be clear, Presidents Obama, George. W. Bush, Clinton, and George H.W. Bush all made claims shown to be false. The statements "...if you like the doctor you have, you can keep your doctor ..."; "Mission Accomplished"; "I did not have sexual relations with that woman . . ."; and "Read my lips: No new taxes" have all become punch lines.

Still each of Trump's predecessors understood what former President Obama said yesterday during his Mandela lecture:
We see it in state-sponsored propaganda; we see it in internet driven fabrications, we see it in the blurring of lines between news and entertainment, we see the utter loss of shame among political leaders where they’re caught in a lie and they just double down and they lie some more. Politicians have always lied, but it used to be if you caught them lying they’d be like, “Oh man.” Now they just keep on lying.
Meanwhile President Trump was asserting:
It should have been obvious, I thought it would be obvious but I would like to clarify just in case it wasn’t. In a key sentence in my remarks, I said the word “would” instead of “wouldn’t.” The sentence should have been “I don’t see any reason why I wouldn’t” or “why it wouldn’t be Russia.” So just to repeat it, I said the word “would” instead of “wouldn’t,” and the sentence should have been, and I thought I would be maybe a little bit unclear on the transcript or unclear on the actual video. 
The sentence should have been “I don’t see any reason why it wouldn’t be Russia,” sort of a double negative. So you can put that in and I think that probably clarifies things pretty good by itself. I have on numerous occasions noted our intelligence findings that Russians attempted to interfere in our elections.
In schools, the young'uns are often told to use context clues, so let's look at the original comments for some context from the Helsinki press conference transcript.

TRUMP: So let me just say that we have two thoughts. You have groups that are wondering why the FBI never took the server. Why haven't they taken the server? Why was the FBI told to leave the office of the Democratic National Committee? 
I've been wondering that. I've been asking that for months and months and I've been tweeting it out and calling it out on social media. Where is the server? I want to know where is the server and what is the server saying? 
With that being said, all I can do is ask the question. 
My people came to me, Dan Coates, came to me and some others they said they think it's Russia. I have President Putin. He just said it's not Russia. 
I will say this: I don't see any reason why it would be. But I really do want to see the server but I have, I have confidence in both parties. 
I really believe that this will probably go on for a while but I don't think it can go on without finding out what happened to the server. What happened to the servers of the Pakistani gentleman that worked on the DNC? 
Where are those servers? They're missing. Where are they? What happened to Hillary Clinton's emails? 33,000 emails gone, just gone. I think in Russia they wouldn't be gone so easily. 
I think it's a disgrace that we can't get Hillary Clinton's thirty three thousand e-mails. 
I have great confidence in my intelligence people but I will tell you that President Putin was extremely strong and powerful in his denial today and what he did is an incredible offer. 
He offered to have the people working on the case come and work with their investigators, with respect to the 12 people. I think that's an incredible offer. Ok? Thank you. [emphasis mine]
Given the fact that he questions the FBI handling of Hillary Clinton's email server and says Putin "was extremely strong and powerful in his denial today," it beggars belief that he meant to say "wouldn't." Of course, Trump made it very clear that he himself doesn't believe what he just said when he later asserted, "I accept our intelligence community’s conclusion that Russia’s meddling in the 2016 election took place. It could be other people also. There’s a lot of people out there."

The result of yesterday's speeches was that the members of the various populist tribes all issued social media pronouncements reminding the world about Obama's statement about keeping one's doctor. The #neverTrump tribal members all pointed out that Trump could not have meant what he said.

Those predictable responses are dangerous. First, the "everybody does it" or "what about that one time" never move to the key question "HOW DO WE FIX THE PROBLEM?" (Yes, I am shouting.) 

The most recent and best example of the failure of "your guy did it too" is the family separation situation. The fact that Presidents Trump, Obama, and George W. Bush all separated families at the border and housed children in cages does not justify the practice. Pointing out that Obama and Bush did it does not mean Trump should continue the practice. It does nothing to help create policy that distinguishes refugees from migrants and it does not create a policy on legal migration. Pointing out the sins of previous administrations leaves kids in cages without their parents.

Lying and the justification of one's preferred leader's lies over the lies of whoever preceded or followed him not only leads to bad policy; it also destroys democracy's foundation by encouraging the lying and weakening curiosity. Former President Obama made the point eloquently yesterday,
And, as with the denial of rights, the denial of facts runs counter to democracy, it could be its undoing, which is why we must zealously protect independent media; and we have to guard against the tendency for social media to become purely a platform for spectacle, outrage, or disinformation; and we have to insist that our schools teach critical thinking to our young people, not just blind obedience.
I don't know how to solve the problem of habitual liars. I was always tempted to require my Debate II to students to read "On Bullshit" as way to deal with false claims. I never gave in to that temptation. I commend it to everyone now. I also ask that everyone start asking "What caused the problem?" and "How can we fix it?" before screaming "What about that time that . . ."

Tuesday, July 17, 2018

An Update On Signing Up For Campaign Newsletters

Last week I bemoaned the fact that I could not sign up for campaign spam for some of the candidates for statewide office in South Dakota. In the past week, Tim Bjorkman has updated his website.  The site now looks professional done and no longer has a mile of empty blue space. It matches the claims in this Bjorkman tweet
 On the other hand, Jason Ravnsborg's site still fails to provide a space for newsletter signup and Steve Huff's name is still spelled Steve Hff.

Monday, July 16, 2018

Is Senator Mike Rounds Asserting Donald Trump Tells Bigger Lies Than Putin?

I cut and paste. You decide.

It's Tough To Make Sense Of The World When People React As If They're In A Comic Book Multiverse

President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin held their summit today. Following their one on one meeting, they held a joint press conference. Reactions to the press conference were fairly uniform. CNN called it "The most shameful, stunning moment of the Trump presidency."  Senator John McCain said, 
“No prior president has ever abased himself more abjectly before a tyrant. Not only did President Trump fail to speak the truth about an adversary; but speaking for America to the world, our president failed to defend all that makes us who we are—a republic of free people dedicated to the cause of liberty at home and abroad. American presidents must be the champions of that cause if it is to succeed. Americans are waiting and hoping for President Trump to embrace that sacred responsibility. One can only hope they are not waiting totally in vain.”
Even folks who should be reliable Trump supporters like the daughter of the U.S. Ambassador to Russia and a Fox News Anchor are outraged.
CBN's David Brody calls it "plain bad."
 And yet, there is one political group that can praise Trump's performance, the leaders of religious right.

Graham doesn't seem to be alone. As Brody notes, there are other religious conservatives defending Trump's performance.

The only analogy I have is the DC Comics multiverse. On one Earth-1, there's the Justice League; Earth-X is populated by evil doppelgangers known as the Crime Syndicate of America. I am not trying to make light of the situation or hype today's events. I am trying to underscore the fact that it seems as if it will soon be impossible for Americans to discuss any event because they they won't be seeing the same facts. The Republic works when people argue interpretations of agreed on facts. I don't know if it works when groups of citizens live in two different universes and refuse to agree on both facts and interpretation.

Sunday, July 15, 2018

Inflation Wipes Out Wage Gains: So Much Winning

The Chicago Tribune points to the fact that workers like farmers are feeling the brunt of the trade war.
The cost of food, shelter and gas have all risen significantly in the past year. Gas skyrocketed more than 24 percent, rent for a primary residence jumped 3.6 percent and meals at restaurants and cafeterias rose 2.8 percent. 
Prices have risen roughly at the same rate as wages, erasing any gains workers may have hoped to realize via bigger paychecks. 
"While the labor market remains historically tight, the pace of U.S. inflation is now outpacing wage gains late in the business cycle," said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at RSM, an audit and advisory firm. "The U.S. is now ensnared in a three front trade war which will in the near to medium term result in higher prices." 
For workers, more pain may be coming, as economists are concerned that prices could rise further due to President Trumps tariffs on many foreign imports. Trump put a 20 tariff on foreign washing machines earlier this year, and the inflation report Thursday showed more than a 13 percent spike in laundry equipment over the same period last year. 
"Expect rising transportation costs to start getting passed on to us, along with the tariff induced jump in costs," said Peter Boockvar, chief investment officer of Bleakley Advisory Group.
This article reminded me of another time WIN was a key part of the political discussion. During the 70s, it stood for "whip inflation now." There were even pins.

Whip Inflation Now pin circa 1974
From Wikipedia
We're nowhere near the levels of inflation that existed in the 1970s. Trump's policies may, however, be creating the conditions that will produce double digit inflation. Trump stole "Make America Great" from Reagan. With his love of "winning," he has a ready made slogan used during the Ford administration.

Saturday, July 14, 2018

And The Dog Whistles Yet Remain

According to the counter on my sidebar, I have written more posts in June and July than I did in the years 2016 and 2017 combined.  I should match my 2015 yearly total in a few days.

Honesty compels me to admit that in addition to not writing posts, I didn't read South Dakota blogs as much as I should have the past few years. That lack of reading was especially pronounced from October through March and during May and June when debate season or nationals preparation was in full swing. There was not enough caffeine in the world to provide enough energy to get me past teaching and coaching.

While reacquainting myself with the South Dakota blogosphere, I've learned Bob Ellis has stopped blogging, seen that Sibby is still obsessed with Cory Heidelberger but hasn't posted anything in a few months, and noticed what I believe is a decrease in the number of regular commenters on Dakota War College and Dakota Free Press. The latter observation may be a function of age and not actually be fact.

On Right Side South Dakota, however, Brad Ford remains unchanged. He still tosses out dog whistles like this insinuation that, despite libraries worth of evidence to the contrary, slaves must have been well cared for.
The family’s workhorse (“Old Doc”) seems to symbolize the difference between then and now.  Cash outlay was minimal over the 34 years of the horse’s life.  Food was free from the harvests. There were no veterinary bills or insurance policies needed:  “Since the horses had the hard work to do, and would as busy as the men all summer, simple wisdom demanded that they be treated considerately.  During the first week or so of plowing days they were permitted to stop for frequent rests, because their muscles were soft from the comparative idleness of winter. On warm days, when their breathing become fast, the plow was stopped to allow them to cool off.” 
Of course, farmers today are just as motivated to care for their expensive machinery to prevent breakdowns.  It seems just as likely that plantation farmers in the Old South would have done likewise.  McMillen suggests that such practicality is built right into the natural order: “The cow permits herself to be milked, and the sheep yields up her wool.  The horse, despite his great strength, stupidly lets man make him into a slave laborer” in exchange for ample food, comfortable housing, and parent-like care. [emphasis mine]
Ford's ignoring the horrors of slavery are bad enough, but the paragraph's structure and the placing of the quotation not only furthers the idea that "plantation owners in the Old South" not only provided "ample food, comfortable housing, and parent-like care" but also that slave labor is part of "the natural order." More importantly, Ford's placement of the quotation likens humans to horses and impugns the intelligence of a whole race.

Perhaps the South Dakota blogosphere made the collective decision to ignore Ford while I wasn't looking. Perhaps I should ignore him too. That decision would certainly keep my blood pressure in check. I retain, however, a silly notion that humans are created equal and that it might be better for the world if one points out that no natural order exists where humans should be treated like animals.