Showing posts with label Kristi Noem. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kristi Noem. Show all posts

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Governor Kristi Noem After 47 Days: A Minor Musing

I proudly voted against Kristi Noem twice in 2019. I had numerous reasons, but one of the largest was the nagging question of how a Governor Noem would handle the South Dakota Republican Party's far right fringe.

During the campaign, Noem indicated she would sign a permitless carry bill, something of a grail for that fringe. She kept her promise, signing the bill with more than a little pageantry in the capitol rotunda.

A week later, Noem called legislative leaders to what was allegedly a come-to-Jesus meeting:

By all accounts, Noem was sick of the weird stuff coming from the Legislature, in particular the House, when she summoned legislative leaders to her second-floor offices last week. Her message was simple: Cut it out. 

There was the issue with the prudish dress code drawn up by House leadership, the one that several Republican women objected to. There was the spat between House Speaker Steve Haugaard and longtime lobbyist Yvonne Taylor, where Haugaard banned her from the House floor because she wrote something in May that he didn’t like.
 

Noem was also upset that House leaders were trying to submarine her budget, demanding a 3 percent cut. And she wanted to know why there were more than 40 bills that had been introduced without meaningful content. These bills – vehicle bills or hoghouse bills – are used by lawmakers to spring surprise legislation late in the session before anyone has had time to review them. They are the antitheses of open government.

From a distance it's unclear if Noem's scolding ending the "weird stuff" or if the legislative calendar forced a halt to the surreal proposals. 

For his part, Speaker Haugaard led efforts to defeat House Bill 1175 which would have established an Early Learning Advisory Council because such a council would be  "a transformational approach to instilling a—more of a socialist agenda into the system.” The Early Learning Advisory Council would have consisted of parents, representatives of various state agencies, and educators. Haugaard's weirdness seems to be continuing apace.

On the less weird end of legislature, Noem's signature civics education proposal has become a 10 question trivia game and the legislature may well pass an industrial hemp despite her opposition.

Today, Noem suffered another setback; this loss coming at the hands of Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg.
The Senate Judiciary Committee voted 5-2 to send the cornerstone of Attorney General Jason Ravnsborg’s legislative agenda to the floor. The move comes a day after Republican Gov. Kristi Noem said she’s asking that lawmakers hold off on reversing the policy, citing the cost.
That cost is $53 million.

I hope Noem wins the presumptive probation fight. I was pleasantly surprised the took on the legislature over some of the nonsense resolutions and hoghouse bills. I hope the legislature passes industrial hemp legislation this session.

All of these struggles, however, indicate that Noem gave the Republican fringe a golden calf they had been pining for, but they seem unwilling to respond in kind. 

Thursday, January 10, 2019

A Minor Musing About Tests, Citizenship And Otherwise

Let's begin with a point of agreement. It appears both Governor Noem and I want young'uns to be good citizens. Some of the best debaters I coached served as legislative pages.  Lincoln-Douglas debaters spent hours researching the nature of good and bad governments. Policy debaters, their desire to have every discussion reach a terminal impact notwithstanding, debated what the U.S government should and should not do. Public forum debaters argued about a little bit of everything relating to important political events. In one way or another, each of them dealt with what it means to be a good citizen.

Governor Noem doesn't want students to debate about the nature of good government or what constitutes a good government policy. Instead, she wants students to pass a citizenship test in order to earn a high school diploma. This is a bad idea.

First, I cannot count the number of times I have supervised a study hall and heard a freshman say, "When am I ever gonna use this?" when doing an Algebra I, physical science, or world history assignment. Every grammar class that I taught had a student who said, "I don't need grammar; I talk good." The reaction to the citizenship requirement will be the same if not worse. "I don't need to think about citizenship; I vote gooder than you" is not a habit or a syntax that South Dakotans should encourage.

Second, if the testing that has come with No Child Left Behind, Common Core, and any other education policy conceived in the 21st Century has shown anything, it's that the mandated measurement ceases to be a measurement: it becomes the goal. In other words, the test will soon become more important than good citizenship. I may be in a minority, but rational, curious, and independent voters should be the goal. If this policy is enacted, the goal will become good test takers.

Third, the citizenship test may require students to know that Hamilton, Madison, and Jay wrote the Federalist Papers, but does it require them to explain why "Federalist 10" or "Federalist 51" matters in 2019? The test may require students to know that the first ten amendments to the Constitution are known as the Bill of Rights, but will they be able to discuss why the absolute phrase "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State" has caused so much controversy over the past few decades? If the test requires students know the term "checks and balances," will it also include examples of when checks and balances have been successful or failed? In short, it's doubtful students be able to explain how the United States government works; they will just identify a few concepts.

Finally, my cynical nature causes me to suspect that this proposal is a throwaway line designed to further the impression that Republicans are the sole possessors of virtue, rectitude, and patriotism whereas non-Republicans hate the every decent part of western civilization writ large. Creating good citizens is an important goal, especially for a credal nation such as the United States. It's certainly a far too important goal to become a political talking point.

Friday, August 10, 2018

Funny, Kristi Noem Doesn't Look Anything Like Heimdall

For those unfamiliar with Norse mythology, Heimdall is the Norse god who stands at the edge of Bifrost, the rainbow bridge that stretches between Earth and Asgard, the gods' home. His chief task is to sound the alarm when the frost giants begin their assault on Asgard, an attack that will lead to Ragnarok, the twilight or death of the gods.

Yesterday, Kristi Noem's campaign claimed a scheduling conflict prevented her from debating education issues at an event to be hosted by  the Associated School Boards of South Dakota, the School Administrators of South Dakota and South Dakota Public Broadcasting.

According to the Rapid City Journal, 


[Campaign manager Justin Brasell] did not divulge the scheduling conflict, and did not immediately return later messages from the Rapid City Journal asking what Noem planned to be doing today that precluded her from accepting the debate invitation.  
Noem made public appearances in Madison and Sioux Falls on Wednesday, and she was scheduled to attend a fundraiser for her campaign Thursday night in Sioux Falls. As of Thursday afternoon, Noem’s campaign Facebook page showed one future event: a Saturday morning parade in her hometown of Castlewood.
I admit I'm speculating as to Noem's undisclosed location, but Bifrost seems a logical conclusion because later in the day, Noem's campaign warned of a threat Republicans fear almost as much as the Asgardians fear frost giants: organized labor.


'. . . unions are undertaking a massive nationwide effort to overturn right-to-work laws, which protect workers from being forced to join labor unions. Earlier this week, unions were successful in overturning Missouri’s right-to-work law, which Billie Sutton’s Democratic Party touted as a “huge win” before calling on South Dakota to “follow Missouri’s lead.”


Just like Fenrir, the wolf that will swallow Odin whole, organized labor will, according to Noem, eliminate all worker freedom in South Dakota.


“South Dakota has been a right-to-work state for more than 50 years, and Kristi Noem will keep it that way,” said Justin Brasell, Kristi for Governor Campaign Manager. “That’s why we’re seeing out-of-state union heads investing thousands into Billie Sutton’s campaign. He’s their best bet to repeal the state’s decades old right-to-work laws and force South Dakotans into labor unions they don’t want to be a part of.” 
South Dakota is one of the nation’s earliest adopters of right to work protections, passing legislation in 1946 to protect people from being denied employment “on account of membership or nonmembership in any labor union.”
Soon, Noem, from her perch atop Bifrost, will warn that Medicaid expansion will destroy South Dakota's economy just like the Midgard Serpent drenched Thor in its venom and killed him. If her campaign is in real danger, Noem will probably conjure visions of giants riding on Naglfar, the ship of death, and resort to telling voters about threats posed by illegal immigrants, ISIS, and MS-13. God forbid, South Dakotans may even be threatened by National Football League players kneeling during the national anthem.

It's going to be a long campaign season if Noem stays on Bifrost and warns of series of impending Ragnaroks.Voters need to know candidates' policies on education and other important issues. They don't need politicians to create contemporary apocalyptic tales warning of events that will never happen.

Friday, July 20, 2018

Kristi Noem: 20th Century Thinking For 21st Century Problems?

Russia's hacking of American elections may be the tip of the iceberg.
Now intelligence agencies and security companies have connected Russian hackers to the shutdown of a German steel mill, the cutting off of phone and Internet service to some 900,000 Germans, and most ominously, two disruptions of the power grid in Ukraine. The right takeaway from Russian interference in 2016 is not just that Washington needs to protect American elections; it’s also that what Russia does in cyberspace in its near abroad should be a warning about what can be done in the United States.
The job of protecting the the United States from foreign cyber aggression got a bit tougher. Yesterday, three people in charge of protecting the grid and the election infrastructure announced their retirement. They will be taking jobs in the private sector.
Three of the top cybersecurity officials at the Federal Bureau of Investigation are retiring from government service, according to people familiar with the matter—departures that come as cyberattacks are a major concern for the country’s security agencies. 
Senior U.S. intelligence officials warn that the country is at a “critical point” facing unprecedented cyberthreats, including Russia’s ongoing attacks on the American political system. They retirements also come as the FBI is facing regular criticism from President Donald Trump and his supporters, and is working to attract and retain top cyber talent.
Other that driving experienced people from the FBI to the private sector, Republicans seem to have no plan to deal with foreign cyber attacks. In May, the White House eliminated the position of cybersecurity coordinator. Yesterday, the House of Representatives voted against funding extra election security measures. The vote was a strict party line vote.

Instead of protecting the nation's election infrastructure, a Republican leader offered a 20th Century solution to a 21st Century problem.
Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), a leader of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, discounted the need for any new security spending. 
“I know what we need for safe and secure elections, and that’s voter ID,” Jordan said.
A laminated card with a photograph won't prevent voting machines from being hacked. Further, Republicans have not made protecting the country's power grid a priority. When it comes to digital infrastructure Congressional Republicans seem to maintaining a Commodore 64 mindset. 

Representative Kristi Noem joined her Republican cohorts and rejected extra funding for extra election security measures. I have not heard her criticize President Trump for his attacks on the FBI nor his decision to eliminate the office of cybersecurity coordinator. The energy section of her House of Representatives webpage promotes Keystone XL Pipeline and tax credits but says nothing about protecting the power grid. In short, she's advocating issues and policies that would have been at home in the Reagan administration, the era when the Commodore 64 was new.

The next governor of South Dakota will have to deal with economic, political, and cultural issues brought on by the digital age. Noem's candidate page mentions increasing rural broadband, but "the creation of  'a national, competitive, deregulatory telecommunications policy' to bring the promise of broadband communications networks and services 'to all Americans wherever they live'" was an issue in 1999. It's certainly not a cutting edge proposal. If Representative Noem has nothing to offer but 20th Century thinking, she is unprepared to serve as governor in the 21st Century.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Noem Completes Hypocricy Trifecta

No one should be surprised that Representative Kristi Noem voted to keep the government shut down. That vote completed a hypocrisy trifecta  Vegas of course would have taken that bet off the board; betting that Noem would cast a vote with consistent with principle is the definition of a sucker bet.

Let's review Noem's accomplishment. First, there was the vote to give the NSA carte blanche to violate the Fourth Amendment. Noem claims to be a small government conservative. The NSA may be many things, but small government is not one of them. If one wants to vote like a big government neocon, one should own the label.

Her vote to give corporate welfare to herself and her friends while cutting funding for food stamps is the second stage of her trifecta. One who votes for welfare for everyone may be a spendthrift. One who votes for welfare for no one may be hard hearted. One who votes for welfare for me but not for thee is hypocritical.

Those two votes set up last night's hypocritical vote. If one casts a vote to support big government spying on American citizens and for welfare payments that benefit oneself, one cannot logically claim to be anything other than hypocritical with a vote to keep the government shut down.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Noem Will Have An Opponent; Thank God

Jonathan Ellis is reporting that Corinna Robinson, who has spent 25 years serving in the United States Army, will seek the Democratic nomination to challenge incumbent Republican Kristi Noem for South Dakota's lone seat in the U.S House of Representatives.

According to Ellis,
Robinson, a Democrat, said she was prompted in part because of a dysfunctional Congress that has resulted in furloughs, a partially closed government and threats to veterans.
"It’s very discouraging," she said. "It just seems like the parties can’t work together."
Ellis's Argus colleague David Montgomery provides a necessary caveat:
As far as potential Democratic recruits go for the U.S. House, Robinson seems like a pretty good catch. That’s not to say she’ll win (plenty of candidates who are impressive on paper end up flopping) but she has a pretty impressive resume.
That caveat notwithstanding, I have a rather low bar for casting an anybody-pleasedearGod-letmevoteforanybody-i'mbegginghereGod-anybodybutKristiNoem ballot. In fact, I think there are only three criteria. First, this person should not be Kristi Noem. Second, this person should be able to express a clear thought cogently.Third, this person should not have been convicted of hitting a woman with a belt or any other similar offense.

Robinson will be able to utter one sentence that doesn't contain a vapid talking point, so she meets all three criteria. Further, her service in the army will, one hopes, prevent Noem from running a version of this ad touting her winning awards from the Watertown Jaycees and soybean growers as noteworthy achievements. Surely, even Kristi Noem doesn't have the chutzpah to run this sort of ad against against someone who spent 25 years in the military.



Saturday, September 21, 2013

A Note To Congresswoman Kristi Noem

Dear Representative Noem:

First, I wish to congratulate you for being able to avoid a primary challenger. Mike Rounds, a person of superior accomplishments albeit inferior tea party rhetoric, has no shortage of opponents. A cynic might suspect that you possess video of prominent South Dakota Republicans sitting naked in a Native American sweat lodge, smoking Cuban cigars, drinking Jose Cuervo shots, worshiping an  idol of Barack Obama while singing the old National Anthem of the Soviet Union.

That said, a few of your recent votes seem problematic. Apparently, Republicans are taught from the cradle that cutting welfare is a holy mission. Devout Republican mothers may have secret lullabies about waste, fraud and abuse. That said, cutting $40 billion from food stamps during high unemployment and a jobless recovery seems counterproductive. John Steinbeck correctly noted that there's a thin line between hunger and anger. America has had a cheap food policy for a long time because wise folks discovered Steinbeck's truth.

I'm sure that you or one of your staff members will respond by reminding me that Rome fell because citizens wanted bread and circuses. It might be worth the effort to have a qualified independent historian or two examine the records to determine if the bread extended Rome's life a few decades. On a side note, start taking talking points from a think tank other than Heritage; Jim DeMint has turned that think tank into a political rhetoric tank. Cato's scholars may slant libertarian but they are at least scholars.

Finally, there's the matter of the Farm Bill. The first rule of legislating should be do no harm. Your food stamps vote likely violated that principle. The second rule should be avoid the appearance of evil. When you and other members of the House of Representatives get Farm Bill benefits of $150,000 or $1,500,000 a year, it's difficult to avoid the appearance of evil. If a percentage of the American populace is going to be tempted to defraud the American taxpayer for about $150 a month, it seems likely that an equal percentage will be willing to commit fraudulent practices for $150,000 a year.

Congresswoman Noem, you have no Republican challengers. You live in a state that is so Republican, the very idea of a Democrat challenging you is a punch line to a bad joke. Perhaps, you can start voting on the above principles instead the pragmatics of re-election. I'll even give you a pass on the next 40 wasted votes to repeal or defund Obamacare.

Friday, February 3, 2012

Let's Meet Stephanie Strong And Look For Propaganda, Especially Glittering Generalities

I suppose one could look for alliteration too.

Stephanie Strong, the Rapid City businesswoman not the adult film star, is running for Congress.  Cory has covered her website here.  The Right Side Blog touts her candidacy with the following propaganda.
She believes in:
•limited Constitutional government;
•the vigorous defense of our Constitutional rights;
•debt reduction by reducing spending, not raising taxes;
•reduction in government interference in business through excessive regulation;
•a strong military;
•traditional Judeo-Christian values;
•US energy independence.
I use the term propaganda academically not pejoratively.  Every phrase fits the example of a glittering generality.

Glittering generalities are words that have different positive meaning for individual subjects, but are linked to highly valued concepts. When these words are used, they demand approval without thinking, simply because such an important concept is involved.
I think I'm going to have to stock up on some popcorn.  Between Kristi Noem's leather jacket glitz and Stephanie Strong's glitter, this race might be entertaining.  I would rather have substantive, but one takes what one can.