Showing posts with label 2018 Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2018 Election. Show all posts

Thursday, September 6, 2018

Some Minor Musings About 2018 Election Season

It's been a bit since I posted. There are a couple of reasons. First, in July I transitioned from full time to retired. I am currently transitioning from retired to part time. I hope to get a regular schedule going again soon. Second, I have been musing a lot about the 2018 election season and have come to a couple of conclusions.

The musings began with this Tom Nichols tweet.
The Republicans are acting like a parliamentary party. So you have to vote as though they are a parliamentary party, by voting against the party to get rid of the leadership.
I have long blamed Newt Gingrich for moving the United States Congress in the direction of a parliament when he introduced his Contract With/On/For America campaign in the 1990s. Treating congress and the president like a parliament and prime minister distorts the American system that was designed to avoid factions and divide powers among the branches. Nichols makes the point in a September 4 Washington Post column:


. . . one of the great virtues of the American system of separated powers is that voters, usually, can ignore party affiliation if they feel a candidate is worth their support. Our model forces the legislative and executive branches to seek separate mandates from the electorate. In our system, voters can separate the party from its leader. They can split their tickets regionally, nationally and by party. They can even vote for divided government, and choose to place the executive and legislative power in opposing hands.

In the Post column, Nichols doubles down on his premise that the only way to cure the distortion that the Republican Cult of Trump has caused is to vote for the opposition as one does in a parliamentary system. As a ticket splitter of long standing, I am generally skeptical of the "break it worse in order to fix it" method, but I see few other avenues to reining in megalomaniac who has more in common with a Mafioso than he does with being a President of the United States. I will likely be voting straight Democrat in November.

The qualification "likely" comes from another series of musings about the changes that digital technology has caused. These widespread changes alter not only the ways in which people work and communicate; they also change how people view their neighborhoods and the wider world. More importantly, if my former students are any indication, the technologies change how people think.

Quite frankly, I am not certain that anyone older than I am can understand how to successfully navigate the world digital has created. Posting pictures on one's grandkids on Facebook or ranting on Twitter does not necessarily indicate the ability to navigate that world. It merely indicates that users have learned how to use an app and fooled themselves into believing they are able to keep up with the younger folk.

The belief that older folk may not be able to deal with results digital technology has produced has led me to conclude that I cannot vote for folks older than I am. In fact, I may not vote for anyone older than 55.

Finally, the United States's political season traditionally begins with the Labor Day weekend. Although Republicans have an edge among South Dakota's humans who vote, bovines seem rather displeased with Republican attorney general candidate Jason Ravnsborg. While travelling home from a visit to my mother, my wife and I witnessed a black bovine of unknown gender destroying one of his campaign signs in a pasture bordering I-90. That beast expressed more political certainty than I feel about the choices I will be forced to make in November

Friday, August 10, 2018

Funny, Kristi Noem Doesn't Look Anything Like Heimdall

For those unfamiliar with Norse mythology, Heimdall is the Norse god who stands at the edge of Bifrost, the rainbow bridge that stretches between Earth and Asgard, the gods' home. His chief task is to sound the alarm when the frost giants begin their assault on Asgard, an attack that will lead to Ragnarok, the twilight or death of the gods.

Yesterday, Kristi Noem's campaign claimed a scheduling conflict prevented her from debating education issues at an event to be hosted by  the Associated School Boards of South Dakota, the School Administrators of South Dakota and South Dakota Public Broadcasting.

According to the Rapid City Journal, 


[Campaign manager Justin Brasell] did not divulge the scheduling conflict, and did not immediately return later messages from the Rapid City Journal asking what Noem planned to be doing today that precluded her from accepting the debate invitation.  
Noem made public appearances in Madison and Sioux Falls on Wednesday, and she was scheduled to attend a fundraiser for her campaign Thursday night in Sioux Falls. As of Thursday afternoon, Noem’s campaign Facebook page showed one future event: a Saturday morning parade in her hometown of Castlewood.
I admit I'm speculating as to Noem's undisclosed location, but Bifrost seems a logical conclusion because later in the day, Noem's campaign warned of a threat Republicans fear almost as much as the Asgardians fear frost giants: organized labor.


'. . . unions are undertaking a massive nationwide effort to overturn right-to-work laws, which protect workers from being forced to join labor unions. Earlier this week, unions were successful in overturning Missouri’s right-to-work law, which Billie Sutton’s Democratic Party touted as a “huge win” before calling on South Dakota to “follow Missouri’s lead.”


Just like Fenrir, the wolf that will swallow Odin whole, organized labor will, according to Noem, eliminate all worker freedom in South Dakota.


“South Dakota has been a right-to-work state for more than 50 years, and Kristi Noem will keep it that way,” said Justin Brasell, Kristi for Governor Campaign Manager. “That’s why we’re seeing out-of-state union heads investing thousands into Billie Sutton’s campaign. He’s their best bet to repeal the state’s decades old right-to-work laws and force South Dakotans into labor unions they don’t want to be a part of.” 
South Dakota is one of the nation’s earliest adopters of right to work protections, passing legislation in 1946 to protect people from being denied employment “on account of membership or nonmembership in any labor union.”
Soon, Noem, from her perch atop Bifrost, will warn that Medicaid expansion will destroy South Dakota's economy just like the Midgard Serpent drenched Thor in its venom and killed him. If her campaign is in real danger, Noem will probably conjure visions of giants riding on Naglfar, the ship of death, and resort to telling voters about threats posed by illegal immigrants, ISIS, and MS-13. God forbid, South Dakotans may even be threatened by National Football League players kneeling during the national anthem.

It's going to be a long campaign season if Noem stays on Bifrost and warns of series of impending Ragnaroks.Voters need to know candidates' policies on education and other important issues. They don't need politicians to create contemporary apocalyptic tales warning of events that will never happen.

Tuesday, August 7, 2018

A Post Wherein I Reveal My Inner Cassandra

For those unfamiliar with mythology, Cassandra was a princess of Troy with the gift of accurate prophecy. She was cursed, however, so no one would believe her prophecies. The current definition of cassandra is "one who predicts misfortune or disaster."

In light of the contemporary definition, I hope the Democrats who will be reconvening at the end of the week  for what they call "a small procedural step in the process of certifying our Constitutional candidates" follow both party bylaws and state law fully.

It beggars belief that Republicans would force Democrats to reconvene merely for a public relations win in July and August. The undecided or unaffiliated voters that the Democrats need in order win a statewide race will have forgotten about the incident by late October or early November when they decide whom to support Although the unforced error that necessitated reconvening is nothing like the Constitution Party's dramedy, Republican Party Chairperson Dan Lederman claims he "reviewed their bylaws" as part of the Republicans' challenge to the Secretary of State's decision about that party's dueling slate of party officers and competing conventions. If Republicans are making the extra effort to review bylaws to keep a party with fewer than 500 registered voters off the ballot, they will certainly look for another mistake from the Democratic Party.

Despite my complaints about Democrats' failure to develop legislative candidates, it's obvious that they face an uphill battle against Republicans in South Dakota. The urban-rural divide continues to become more pronounced. South Dakota is a rural state, and Republicans dominate in rural areas. South Dakota's Democrats should take care to avoid another unforced error that increases the advantages that South Dakota's Republicans enjoy.

Sunday, August 5, 2018

A Musing About Fundraisers, Power, And Access

A bit of South Dakota political blogosphere angst has arisen over the Billie Sutton fundraiser sponsored in part by Republican Ryan Maher and the Kristi Noem $500 a plate fundraiser. Lost amid the comments about personal loyalty, hypocrisy, and the alliterative "cowboy caucus" is this trenchant admission: [t]he world is run by the people who show up."

The verb "run" connotes the projection of power despite the fact that people elected to office claim to "serve." A fundraiser, therefore, is about who has access to power or service that others will not receive. In one case, a person can show up and drop $25 in the hat. In the other one must have $500.

There's no logical reason in a country premised on the idea that all are created equal that a person who shows up at a fundraiser with $500 should have more access to those in power than someone who has no money to contribute or someone who contributes only $25. Literature, as it often does, provides an illustrative answer to the conundrum. In Flannery O'Conner's short story "Revelation," the protagonist Ruby Turpin is in a doctor's waiting room. After a brief exchange with a woman Turpin finds undesirable, O'Connor describes Turpin's alliance with another waiting patient: "The look that Mrs. Turpin and the pleasant lady exchanged indicated they both understood that you had to have certain things before you could know certain things." (emphasis mine) In Noem's case, it boils down to you have have $500 before you can know certain people.

In fairness, Suttion will likely have $100, $200, or $500 fundraisers. No one can win a statewide campaign passing the hat, even one as impressive as Sutton's. He has, however, sent the message that his door might be more open to those who can't contribute $500 at a single event whereas Noem has confirmed that under her watch, the state will be run by those who show up with money because only those with money can know certain things or certain people.

Thursday, August 2, 2018

About That Billie Sutton Poll....

I distrust internal polls, so I ignored the Democratic candidate Billie Sutton's tweet that announced Representative Kristi Noem's lead in the gubernatorial race was within the margin of error. I ignored  Sutton's emailed press release with the bold print announcement that indicate Sutton might have lead if voters are given information about both candidates.
When balanced profile information about both candidates is presented, Sutton takes a 6 point lead (48% Sutton / 42% Noem / 11% undecided). emphasis in original]
I smiled and did a "from your lips to God's ears" prayer when I read Dakota Free Press's enthusiastic post about the poll results.

But then, this tweet from political forecaster Harry Enten came across my feed. Enten claims that he was told in 2017 that Sutton was a candidate to watch. I became a bit less skeptical because Enten's job is political forecasting. As an aside, Enten  later tweeted a picture of a business card that he got from the conference with his note about Sutton handwritten on the back.

Later, friends forwarded a link to an article entitled "Billie Sutton Will Not Be Out-Cowboyed." The title comes from conversations the reporter had with Democrats at two Sioux Falls events:
At both events, I meet dozens of loyal Democrats, most of whom clearly identify as far to the left of Sutton, but I'm unable to find anyone who's particularly perturbed by the candidate's more centrist positions, even on abortion or guns. They like his education plans. They like his chances to win. They are realists about the political make-up of the state where they all reside, and no one outside the campaign is wholly confident of victory. "There's nothing as brutal as a Wednesday in November," one supporter remarks wryly, remembering years of Democratic defeat. But she's optimistic. At least no one is going to out-cowboy Billie Sutton.
Before one gets to that paragraph, however, there's a report about a newspaper publisher who declared his support for Sutton after decades of supporting Republicans. The anecdote looked familiar as it should have. Dakota War College had covered the same article. In that post Pat Powers took issue with the newspaper publisher and opined that a brief mention of Obamacare might prove problematic for Sutton. Powers did not, however, challenge the article's conclusion that Noem will have to do more than ride a horse and demonstrate that she can shoot a gun to defeat Sutton or that economic issues might turn the race.
That line of attack, though, isn't going to work well against Sutton, the former rodeo rider. And, as the summer wanes, it seems likely that the race will shift to bigger economic factors. President Donald Trump's global trade war is affecting core South Dakota products like corn, beef, and especially soybeans. Soybean prices have fallen 16 percent in the last few months. If a blue wave hits the prairie, it will be because of frustration about global commodity prices linked to foreign retaliatory tariffs.
Powers, a connected partisan, rarely misses any chance to dismiss Democrats' chances in a South Dakota race, so it seems odd that his response to the conclusions about Sutton's chances or Democrats' optimism was subdued.

Finally, there's yesterday's news that the South Dakota Republican Party intends to sue to keep Constitution Party candidates off the 2018 general election ballot. It's a move that seems too heavy-handed by half. In fact, it smacks of fear. The Constitution Party, which has only 489 registered members, resembles a circular firing squad more than a political party. Republicans apparently fear  the loss of some social conservative voters who might find the Constitution Party appealing more than they fear looking like a high school bully kicking a kindergartner.

I remain doubtful that enough South Dakota Republicans will end their infatuation with Kristi Noem and vote for Sutton even though Noem's political career is a case study for the Peter Principle. The South Dakota Republican Party, however,  through its actions and inaction leads one to believe that the Sutton poll might be more accurate than a skeptic might have thought. 

Friday, July 27, 2018

A Post Wherein I Offer Billie Sutton Some Unsolicited Advice

I used to tell my young policy debaters to be sure they got their opponents' sources and numbers. It was a central part of understanding an opponents case or disadvantage.

Billie Sutton doesn't need my assistance, but I offer him the same advice if he and Kristi Noem debate next fall.

Over the past few days Noem has hailed the  the trade agreement that Trump announced with the EU. Noem calls Trump "best negotiator we have" and asserts "[h]e's doing an incredible job fighting for our farmers." She claims that the Rose Garden announcement was "wonderful" and that the President will "continue to negotiate" to open more markets.

Let's start with a simple question that seems to have not been asked: when it comes to soybeans how much more will the European Union buy than it would have purchased before the tariff silliness began? Has anyone given a number in bushels or tons or a percentage increase? Heralding a trade deal with no numbers seems akin to celebrating the purchase of pig in a poke.

Sutton should also ask about other crops. The American negotiators claim that all agricultural trade is on the table in the future.

“It’s more than soybeans. All agricultural products are something that will be discussed [in the trade talks with the EU],” Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross told Fox News on late Wednesday. “Soybeans was simply a very timely example of those [agricultural products],” he added. 
Trump’s chief trade enforcer, U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, also demanded during a Senate hearing on Thursday that the EU deliver more. “Our view is we are negotiating about agriculture,” he told lawmakers. “That’s part of the project.”

On the other hand, the EU asserts that other agricultural products are not part of the agreement.

Brussels was quick to shoot down such suggestions. “Agriculture is not part of the scope of the talks,” an EU official told reporters on Thursday. 
“It’s clear that the U.S. side would’ve liked [it] but it has not been agreed, and Mr. Ross can say what he wishes but it doesn’t correspond” to the deal agreed, the official added. “There is no ambiguity in this regard.”

Given this conflict one day after the agreement was allegedly reached, Sutton can ask if Noem and Trump sold out wheat, corn, beef and every other ag producer just to get a photo op about an unspecified amount of soybeans.

My Lincoln-Douglas debaters used to work to capture their opponents' value and value criterion. Sutton can use this tactic as well. Republicans, in general, have one overarching value: hate Barack Obama. This trade deal, however, is an extension of Obama's policies.


European Commission boss Jean-Claude Juncker wouldn’t pitch it this way. But on Wednesday, he and U.S. President Donald Trump essentially revived trade goals dating from the Barack Obama era. The European Union will buy more American soybeans and liquefied natural gas, while U.S. tariffs on steel imports from that region may be eliminated if the parties can agree. Other goals featured in negotiations about the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership, or TTIP, under Trump’s predecessor.

Noem touts this deal which follows Obama's trade policy as wonderful. As a Democrat, Sutton has a better claim to Obama's successful policies that she does. He wins on the value level.

Policy debate rounds often close on impact calculation. What's the time frame, magnitude, and probability? Noem and Trump have not given a time frame, and they have no numbers to show the magnitude of the deal. Further, other ag products may not be subject to the deal. Finally, given Trump's erratic nature, the deal, no matter how good it may be, might be disavowed tomorrow, so even the probability is in question. When it comes to this trade deal, Sutton has the advantage on both the policy and value levels.

Saturday, July 21, 2018

Some Musings About Article V Convention Silliness That Will Surely Occur In Pierre in January 2019

Last month, Bloomberg writer Noah Smith posted a tweetstorm that demonstrated the risks an Article V constitutional convention poses. Smith opined that one of those risks was an end to birthright citizenship. This week Michael Anton of Hillsdale College proved Smith prescient when he wrote a Washington Post opinion piece arguing for the end of birthright citizenship. 

Last year, the South Dakota Legislature debated two conflicting Article V resolutions. Thankfully, Senate Joint Resolution 3 died with 16 senators voting in favor and 18 opposing. House Resolution 1003 which which would have rescinded a 2015 resolution for an Article V convention to consider a balanced budget amendment was deferred to the 41st legislative day. There will no doubt be a 2019 Article V Resolution, so let's deal with the dangerous silliness now.

In addition to Smith's fear about the elimination of birthright citizenship, numerous reasons exist to oppose an Article V convention.

First, with all due respect to the 330 million people residing in the United States, James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and Benjamin Franklin won't be there. If one wants to charge me with doubting my fellow citizens' ability to use their reason to govern their passions, I plead guilty.

Second, history proves it's impossible to prevent a runaway convention. The convention that Madison euphemistically called "the business of May next" was called to revise the Articles of Confederation not produce the current Constitution. (I willingly cheer the fact that the Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation; however, I refer readers to my first objection.)

Third, once the Article V convention gets out of hand, as it surely will, its targets will include the equal protection clause, long a project of 14th Amendment deniers, the 17th Amendment because Americans allegedly "have never had the right to elect their senators." and the 22nd Amendment because Donald Trump wants more than two terms. Of course, birthright citizenship will be a target as well.

Finally, both former Associate Justice Anton Scalia and former Chief Justice Warren Berger opposed an Article V convention. If two jurists who had diametrically opposed views of the limits of the Constitution could agree on that issue, then perhaps it's a really horrendous idea.

It's summer and the legislative election season, like baseball's pennant races, won't get serious until September. The resolutions won't be in the hopper until January, but voters should always be vigilant to protect themselves from dangerous ideas.

Friday, July 20, 2018

Kristi Noem: 20th Century Thinking For 21st Century Problems?

Russia's hacking of American elections may be the tip of the iceberg.
Now intelligence agencies and security companies have connected Russian hackers to the shutdown of a German steel mill, the cutting off of phone and Internet service to some 900,000 Germans, and most ominously, two disruptions of the power grid in Ukraine. The right takeaway from Russian interference in 2016 is not just that Washington needs to protect American elections; it’s also that what Russia does in cyberspace in its near abroad should be a warning about what can be done in the United States.
The job of protecting the the United States from foreign cyber aggression got a bit tougher. Yesterday, three people in charge of protecting the grid and the election infrastructure announced their retirement. They will be taking jobs in the private sector.
Three of the top cybersecurity officials at the Federal Bureau of Investigation are retiring from government service, according to people familiar with the matter—departures that come as cyberattacks are a major concern for the country’s security agencies. 
Senior U.S. intelligence officials warn that the country is at a “critical point” facing unprecedented cyberthreats, including Russia’s ongoing attacks on the American political system. They retirements also come as the FBI is facing regular criticism from President Donald Trump and his supporters, and is working to attract and retain top cyber talent.
Other that driving experienced people from the FBI to the private sector, Republicans seem to have no plan to deal with foreign cyber attacks. In May, the White House eliminated the position of cybersecurity coordinator. Yesterday, the House of Representatives voted against funding extra election security measures. The vote was a strict party line vote.

Instead of protecting the nation's election infrastructure, a Republican leader offered a 20th Century solution to a 21st Century problem.
Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), a leader of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, discounted the need for any new security spending. 
“I know what we need for safe and secure elections, and that’s voter ID,” Jordan said.
A laminated card with a photograph won't prevent voting machines from being hacked. Further, Republicans have not made protecting the country's power grid a priority. When it comes to digital infrastructure Congressional Republicans seem to maintaining a Commodore 64 mindset. 

Representative Kristi Noem joined her Republican cohorts and rejected extra funding for extra election security measures. I have not heard her criticize President Trump for his attacks on the FBI nor his decision to eliminate the office of cybersecurity coordinator. The energy section of her House of Representatives webpage promotes Keystone XL Pipeline and tax credits but says nothing about protecting the power grid. In short, she's advocating issues and policies that would have been at home in the Reagan administration, the era when the Commodore 64 was new.

The next governor of South Dakota will have to deal with economic, political, and cultural issues brought on by the digital age. Noem's candidate page mentions increasing rural broadband, but "the creation of  'a national, competitive, deregulatory telecommunications policy' to bring the promise of broadband communications networks and services 'to all Americans wherever they live'" was an issue in 1999. It's certainly not a cutting edge proposal. If Representative Noem has nothing to offer but 20th Century thinking, she is unprepared to serve as governor in the 21st Century.

Tuesday, July 17, 2018

An Update On Signing Up For Campaign Newsletters

Last week I bemoaned the fact that I could not sign up for campaign spam for some of the candidates for statewide office in South Dakota. In the past week, Tim Bjorkman has updated his website.  The site now looks professional done and no longer has a mile of empty blue space. It matches the claims in this Bjorkman tweet
 On the other hand, Jason Ravnsborg's site still fails to provide a space for newsletter signup and Steve Huff's name is still spelled Steve Hff.

Friday, July 13, 2018

The Blogger Doth Protest Too Much Methinks

It likely reflects poorly on my character that I enjoy using literary allusions to refer to everyday occurrences. In the case, this post's title refers to the fact that South Dakota War College has posted at least  6 posts referencing the fact that the Democrats must reconvene in August to properly certify their candidates for constitutional offices in South Dakota.

Were I a Republican insider, I would chortle a bit at a major unforced error. I don't believe that this incident is worth six posts worth of pointing and giggling. Further, Dakota War College's latest post, implies that Republicans presented Democrats with a gift and states that "Democrats should be thanking the GOP" for pointing out the error "in the interest of transparency."

Transparency is not a term I would use to describe a party that dominates the legislature but keeps its caucus closed. Also, I have never associated the South Dakota Republicans with benevolence. If anything, they are ruthlessly efficient.

That nature reminds me of a few classics, chiefly The Iliad which features the ruthlessly efficient killing machine Achilles and The Aeneid which contains the story of the Trojan Horse. South Dakota Democrats would do well to remember one of the key lines from The Aeneid, "I fear the Greeks even when they bring gifts." This "gift," like that famous giant wooden horse may not be given with good intent and Democrats should exercise due caution.

Tuesday, July 10, 2018

In Some Cases, Signing Up For Campaign Newsletters Is Harder Than It Should Be

The last time I was actively blogging during an election was 2014. It seemed, therefore, prudent to get signed up for campaign emails and look for party platform points to nitpick. Today is hot, humid, and uncomfortable, so I thought it would be a great time sign up for campaign spam from Noem, Sutton, Bjorkman, Johnson, Ravnsborg, Seiler, Frederick, Barnett, Haeder, Matson, Cool, and Sattgast. I also thought the party websites along with the individual campaign sites would make that task easy. I was proved wrong in several instances.

Both the South Dakota Republicans' and Democrats' sites could be easier to navigate. It takes a few clicks to discover party platforms, the party officers, and their elected officials. One can sign up for spam, find party offices, and click buttons to donate or volunteer. As of this writing, however, neither party has a link or tab with a list of their 2018 candidates for statewide office. Maybe I'm feeling the lack of caffeine or am angry about the weather, but I should not have to consult Ballotpedia to discover South Dakota's statewide candidates. (I did eventually find the Democratic candidates on their blog page.)

On to the candidates. Both Kristi Noem and Billie Sutton make it easy to sign up for campaign updates. Both have policy positions. I do wish Sutton's were not hidden under the "Meet Billie" tab and I wish that Noem's site did not feature an annoying "Meet Larry" video pop up, but the sites are usable and reasonably easy to navigate.

The Dusty Johnson home page may be my favorite. It's uncluttered and easy to navigate. Signing up for email updates was easy. On the other hand, I couldn't find a way to subscribe to a Tim Bjorkman newsletter and there is a whole bunch of empty blue between the "Tim on Twitter" and "Tim on Facebook" sections of the home page. Both sites, however, have easy to find information about the candidates' respective positions.

In the Attorney General's race, Randy Seiler's home page has a lot of stuff on it, but it's clean enough so that I don't feel as if information is slapping me in the face. It's also easy to sign up for campaign updates. Jason Ravnsborg, like Bjorkman, doesn't seem to have a spot to sign up for a newsletter. Like Seiler the site is busy but not annoyingly so. Ravnsborg does, however, misspell the name of one of his endorsers: "YANKTON, SD - Yankton Attorney Steve Hff endorses Attorney General Candidate Jason Ravnsborg." I'm willing to cut amateur bloggers and local candidates a break, but an attorney general candidate should be a bit more careful. Misspellings in a legal brief may have numerous unintended consequences. Also, Steve Huff's son debated for me. Both Steve and his son are wonderful human beings who treated me well over the past year, so they should get proper due. Besides, Huff is not that hard to spell.

Running down the rest of the statewide candidates web presence and newsletter availability. Alexandra Fredrick the Democratic candidate for South Dakota Secretary of State is using a Facebook page, but I couldn't find a spot to sign up for a newsletter. Googling "Steve Barnett Secretary of State" did not produce a campaign web page. In the State Treasurer's race, both Aaron Matson and Josh Haeder have Facebook pages. I could find links to donate or volunteer on Matson's page but there doesn't seem to be a spot to sign up for updates. Haeder also has a campaign website that seems to be a work in progress. That page allows one to sign up for a newsletter, but the Mail Chimp link is apparently broken. Finally, Googling "Tim Cool for South Dakota Auditor" produced no campaign web page. Republican Rich Sattgast has a Facebook page with a broken link for Sattgast for Auditor.

It's admittedly early in the campaign season, and I expect pages to be created and updated, but I honestly thought all candidates for statewide office would be eager to send me campaign spam.

Is Kristi Noem Running Scared?

Let's begin with the caveat that I expect Noem to be elected governor in November. She has won two statewide Republican primaries and has been elected to Congress four times. That said, some recent events lead to the belief that she's not running a campaign based on confidence.

First, she selected Larry Rhoden to be her running mate. Rhoden's most obvious contribution to the ticket is the fact that he provides a West River geographic balance. This selection seemingly indicates she's worried that Democratic candidate Billie Sutton will cut deeply into her West River advantage, something Republicans in general and Noem, as she showed in her primary victory over Marty Jackley, in particular enjoys.

Second, the South Dakota Republican Party's predictably over-the-top response to a silly tweet mentions Billie Sutton twice as much as it mentions Samuel Parkinson, the tweet's author. It mentions no other Democratic state-wide candidate. The emphasis on Sutton alone seems curious.

Finally, there's a ridiculous press release posing as a fact sheet that claims Sutton is a "Pierre insider" who will be unable to "upset the status quo." Had Democrats been in charge of the legislature or the held the governor's office in recent memory, that charge might have merit. However, Republicans have been in charge. If Noem is truly an outsider to the Pierre political culture, she must be claiming that she has not actively been working with Republican governors and legislative leaders when she was representing South Dakota in Washington, a dubious claim at best. 

Further, if being in Pierre in the minority "for nearly a decade" makes Sutton an insider what does being in Pierre in the majority since 2001 make Rhoden? I doubt the correct answer is "outsider."

The farcical insider/outsider rhetoric pales in comparison to one of the chief proofs of Sutton's status as an insider: Sutton's "grandfather was the Democratic candidate for lieutenant governor in 1978." If one is to judge a person's insider status by what a grandfather's did in 1978, I must be a medium or a mortician, a dead person insider if you will, because both of my grandfathers died prior to 1978.

As I said in the first paragraph, I expect Noem to win. I would also expect a confident candidate and party to act as such and campaign on issues not vague slogans juvenile insinuations with no logical backing.

Sunday, June 10, 2018

If I Had A Sunday Morning Talk Show: Questions For South Dakota's Gubernatorial Candidates

Given the fact that I have a face best designed for radio and voice best suited for silent film, I am unlikely to get a Sunday morning talk show. My curiosity, however, does prompt the following questions that I hope the candidates will be asked.

First question: The Trump administration has asked a federal court to remove current protections for people with pre-existing conditions. Do you support the administration's effort? If so why? Please explain what protections you believe people should have.

Second question: The Trump administration has held office for 72 weeks. It has tried to roll out several "infrastructure weeks." Given the federal government may not be able to create an infrastructure plan and South Dakota's infrastructure earned a D+ in 2017, what can the South Dakota do to improve it's infrastructure without federal support?

Third question: Recent celebrity suicides have brought the issue to the forefront of the national discussion. "Suicide numbers in South Dakota have increased substantially in recent years. According to a recent report from the Centers For Disease Control, the state's suicide rates have increased 44.5 percent between 1999 and 2016. " What is your plan to help South Dakotans dealing with mental illness?

Fourth question: James Poulos, one of the nation's best young public intellectuals, has opined that the digital age accelerates public passions while predigital institutions have become too weak to react. What would you do to help South Dakota's public institutions be more responsive to the public demands created by the digital age?

Finally, former Indiana governor and current president of Purdue University, Mitch Daniels has said, 
Pollsters have even begun to use the term “hatred” to describe the degree of estrangement. They tell us that members of both tribes [those with a university education and the hopes of a good paying job and those without those advantages] tend to belong mostly because of their animosity to the other side. In almost reciprocal numbers, they describe the other side as “closed-minded,” “dishonest,” “unintelligent,” even “immoral.” As we trust each other less, trust in the institutions of our society has eroded in parallel. Almost no sector—government, business, the media, higher education —has escaped a steep drop in public confidence. Some constant vigilance and skepticism about centers of authority is a healthy, all-American instinct. 
But ultimately, to function effectively as a free and self-governing people, we must maintain some degree of faith that our institutions and those leading them have our best interests at heart, and are performing their duties with sincerity and integrity. And today, we plainly lack such faith.

South Dakotans are not immune the erosion of faith in our fellow citizens, leaders and institutions. What will you do as governor to begin the process of restoring that faith?