Showing posts with label Opt out. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Opt out. Show all posts

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Song Of The Day: Opt Out Edition

Based on history and this Press & Dakotan editorial, the title fits, but the tone and mood might be a bit ironic.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Moms Say It Best

I tend toward the sardonic, satiric, and angry.  Mom's tend to go for the heartstrings.  This Pam Fedders letter to the editor shows that moms sometimes do know best.
As I watched my fourth-grade daughter put her recorder away in her backpack, excited about an anticipated “music challenge” the next day in music, I listened to the results of the Feb. 28 opt-out vote. When we heard the results, she looked at me and asked, “They won’t take away music will they?” Without thinking, I replied that anything is possible, because they can’t take away something that affects a core area like Reading, for instance. She looked at me seriously and said, “They already have, they already took away our librarian.”

What a sad reflection on our community’s decision to not financially support our public education system adequately, even when it will not increase the majority of peoples’ current tax burden. Our community had the opportunity to demonstrate to state leaders that we care about education, and we failed!

I have been a resident of the Yankton community for more than 35 years and have never been more disillusioned and embarrassed to be a part of community with such selfish short-sightedness and lack of vision for the future. Worse yet, is that people are proud of “beating the Chamber, Yankton Area Progressive Growth and some of our state leaders” — as if it was some sort of competition or game! While Yankton School District has always been one of the leaders in the state in academics, fine arts, and athletics, our community’s vote and negative press has made us the laughing stock.

Never once growing up in Yankton did I have anything but pride for being from Yankton and graduating from Yankton High School; unfortunately, that’s now changed. I have to try to explain to my children why there is inadequate support to maintain our school system, yet they should be proud to live and be a part of Yankton, a community that feels it’s more important to put a few more pennies in their pockets than invest in our children, our future. That’s a tough sell!
 
 Now, since I am cynical, I will put on my bookmaker hat.  I put the over/under of commenters on Press & Dakotan comment boards telling her to leave town if she's so ashamed at 3.  Those comments will be posted before noon today.

Monday, February 27, 2012

Yankton Opt Out Election, The Sequel

I do not know if Flora Knodel is a member of COBRA Command We The People Yankton (WTPY), but she seems to express their sentiments quite well when she asserts: "We cannot afford an elite school system" because "instead of the taxpayers realizing an overall decrease in property taxes, we face another opt-out vote to essentially have a net increase in our property taxes."

No one from the WTPY has spoken to me.  My wife said they sent us a mailer telling us that they weren't opposed to teachers.  She didn't show me the pamphlet, but I'm guessing they left out the part that explains that their efforts will mean that some teachers will lose their jobs, and that those still employed will have to take another long term pay freeze.  Further the group's emails indicate that WTPY seems intent on having teachers pay more for insurance.  They may not oppose teachers, but they certainly want them to have less money for the foreseeable future.

More importantly, WTPY apparently drew the organization's name from the Constitution's Preamble.
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
If WTPY wants to "establish justice", the rendering of each his or her due, they should explain to the current students why students who graduated 10, 20, or even 50 years ago were due an "elite" education while the students currently in school are not.

Reviewing that last paragraph made me realize that WTPY seems intent on denying current students one the "blessings of liberty" that the Constitution ensures for the young of each generation.  I guess it's possible that WTPY doesn't view education as a "blessing."

WTPY may have taken their name from the Constituion, but they seem perfectly willing to ignore Constitutional principles.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Another Election Eve Rambling

Names matter.

The opt out opponents hired Paul Dorr’s Copperhead Consulting Firm.  During the Civil War, Northerners who supported the Confederacy called themselves Copperheads. “Mr. Dorr loves the South and as a studentof history, especially of how government schools flourished after the CivilWar, he named his company after the Copperheads, i.e. Northern sympathizers.”  The Copperheads were infamous for their scurrilous attacks on Abraham Lincoln, a president who preserved the Union and who urged Americans to appeal to “the better angels of our nature."  It’s curious why one would reject Lincoln’s "efforts to bind up the nation's wounds" and side with the Copperheads who sought to destroy the United States.

Symbols matter.

One CFSE member has taken to bedecking his vehicle with American flags and "Vote No" messages.  It is his right to do so.  If he is implying, however, that those who support the opt out, especially those who have served or who lost family members in Iraq, are unpatriotic, then Yankton residents should be aware that we are witnessing empty jingoism not patriotism.

Visions Matter.

The American Dream has always seemed a misnomer.  It’s a uniquely American Vision that people of the future will have more opportunities than we enjoy now.  A dream is ethereal; a vision demands effort to achieve.  The opt out is about maintaining a status quo; should it fail, certain parts of the local vision will fade to dreams.  There is no way that students will have the same opportunities two years or five years or ten years from now without more funding to continue to offer the diverse curriculum that has benefited so many over the past decades.  More importantly, some people who helped make learning possible will be missing.  The spirit to carry on may be willing but the flesh is weak and unable to effectively replace over twenty people.

Tomorrow matters.

Tomorrow is the chance to answer the appeal to one’s better angels, to reject empty symbolism, and to ensure that the vision that has helped foster success continues.  Tonight, one clings to the fog of hope believing that tomorrow will produce the substance of a good future.

A Conspiracy Theory Post Card

This morning's P&D contained a note from William Collen reminding readers that those who can't do, teach.  That cliche has been around for a long time.  The first person to hear it allegedly died after laughing too hard and falling off his dinosaur.

Because the morning letters were a bit stale, I was thrilled this afternoon to get a post card from Dan Brown, author of The Da Vinci Code, CFSE outlining a new conspiracy theory.  I think I was supposed to be left out of the loop on this particular theory because the postcard, like last Saturday's yellow mailer, was addressed to my wife's ex-husband.  I love conspiracy theories, so I couldn't help myself; I read the post card.

The plot goes something like this:  there is a giant, nebulous organization school district trying to hide facts from common ordinary citizens.  The ringleaders are church officials respected community members and a cardinal/pope school superintendent.  At first, I thought it was a bit to derivative of Brown's other works CFSE's yellow pamphlet, but John Wayne made both Rio Bravo and El Dorado, and the plots of those films are nearly identical.  If it's good enough for the Duke, it's good enough for me.

This particular theory has some big holes, however.  The first lines describe a cruel school board that crushes the hopes of its teachers.  Then a few lines later the school board treats its employees to "plush" benefits [emphasis in original].  Good conspiracy theories usually have more consistant character development.  Then, this same board is so incompetent that it doesn't know that it must be told to cut spending while at the same time it's so intelligent it creates a slush fund that no one will ever discover even though all of the financial dealings have to be published in legal notices and audited yearly.

Maybe Brown CFSE can put that story together using church cardinals or scientists who work at CERN but these evil antagonists, opposed only by an Iowa based consultant, are TEACHERS, those people who can't do anything else.  And the mastermind, the man behind everything, is a school superintendent who began his career as an elementary teacher, the lowest of the low.  No one would ever believe that plot, would they? Seriously?

On a serious note, look at what Matt Michels said last Friday,
“It’s not them and us — it’s us. It’s us working together to either improve lives or advance causes to make sure people are well. To have a gap, and have a view that people who are serving us in our state government are leaning on a shovel, is wrong. I’m not saying that’s a pervasive view. I have just taken it upon myself to say we are blessed.”
I know he doesn't mention teachers.  The view that state government workers are lazy is just as old and pernicious as the view that teachers can't do anything else.  Both should be rejected.  The new permutation of the tale, that the Yankton Board of Education, not the "YSD board of directors," as page 4 of the yellow mailer called them, is bilking Yankton residents in a manner that would make Bernie Madoff blush should be rejected as well.

Let's decide this election civilly and use facts not conspiracy theories.

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Plains Pops: Paul Dorr's Yellow Flyer Edition

Although, the yellow flyer is addressed to my wife's previous husband, the address also includes the word "occupant," so I don't think that I've broken any laws by reading it.  Yankton's opt out version of Adam and Jamie in at optoutmythbusters.com are taking a look at the mailer as well, and probably need little help from me, but I will add a few comments.

*When Paul Dorr quotes Wal-Mart executive Paul Duke, Dorr conveniently forgets to include several statements. First,
Wal-Mart has struggled with seven straight quarters of sales declines in its stores.

Addressing that challenge, Duke said the company made mistakes by shrinking product variety and not being more aggressive on prices compared to its competitors. [emphasis mine]
In short, Wal-Mart admits that other stores are offer customers better prices. Wal-Mart's customers have less money to spend at the end of the month because Wal-Mart charges them more.  Duke even admits as much.,
"What's made Wal-Mart great over the decades is 'every day low prices' and our [product] assortment," he said. "We got away from it." [emphasis mine]
Further, a May 19, 2011 Wall Street Journal article states,
[Dollar Tree's] successful first quarter contrasts what is going on at the U.S. operations of the nation's biggest retailer, Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (WMT), and may further sentiment that Wal-Mart's business is being siphoned off by more convenient and just as bargain-oriented retail chains.

Dollar Tree, whose array of home goods, healthcare products and office supplies are all priced at $1 or less, saw higher customer traffic and more buying per trip propel it to a 59% jump in first-quarter profit.

"We are gaining new customers all the time," Chief Executive Bob Sasser said on a conference call with analysts. "And when they are in the store, they like what they find. They are buying more." [emphasis mine]
Fuel prices may be a factor, but the major factors for Wal-Mart's decreased sales are its business model and the fact that Super Wal-Marts are inconvenient for quick purchases.  Shoppers spend less at Wal-Mart because they buy more elsewhere.

*Next, Paul Dorr asserts that defeating the opt out "could prove very valuable to the financial future of our young people"  because it would allegedly teach them frugality.  Am I the only one who remembers this line of reasoning being expounded by a recent school board candidate who lost?

Frugality, it seems, is easier to preach than practice.  One would think that $5,550 would buy more than a yellow pamphlet, especially since Dorr has made destroying public education his life's calling. 

*Watergate, my first political memory, taught Americans to follow the money when one seeks to know the truth.  Rough estimates indicate that a Yankton School Board member would have to serve two three year terms to receive a stipend equal to Dorr's.  Dorr will get his money for approximately six weeks of work.  Following the money indicates that Dorr may have more personal reasons to spin and shade facts than the school board does.

*The yellow mailer has several charts that purport to illustrate a "dramatic" declining enrollment.  I will note that the author distorts the scale of various items, a classic propaganda tactic.  Further, the board has provided those numbers to the public in other forums.
A document has been produced by the Yankton School District showing full-time equivalent employees (FTE) by function in both the school years 2002-03 and 2010-11. There are 10 less FTE K-12 teachers —151.1 to 141.0. In the terms of total number of teachers (including special education, alternative education, music, technology and Title 1) there were 188.1 FTE’s in 2002-03 compared to 180 FTE’s in 2010-11. There are currently more Title I teachers on staff.

The total number of paraprofessional employees of the district in 2002-03 was 51 (9 regular classroom and 42 special education) in 2010-11 the total number is 65.6 (9.6 regular classroom and 56 special education).

The total number of support personnel in 2002-03 was 138.55 FTE, currently that number is 132.35 FTE.

In the same time frame, student enrollment has gone from 3,104 students to 2,747.
Tellingly, the mailer fails to mention that the district has fewer teachers than it had a decade ago.  It also fails to discuss new federal and state mandates that require additional staff.  Further, the pamphlet does not mention of NCLB or the fact that the number of graduation requirements has increased from 18 to 22.

*Nothing in the pamphlet answers the questions posed here.

*Finally, Dorr cites some of his statistics, but on page 3, he fails to identify a "SD group-health insurance leader."  One wonders if this "leader" could be the same person who lost the recent school board election and who held a forum where he "said the district is running a self-insurance program that violates its own policies, making it illegal and unconstitutional" and told  respected community members to sit down when they questioned him.  Eyewitness accounts have this same "leader" asking the school board to be "discourseful" at the conclusion of the May 19, 2011 special meeting.

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Responses: May 20, 2011 in Opt Outs

I had a full plate yesterday, so I didn't get to post a few comments that I wanted to make.

In a P&D letter to the editor, Darwin List asks, "If the opt-out is voted in or out, what are they going to do to prevent this from happening again?"  I will offer a cliched answer: get involved.  The legislature changed the rules and failed to honor their legal obligation to to increase funding this year.  If fact, they cut funding.  Citizens need to pressure legislators to honor commitments.  Further, school board meetings are sparsely attended, and I doubt that minutes are read.  Those on both sides of the opt out issue must be vigilant and involved if they wish to avoid another situation like this one.

In another P&D letter, LaDawn Remington implies that district employees have no effect on education and suggests that
each person who draws a paycheck from the school district’s General Fund would volunteer to take a 20 percent pay cut, there would be a net savings of more than $3 million — enough money to more than cover the missing state dollars and nobody would lose their job.
Her suggestion that custodial staff and food service workers who draw salaries from the general fund take a twenty percent pay cut insults those hardworking people. The idea that these workers can afford a twenty percent cut beggars belief.

Additionally, Pete Ehresmann paid for an advertisement opposing the opt out.  It contains Dickensian references to the best of times and the worst of times introduction to A Tale of Two Cities as well as subtle allusions to the pain of poverty that Dickens so eloquently describes.  Mr. Ehresmann also makes public his tax bill.  I am not in a position to know his finances, so I will let that information go without comment.

Mr. Ehresmann's discussion of property taxes does contain one glaring omission that I would like to address.  He fails to note that property taxes are the only instrument available to the school board if it needs to raise revenues.  I suppose the board could host a year round bake sale at one of the 24-hour convenience stores in town, but local confectioners might begin to complain that socialism is creeping into the snack food industry.

Finally, I apologize to out of town readers for posting so much about the opt out.  I would like to engage in the dialogue started about rural communities started at Reimagine Rural and continued at The Madville Times.  To quote Marilynne Robinson's Gilead, I'd like to write about "books, baseball, and fried egg sandwiches." In short, I'd like to write about hundreds of other things.  As my mother and Mick Jagger constantly remind me, I can't always get what I want.  The opt out is necessary for both school and community.  I feel compelled to do my small part.

Friday, May 20, 2011

Irony: May 20, 2011 in Opt Outs

Yankton Citizens for Sustainable Education (CFSE) continues to challenge my understanding of irony.  Neither a graduate seminar over Jonathan Swift nor a lifelong appreciation of pop culture irony such as Saturday Night Live, The Onion, The Daily Show, or The Colbert Report has prepared me to deal with the intricate irony that CFSE promulgates.  Even familiarity with purveyors of religious irony such as Lark News has left me ill-prepared.

The group claims that it has organized itself  to sustain education, but members have hired Paul Dorr, a man who has dedicated his life to speeding public education "on towards its certain demise."  This act seems the epitome of irony.  One does not attempt to kill that which one hopes to sustain.   Yet, events indicate that the group is not being ironical.  

It strikes me that I am left with two alternatives.  Both seem as flawed as the belief that the group is attempting a heretofore unknown subtle formulation of irony.  First, Mr. Dorr overstates his dislike of public education in order to drum up business for his consulting firm.  This possibility has merit; hyperbole is frequently used as an advertising tool.  The other option, one I have heard mentioned by certain Yankton residents who could charitably be called skeptics, is that Messrs. Murphy and Wurth, CFSE officers both, are being disingenuous when they assert they hope to nurture Yankton's public education.  (I must confess that I took the term nurture from a list of synonyms for sustain. Honesty forces me to admit that I have not personally heard Murphy or Wurth claim that they wish to nurture Yankton's public schools.)

Today, my mailbox contained a mailing from CFSE.  It was addressed to my wife's previous husband whom she divorced over a decade ago.  He has been living near St. Louis, Missouri for the entire time.  My wife and I have been married for nearly eight years.  Both of us have taught in the Yankton School System for over fifteen years, so it's a bit disheartening that a group dedicated to sustaining local education did not care enough to address a mailing to us.  I probably have accept part of the blame for this confusion; I don't socialize much during the school year.  Still, it strikes me as ironic that the group would not send their material to teachers since they claim that they are opposing the opt out because they owe it to the district's "good teachers."  I also find it ironic that I have not met the group's officers at a school board meeting, especially since this group "has supported our school through thick and thin."  Perhaps CFSE members believe that my wife and I are not good teachers.  I find such a possibility too hurtful to seriously contemplate.

I hope a good night's sleep will help me make sense of these conundrums.

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

I Might Be Being Picky.....But ....

The Press & Dakotan published a thoughtful letter from Duane Grimme today.  Mr. Grimme writes,
Dr. Evelyn Hohf, academic dean during my time teaching at Yankton College back in the 1960s, said something like, “It is in our differences wherein greatness lies.” Any such greatness is in defending others’ rights to say something different (defending to the death, as Voltaire once put it).

There have been arguments thoughtfully put for and against the opt-out, positions begging child and adolescent needs and interests and where Yankton schools budgetary limits need be. And so there are “Yes For Kids” and “Citizens For Sustainable Education,” both for kids but differing in the extents this community and its schools can and need go while striving to educate its youth.

Let us hold high the right to disagree, to let our differences be heard, respectfully.
First, it's always good to see allusions to classic thinkers such as Voltarie.  Second, I agree wholeheartedly that differences and disagreements need to be aired and heard respectfully.

In the same letter, Mr. Grimme takes issue with Press and Dakotan's applying the the term "foes" to opt out opponents.  Mr. Grimme limits the definition to "a term defining one or any group who “'hates or seeks to injure another.'"

According to The Free Online Dictionary, "foe" means
1. A personal enemy.
2. An enemy in war.
3. An adversary; an opponent: a foe of tax reform. See Synonyms at enemy.
4. Something that opposes, injures, or impedes: taxes that were the foe of economic development. [emphasis mine]
Lest I be accused of picking an inferior dictionary, the Free Online Dictionary is version of the "The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2009. Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved."

The Merriam Webster Online Dictionary defines "foe" as
1: one who has personal enmity for another
2 a : an enemy in war
  b : adversary, opponent
3: one who opposes on principle --a foe of needless expenditures
4: something prejudicial or injurious [emphasis mine]
I hope that Yankton gets through the next week without prejudice, enmity, or injury.  At the same time the bolded definitions indicate that the P&D was not prejudicial or biased in its word choice.  In fact, the example phrase accompanying the second bolded definition indicates that their word choice was exact.  Opt out opponents claim that the school district has been making many needless expenditures.
Once again, let's have a civil debate, but let's also have an accurate one.  The P&D correctly used the term, and their use of the term does not reflect a bias nor is it a case of the “'pot calling the kettle black.'”

Questions About a Four Day Week and Keeping Students

In the Yankton County Observer, Wayne Pibal asks some thought provoking questions.  He wonders about a four day school week.
Also, I like to see students attend class five days a week, but other nearby districts are saving money by going to four-day weeks.
I'm not sure the savings are there.  In this interview, Mike Griffith, the senior school finance analyst for Education Commission of the States, contends,
The only districts that save a lot money for moving to this are those districts that have an awful lot of bussing required and high transportation costs. So, it's those schools districts that have a small amount of students in a large geographical area. So, it tends to be rural districts that mostly pick up on this program.
Later, Griffith says,
They are because right now with the cutbacks in state funding and local funding they need to find ways to balance their budget. So, they're not left with many options at a certain point, so the things you're looking at are choices that are tough for anyone to make. Either larger class size or discontinuation of programs like arts and science and music or moving to something like this.


Now one of the issues around it is at first you think you can save a great deal of money, but as you look at it as a school or school district the amount you save is really not that high. You're talking maybe saving five percent or so from your budget. And so, once people start to see that the savings are that low, even though they talk about it and think about it they tend to back away from the four-day week
Griffith's analysis seems to indicate that the four day week will work for a district like Faith, South Dakota. Savings for districts like Yankton will be minimal.  Also, I'm pretty sure that parents with younger children in kindergarten, first grade, second grade will spend more on Friday day care than they will on the opt out.

Mr. Pibal also makes a good point about keeping Yankton's student base.
Finally, we have about 500 kids in the district who are choosing NOT to go to Yankton public schools. Why aren’t efforts being made to get them and their money back? They, alone, represent $2.25 million dollars.
I'm guessing here, but most parents who send their children to Sacred Heart, Yankton's christian schools, or who home school their students do so for religious reasons.  I doubt that any argument that the school district can muster will change their minds.  That fact doesn't mean that a careful, concentrated, tactful effort to recruit those students should not be made.

It also seems that the school and community need to ask if more students will be lost if the opt out doesn't pass.  For example, will parents will make other arrangements for their children because Yankton Middle School no longer offers after school activities?  If so, how many?  Exacerbating the problems caused by shrinking enrollment might be another potential hidden cost of a failed opt out.  For others, see Dr. Angie Hejl's excellent letter here.

Governor Daugaard and the 2011 South Dakota Legislature wounded Yankton School District.  Before one looks for ways to tone muscles, one should try to stop the bleeding.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Some Musings about Fear Mongering

The first song I remember hearing come out of a record player is "Just A Little Talk With Jesus."  In fact, I think it was this Tennessee Ernie Ford version.  My parents probably owned a version of the song on a 78, a 45, a 33 1/3 LP, a cassette, and a CD.  Some of you may have to ask your grandparents or great-grandparents what the numbers mean.


That song combined with one of the first Bible verses I remember memorizing for Sunday School--For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind (2 Timothy 1:7)--allowed me to understand that faith involves overcoming fear.

After the past few years, it's easy to see why people are afraid.  People in Yankton and throughout the United States lost homes and jobs.  During this opt out campaign, people have openly admitted that they fear not being able to buy food and pay the increased taxes because they are on a fixed income.  Others admit that they are afraid that current students won't have the same opportunities as previous Yankton graduates.  As teachers have lost jobs and programs have been cut, fears inside the school system have increased as well.

At this point, it does little good to try to place blame.  I don't believe that the Yankton School Board intended to frighten people.  Deep down I believe that most opt out opponents don't mean to unnecessarily frighten people either.

That's why hiring someone who sold Y2K survival kits is so troubling.  See here, here, and here.  Making money from fear should be left to Stephen King or Sam Raimi.  Of course, Y2K didn't happen.  That's why it's even more alarming that the same person would try to continue to hype the non-event by reminding people about it in 2008 when a Russian political analyst predicted the dissolution of the United States.

It's beyond troubling that this person drums up fear to advance his version of Christianity.   I was always taught that Christ was both perfect and the epitome of love.  I had to memorize this verse for Sunday School too: "There is no fear in love; but perfect love casteth out fear: because fear hath torment. He that feareth is not made perfect in love" (2 Timothy 4:18).

No one is perfect, so we will never totally eliminate fear.  Still the opt out debate will be much better if everyone tries to appeal to "sound minds" and not frighten people into voting only "the interests of their own pocket book."

Monday, May 16, 2011

I Think Silly Season Will Start Tonight

The Press & Dakotan carried this announcement in its May 3rd edition.
A public meeting concerning the Yankton School District opt-out, “Summit at the Summit II,” will be held at 7:01 p.m. Monday, May 16, at the Summit Activities Center, Yankton.

All citizens are invited to the second this event. Facts, feelings, healing and education will be discussed.

Special invitees include South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard, Secretary of Education Melodee Schopp and Superintendent of Yankton Schools Dr. Joseph Gertsema.

This opportunity is being presented for all citizens, especially those from South Dakota, and for citizens and friends of neighboring states.
Today, the paper carried this announcement:
A public meeting concerning the Yankton School District opt-out, “Summit at the Summit II,” will be held at 7:01 p.m. tonight (Monday) at the Summit Activities Center, Yankton. (This event is not sponsored by the Yankton School District.)

All citizens are invited to the second this event. Facts, feelings, healing and education will be discussed.
It's 6:07 am according the computer clock, so I might be a little punchy, but I don't see any mention of the Governor Daugaard or Secretary of Education Melody Schopp.  I'm really disappointed.  I have spent the past two weeks writing up questions about why they continue to emphasize STEM at the expense of the rest of the curriculum.

Again, it's a little after 6 am and I don't have my coffee, but I don't know how to attend "to the second" this event.  Does that mean if I show up before or after 7:01 pm I won't get a dorr prize?

If I were a betting man, I'd bet that someone who doesn't live in Yankton will speak at the meeting tonight.  He'll say things like "I'm not saying that Yankton schools do this but many places do....." or some variation of that statement.  Every one of the statements will be designed to put the school district in the worst possible light and inflame the situation.

Facts will be in the background.  "Feelings" will dominate.  Some will have been coached to express "feelings" designed to anger opt out supporters and promote a confrontation.

If this had been a genuine effort, the Yankton School District would have participated.  If this had been a genuine effort, I suspect that Governor Daugaard would have dispatched his Lieutenant Governor Matt Michaels, a Yankton native, to attend, and his attendance would have been confirmed in the first announcement and covered in a front page article today.

I'm really torn.  Do I want to watch this meeting turn into a tragic circus or do I want to stay home and watch House?  Both are likely to have the same amount of genuine "facts, feelings, healing, and education."

Now that I've had coffee, I will place one small bet.  Nothing at tonight's meeting will "heal" the situation for teachers who have lost their jobs.

Friday, May 13, 2011

Opt Out Opponents Won't Answer Questions

Blogger has been down, so some posts and comments have disappeared, and this post may show up twice.  Because it’s been sent by email twice, the format may be a little off.

Shane Gerlach posted my questions from this post on this Press and Dakotan comment thread. I understand why there’s no comments here; Blogger has been less than cooperative.  However, even in that forum, opt out opponents (OOOs), refused to give any numbers in this response:

charlie wrote on May 12, 2011 3:00 PM:
" The school board is a government entity.
As such, they typically will not cut their budget voluntarily. Once a new position, schedule, service, sport, etc. is established (should have included taxes) it will remain forever. It is so much easier to request more money than it is to fine tune the budget. The school board has opted out. That is not a request for money, that is a statement that they are taking more money.
Taxpayers were not included in their decision making, but we will be now.
How much is too much and how long is too long?
My answer is to have the board ( who I heard is making plans for another less invasive opt out) show the taxpayers last years expenses compared to next years. Sell the taxpayers on a program that couples budget cuts with opt-out dollars, whatever that figure may be.
Length of each opt out should be no longer than one year at a time. It is a simple majority vote to make this happen.
Taxpayers can assess their opt out figures and do nothing or refer again if they consider it excessive.
In the words of one of our greater Presidents "Trust but Verify". "
Let's parse this response a bit. First, the anti-government rhetoric is straight from the starve the beast playbook. In short, starve the beast is an effort to destroy any government entity by refusing to fund it. Next, there's the salute to Ronald Reagan's repeated Russian proverb "Trust but Verify." I don't know who Charlie is, but I'm betting that Charlie and I both remember that Reagan used this phrasing when negotiating with the Soviets. In short, Charlie seems to be implying that public schools are linked to Soviet dictatorships. That tactic seems to come straight from the Paul Dorr playbook.

Most importantly, there are no numbers.  Sometimes what's not said is as important as what is said.  The stubborn refusal to even consider supplying numbers indicates that no amount will satisfy OOOs.  Every piece of information Charlie requests is available here and OOOs know it.

Let's review.  An OOO spokesperson uses starve the beast language and implies that Yankton School District is a relic of the Soviet Union.  Charlie also refuses to give any number that would be acceptable for an opt out.  Finally, OOOs hire Paul Dorr who has repeatedly stated he wants to insure the demise of public education.

There's another old saying that's as important as "trust but verify"; "Once is an accident . Twice is a trend. Three times is a problem."  OOOs have a problem:  their tactics, words or lack of words, and hired consultant all seem to indicate that their ultimate goal is to destroy Yankton's public schools.

Update #1:  This comment has been made on the thread accompanying "Opt-out Foes Hire Consultant."
charlie wrote on May 13, 2011 7:06 AM:
" I agree a mess is coming. As one opposed to the opt-out I am also opposed to bringing in outside consultants. Our community can fight it's own battles.
However, one must keep in mind that it was not CFSE or Dorr or taxpayers that threw the first punch. Our school superintendant and school board voted to shackle our homeowners, businesses, and farmers with a 41 million dollar ball and chain that they admit they may not need. Also, the board cannot possibly foresee 10 years down the road what income and expenses they will have. 
Had the board solicited taxpayer input prior to demanding this obscene amount of money for an obscene amount of time we would not be in this position.
We don't need Paul Dorr, but we also don't need a school board that frightens the taxpayers so much that they would hire him. "
Although I strongly disagree with Charlie's statement that the school board has said they won't need the money or that they "threw the first punch," I appreciate Charlie's response to Mr. Dorr's arrival.  It takes more courage to stand up to those in your own circle than it does to take on your opponents.

A hearty debate helps communities grow.  Mr. Dorr does not promote healthy debate; he will leave a divided, angry community in his wake.  He will also leave a weakened school system.   That divided community and weakened system make it unlikely that an opt out effort that meets Charlie's criteria will ever come about.  Mr. Dorr's arrival will permanently change Yankton's social and political landscape.  If this opt out fails, proposals for one year opt outs for minuscule amounts will be challenged, and Yankton will the see the current cracks in its social structure become chasms.

Update # 2:  This comments thread still has no answers to the questions posed here.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

What The Opt Out Debate Has Been Missing

Maybe it was this Madville Times post that fleshed out Paul Dorr's original colorful unique bizarre world view a little more. Maybe it was this comment to my Paul Dorr post:
The situation regarding the Yankton school boards decision to opt-out is not being challenged because the district residents do not want to properly fund education. The opt-out calls for over 41 million dollars and extends for 10 years. Opponents of this claim it is too much and too long a period and believe the school board overstepped its responsibility to the taxpayers.With or without Mr. Dorr this opt-out is doomed to fail. 
Anyway, I was suddenly struck with the fact that this debate has had cases laid out on both sides.  The opt out opponents have asked questions "for the purpose of cross-examination and points of clarification."  In fact, one of the first ads opposing the opt out listed numerous questions.  I have yet to see the opt out supporters ask their questions.  So at the risk of being presumptuous, I'll ask a few questions using the above comment and a few other issues that have dominated the debate so far as a flow.

If 4.1 million dollars per year for 10 years is "too much and too long," what dollar amount is acceptable?  Is it $3.8 million?  $2.5 million?  $750,000?  $2.25?  As a follow up, how long is acceptable?  7 years?  4 years? 1 year?

Can we all agree that bus barn and administration building will not be "un-built" if the opt out fails?  Since that's the case, how will stopping the opt out remedy the harm that opponents claim the building project caused?  As a follow up, do you think the school board and administrators are lying when they say that the capital outlay fund that was used to build those buildings can't be used for general fund obligations?

Do you think that the current general fund balances are sufficient for the school district to do its job?  What level would be sufficient?

Opponents of the opt out claim that Dr. Gertsema and other administrators are overpaid; what should their salary be?  Is there a salary amount that will not be too high?

Some opponents have suggested that Yankton teachers take a pay cut.  Have any of the opponents done any studies of the economic impact of those cuts?  For example, if teachers were to take a 10% cut, which businesses will see their profit margin drop because fewer goods or services are being purchased?  As a follow up, would that loss in business be more or less than the cost of the opt out?

Is anyone opposing the opt out hoping to see an increase in business as they help those people whose jobs have been eliminated leave town?

If the opponents of the opt out are not opposed to funding public education, why are they allying themselves with a person who vehemently expresses his desire to see public education ended everywhere? 

If the opt out is truly doomed to fail, why risk the possibility of "guilt by association"? Why not defeat the opt out without Dorr's involvement? 

As a final question, Dorr claims he opposes opt outs for profit.  If the opt out is going to lose anyway, why spend the money to hire a consultant to accomplish something that is going to happen with or without him?  Does that act make good business sense?

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Let's Talk Or Not

This morning The Madville Times made the following observation about the Madison school board's budget decisions.  
Note also that there was no public discussion of these cuts prior to Monday night’s meeting.. . .

We just drop the bomb, then tell the paper the board “will review other budget reductions in the future,” with no indication of what those cuts might be.
This morning the Yankton Press and Dakotan made the following observation about the Yankton School Board's Monday meeting that cut 22 teaching and 39 extracurricular positions.
During the meeting, the board adopted the personnel cuts and other budget strategies that were unveiled late last week. It was a harrowing evening for all involved, from the school officials on the YMS auditorium stage to the large crowd on hand (not to mentions the teachers whose names were read aloud as they were officially placed on the chopping block).

But one thing that was missing was input from the public. School officials explained the reasons why they did what they felt they had to do, meticulously going over the numbers and the projections. But then publicly elected officials took no questions or comments from the public that elected them. One person did try to address the board, but he was told that there would be time to ask questions later. Some audience members probably assumed this meant there would be an opportunity for public comment later, but this did not happen. Instead, the school board adjourned into an executive session and did not reconvene.
It seems both governing bodies want to avoid confrontation.  Perhaps both boards believe that a utilitarian calculus or pragmatic reasoning works best.  In short do the best for the most in the most efficient way possible.  That strategy probably won't work in stressful times, especially times that include job cuts.  These times demand both actual fair treatment and the perception of fairness.

Therefore, it seems necessary that someone practice philosophy without a license and introduce both to a portion of Jurgen Habermas's Discourse Ethics as explained by Robert Cavalier.
As David Ingram puts it, community members' participation in discourse will be "unobstructed by ideological prejudices, temporal limitations, and external domination - be it cultural, social, political, or economic" (Ingram, 1990, 148).     To circumscribe such discourse more carefully, Habermas takes up rules first proposed by Robert Alexy as "the Rules of Reason" (1990, 165-167). In Habermas's formulation in "Discourse Ethics," these are:
     1. Every subject with the competence to speak and act is allowed to take part in a discourse.
     2a. Everyone is allowed to question any assertion whatever.
     2b. Everyone is allowed to introduce any assertion whatever into the discourse.
     2c. Everyone is allowed to express his attitudes, desires, and needs.
     3. No speaker may be prevented, by internal or external coercion, from exercising his rights.
Such rules are seen to circumscribe the ideal speech situation, one which stresses equality and freedom for each participant - especially
freedom to participate in the discourse in critical ways so as to express one's own attitudes, desires, and needs, and
freedom from coercion of several sorts.
School boards have to make difficult decisions.  It makes sense to want to make them quickly and cleanly.  Habermas's method may be messy, but in the long run allowing people the "freedom to participate in the discourse in critical ways so as to express one's own attitudes, desires, and needs" will allay the fears of the people who are anxious and confused.

The P&D editorial concludes.
These are six weeks before the opt-out referendum, and school officials and their allies will be working hard to sell the need of this move. But along the way, they also need to take the time to listen, to answer questions and to reassure the public that this is the right approach. A little empathy would go a long way on this issue right about now. 
 Being a little philosophical might be the most practical thing for all concerned right now.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

This Week In Opt Outs

Tom Holmstrom wrote a letter to the editor supporting the opt-out.  Using Department of Corrections data, Holmstrom noted that that South Dakota correction facilities need from $5,777.95 to $29,189.05 to house an inmate whereas schools got by on $4,804.60 last year.  Holstrom does not remind his readers that schools will have $4,389.95 next year.  Given that over $90 of that is one-time money, schools will probably have less than $4,300 in the 2012-2013 school year.

The Yankton Press & Dakoton's River City section contained an advertisement questioning, among other things, the construction of the new administrative building and bus barn and YSD's retire and rehire practices.  It also alleges that YSD has a history misleading the public.  I can't find the ad online, but will try to scan a PDF and post it later.

The Yankton County Observer gives front page coverage to the Charlii Gilson's efforts to bring the opt out to a public vote.  The online Observer requires a subscription, but the print edition reports that Gilson, a Yankton realtor, will return to Yankton from and undisclosed Arizona location to turn in a "pile" of petitions before the April 4 deadline.  Gilson hopes to have over 1,000 signatures.  Fewer than 600 would be needed to put the opt out to a vote.  The Observer quotes a senior citizen who signed the petition as saying that she "doesn't want anyone to lose a job"; she favors "across the board cuts" including "giving all school district personnel less pay than they have been receiving."

Inside, Wayne Pibal, one of the Observer's publishers, opines that YSD officials should carefully answer the questions posed by the P&D ad.  Pibal concludes with the following advice, 
Should there be an opt-out vote, and we think there just might be, people that want it passed might have to hold our hands a little more than should be necessary.
If they do your job well, though, they will lead us to the place we ought to be.
The pronoun references in the last sentence confuse me a bit, but I believe that last sentence means that Pibal concludes YSD might get the opt out if they play the political game shrewdly.

Finally, in my continued effort to introduce mythological digressions, Rumor, the swiftest of all evils, dashed through one of the district's buildings and caused whiplash and welts as employees tried to determine which aging debutante working in the building had signed the petition to bring the opt out to a vote.