Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 22, 2019

What All The Civics Education Proposals Miss: BS Detection 101

The 2019 South Dakota Legislative Session is awash in civics legislation and proposals. HB 1051 will put a sticker on diplomas of students who "demonstrate competencies" in the following:
(1)    An understanding of the basic principles of American democracy and how those principles are applied in a republican form of government;
(2)    An understanding of the Constitutions of the United States and of this state;
(3)    Knowledge of the founding documents and how those documents shape the nature and function of the government; and
(4)    An understanding of landmark United States Supreme Court cases and the impact of those cases on law and society.
SB 52 requires a semester of civics education. Governor Noem wants students to pass the citizenship test.

There's nothing inherently wrong with any of those proposals, but they miss the point. Any civics education program should begin with long unit on BS detection. I'd suggest this video as start. It has the basis of two weeks worth of lessons if not more.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Intelligence, Education, And Insults Edition


Indeed, the biggest insult to the intelligence of American teachers is the idea that their intelligence doesn't matter. “The teaching of A, B, C, and the multiplication table has no quality of sacredness in it,” Horace Mann said in 1839. Instead of focusing on students’ mental skills, Mann urged, teachers should promote “good-will towards men” and “reverence to God.” Teachers need to be good, more than they need to be smart; their job is to nurture souls, not minds. So Garret Keizer’s first supervisor worried that he might have too many grades of A on his college transcript to succeed as a high school teacher, and Elizabeth Green concludes her otherwise skeptical book with the much-heard platitude that teachers need to “love” their students.
Keizer is offended by comments like that, and he has every good reason to be. Do lawyers have to love their clients? Must doctors adore their patients? What American teachers need now is not love, but a capacity for deep and disciplined thinking that will reflect—and respect—the intellectual complexities of their job. It won’t do to simply strip away our insipid accountability systems and leave everything in the hands of present-day teachers, who are mostly unprepared for the tasks we have set before them. The US badly needs to design and develop an entirely different system of teacher education, stressing cognitive skills above all else. Anything less will leave our teachers languishing in “intellectual stagnation,” as Elizabeth Cady Stanton told Susan B. Anthony, and our schools mired in mediocrity.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

Unless One Is Starving, Many Things In Education Are More Important Than School Lunch

I really shouldn't have to point out the claim this post's title makes. The fact should be rather self-evident. Unfortunately, Representative Kristi Noem (R-SD), seems fixated on school lunches.

Tweets are supposed to be short, but Noem used only 115 of her allotted 140 characters, so let's go through a short list of "issues that impact SD schools" Noem could have emphasized with a similar number of characters.
25% new superintendents
SD's teacher shortage
Students in poverty
DoE usurps federalism (It's possible I missed the memo that conservatives no longer support federalism or that Noem has renounced conservative principles.)
Testing = corp welfare (I suppose I shouldn't expect Noem to discuss this issue. Corporate welfare is the onlywelfare she supports.)
Arne Duncan's failures (Why is he the only member of the Obama administration Republicans won't criticize?)
Frankly, school lunches should have been part of the tweet only if Noem has evidence that school lunches are composed of Soylent Green. She could have edited other parts of her tweet to make room for"Soylent Green is people!.

Friday, June 13, 2014

The David Brat Victory Has Produced Good Results

The Brat victory and some reactions to it have led to this Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry column "It's Urgent To Put The Liberal Arts Back At The Center Of Education" in  Forbes. Contra South Dakota Governor Dennis Daugaard, Gobry asserts that education ought not exist solely to crate workers:
Nobody stops to ask what education is for, because the answer is implicitly accepted by all: an education is for getting a job. It is, in other words, for being a cog in the giant machine of post-industrial capitalism. It is, in other words, for the opposite thing that our forefathers wanted for us. I do not use these words lightly, but it is against–in the sense that a headwind is against a ship–the very foundations of our liberty and our civilization.
Before reaching this conclusion, Gorby runs through a brief primer on a liberal education and virtue. Did I mention this post was on the Forbes website?

Back to David Brat, apparently he wrote an academic paper asserting that the state retains a legitimate monopoly on violence. At the National Review Charles Cooke runs down the outraged reactions (PNR is off to other duties this week, so it falls to me to be the member of the South Dakota blogosphere who posts an NRO quotation .)
“Unusual” and “eye-opening” was the New York Daily News’s petty verdict. In the Wall Street Journal, Reid Epstein insinuated darkly that the claim cast Brat as a modern-day fascist. And, for his part, Politico’s Ben White suggested that the candidate’s remarks “on Neitzsche and the government monopoly on violence don’t make a whole lot of sense.” As is its wont, the progressive blogosphere lost its collective marbles too: One contributor sardonically described Brat’s claim as a “doozy,” while another contended that such opinions were sufficient for “one to question his, shall we say, cognitive coherence.”
Cooke then goes on to take these reporters to task for not understanding a relatively basic concept enunciated by Max Weber. Cooke also rightly faults both ends of the political spectrum for using language imprecisely:
To refuse to subordinate language to politics is the first and most important duty of the free man. Alas, both Left and Right too often lean toward imprecision and pretense when it suits their ends, shooting sharpened daggers at plain-speaking sorts who dare to express the less pleasant truths of our society in harsh and unlovely language. The Left reacts with particular exasperation when one observes that taxation is forced confiscation of property; the Right when one points out that firearms are lethal weapons whose purpose is to kill.
Brat's candidacy has brought about a column discussing the nature of government and a column explaining that education ought to create citizens not workers. Apparently, he also defeated an arrogant ass. If only he could just get rid of that Ayn Rand fetish.

Thursday, July 18, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Technology And Education--Do As I Say, Not As I Do Edition

From this Alan Jacobs post:
But most important, as Newstok points out, the very same technology mavens who insist that excellent education can be provided, via MOOC, to people dispersed all over the world — “The changes ahead will ultimately bring about the most beneficial, most efficient and most equitable access to education that the world has ever seen” — do not themselves act as though physical proximity to smart, gifted, exciting people is a matter of no significance. Rather, they consistently pay premium prices in housing to live in one of the handful of places in the United States — Silicon Valley, Seattle, Brooklyn, Austin, Cambridge — where they can count on a critical mass of like-minded people being present. They clearly believe that not just their personal well-being but also their intellectual sharpness depend on regular face-to-face encounters with others like them. Yet they proclaim that for hoi polloi none of that matters.
If physical presence is as important in education as the technologists’s actions say it is, then perhaps their energies are misapplied. Instead of looking for ways to eliminate or bypass brick-and-mortar schools — and, not incidentally, making a hefty profit for themselves in doing so — maybe they should bend their considerable intellectual powers to the more challenging, less destructive, and far more meaningful challenge of making college education more affordable for everyone who can truly benefit from it.

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: The Less Educated Generation Edition

From this Alan Jacobs post:
Jeffrey Selingo, who has written a book about American colleges and universities, says: “One of the fears, and one of my fears, is that we might become a country where the next generation is less educated than the generation that preceded it.”
A major part of the problem is that colleges and universities have invested more strenuously in amenities than in education, with the assumption that students absorbed in the delights of their dining halls and climbing walls won’t notice that their teachers are largely underpaid adjuncts who have to jump from course to course and college to college to try to get something close to minimum-wage levels of pay. (Consider this:“About 70 percent of the instructional faculty at all colleges is off the tenure track, whether as part-timers or full-timers, a proportion that has crept higher over the past decade.”) 

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Quotation Of The Day:Vocabulary And Education

From E.D. Hirsch:
It isn’t overstating the case to say that the most secure way to predict whether an educational policy is likely to help restore the middle class is to focus on the question: Is this policy likely to expand the vocabularies of 12th-graders?
Hirsch may be correct, but his Common Core disciples and their STEM allies aren't producing those policies.

Friday, November 9, 2012

Person Who Helps Determine What Goes In Nation's Textbooks Claims People Who Voted For Obama Racist Maggotss

Given some of the hyperbolic reactions that South Dakotans have had to Obama's re-election, (sorry, I can't bring myself to link to Howie's site to back up my point about hyperbole) one should have expected that Texas would do it much bigger. Hardin County Republican treasurer Peter Morrison wants to separate from the Untied States:
"Let each go her own way," he writes, demanding an "amicable divorce" from the U.S. and from the "maggots" who re-elected President Obama.

Evoking the history of Confederate soldiers who refused to surrender after Gettysburg, Morrison, 33, calls for Texans to fight "in hopes that Providence might shine upon our cause."

Morrison is particularly angry at Asian-Americans and Hispanics who backed Obama, accusing them of voting on an "ethnic basis."

"'They' re-elected Obama," Morrison wrote. "He is their president."
Given that I don't know who chairs the Democratic or Republican parties locally, I really shouldn't care what a racist Texan writes in a "race-heavy newsletter."

On the other hand, "Morrison was chosen by former State Board of Education Chairman Don McLeroy to help screen Texas public school textbooks."

It's taken as an article of faith in the education community that Texas has a disproportionate impact on the textbooks used the nation's schools. Even Fox News says so:
Since Texas is the second largest consumer of textbooks in the U.S., publishers often create a book that meets Texas standards and then sell the same version to school districts across the country.
I hope Dr. Blanchard has posts some back up material to help South Dakota history teachers remind students that the Civil War was about slavery and nothing else. I have no desire to parse the sentence: "Everyone who voted for President Obama is a maggot." I don't want to use that sentence as an example of a metaphor either.

Morrision's ideas, however, may make my job as a debate coach easier. Last session, Representative Steve Hickey pushed through a resolution urging schools to teach the Bible. Romans 13 poses some interesting questions about succession or "separation."
1 Let everyone be subject to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. 2 Consequently, whoever rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves.
The Bible also has that pesky little reminder that everyone is created in God's image; it's tough to see how people created in God's image and who did their duty and voted are "maggots," but I don't live in Texas and I'm not a Republican.
Read more here: http://www.star-telegram.com/2012/11/08/4399621/hardin-county-gop-official-wants.html#storylink=cpy

Friday, October 5, 2012

Someone In Yankton Doesn't Have A Foot Fetish

That person may also need corrective lenses. I suggest that he or she drink a bit of warm milk and take some Ambien. I'm not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV, but I do know that lack of sleep blurs one's vision and makes one irritable.

The Yankton School District has hired a new counselor, Tiffany Kashas, to help develop drug and alcohol prevention programs and help students who suffer from substance abuse. The Woksape, the school newspaper profiled Ms. Kashas and the programs she is beginning. The profile was accompanied by the following photo.


An unknown enlightened citizen, presumably one who keeps track of those who wear white after Labor Day, saw fit to send Ms. Kashas a note taking her to task for not wearing shoes and complaining that her bare feet were disgusting.

Far be it from me to criticize a person for his or her fetishes or lack thereof. I also don't claim the right to arbitrate fashion.

I would like to point out that Ms. Kashas is wearing sandals. I would also like to remind the anonymous person who sent her the letter criticizing her wardrobe that the young'uns don't trust the folks in  formal suits. They are much more likely to trust a young person who dresses and talks like a young professional.  Finally, isn't having programs to help students more important than whether a young woman wears sandals? (That's a rhetorical question, an accepted literary device in situations such as this.)

So allow me to offer the following advice to the anonymous person.
  1. Get your eyes checked. Buy some readers. They are a cheap alternative to prescription glasses.
  2. Cut back of the caffeine and lighten up! Seriously, whether another human being wears sandals is enough to rile you up?
  3. Concentrate on what's important: you know, helping kids avoid or confront drug abuse.
  4. Keep you fetish preferences or lack thereof to yourself.
  5. Have the guts to sign your name to every letter you send or don't send it.

Monday, September 24, 2012

This May Be The Best Education Video Of All Time

Father Guido Sarducchi solved America's education problems, but no one listened. Our loss!


Monday, September 10, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Capitalism And Education Edition

Gary Gutting explains capitalism and education::
From our infancy the market itself has worked to make us consumers, primed to buy whatever it is selling regardless of its relevance to human flourishing. True freedom requires that we take part in the market as fully formed agents, with life goals determined not by advertising campaigns but by our own experience of and reflection on the various possibilities of human fulfillment. Such freedom in turn requires a liberating education, one centered not on indoctrination, social conditioning or technical training but on developing persons capable of informed and intelligent commitments to the values that guide their lives.
This is why, especially in our capitalist society, education must not be primarily for training workers or consumers (both tools of capitalism, as Marxists might say). Rather, schools should aim to produce self-determining agents who can see through the blandishments of the market and insist that the market provide what they themselves have decided they need to lead fulfilling lives. Capitalism, with its devotion to profit, is not in itself evil. But it becomes evil when it controls our choices for the sake of profit.
The whole article is a must read. I also loved his analysis of the role of work in creating human flourishing.

Monday, September 3, 2012

Students Need To Sleep BEFORE Class

It's Labor Day, and I'm already feeling like the old cantankerous curmudegeon that I usually become in February. I'll blame the July and August heat.

One of the statments that angers me and turns me into the curmudgeon by February is parents' statements about their students' study habits. The conversation goes something like this:
Me: Your young'un has failed a couple of quizzes.
Parent: I don't know what to do; the young'un studies way past midnight every night.
I am always tempted to responsd that the learning that goes on in a bedroom after 1 a.m. probably has little to do with what happens in the classroom, but I also want to stay employed, so I refrain.
Now, I have a scientific answer: MAKE THE YOUNG'UN GO TO SLEEP. Scientific American reports,
In a new study, scientists had more than 500 high school students document how long they studied and slept over two weeks. They also had them note any negatives during that period—things like not understanding a lecture.
The researchers found that the students who studied a lot at the expense of sleep had significantly more issues than those who kept a more balanced study schedule. The academic issues typically came the day after sacrificing sleep.
The article also brings up something I've long believed. The students who balance studying, rest, and their social life tend to study more than those who claim they put in the long marathon sessions:
Overall, those students who studied the most still had the best grades. But researchers note that those same students tended to keep a consistent schedule, and did not vary the length of study or sleep time. It was the irregular sleep schedules in particular that correlated with more academic problems.

Saturday, August 18, 2012

How Many South Dakotans Agree That School Are "Godless" And Teachers Are "Vampires"?

A commenter left the following opinion on the Yankton Press & Dakotan comment section:
Public schools are Godless and socialist. Parents should pay for your child's education not me.
He further opined that "teachers are vampires that suck the blood from tax payer."

I'm curious about how many South Dakotans share his views. I don't have firm stats or a poll, but I think it's safe to say that about 15% of the state identifies with Gordon Howie, Bob Ellis et al. The over/under of those citizens who agree with the comments is 90%.

I'm guessing that about 20% of the state is self-identified liberal Democrats. They would disagree with the premise that there should be no public schools and may not care if the schools are Godless. They may still see teachers as vampires. Even with that caveat, the over/under of the liberal Democrats who would agree with the proffered opinion is 6%.

The remaining 65% are mainstream Republicans and conservative Democrats. Republicans make up the lion's share of that number.. Here's where the guesstimates get scary. Ten years ago, I would have set the over/under for members of this group who agree with comment at 15%. Now, I'm setting it at 55%.

I welcome comments about either my analysis of South Dakota's political make-up or my my odds making..

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Everything That's Wrong With Education: A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words

The picture comes from a late 19th Century and early 20th Century series designed to show what France would be like in the 21st Century:
France in the Year 2000 (XXI century) – a series of futuristic pictures by Jean-Marc Côté and other artists issued in France in 1899, 1900, 1901 and 1910. Originally in the form of paper cards enclosed in cigarette/cigar boxes and, later, as postcards, the images depicted the world as it was imagined to be like in the year 2000. There are at least 87 cards known that were authored by various French artists, the first series being produced for the 1900 World Exhibition in Paris.
It's a bit disconcerting how accurately the artist predicted American education in 2012.

Image Via Wikimedia Commons

Let's look at a few specifics:
  • Fill students up with unconnected facts to meet standards of indeterminate worth: check
  • Boredom: check
  • Technology without context: check
  • No serious interaction with materiel: check
The only thing missing is a bubble test and a state bureaucrat looking over the teacher's shoulder.

Monday, August 6, 2012

Proof That Public Education Has Failed

Last night, I stayed up to watch the Mars Rover Curiosity land. I discovered a couple of things that led me to conclude that American public education has failed.

Education should remind one that limits exist. Some seem to have forgotten that fact

Public education probably deserves a pass for this faux pas. Last night was a  celebratory moment for the science geek crowd. I wouldn't have stayed up to watch a rover land on Mars if it weren't for a few talented science geeks who must have learned something in school.
 
On the other hand, some failures are damning. While waiting for the rover to land, I clicked on a couple of links that led me to the Florida Constitution Party's site where I "learned" that President Obama will fake his assassination to prevent the 2012 election from occurring.

The post admits that the possibility is based on rumor but tells readers that one must be vigilant:
What I’m going to report here is only a rumor that presently can’t be confirmed. But it is of such magnitude that it must be made known if only to prepare America for a possible terrible eventuality. And while it has not been confirmed, neither can it authoritatively and convincingly be denied, certainly not in a United States where our Constitutional rights are under constant attack.
The Florida Constitution Party quotes a Canada Free Press claim that the  Department of Homeland Security is conspiring with President Obama in order to start a racial civil war:
“The DHS is actively preparing for massive social unrest inside the United States . He then corrected himself, stating that ‘a civil war’ is the more appropriate term. Certain elements of the government are not only expecting and preparing for it, they are actually facilitating it.”
The DHS whistleblower mentioned a recent meeting at the Department of Homeland Security where plans were discussed to use pawns to simulate the rioting seen in the Arab Spring countries that would bring on a “controlled chaos” for the benefit of the Obama administration.
“Envisioned by these conspirators are riots starting in urban areas such as New York , followed by a disruption of business and commerce,” the DHS source added. “They want to restrict travel, if not through high energy prices, then by checkpoints and curfews mandated by the rioting and unrest…The whole purpose is to keep Obama in office for another term, no matter how unpopular he is, as he is not finished changing our country from a Constitutional Republic .”
I'm a bit shocked that the Florida Constitution Party didn't mention Marxist agitators with Alinsky leaning Masonic tendencies or New Age  Kenyan socialist colonialists who worship Thor on Wednesdays, but I digress.

The Constitution Party offers proof; there have been other rumors:
This certainly isn’t the first rumor to surface about Mr. Obama’s intention to subvert the U.S. Constitution, by manipulating economic, racial and social issues that would polarize Americans and bring on enormous conflict but the full measure of this contrived event, if true, involves total suspension of our democratic rights, and repression on a scale never thought possible in the America we’ve known and cherished all our lives.
The Florida Constitution Party must have stayed awake during a win/win class discussion. They have set up a classic win/win:
It’s a rumor that bears watching…and is worth spreading because the more people who know about it–and understand the high level of deceit and treachery that confronts us daily in Washington –the less likely it is for the rumor to become a reality.
They get to scream "I told you so!" or "We saved the Republic!"

I don't want to count the logical fallacies wrapped in racism that these people are perpetrating. I will point out that students graduating from any high school in the United States should know  being "updated several times a day" or claiming to have "more than 100 writers and columnists who file stories regularly to the newspaper from all corners of the globe" does not make a site reliable. The World Weekly News makes the same claim with they allege that Bat Boy will be Romney's running mate. More importantly they all should know that one doesn't use one unsubstantiated rumor to support another.

I need to make sure I add recognizing stupidity in all of its various forms to a few more lesson plans. For the members of the Florida Constitution Party, I'll offer the following: people put false claims on the Internet. This State Farm advertisement is using irony when the actress states otherwise. The character is gullible. By the way, the guy with the beard really isn't a French model.

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

The Bane Of Education

It's not this; teachers aren't superheroes.


Instead, the Tempered Radical points out that it's this.






By the way, merit pay and testing just to test isn't creative, but this slide is also a mirror.  I got in a rut last year and need to change some things.

Sunday, June 10, 2012

A Musing About Politics And High School Debate

People tend to believe high school teachers are liberals.  The thinking apparently stems from the logic that the National Education has endorsed President Obama and Obama instituted health care reform so teachers must be socialists.

At the National Forensics League's National Tournament, conservative vendors seem to be engaging in capitalism.  One vendor sells handbooks extolling conservative values of the Constitution.  My favorite, however. Is the Ayn Rand Institute.  The young, enthusiastic Randians handed out a free Ayn Rand Sampler that contained excerpts from Atlas Shrugged and The Virtue of Selfishness.  I'm unsure how Rand herself would react to her work being given away.

For the record I saw no Chomsky readers and no one offered handbooks deconstructing the Constitution.

Is it possible that education is not a liberal monolith?

Monday, May 28, 2012

How People Think And How To Think About School

A thought provoking look at how people think and create and what schools do to them.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Maybe We Shouldn't Study War So Much

While discussing Romney's foreign policy team, Colin Powell gave the following sound advice:
"Look at the world. There is no pure competitor of the United States of America.  All the problems we talk about in Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran ... they count about 700 million people in a world of seven billion. What are the rest of them doing? They're increasing their economies, they're building wealth, they're educating their kids, they're building their infrastructure. That's what we need to be doing."
A little Louis Armstrong might help make the point.



Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Today I Really Like Google Edition

Marissa Mayer, Goggle's "vice president of local, maps, and location services—and the driving force behind more than a hundred of Google’s products and services, including search, news, gmail, earth, books, and toolbar" just made my school year seem worthwhile.  In a Daily Beast interview, she asserts,
"One of the more interesting things they’ve found is that programming aptitude and excellence is more tied to verbal SAT scores than to math SAT scores,” she explained. “Beyond basic mathematical aptitude, the difference between good programmers and great programmers is verbal ability.”
Clarity of expression is something Mayer prizes so dearly that she uses it as a litmus test when evaluating new ideas. Disruptive technology should solve big problems and have widespread applications, but it should also be easy to understand. “I think about my mom,” she told Brown. “She’s very smart. She’s a little intimidated by technology. So when a new idea comes up, I think, ‘How would I explain it to her?’”