Showing posts with label A Minor Musing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A Minor Musing. Show all posts

Sunday, January 26, 2020

HB 1078 And Exempting Guns From The Sales Tax: A Minor Musing

It's difficult to take  HB 1078, a bill to exempt guns, bullets, and gunpowder from sales tax seriously.

First, some of its sponsors frequently seem more interested in triggering the libs than they are in passing productive legislation.

Second, it's entirely possible the bill is merely a vehicle for a scorecard issuing group with a name like People Perpetuating Pistoliers into Perpetuity to point out someone they deem a Republican in Name Only (RINO) lacks perfect fealty to the Second Amendment.

For this post, let's stipulate that Representatives Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, and Weis along with Senators (Phil)  Jensen and Monroe have every intention of passing this legislation.

Their argument likely proceeds as follows.
  1. The right to self-defense is a human right.

  2. That right is enshrined in the Second Amendment.

  3. With rights come responsibilities and citizens have a duty to carry firearms to protect themselves.

  4. When South Dakota taxes guns and ammunition, the state places an onerous burden on citizens' efforts to exercise that right and fulfill their duty.

  5. No state should place onerous burdens on the exercising of rights; therefore, items necessary to exercise a right, in this case guns and ammunition, should be exempt from the sales tax.
One wonders if sponsors Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, Weis, (Phil)  Jensen, and Monroe have thought through the ramifications of the argument because points 4 and 5 tacitly admit that South Dakota's sales tax is regressive.

Further, if humans indeed have an inalienable right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness," it follows that they have a right to items, like food,  that are necessary to exercise the right to life. If the solution to solve regression is exempting items from the sales tax, then there shouldn't be any argument against exempting groceries

I haven't heard the the bill's sponsors speak on the issue, but they may believe guns are more necessary than groceries. That's a tough argument to win. People need to eat more frequently than they need to use a gun for self-defense or any other reason. I'd wager that they and everyone who reads this post has eaten more often than they have used a gun in self-defense.

Perhaps their argument is that states as an entity should protect guns and not protect butter. That analogy has a fraught history.

In short, legislators Pischke, Hammock, Mulally, Weis, (Phil)  Jensen, and Monroe seem to have been too clever by half. In creating legislation that tacitly admits that South Dakota's tax structure is regressive, they are laying the groundwork necessary to eliminate the sales tax on food. I doubt that was their intention.

Monday, September 2, 2019

The Summer Of 1957 Wrecked Castles: What I Learned On My Summer Vacation.

I have spent good portions of the summer making eight hour car trips and reading books and articles written by people smarter than I am. The latter activity caused me to play too many hours of Castle Wreck on my phone as I tried to think through some subtle points. Here's what I concluded.

Conclusion 1: Populists may be correct that the educated elites who have run the nation's public and private institutions have failed. HOWEVER, the fact that intelligent educated folk have failed does create the corollary that poorly educated folks who dislike thinking or who are unable to think will succeed.

Conclusion 2: Fear dominates the national zeitgeist.

Conclusion 3: In The Grapes of Wrath, Steinbeck writes that there's fine line between fear and anger. The current era points to a fine line between fear and languor.

Conclusion 4: Public debate was formerly dominated by disputing the implication of facts; it's now dangerously dominated by disputation of what constitutes a fact.

Conclusion 5: Personal stories still retain power, but shortened attention spans and listeners' desire to have personal biases confirmed makes people less likely to share their stories honestly.

Conclusion 6: The weaponizing of Christianity in the service to Trump has less to do with glorifying God than it does in justifying the practitioners' preferred sins.

Conclusion 7: Too many now view politics as a religion or power as a god. Those that have those attitudes increasingly view people outside of their circle as threats or evil. I doubt any democratic republic can survive once a plurality holds those views.

Conclusion 8: If being created in the image of God or endowed with inalienable rights means anything, humans should not be treated as pawns by employers or governments.

Conclusion 9: I have never been to Mt. Sinai, so I don't need ten conclusions.

By the way, Castle Wreck drains phone batteries quickly. 

Saturday, July 20, 2019

MAGAs Revive "Love It Or Leave It," A Minor Musing About A Logical Fallacy

I was young when I first heard "America, love it or leave it." If I were to venture a guess, I probably first heard a Vietnam War supporter utter the phrase on radio or television when I was 9 or 10 years old.

During the past week, Trumpists of all ages and stations in life have trotted out the trite phrase as if were something original, witty, logical, or patriotic.

The phrase, is of course, a logical fallacy which can be succinctly defined:
When only two choices are presented yet more exist, or a spectrum of possible choices exists between two extremes.  False dilemmas are usually characterized by “either this or that” language, but can also be characterized by omissions of choices.
This afternoon, I was reminded of how everyone should know how unpatriotic that phrase is when this tweet came across my twitter feed.
Because I don't trust Blogger to allow the picture in the tweet to be enlarged, I am uploading a copy as well.


The second column of this 50 year old editorial has two important paragraphs. Sydney J. Harris writes,
Those who want to leave have a right to, but those who want to stay and work for what they consider a better society must be protected in that right--for without it, our nation would sink into stagnation and the process of change would harden into repression by those who benefit by keeping things just as they are. . . . 
Somebody who truly didn't like what America stands for ought to be invited to leave; but there is a vast difference between such a person and those who dislike what we have allowed ourselves to become, through greed and prejudice and provincial indifference to the great problems we now face. No community can afford to lose these good "agitators."
Most recent political and policy discussions have devolved into each side calling the other names bereft of context that provides meaning: fascists, socialists, racist, anti-Semitic. Nearly every devolves into whataboutism and dueling charges of hypocrisy.

Since the nation seems to have lost all of its adults, can we perhaps listen to one from 50 years ago and develop new ways to facilitate the process of change which has stagnated and hardened into repression.

Certainly, we can all be better "agitators" and refrain from the illogical and unpatriotic "love it or leave it" fallacy.

Sunday, July 15, 2018

Inflation Wipes Out Wage Gains: So Much Winning

The Chicago Tribune points to the fact that workers like farmers are feeling the brunt of the trade war.
The cost of food, shelter and gas have all risen significantly in the past year. Gas skyrocketed more than 24 percent, rent for a primary residence jumped 3.6 percent and meals at restaurants and cafeterias rose 2.8 percent. 
Prices have risen roughly at the same rate as wages, erasing any gains workers may have hoped to realize via bigger paychecks. 
"While the labor market remains historically tight, the pace of U.S. inflation is now outpacing wage gains late in the business cycle," said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at RSM, an audit and advisory firm. "The U.S. is now ensnared in a three front trade war which will in the near to medium term result in higher prices." 
For workers, more pain may be coming, as economists are concerned that prices could rise further due to President Trumps tariffs on many foreign imports. Trump put a 20 tariff on foreign washing machines earlier this year, and the inflation report Thursday showed more than a 13 percent spike in laundry equipment over the same period last year. 
"Expect rising transportation costs to start getting passed on to us, along with the tariff induced jump in costs," said Peter Boockvar, chief investment officer of Bleakley Advisory Group.
This article reminded me of another time WIN was a key part of the political discussion. During the 70s, it stood for "whip inflation now." There were even pins.

Whip Inflation Now pin circa 1974
From Wikipedia
We're nowhere near the levels of inflation that existed in the 1970s. Trump's policies may, however, be creating the conditions that will produce double digit inflation. Trump stole "Make America Great" from Reagan. With his love of "winning," he has a ready made slogan used during the Ford administration.

Sunday, August 20, 2017

A Minor Musing About Comforting The Troubled And Troubling The Comfortable

Recently, Pat Powers used the famous aphorism "comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. As first written, the phrase originally described the duty of the newspapers. It has been called "the purpose of all gospel ministry." If memory serves, I first heard the injunction in the early 1980s when now state senator James Bolin told me that it was one the prime duties of an educator.

In 2017 America, the phrase seems more than a bit problematic because apparently everyone is afflicted. If one is unable to buy any gun he wishes, he is afflicted. If a college student is assigned a text written by a dead white male, she is afflicted. Everyone reading this post may be afflicted because the previous sentences contain examples of gender stereotypes.

At the societal level it's nearly impossible to find a group that has not been afflicted: old, young, poor, rich, male, female, trans, straight, gay, Christians, Muslims, Wiccans, Atheists, teetotalers, whiskey connoisseurs, immigrants, and descendants of those who sailed on the Mayflower all claim to be a mistreated and misunderstood community. With all of this affliction being endured, it's doubtful enough people are available to offer comfort.

If being afflicted has become an epidemic, the idea of troubling the comfortable has morphed. In the past it involved speaking truth to power. The practice has distorted into deliberately pissing off people whom one disagrees with just for the hell of it.

It takes neither genius nor prophet to understand the current situation poses two distinct problems. First, all the false claims of affliction cause us to lose sight of who is truly afflicted, and, therefore, who truly needs comfort. Second, angry people seeking to trouble those who are looking for reasons to feel afflicted will produce a violently widening gyre.

Lincoln urged Americans to appeal to the better angels of our nature. Theodore Roosevelt exhorted Americans to channel that energy to stand at Armageddon and battle for the Lord. Our current political leadership lacks the vision and moral authority to do either. Even if that were not the case, too many people are too busy enjoying their imagined martyrdom to listen.





Monday, November 14, 2016

A Minor And Somewhat Silly Musing About The Twilight Zone And Changes In The Political Landscape

I freely admit the following is silly. The nation, however, seems to be entering Rod Serling territory, so, "Picture if you will, . . ."

Donald Trump has appointed Breitbart News executive Steve Bannon as his "chief strategist and senior counselor." The post doesn't require Senate approval, so Mr. Bannon will serve at Mr. Trump's pleasure.

There is a tenuous but interesting South Dakota connection to Bannon. Lee Stranahan, a strong supporter of erstwhile United States Senate candidate Annette Bosworth throughout her fraught candidacy, is a reporter with Breitbart.

Donald Trump has also appointed Reince Priebus as his White House chief of staff. I'm guessing, and I am certainly willing to be corrected, that Priebus would be the chief intermediary South Dakota Governor Dennis Daugaard would talk with should the governor require assistance from the Oval Office.

Here's where the Twilight Zone music starts going. Daugaard distanced himself from Trump during the latter stages of the campaign. Assuming all phones are working properly, has American politics come to the place where Bosworth can call Stranahan who can call Bannon who will talk to Trump on her behalf before the White House switchboard will connect Daugaard to Priebus and have Priebus present Daugaard's request to Trump?