Thursday, January 10, 2019

A Minor Musing About Tests, Citizenship And Otherwise

Let's begin with a point of agreement. It appears both Governor Noem and I want young'uns to be good citizens. Some of the best debaters I coached served as legislative pages.  Lincoln-Douglas debaters spent hours researching the nature of good and bad governments. Policy debaters, their desire to have every discussion reach a terminal impact notwithstanding, debated what the U.S government should and should not do. Public forum debaters argued about a little bit of everything relating to important political events. In one way or another, each of them dealt with what it means to be a good citizen.

Governor Noem doesn't want students to debate about the nature of good government or what constitutes a good government policy. Instead, she wants students to pass a citizenship test in order to earn a high school diploma. This is a bad idea.

First, I cannot count the number of times I have supervised a study hall and heard a freshman say, "When am I ever gonna use this?" when doing an Algebra I, physical science, or world history assignment. Every grammar class that I taught had a student who said, "I don't need grammar; I talk good." The reaction to the citizenship requirement will be the same if not worse. "I don't need to think about citizenship; I vote gooder than you" is not a habit or a syntax that South Dakotans should encourage.

Second, if the testing that has come with No Child Left Behind, Common Core, and any other education policy conceived in the 21st Century has shown anything, it's that the mandated measurement ceases to be a measurement: it becomes the goal. In other words, the test will soon become more important than good citizenship. I may be in a minority, but rational, curious, and independent voters should be the goal. If this policy is enacted, the goal will become good test takers.

Third, the citizenship test may require students to know that Hamilton, Madison, and Jay wrote the Federalist Papers, but does it require them to explain why "Federalist 10" or "Federalist 51" matters in 2019? The test may require students to know that the first ten amendments to the Constitution are known as the Bill of Rights, but will they be able to discuss why the absolute phrase "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State" has caused so much controversy over the past few decades? If the test requires students know the term "checks and balances," will it also include examples of when checks and balances have been successful or failed? In short, it's doubtful students be able to explain how the United States government works; they will just identify a few concepts.

Finally, my cynical nature causes me to suspect that this proposal is a throwaway line designed to further the impression that Republicans are the sole possessors of virtue, rectitude, and patriotism whereas non-Republicans hate the every decent part of western civilization writ large. Creating good citizens is an important goal, especially for a credal nation such as the United States. It's certainly a far too important goal to become a political talking point.

Saturday, January 5, 2019

An Open Letter To South Dakota's 2019 Legislators

Dear Legislators,

We live in an angry era. In my memory, citizens have not been this divided since the Vietnam War/Watergate era. We also live  in an era in which many believe that people are entitled to select their facts as well as their opinions. You have chosen to serve in interesting times.

Given the divisiveness and anger rampant in political discourse nationally and online, I have three small requests that I believe are achievable and may even be bipartisan.

First, I don't expect you to agree on everything. In fact, the two of you whom I know personally may vote against each other 75% of the time. I would ask, however, that you remember the words of a former state legislator from Illinois who urged that people act "with malice toward none [and] with charity toward all." If South Dakotans are indeed the friendly, neighborly folks we claim to be, this request should not be that difficult to fulfill.

Second, put South Dakota first and the national debate second. Although many politicians seem fixated on a large construction project far south of us, many South Dakota communities struggle to maintain their infrastructure. In addition to physical roads and bridges, work to bridge the divide that separates South Dakota's Native American community from the rest of the state's citizens. Further, don't leave education for the last moments of the session. South Dakota's students at all levels deserve better.

Finally, accept that change is a constant. In 1999 many were worried about a Y2K computer glitch creating economic ruin if not societal collapse. Google was not commonly used as a verb; Facebook did not exist, and birds were the only species associated with tweeting. In short, remember that many current controversies will not matter 20 years from now Seek the counsel of clear headed people who look to the future to guide your deliberations and decisions.

As is often the case, Shakespeare offers the best closing: as you serve during 2019, "God's benison go with you and with those who make good of bad and friends of foes." (Macbeth Act II, Scene 4)

Thursday, January 3, 2019

A Musing About State Senator Stace Nelson's Wall Resolution, Facts, Lies, Truth, And Politics


I thought of Moynihan this morning when I read this Stace Nelson's comment on Dakota Free Press.
35+ posts of personal attacks and absolute rubbish with not one intelligent comment about the actual bill. Who does that? The Trump Derangement Syndrome is alive and well. Ranting and raving and not one of you have read the actual bill.. If you can’t debate the issues? Make things up and lie, lie, lie.
Nelson's outburst was in response to comments about his proposed resolution supporting Trump's border wall. His comment also contains a draft of his own resolution. My comment which contained a link to a Washington Post article and used numbers that come from various media sources was apparently one of those pieces of "rubbish."

Perhaps I am being nostalgic and naive, but the Moynihan assertion was made a time when people agreed what the facts were and political arguments were about the implications of those facts. Granted, I can't remember a time in my life when someone didn't mutter something about lies, damned lies and statistics or utter the phrase "figures don't lie, but liars sure do figure." Even with those caveats, it seems that people used to agreed about what the facts were. The political arguments were about the best way to deal with those facts.

In 2019 no one seems willing to agree what the facts are. I believe that Trump has said 3924 false things as president as of this writing. Based on his comment cited above, Nelson may accuse me of having Trump Derangement Syndrome. Nelson's proposed resolution contains a copious amount of numbers, many of which Nelson claims he found in congressional records. I recognize some of them as numbers originating from sources that I believe to be biased. As I did at Dakota Free Press, I will point out that Trump seems to have made up the number about the cost of illegal immigration. Many supporters of the wall will claim the article is an example of mainstream media bias.

A few years back, Chris Mooney wrote an article "The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science." These conclusions seem relevant to the point at hand.

In other words, people rejected the validity of a scientific source because its conclusion contradicted their deeply held views. . . . The study subjects weren’t “anti-science”—not in their own minds, anyway. It’s just that “science” was whatever they wanted it to be. “We’ve come to a misadventure, a bad situation where diverse citizens, who rely on diverse systems of cultural certification, are in conflict,” says Kahan. 

And that undercuts the standard notion that the way to persuade people is via evidence and argument. In fact, head-on attempts to persuade can sometimes trigger a backfire effect, where people not only fail to change their minds when confronted with the facts—they may hold their wrong views more tenaciously than ever.

Were this post a high schooler's original oratory, I would expect a solution at this point in the composition. I don't have one. I'm going to try to approach issues like I approached judging a debate round and look for the best evidence and the best arguments. Nelson and other supporters of Trump's wall will likely claim they're doing the same thing.

If we can't agree about facts and Mooney is correct that evidence and argument only cause people to hold their views more firmly, the political climate will get more charged and angry. To apply an overused Thomas Hobbes statement, it will be nasty and brutish, a war of everyone against everyone. Welcome to post-truth America.

Wednesday, January 2, 2019

A Minor Musing On Idolatry And Trump

If it were possible to boil the problems with the Trump reign into three words, one could do worse than character, competence, and corruption. Yesterday, Mitt Romney succinctly explained Trump's character problem:
To a great degree, a presidency shapes the public character of the nation. A president should unite us and inspire us to follow “our better angels.” A president should demonstrate the essential qualities of honesty and integrity, and elevate the national discourse with comity and mutual respect. As a nation, we have been blessed with presidents who have called on the greatness of the American spirit. With the nation so divided, resentful and angry, presidential leadership in qualities of character is indispensable. And it is in this province where the incumbent’s shortfall has been most glaring.
The other problem, however, is that Trump's followers, even those who should know better, deify him.  For example, Jerry Falwell Jr. asserts he can see no circumstance that would lead him to not supporting Trump.

Is there anything President Trump could do that would endanger that support from you or other evangelical leaders? 

No.
 

That’s the shortest answer we’ve had so far.
Only because I know that he only wants what’s best for this country, and I know anything he does, it may not be ideologically “conservative,” but it’s going to be what’s best for this country, and I can’t imagine him doing anything that’s not good for the country. [Emphasis in original]

In response to Romney's op-ed, Trump's campaign manager, Brad Parscale doubled down on deification
That tweet, which borders on idolatry, certainly goes against scriptural injunction found in Psalm 146: 3-4.

Do not put your trust in princes,in human beings, who cannot save.When their spirit departs, they return to the ground;on that very day their plans come to nothing.

The more secular and mundane problem with deification and the belief that Trump or any other human will save the nation is the fact that the "savior" needs a threat to save the nation from. That fact creates an illogical conundrum: there's a threat and the nation needs a savior; the savior has saved the nation, but now there's a bigger threat and the nation needs to be saved again.

Trump will not save the nation; he is incapable of saving the nation. That's not an insult or a political judgement. No human can save any nation. The danger is believing a human can do no wrong or singlehandedly save one. Deifying a human rarely works well.

Tuesday, January 1, 2019

A Look Ahead To 2019

Few of the comments that follow count as predictions; rather, they are events that bear watching.

On the national level, I have a few things I am keeping an eye on.

Will Lindsey Graham, the man who has yet to find a war he didn't love, devolve into a a 21st Century version of Joseph McCarthy? It seems obvious that the late John McCain had a far greater moderating influence on Graham's worst instincts than was previously known. Trump seems to have the superpower of making people debase themselves, so Graham, who seems to vying for the role of Trump's chief apologist,  may well sink to new depths

How will House Democrats play the game of chicken that Donald Trump has set up? It's clear that Trump is ginning up his base into a berserker rage to fight an impeachment battle. It's unclear if the Democrats have a coherent strategy to both pass legislation and deal with an angry old man full of sound and fury and capable of little to nothing positive.

Will the Democrats move beyond Warren, Sanders, or Biden and avoid the shining star of the moment like O'Rourke? In any election for national office, I will refuse to vote for anyone older than I am. The digital age demands someone who isn't old enough to remember sticking a quarter in a machine to play Pong. Likewise, I would prefer a candidate who has more of a record than raising a crap ton of money and losing to Ted Cruz.

Finally, the nation hasn't faced a major crisis since 2008, and we are likely overdue. Are there any adults in Washington capable of dealing with one when it occurs?

At the state level, there are are also three things.

Will Kristi Noem govern as a Trumpist? Governor Daugaard, for all his faults, was able to keep the worst elements of the Republican populist right fringe at bay. Noem seems much more willing to give that faction free rein.

The second question is related: what will Noem do? Her political raison d'ĂȘtre has been ending the estate tax. South Dakota Republicans take perverse pride in the state's low taxes and Noem's campaign promises about transparency and ethics were both vague and vapid, so it's unclear if she wants to accomplish anything other than be elected the state's first woman governor.

Finally, can the state's Democrats finally realize that Will Rogers wasn't praising them when he said, "I am not a member of any organized party — I am a Democrat"? I'll stipulate that demographics, including the urban/rural divide are against them, so they will not be the majority party, but adding a few seats shouldn't be too much to ask. Also, I fear they will continue the practice of eating their young and force some of the rising stars into statewide races prematurely.

Finally, I see that I averaged 111 words per comment in 2018 on the Dakota Free Press. I have to work to become more concise. That too will have to be a work in progress.

Sunday, December 23, 2018

The Ghost of Blog Posts Past

As has frequently happened over the past few years, I have found myself unable to juggle work and blogging. Since September, that has been part-time work, but I still didn't make time to sit down at the keyboard.

In addition to an inability to deal with more than one job at a time, I was, and likely remain, a bit tired of typing the same five or six posts with a few different facts. You know the posts:
1. Trump is the worst mix of incompetence, incoherence and odiousness to occupy the Oval Office in my lifetime. 
2. Trump's evangelical base seems to ignore the Biblical injunction "Do not put your trust in princes, in human beings, who cannot save. When their spirit departs, they return to the ground; on that very day their plans come to nothing (Psalm 146). They also seem to have forgotten, "Fear thou not; for I am with thee: be not dismayed; for I am thy God: I will strengthen thee; yea, I will help thee; yea, I will uphold thee with the right hand of my righteousness (Isaiah 41). Finally, they pay no heed to the command  ". . . be ye therefore wise as serpents, and harmless as doves." (Matthew 10). 
I have no explanation for their deification of Trump, fear of  any idea that didn't appear on Ozzie and Harriet, and their braying of witless bromides as if those utterances contained the wisdom of Solomon. I just know people of the Book should know better. 
3. At the statewide level, South Dakota's Democrats need to organize something other than a circular firing squad. 
4. Then there's the post relishing the delicious irony that the same populists who destroyed the meaning of the word liberal have now basically destroyed the meaning of the word conservative. It's not clear what ideology Trump holds, but it's clear that it has nothing to do with the conservatism of Hayek, Buckley, or Reagan. 
5. There also is the post that education policies pushed by Daugaard, and I'm sure Noem, are designed to create folk who "may be a productive employee at work [but] a gullible consumer in the market and a docile subject of the state."
I'm not sure I have a solution to the problem about regular blogging. I will enjoy the pumpkin plachinda I baked this morning and the apple plachinda I will bake tomorrow.  Even though I plan to guilt trip the heck out of the young'un who made it home for Christmas, I'll  take pleasure in cooking her knoephla and country style sausage for Christmas Eve and spending some time with family on Christmas Day. After that I might get curmudgeony enough to put a few regular posts together. Until then, God bless us every one.

Saturday, October 6, 2018

Trump, Kavanaugh, and Justice: A Minor Musing

Sometime today, the Senate will vote to confirm Brett Kavanaugh as a justice on the United States Supreme Court. His self-righteous outburst last week should have disqualified him because it demonstrated his lack of judicious restraint and sense of entitlement.  All Supreme Court justices ought to be judicious and restrained when their every word affects the course of history. No one should be entitled to a lifetime appointment. Apparently, a Wall Street Journal apology covers multitude of sins.

In the past few days, Donald Trump has taken to mocking Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, the woman who accused Kavanaugh of assaulting her decades ago. He has also mocked former Senator Al Franken for resigning from the United States Senate when Franken was accused of sexual impropriety.

It's impossible to know what cases will come before the Supreme Court two, five, or ten years from now. Three certainties exist, however. First, Republicans may have had cause to accuse the Democrats of falling prey to relativism and postmodernism over the past twenty or thirty years, but the events of the Kavanaugh hearings and the aftermath show Republicans, like all postmodernists, returning to the Sophists and giving full throat to relativistic arguments. The idea that justice is the rendering of due is no longer an operative principle for Republicans or this allegedly conservative court. Both are acting and will continue to act on Thrasymacus's argument that justice is "nothing else than the interest of the stronger." Only those with wealth and connections need seek relief in the courts or the legislatures.

Second, Trumpists will continue to confuse bellicosity with strength. President George H.W. Bush sought "a kinder, gentler nation." President Abraham Lincoln believed Americans would be governed "by the better angels of our nature." Trump throws tantrums and urges his base to throw them as well. Kavanaugh's contempt and anger was nothing but a tantrum without profanity. The fact that the tactic was successful presages more of the same

Third, public discourse will resemble Flint's water supply for the foreseeable future. Democrats are enraged at how Republicans treated Dr. Ford. Republicans are enraged at how Democrats treated Kavanaugh. Even if senators from both parties are merely posturing for the cameras and their respective bases, the rhetoric has reached a level where comity and reasoned political debate have become impossible at the national level.

Throughout the entire 2016 election season and on a weekly basis since, I have thought about the first stanza of Yeats's "The Second Coming." The following lines capture the current cultural climate:
Turning and turning in the widening gyre 
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere 
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst 
Are full of passionate intensity.
Yeats concluded by wondering
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, 
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Whatever curiosity I may have had about the answer to that question has given way to dread.