Via Mr. Heidelberger, I note that the ACLU has challenged Attorney General Marty Jackley on his assertion that county clerks could refuse to issue marriage licences to same sex couples if the official's conscience or religious convictions so dictated, the recent Obergefell decision not withstanding. Jackley, who will almost certainly run for governor in 2018, likely anticipated this challenge and is probably planning campaign commercials touting his quixotic effort, alleging that it was thwarted by a leftist, liberal, progressive, socialist, cabal of atheistic lawyers. (I hope I didn't leave out any current dog whistles.)
Meanwhile, at debate camp in beautiful Brookings, South Dakota, the young Lincoln-Douglas debaters are preparing cases on Resolved: In the United States criminal justice system, jury nullification ought to be used in the face of perceived injustice. The cynic in me wonders if Jackley will now appeal to the South Dakota Republicans of a more libertarian bent and advocate that juries be informed that they are judges of both the law and fact, at least in court cases involving weddings.
In other political news, Reverend Steve Hickey has announced he will be leaving the legislature and his pulpit to "study Christian ethics with an emphasis on surveillance in the modern world in the Bonhoeffer Studies program at the University of Aberdeen." In a serendipitous coincidence, the policy debaters are preparing to spend the next season debating Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially curtail its domestic surveillance. My knowledge of Bonhoeffer is limited to knowing that he prophetically spoke against "cheap grace." If Reverend Hickey stumbles upon this blog, my students and I would appreciate his forwarding any reading lists about both Bonhoeffer and surveillance.
Finally, in one other debate camp and politics connection, I notice that Cory has created a debate tournament for the Republican Presidential candidates. I look forward to his format for quarters, semis, and finals.
Showing posts with label Debate Camp. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Debate Camp. Show all posts
Thursday, July 9, 2015
Friday, July 5, 2013
What I Learned At Debate Camp 2013
I spent the past week helping out at a debate camp on a campus in the 5th most livable small town in the country. The campus may lead the nation in construction activity. I should also note that the Twins lost every time I saw an advertisement featuring a certain blogger while a game was being telecast. I know correlation doesn't equal causation, but the trend was troubling. I should also add that the sample size is pretty small, I saw only parts of two games.
The dozen policy debaters spent time working out positions to affirm and negate "Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico, or Venezuela." The bakers dozen Lincoln Douglas debaters spent most of their time dealing with "Resolved: Compulsory inclusion of non-felons' DNA in any government database is just."
Listening in on a few lectures and talking with the young'uns about their cases reaffirmed the principle "simple ain't easy."
More importantly, it history has a long arm. The U.S.'s relationships with Cuba and Mexico have unresolved issues that go back more than 50 years.
Finally, an excellent lecture about performance debate, a form that most South Dakota coaches find anathema, provided an important reminder that passion, art, and literature speak in ways that statistics cannot.
Regular blogging to resume shortly
The dozen policy debaters spent time working out positions to affirm and negate "Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico, or Venezuela." The bakers dozen Lincoln Douglas debaters spent most of their time dealing with "Resolved: Compulsory inclusion of non-felons' DNA in any government database is just."
Listening in on a few lectures and talking with the young'uns about their cases reaffirmed the principle "simple ain't easy."
More importantly, it history has a long arm. The U.S.'s relationships with Cuba and Mexico have unresolved issues that go back more than 50 years.
Finally, an excellent lecture about performance debate, a form that most South Dakota coaches find anathema, provided an important reminder that passion, art, and literature speak in ways that statistics cannot.
Regular blogging to resume shortly
Labels:
Debate,
Debate Camp
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Debate Camp 2012 Update
The utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics lectures have all been delivered. We didn't get into the really deep philosophy that would explain why the Blogger spell checker wants to change deontology to demonology. We'd need at least another whole week to develop that idea fully.
The young'uns have brainstormed about big ideas including the following:
Meanwhile, I'm impressed with a lot of students who are developing virtuous habits like thinking deeply about important issues, going above and beyond the call of duty to spend a week of their summer to think about both obscure and important issues, and who will make the world a better place.
These students exhibit have shown themselves willing to follow a golden mean, have the best intentions, and work to achieve the best consequences every day they have been at camp. I hope no one tells them that they have exhibited the best qualities and acts that each of the three normative theories call for, so they probably didn't need to listen to the lectures.
The young'uns have brainstormed about big ideas including the following:
Resolved: The constitutions of democratic governments ought to include procedures for secession.The values, criteria, and contentions in the affirmative cases over "Resolved: Oppressive government is more desirable than no government" have been coach checked; negative cases will be ready tomorrow, and the official arguing will begin on Saturday during the camp tournament.
Resolved: The United States is justified in intervening in the internal political processes of other countries to attempt to stop human rights abuses.
Resolved: In a democracy, voting ought to be compulsory.
Resolved: Rehabilitation ought to be valued above retribution in the United States criminal justice system.
Meanwhile, I'm impressed with a lot of students who are developing virtuous habits like thinking deeply about important issues, going above and beyond the call of duty to spend a week of their summer to think about both obscure and important issues, and who will make the world a better place.
These students exhibit have shown themselves willing to follow a golden mean, have the best intentions, and work to achieve the best consequences every day they have been at camp. I hope no one tells them that they have exhibited the best qualities and acts that each of the three normative theories call for, so they probably didn't need to listen to the lectures.
Labels:
Debate Camp
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)