Showing posts with label South Dakota Taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Dakota Taxes. Show all posts

Friday, May 10, 2013

Retire In South Dakota; Die In Texas

The New York Times reports that South Dakota long with our neighbors to the north and south are places for retirees:
The top 10 states, in descending order, are Tennessee, Louisiana, South Dakota, Kentucky, Mississippi, Virginia, West Virginia, Alabama, Nebraska and North Dakota.
The financial Web site crunched a variety of data on the cost of living, taxes, health care, crime and climate to come up with the ranking. Access to health care, for instance, was measured by the number of hospital beds per 1,000 people, using data from the Kaiser Family Foundation.
Bakerate.com, the site that developed the rankings that the Times reports, extols South Dakota's crime rate and low tax burden:
And the third-best state for retirement is ... South Dakota? That's right. The Mount Rushmore State may not be on many retirement wish lists, but it should be. What it lacks in warmth, it makes up for in a variety of ways.
South Dakota has the lowest crime rate in the nation. The Tax Foundation also says South Dakota residents have an estimated state and local tax burden of 7.6 percent, which is lower than every other state except Alaska. Its temperatures are on the chilly side, with a 30-year average of 46 degrees -- about the same as New York and Colorado.
Of course, if one does not want to retire in the cold, one can go to Texas and die in a workplace accident.
But Texas has also had the nation’s highest number of workplace fatalities — more than 400 annually — for much of the past decade. Fires and explosions at Texas’ more than 1,300 chemical and industrial plants have cost as much in property damage as those in all the other states combined for the five years ending in May 2012. Compared with Illinois, which has the nation’s second-largest number of high-risk sites, more than 950, but tighter fire and safety rules, Texas had more than three times the number of accidents, four times the number of injuries and deaths, and 300 times the property damage costs. 
(I know--I power tagged the headline and I should comment on both situations a bit more, but I only have a 24 minute lunch breack. To be continued . . .)

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

A Minor Musing About The South Dakota Legislature And ALEC

Today's Argus had a he said/she said article about the South Dakota Legislature's executive board's decision to pay legislators' memberships in the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC). The Democrats point out that the group is pro large corporation advocacy group funded by the Koch brothers and other conservatives. Republicans take issue with the assertion that the Koch brothers use ALEC to push their agenda and claim that the group educates legislators.

Then there's this bit of reasoning:
Sen. Ryan Maher, R-Isabel, said interactions with corporations at ALEC meetings are positive.

“Yes, there’s corporate people there, too. But you can learn from them,” Maher said. “What better opportunity than to sit down with these people and have a discussion and promote the state of South Dakota as a tax-friendly state?”
So, ALEC isn't about a right-wing agenda; the group merely allows legislators to convince ALEC's corporate members that South Dakota is a tax friendly state. Corporations should have their own bean counters to determine that fact, so the corporations shouldn't need much convincing.

If it's not about the Koch brothers and it seems unlikely South Dakota needs ALEC meetings to prove the state's low tax bona fides,  then it seems that these meetings are ways for ALEC's corporate members to convince legislators which corporations should be winners and which should losers. Given that ALEC purports to support free enterprise capitalism, attempts to have the government pick winners and losers seems either ironic or more than a little disingenuous.

Saturday, March 9, 2013

Saturday Morning Reads: March 9 Edition

Nathan Johnson delves into the details that South Dakota has 3rd most regressive tax structure in the nation.
According to a recent study by the Institute on Taxation & Economic Policy (ITEP), South Dakota had the third-most regressive tax system in the United States as of the beginning of 2013. The bottom 20 percent of the state’s earners pay 11.6 percent of their income in taxes. The top 1 percent pay 2.1 percent.
“One could rightly say that the rate on poor people in South Dakota is 552 percent higher than the rate on those in the top 1 percent,” said Reynold Nesiba, an associate professor of economics at Augustana College. “I think most outside of the top 1 percent of the population would agree that this is grossly unfair and by no stretch of the imagination equitable.”
A self-described liberal gun guy is shilling his book. My take-away doesn't fit the general tone of the interview, so read it for yourself. My take-away:
"The people who buy most of the guns are middle-aged white men who have not finished college.. . [because] gun guys derive [self-esteem] from their guns"
The title alone makes it worth the read: The Professor, the Bikini Model and the Suitcase Full of Trouble

Brew another cup of coffee and enjoy.

Friday, January 4, 2013

Everything Should Be Pay As You Go

Yesterday's Yankton Press & Dakotan printed a letter from Dennis J. Muser of Pierre. Mr. Muser contends:
I think that the real question is WHO is responsible for the education of children? The simple answer in three words — PARENTS, PARENTS, PARENTS! The point being, if schools really do need more funding, it is way past time that parents start paying tuition to their public schools rather than relying on the coercive power of government to hit property owners, etc.
 Let's leave aside the little technicality that the South Dakota Constitution mandates "it shall be the duty of the Legislature to establish and maintain a general and uniform system of public schools wherein tuition shall be without charge . . ."

In fact, let's take this suggestion out to its logical conclusion. I'm sick of government using its coercive power to tax gasoline. Let's run everything on a pay as you go system.. Let's put a ticket machine at the end of each driveway and the entrance to every roadway so that drivers pay every time we drive. Drivers can grab a ticket when they enter a roadway and pay when they leave. It doesn't matter if they're driving from their home to the nearest Walmart or from Walla Walla, Washington to Washington DC. Everyone should pay every time he or she drives.

I suppose bicyclists could pay a lower rate because they cause less wear and tear on the road, but with a pay as you use system, they'd have some skin in the game. Right now, they're freeloaders using the public roadways without paying gas taxes that fund roads. They even have the gall to complain if someone driving a 4x4 pickup runs them over. Skin in the game isn't the same as skin on the road. That 4x4 driver pays more for those roads than the bicyclist; he should have the right to drive from center line to shoulder as he sees fit.

People could hire their own private security forces instead of relying on police and fire department. Every individual could hire his or her own health inspector to insure that all the food one consumes is safe. That situation alone might make everyone feel like a king or queen. Didn't they have food tasters in the Middle Ages? Safety and self-esteem in one fell swoop, who could ask for anthing else?

Heck, let's do away with all taxes and rely of tariffs the way the country did for most of the 18th and 19th Centuries. A standing army is only quasi-constitutional anyway.

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Initiated Measure 15: A Study In Political Naivete

On the other hand, it may be a study in incompetence.

The folks behind Initiated Measure 15 which will raise the sales tax to to fund K-12 education and Medicaid began with a number of difficult problems.

First, South Dakotans don't like taxes; it's a safe bet that 40% of South Dakota voters will vote no on any tax increase. That fact means that supports will have to convince 5 of ever 6 remaining voters to support this measure. That's a tough call anywhere, but especially tough in South Dakota under the current environment.

Second, the Pierre Machiavellian, Governor Dennis Duagaard, has suddenly found a budget surplus, so opponents of the measure have an easy talking point.

Third, even if the surplus had not magically appeared, this measure was easy to slogan against.. It is after all a 25% tax increase. That number jars. Besides, the "A penny for T Denny,"  hits a strong populist tune. T. Denny is South Dakota's one percenter.

Fourth, there is a strong progressive argument against the sales tax as South DaCola and The Madville Times both illustrate. There's no doubt that the sales tax is extremely regressive.

Fifth, schools aren't popular now; neither are poor people.

Finally, there's a cynical argument to be made that if the measure passes, there's nothing preventing the legislature from changing the funding formula so that schools and medicaid receives the same dollar amount that they currently do.

One has to wonder at the silence. Silence may be golden but it's not going to buy facts that change any of the above. It's certainly not going to convince 5 out 6 voters who may be persuadable.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

What Does One Do With A $50 Million Budget Surplus?

The Sioux Falls Argus Leader opened their July 16th story with a similar question.  There seem to be three answers.

First one can be blatantly political. The Dakota War College quickly trumpets the idea that the surplus means that the sales tax initiative should be defeated:
Does anyone wonder why exactly some would be pushing for a 1 cent sales tax increase when our state is coming up with $50 million budget surplus? Your thoughts are as good as mine. Somebody must like to spend money. . . .

The recent budget surplus indicates that amount is obviously not ”necessary,” Since our state is sitting on $50 million extra. Education and health care providers just need better lobbyists. Why would I as as citizen vote to pay another penny in sales tax when our state is flush with cash?
 Expect that talking point to become a drum beat over the next few months.

One can also be political and hopelessly naive.  South Dakota Education Association spokesperson Bryce Healy "said the budget surplus is 'good news for everybody.'” The Argus Leader reports:
“SDEA hopes our state leaders will look into investing those resources in our education system and not just putting them into reserves,” Healy said. “These dollars would help, but we still have a long way to go in education funding to get us back to the levels where we need to be.”
I'll let the attitudes and laughter from the following commercial provide my response to Healy's naivete.
The Press and Dakotan has the most believable outcome:
If history serves as a template, we will instead probably hear about uncertain times, the need for restraint and, of course, the obligatory IOUs from lawmakers that the money that has been or will be cut or unspent now will find its way back to our schools, our roads and our social programs ... some day.
"Some day" a prince will come, and the sun will come out tomorrow, and if everyone claps Tinkerbell will live

Monday, April 9, 2012

Will States Save Medicare?

At South Dakota Politics, Dr, Blanchard repeats the conventional wisdom when he asserts,
The Social Security system as it exists is unsustainable. Medicare is much more so. Pointing out the role that demographics is playing in this drama is merely pointing out the hard facts. If we don't reform these systems, they will collapse. Probably a lot more of the economy will collapse with them.
I'm unsure about the answers to Social Security and Medicare.  South Dakota's efforts to deal with the issue have been problematic and I'm not sanguine that the initiated measure to raise the state's sales tax a penny to help deal with the shortage will pass in November.  If it does pass, I expect the legislature to alter the law to lessen its impact.

I suspect that Blanchard agrees with with Reihan Salam whom Elias Isquith claims is" the smartest right-wing pundit of his generation." Salam asserts,
So if Ryan is essentially matching the White House on how much he intends to spend on Medicare over the long term, how does he constrain the growth of federal spending more than the president? According to Obama, he does this by starving programs for the poor, like Medicaid and food stamps, and subsidies for higher education, among other things.
One view of the Ryan approach is that state governments and voluntary organizations will pick up the slack for meeting the needs of the non-elderly poor. State governments that do a good job of crafting cost-effective solutions will, over time, beat out state governments that don’t, as households and firms migrate over time to those jurisdictions that offer the best services at the lowest cost. Moreover, the most successful state policies will presumably spread, just as the best management practices tend to spread across competing firms in a given industry.
Ryan has also suggested that his approach, in particular his approach to tax reform, will encourage more rapid economic growth, and that this in turn will translate into increased household income growth. Increased household income growth will make families less dependent on safety-net programs. And when families spend their own money on things like medical care, education and housing, they tend to be somewhat more cost-conscious, thus curbing cost growth in these all-important domains.
The last paragraph is bit of boilerplate; if one creates the right tax policy, especially the right tax cuts, one will spur the economy to new heights has been a mantra since the early 1980s. The middle paragraph contains the intriguing idea that federalism, if left to prosper, will help solve the Medicare problem.

Conor Friedersdorf asks the question that nags at at me every time someone claims federalism can solve budget woes, especially those attached to Medicare or welfare.

Is that true?

When it comes to job creation or building good transportation infrastructure or maintaining a clean environment or establishing a regulatory environment where affordable housing thrives, I have no trouble believing that successful state governments attract residents and that their practices tend to be noticed and mimicked elsewhere.
But caring for the non-elderly poor seems as if it might be different. If a state designs a program that poor people regard as especially beneficial to their interests, wouldn't a lot more poor people move to that jurisdiction? Isn't there a perverse incentive to adopt programs that repel rather than attract the non-elderly poor, who can be a drain on public resources when present in sufficient numbers and are everywhere objects of prejudice no matter how small their population?
 The South Dakota vote on Initiated Measure 15 seems a perfect test case to answer Friedersdorf's question.  I suspect that Salam will be seen to be overly optimistic about voters' willingness to provide and maintain a social safety net.

Monday, January 2, 2012

Plains Pops: Quitting While Ahead Edition

I found this CNN opinion article discussing Tony LaRussa's decision to retire after winning the World Series with the St. Louis Cardinals interesting.  The contrast between the Beatles and Michael Jordan was provocative, but these paragraphs really caught my eye:
There is one kind of resolution, though, that very few of us will ever be in a position to make.

Somewhere today, someone at the very pinnacle of his or her career is thinking of doing in 2012 what Tony La Russa did in 2011:

Get out on top.

Willingly walk away and declare victory
The cynic in me wonders if people don't quit on top because they never get to the top or because being on top in a normal career doesn't offer enough financial security.

On a slightly happier note, Jim Kleinsasser retired on his terms after a 13 year career with the Minnesota Vikings.  As a fellow North Dakota native, I have always rooted for Kleinsasser who may have been one of the best blocking tight ends of the past twenty years.  I do wish they would have targeted him for a chance at one pass completion.

Finally, gamblers seldom get out while ahead, so the increase in Power Ball ticket prices may cause problems for some.  I voluntarily tax myself about $25-$50 a year playing Power Ball. I get as much entertainment value out of it as I do taking my wife out to a movie.  If I buy popcorn and soda, the movie probably costs $30.  Still, South Dakota uses scratch games and Power Ball to generate revenue by taxing the most gullible; this price increase may cause trouble for some.

Saturday, July 30, 2011

I Question My Fellow Teachers' Wisdom Again

I thought that NEA acted unwisely when they endorsed President Obama nearly 18 months before the 2012 election.

Today, I'm wondering if SDEA isn't making an equally unwise decision by beginning an initiative drive to increase South Dakota's sales tax by one percent.

This Nathan Johnson post makes a strong case that South Dakota's tax system is unfair and that the proposed sales tax increase to fund K-12 education and Medicaid is a bad idea.
South Dakota’s tax system is currently structured so that is not even close to the reality. In fact, South Dakota turns that expectation on its head.
According to a 2009 study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), the poorest 20 percent of non-elderly taxpayers in the state contributed 11 percent of their income to the state’s sales, excise and property taxes in 2007. The top 1 percent of that same category of taxpayers — those making $423,000 or more — contributed 1.9 percent.
Today, Bob Mercer adds another reason to doubt that the proposal's wisdom.
If the initiative does pass, the Legislature isn’t bound to follow any of the directives within the new law. The Legislature can change any of it. So there is absolutely no guarantee that the $175 million will go solely to Medicaid and K-12 schools.
Today's Argus Leader implies that the Legislature's ability to appropriate the sales tax increase will have a few limits.
However, it would not completely tie the Legislature's hands when the state is struggling. Each of the past two years, the Legislature has changed state law so that lawmakers did not have to increase per-student funding at the same rate as inflation.
The measure would not prohibit the Legislature from doing that again if revenues either shrink or grow more slowly than inflation. However, the relief would be temporary, as the measure would require lawmakers in subsequent years to make back payments for education when state revenues bounce back faster than inflation.
There's nothing in the article that indicates that the Legislature can't change the payback provision at its pleasure.

The notion that one can trick out-of-state pheasant hunters, Wall Drug visitors, and Mt. Rushmore gawkers to fund necessary programs by charging them an extra penny sales tax is tempting.  Unfortunately, yielding to temptation usually provides temporary pleasure and long lasting negative consequences.  We all have our favorite examples:  that fruit in the garden, the handful of Cheetos that turned into a meal of two family sized bags, and that little credit card spree that took six years to pay off.  In this case, the damage done to those least able to pay, the furthering a terrible tax structure, and the uncertainty that the funds will actually be used for the indicated purpose make this temptation's consequences more onerous than most.