Showing posts with label Fear Mongering. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fear Mongering. Show all posts

Thursday, March 21, 2019

Intellectual Diversity, Fox News, Aexandria Ocasio-Cortez, And The Pygmalion Myth: A Minor Musing

Governor Kristi Noem has signed a bill that purports to promote intellectual diversity. Being the good conservative intellectual that she is, Noem surely will work hard to include expansion of a classic curriculum in addition to decrying the corrosive effects of Foucault's and Derrida's postmodern sophistry. (Were she writing this post, the Governor would surely take a moment to point out that sophistry, as is used here, is not merely pretty talk with no substance but a reference to the ancient Sophists who believed that truth was unknowable.)

One of the benefits of a classic education would be knowledge of the Pygmalion myth. Pygmalion feared women, so he created an ivory statute shaped as his version of the perfect woman. He then asked the goddess Aphrodite to make the statue a real woman. Aphrodite granted his request.

I was most recently reminded of the Galatea myth this morning when my Twitter feed featured this aclip of Fox News coverage of Aexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC). The fearful folk at Fox are not content to brand AOC as a liberal. She immediately became a poster child for socialism. That's an old tactic, but a Democrat who is merely a liberal or a socialist is not a Fox News commentator's or a former Republican presidential candidate's idea of a perfect Democratic woman.

This morning Mike Huckabee and Fox and Friends completed their transformation of a freshman congresswoman who frightens them merely because she knows how to use social media. She is their perfect Democrat, a liberal, socialist Manchurian Candidate. Clearly, AOC is an empty suit who is being fed the questions she asks at hearings.
For Noem and her Trumpist ilk this unsubstantiated, fear-based rumor and others like it will pass for intellectual diversity. Explanations that put the rumor in the context of a long trend of trying to create a perfect woman who doesn't cause men to fear her will be called liberal bias.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

A Minor Musing About Fear And Normativity

Over at The Madville Times, PNR offers the following bit of wisdom: It's always easy to say my fears are realistic and yours aren't."

He's speaking about South Dakota's proposed school pistolier bill and other gun laws. Although I am positive that some bean counter buried deep within the catacombs of some insurance company can provide a statistical certainty that additional guns in school increase the risk of innocents being killed, PNR rightfully asserts likelihood of a school shooter or a sanctioned pistolier in South Dakota killing someone are relatively small.

If one goes a level deeper, the real fear is that cherished norms may soon be violated. Professor Terry Eagleton in After Theory presents one of my favorite analyses of normativity:
It is a mistake, however, to believe that norms are always restrictive.  In fact it is a crass Romantic delusion.  It is normative in our kind of society that people do not throw themselves with a hoarse cry on total strangers and amputate their legs.  It is conventional that child murderers are punished, that working men and women may withdraw their labour, and that ambulances speeding to a traffic accident should not be impeded just for the hell of it.  Anyone who fells oppressed by all this must be seriously oversensitive.  Only an intellectual who has overdosed on abstraction could be dim enough to imagine that whatever bends a norm is potentially radical.Eagleton, AfterTheory 15
A similar norm would be that first graders are not to be shot in cold blood. I had always believed that norm provided the reason that guns stayed out of a school building. For as long as I can remember, those who wanted to hunt after school locked their guns in their vehicle before coming inside.

Further, I had always thought it a norm that the freedoms enshrined in the Bill of Rights had a few limits. One cannot shout fire in a crowded theater if there's no fire. The longer the school pistolier bill discussion goes on the more I'm beginning to believe that the bill's supporters don't see any limits to the second amendment except the size of one's wallet. In short, the only thing preventing one from owning a predator drone is the damned drone is expensive.

Perhaps I've lived in my own personal echo chamber. I don't recall ever having a discussion with anyone about the priorities within the Bill of Rights, but threats to Amendments 1, 9, 4, 5, 6, and 8 worry me far more that real or perceived threats to Amendment 2. (For the record, I have never seriously thought about Amendment 3 and probably couldn't state its subject if I hadn't just looked it up. For the curious but lazy, it forbids housing soldiers in citizens' home without the citizen's consent.) I have also always believed that one should not sacrifice one of the enshrined freedoms to preserve another

I'm guessing here, but it seems that my concern that putting guns in school irrevocably removes an essential norm may be similar to the concerns that opponents of gay marriage or opponents or legalizing marijuana or opponents of a fence across border the express: sanctioning gay marriage, legalizing marijuana, or building that fence somehow irrevocably violates a norm. Hence, the heat generated behind each issue.

Perhaps the discussion needs to move beyond guns, gay marriage, marijuana legalization or whatever the hot button issue is; instead, the discussion should begin by asking what norms should govern our living together.

Monday, May 23, 2011

Random Monday Morning Musings

I really think the music for this scene would be better that "Pomp and Circumstance" for graduates to entrances and exits.


I hope that Gardy can get the Twins turned around.

This guy thinks mythology has practical uses.  I don't know if I will ever agree with him on anything else, but I do about that.

Watching Treme and reading this post makes me wish that I were a musician.  I need all the brain power I can get, especially after reading this post that tells me what will happen to my older brain.

Secularists use fear mongering too.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Some Musings about Fear Mongering

The first song I remember hearing come out of a record player is "Just A Little Talk With Jesus."  In fact, I think it was this Tennessee Ernie Ford version.  My parents probably owned a version of the song on a 78, a 45, a 33 1/3 LP, a cassette, and a CD.  Some of you may have to ask your grandparents or great-grandparents what the numbers mean.


That song combined with one of the first Bible verses I remember memorizing for Sunday School--For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind (2 Timothy 1:7)--allowed me to understand that faith involves overcoming fear.

After the past few years, it's easy to see why people are afraid.  People in Yankton and throughout the United States lost homes and jobs.  During this opt out campaign, people have openly admitted that they fear not being able to buy food and pay the increased taxes because they are on a fixed income.  Others admit that they are afraid that current students won't have the same opportunities as previous Yankton graduates.  As teachers have lost jobs and programs have been cut, fears inside the school system have increased as well.

At this point, it does little good to try to place blame.  I don't believe that the Yankton School Board intended to frighten people.  Deep down I believe that most opt out opponents don't mean to unnecessarily frighten people either.

That's why hiring someone who sold Y2K survival kits is so troubling.  See here, here, and here.  Making money from fear should be left to Stephen King or Sam Raimi.  Of course, Y2K didn't happen.  That's why it's even more alarming that the same person would try to continue to hype the non-event by reminding people about it in 2008 when a Russian political analyst predicted the dissolution of the United States.

It's beyond troubling that this person drums up fear to advance his version of Christianity.   I was always taught that Christ was both perfect and the epitome of love.  I had to memorize this verse for Sunday School too: "There is no fear in love; but perfect love casteth out fear: because fear hath torment. He that feareth is not made perfect in love" (2 Timothy 4:18).

No one is perfect, so we will never totally eliminate fear.  Still the opt out debate will be much better if everyone tries to appeal to "sound minds" and not frighten people into voting only "the interests of their own pocket book."