Showing posts with label rhetoric. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rhetoric. Show all posts

Saturday, March 16, 2019

A Minor Musing On Justice And Power And Implied Threats Of Violence

I was fortunate to coach some excellent Lincoln-Douglas debaters. (Whether they succeeded with my coaching or in spite of my coaching is an open question.) Lincoln-Douglas debaters debate propositions of value and frequently open their cases with the phrase "I will be upholding the value of justice. . . " The young'uns I coached and those they debated against would frequently argue whether justice meant rendering each their due or a more Rawlsian concept which aregued justice as fairness

Donald Trump swore to uphold a Constitutions designed to "form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity. . . " Trump, however, doesn't see justice as rendering each his or her due or fairness. Instead, he relies on a Sophist argument: "Justice is nothing but the advantage of the stronger." Earlier this week, he told Breitbart News:
. . . I can tell you I have the support of the police, the support of the military, the support of the Bikers for Trump – I have the tough people, but they don’t play it tough — until they go to a certain point, and then it would be very bad, very bad....
These words are a not-so-veiled threat premised on the idea that might makes right. It's unlikely that those who drafted the Constitution understood justice in those terms nor is it clear how the threat of violence promotes the general welfare or insures domestic tranquility. (If I may be forgiven a bit of snark, one wonders if those words constitute "riot boosting" in South Dakota under the recently passed SB 189 and 190.)

This recent rhetoric is just another example of Trump attempting to obliterate political norms. This particular violation moves politics one step further from debate and one step closer to angry confrontation and reveals Trump once again to be a weak man posing as a strong one. More importantly, it confuses the debate about what justice is or should be and returns the debate to what do the strongest and richest want it to be.

For those interested, John Tristan posts what may be a more coherent take.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Rick Santorum Shows Why Ronald Reagan Couldn't Win In The Current Republican Party

I haven't searched all of Ronald Reagan's speeches, but near the end of his administration, he seemed proud of his efforts to protect the middle class. In fact, he sounded like a true class warrior:
The charges go on and on, but the truth remains the same. No matter how you look at it, the last time they were in office, the liberals clobbered the American middle class -- and we stopped them. Some are calling this last-ditch opposition campaign an attempt at ``class warfare.'' So, what's new? Our liberal friends have been at war with America's middle class for years. Now they want you to turn the other cheek -- but will they just take that as an opportunity to really let you have it? Main Street America is in better shape today than it's ever been. Why would we ever want to put it back in the hands of those who almost turned out its lights?
According to Rick Santorum, Reagan needs to be called out for his Marxist rhetoric



It's a dangerous step when the debate moves from how best to help middle income folk to denigrating those who use the term middle class to describe them. Of course, calling people out for using the term middle class shifts the debate away from declining social mobility and income stagnation. That may be the result Santorum desires.

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: We Don't Hear Rhetoric Like This In 2012 Edition

Via James Fallows via Mike Lofgren comes this phrasing from the 1892 Omaha Platform of The People's Party:
"We meet in the midst of a nation brought to the verge of moral, political, and material ruin. Corruption dominates the ballot-box, the Legislatures, the Congress, and touches even the ermine of the bench. The people are demoralized. . . . The newspapers are largely subsidized or muzzled, public opinion silenced, business prostrated, homes covered with mortgages, labor impoverished, and the land concentrating in the hands of capitalists. The urban workmen are denied the right to organize for self-protection, imported pauper­ized labor beats down their wages. . . . The fruits of the toil of millions are boldly stolen to build up colossal fortunes for a few, unprecedented in the history of mankind, and the pos­sessors of these, in turn, despise the Republic and endanger liberty. From the same prolific womb of governmental injus­tice we breed the two great classes - tramps and million­aires."
It doesn't matter whether one agrees or disagrees, "imported pauperized labor," "prolific womb of governmental injustice," and "the ermine of the bench" are wonderful rhetorical flourishes.

Saturday, October 22, 2011

A Vocab Lesson For South Dakota's Republican Party

I tell my students that words and ideas matter.  One should use words precisely to convey ideas clearly.  (I'm a bit less demanding about spelling and neat handwriting.)

South Dakota's Republican Party apparently disagrees with me.  According to a South Dakota GOP press release, Tim Johnson staffer and possible House of Representatives candidate Matt Varilek broke rules, laws, and protocol when he spoke in Mitchell recently.  The party claims that Varilek "delivered vitriolic campaign-style personal attacks against Rep. Kristi Noem." (emphasis mine)

To be "vitriolic" is to express "extreme bitterness and hatred toward somebody or something, or an expression of this feeling in speech or writing."

According to The Mitchell Daily Republic's coverage of the speech,
Varilek said he was struck by Noem’s words when he attended a speech she gave recently in which she said politics are too polarized.
“Well, I couldn’t agree more,” he said. “But that’s kind of like Goliath calling David the bully.”
The phrase "kind of like Goliath calling David a bully" is not vitriol.  It's an allusion, a brief reference to a literary work, mythological character or event, biblical person or event, or a historical person or event.  In addition to committing an allusion without a license, Varilek may be guilty of wry understatement, an ironic remark designed to convey meaning indirectly.  The phrasing certainly is not caustic, bitter, biting, or hateful.

The article reports that Varilek claims that Noem
has supported continuing subsidies for big oil and gas in Congress and he wonders why, since there are no such businesses in South Dakota and the country is in need of tax revenue.


Varilek said a close look at Noem’s campaign finance reports shows she has received thousands of dollars from Exxon, Chevron, Halliburton and other oil and gas companies.


“All of a sudden that vote doesn’t look so mysterious anymore,” he said.
Accusing someone of pandering to campaign supporters now counts as vitriol?  I also thought  such accusations were standard operating procedure.  I believe that people flipping off the President of the United States is vitriolic; accusing him of pandering to Wall Street contributors is probably accurate.  It definitely is not vitriolic.

Maybe the South Dakota Republicans are angry about what he said about the debt ceiling debacle.
Varilek said he was dismayed when Noem sided with House Republicans who threatened to shut down the government this summer. That would have caused severe economic hardships, he said, and he was surprised she adopted that stance.


“It just made so sense at all,” Varilek said. “And I think that’s reckless.”
Most adults thought the debt ceiling debacle was reckless.

Perhaps, Varilek's remarks were ill-timed; they may have been inappropriate. after all the state has only three congressional staffs; they should play nice with each other, and these comments may have angered some of Noem's or Thune's staff.

Even with that concession, I would like to introduce the SDGOP to a new word: "hyperbolic," enlarged beyond truth or reasonableness. Claiming that Varilek's statements are "vitriolic" stretches the meaning of the word beyond any reasonableness." In this instance hyperbole is more dangerous than the alleged vitriol because this hyperbole robs "vitriolic" of its meaning and impact.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

How Many Logical Fallacies Can You Find?

From Politico, Newt Gingrich offers an amazing bit of rhetoric.
"I have two grandchildren — Maggie is 11, Robert is 9," Gingrich said at Cornerstone Church here. "I am convinced that if we do not decisively win the struggle over the nature of America, by the time they're my age they will be in a secular atheist country, potentially one dominated by radical Islamists and with no understanding of what it once meant to be an American."
For those who haven't thought about logical fallacies since high school or college, a list is here and here.

Leave your homework in comments.  Write in complete sentences.

The comment box here claims that Gingrich inadvertently forgot to say "or" before "potentially dominated by radical Islamists. . . " so noting that Islamists probably aren't atheists won't count.

Sunday, January 9, 2011

Real World Interruptions

I had hoped to have daily updates after Friday posts, but certain real life activities like a debate tournament followed by an unplanned five and half hour trip prevented posting.

I want to echo The Madville Times contrast between high school debate and the increasingly, dangerously weird world of American politics.

I found ABC's The Week's roundtable discussion rather fascinating.  I thought Dick Armey seemed to be whistling past the graveyard as he eschewed "pop sociology."  I thought George Will's hope that this one is closer to Columbine rather than Oswald or John Wilkes Booth interesting, but hollow; no matter the reason, scores of people have been killed or wounded in similar shootings since 1999.