Showing posts with label Religious Right. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religious Right. Show all posts

Sunday, January 19, 2020

The MAGA Church Ad: A Minor Musing

It's Sunday morning, so let's mix politics and religion.

During the 2016 campaign, some American Christians voted for Donald Trump because they believed him to be a King Cyrus figure. In the Bible, Cyrus is the Persian king who ended the Babylonian captivity. These same people likely saw Hillary Clinton as a Jezebel analogue. At the time, I saw Trump to be closer to Rehoboam, the king of Israel whose actions literally divided the kingdom. Trump's actions as president have intensified my belief.

Recently, the Lincoln Project, a group of anti-Trump Republicans, has released a campaign video entitled "The MAGA Church." The video begins with the scriptural reminder to beware wolves in sheep's clothing and closes with the tagline "If this is the best American Christians can do? Then God help us all." The ad juxtaposes statements by prosperity gospel preachers and sons of famous preachers with some of Trump's more hubristic  or outlandish comments. It is a powerful well-done ad that will matter not a whit.


First, the ad demonstrates Trump's hypocrisy. Trump's religious base has made peace with that hypocrisy and now sees it as a mark of faith. They did not need Jim Bakker to tell them that supporting Trump was a sign that one is saved. They already believed it. (The ad has a clip of Bakker's utterance, so I am not going to provide a link.)

Second, the ad shows many of the prosperity preachers laying hands on Trump in the Oval Office. Those unfamiliar with charismatic, Pentecostal, or full gospel churches will find the act peculiar at best. Members of those churches who are full-throated Trumpists will take pride in being a "peculiar people." More importantly, they will see the ad as evidence that the wisdom of the world is foolishness to God.

In short, the ad will merely reinforce existing beliefs. Those who believe Trump is a B.S. artist conning the faithful will have a lot of evidence in one place. On the other hand, the ad will likely deepen Trumpists' belief that American Christians are a persecuted minority and that Trump is indeed a modern day Cyrus sent by God to protect them from worse persecution.

Friday, September 14, 2012

Roger Ailes Throws Christian Right Under Bus

Writing in USA Today, Steve Deace fills in the gaps:
On Tuesday, News Corp. chieftain Rupert Murdoch, who oversees the parent company of Fox News, tweeted the following:

"Election: To win Romney must open big tent to sympathetic families. Stop fearing far right which has nowhere else to go."

My translation: Romney should embrace homosexual "marriage" just as the Democrats have, and publicly betray the Christians who have done most of the heavy lifting for the Republican Party since 1980 (not to mention making up most of the audience for Fox News). Just sell out these sad saps as we're about to, and they'll put up with it because the Democrats don't want them either.
I've long warned my Christian friends who vote conservative that they were nothing more than political cannon fodder. It's still surprising, however, to see them so publicly dismissed.




Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Evangelicals Used To Be Progressive Edition

From this James Rohrer post on Salon/Alternet:
Most Sioux County [Iowa] voters are descendants of Dutch Protestant immigrants who settled the area more than a century ago. Their grandparents and great-grandparents were if anything even more theologically conservative, more pietistic, and more inclined to lace every conversation with biblical injunctions. But a century ago, the local folk opened their Bibles and found admonitions against rich rulers exploiting the poor. They found Jesus preaching that the “sinners” would enter the Kingdom of God before the Chamber of Commerce types, and understood that disciples must speak out against the Trusts and war profiteers. I just spent a week reading through the Alton Democrat for 1900, which routinely drew upon the Bible to editorialize against the imperialist ambitions of the United States –even dubbing its capitalist rulers “immoral” and “evil”– and to denounce the moneyed aristocracy that unjustly controlled the destiny of the people. . . .

The Bible has not changed, and neither have the core theological beliefs of the people of Sioux County. But society has changed and the nature of political action has evolved almost beyond recognition since the turn of the 20th century. The Bible and the Christian tradition can be tapped as resources for an array of political agendas. That the “heartland” has in recent decades swung so far away from the populist tradition of [William Jennings] Bryan is not because there is something intrinsically authoritarian or anti-democratic in the religious beliefs of the masses, but because Republican strategists in the last two generations have done a far better job than progressives at organizing, marketing and communicating their message in a way that appeals at a visceral level to the hopes and fears of many people. To change America, we must change this reality.
While discussing Rohrer's essay, Ed Kilgore adds a paragraph from his review of  Michael Kazin's biography of William Jennings Bryan, A Godly Hero: The Life of William Jennings Bryan
Once upon a time, right here in America, tens of millions of people read the Bible daily and read little else; believed it to be the literal and inerrant Word of God; and somehow interpreted it as a saga wherein God repeatedly delivered His people from the predations of the rich and the powerful and the privileged, perpetually condemned their subjugation as a divine commandment, and further commanded that they respect their equality as His children. In other words, those politicized Christians who have formed a firm alliance with Mammon and Mars on the grounds that the Word’s main message today is to condemn abortion and homosexuality and feminism are forever vulnerable to those faithful who read their Bible and see otherwise.

Monday, May 28, 2012

I Let A Guy From The Religious Right Get Under My Skin

When I read Cory's post about a tea party PAC sending out pink flyers accusing Republican state senate candidate Gene Abdallah of "voting to give graphic sexual materials to children at school," I was unfazed.  Similar flyers get sent out during every election, and I had not had my coffee. After all the flyers weren't lilac, and they didn't accuse Abdallah's spouse being an active thespian.

Besides Conor Friedersdorf has recently pointed out that many on the far right "persist in believing, without apparent evidence, that there is a strategic benefit to allying with Rush Limbaugh, Ann Coulter, Rep. Allen West, and others on the right who accuse their political opponents of being demonic, treasonous, moronic Communist sluts. . .,"  so I also felt a bit of relief.  According to the excerpts Cory published, Abdullah apparently has not sold his soul to the Devil, and he possesses, at the very least, average intelligence.

In the comments, however, self-alleged Christian conservative Ed Randazzo writes,
And I thought you liberals were all about tolerance and free speech. If you’re gonna climb in the ring you better be able to take a few punches.
In the original post, Cory ably demonstrates that flyer is at best an obfuscation, at worst a lie.  In the comments, Troy Jones adds credence to Cory's analysis.

Those who want to skip over my Bible-banging can jump down 4 paragraphs.

First, this reminder keeps me running to the mirror to make sure I don't have any logs in my eye while I'm looking for mote:
Many will say to Me in that day, ‘Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?’ And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!’ (Matthew 7:22-23)
For the situation at hand, Exodus 20:16 has a useful reminder:  "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour"

Also, there's this passage in I Corinthians 10:
All things are lawful for me, but not all things are helpful; all things are lawful for me, but not all things edify. Let no one seek his own, but each one the other’s well-being.
It's doubtful one seeks to edify another when one accuses someone of allowing "classroom instruction with . . . graphic and detailed sexual materials."

As far as being conservative, Michael Fumento, a person who worked for Ronald Reagan and wrote for Bill Buckley, recently wrote:
As a conservative, I disagree with the political opinions of liberals. But to me, a verbal assault indicates insecurity and weakness on the part of the assaulter, as in “Is that the best they can do?” This playground bullying – the name-calling, the screaming, the horrible accusations – all are intended to stifle debate, the very lifeblood of a democracy.
He goes on to point out:
Incivility is hardly the domain of the new right. American society grows ever coarser. But this is cold comfort. Conservative ideology demands civility of conservatives; demands, yes, self-policing. Let others act as they will, bearing evidence of the shallowness of their positions. It also demands respect for official offices, such as the presidency. When our guy is in office, you give him that modicum of respect – and when your guy is in office, we do the same. The other party is to be referred to as “the loyal opposition,” not with words the FCC forbids on the air.
In short, he pink flyer, while it may contain a few punches, is neither Christian nor conservative.

I don't know if Ed will get over here to read this.  He is "a nationally syndicated author" and "has been a conservative activist and consultant for over 30 years,"  so he's probably really busy.  If he does and decides to respond, I hope he doesn't resort to "the Devil can cite scripture for his own purpose"; a person with his qualifications should be able to be more original.  Besides, the words come from Shakespeare not the Bible.

I also hope he honestly says he's part of the religious right;  that term is far more accurate than Christian conservative.

Finally, if he does accuse me of being "demonic, treasonous, moronic Communist" or liberal, New Age, freedom hating, he should add "slut."  If he does, my wife will giggle and I love hearing her laugh.