Tuesday, April 23, 2019

A Minor Musing About Trump And Tech Giants With A Dash Of Orwell

I don't know if it's the fact that I'm getting older or the fact that we're cursed to live in interesting times, but I seem to re-read and cogitate over things more than I used to.

One such piece is this Rod Dreher post on The American Conservative site. Dreher wonders at conservative's gleeful reaction to the Mueller Report. He favorably quotes a David Brooks column wherein Brooks opines,
And today, across society, two things are happening: Referees are being undermined, and many are abandoning their own impartiality. (Think of the Wall Street regulators, the Supreme Court, the Senate committee chairmen, even many of us in the blessed media.) Things begin to topple. 
… Trump doesn’t seem to have any notion of loyalty to an office. All power in his eye is personal power, and the government is there to serve his Sun God self. He’ll continue to trample the proper systems of government. 
It’s easy to recognize when you are attacked head-on. But the U.S. is being attacked from below, at the level of the foundations we take for granted.
Dreher also writes,
The center is not holding, and technological changes (as well as cultural evolution) are rendering us unable to recreate a sustainable center.  Whether he leaves the White House in 2021, or 2025, after Trump, I believe that the US will be more or less in a Spain 1931 situation. Trump has done nothing to prevent that, and much to hasten its arrival.
Although Dreher writes, "I fully endorse David Brooks’s take on the corruption of the system, and his judgment on Donald Trump as a moral catastrophe," he does not proclaim himself a #NeverTrump club member. Instead, Dreher concludes,
. . . if you want to talk about the foundations of society being attacked, believe me, we should all worry about Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Silicon Valley on the whole a lot more than we worry about our buffoonish president. What the surveillance capitalists have done, and are doing, matters far more to the future of our democracy and its legitimacy than does Trump.
In fact, he doubles down on this conclusion:
I just know that I’m a lot more worried about Sergey Brin, Larry Page, and Mark Zuckerberg, and the class that they embody, than I am of a crooked real estate magnate from New York who is the weakest and least effective president since Jimmy Carter.
Dreher butters his bread by thinking and writing. Although he calls himself a "Bible-thumping troglodyte," Dreher thinks deeply, comes at the world from an Orthodox perspective, and talks about good food and drink frequentl, so he likely makes many conservative evangelical folk uncomfortable. 

I share Dreher's fears about Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple. The tech giants threaten Americans' privacy and possess a near totalitarian power to control public opinion.They cannot, however, send a person to Guantanamo or launch nuclear weapons. Further, I cannot share Dreher's confidence that Trump "stands, however uncertainly, in the way of the Controllers." Trump's admiration of despots indicates that he would give Bezos et al. free rein were they to offer him just a little flattery. In short, I remain a firm member of the #NeverTrump club.

That said, I worry that Dreher and I are both wrong. Americans seem to possess a certain optimism. The current crop of religious populists claim to be on God's side and view Trump as a savior from the evil liberals. Progressives proclaim that they are on the right side of history's long march toward justice for all. It is, however, likely that such optimism is misplaced and America has reached an Orwellian moment. Not the moment when we all loudly admit to loving big brother, although that moment is certainly possible; rather, we have come to the Animal Farm climax when conservatives, liberals, and displaced folks like myself stand outside the window and look "from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but [find it] impossible to say which was which. "

Thursday, March 21, 2019

Intellectual Diversity, Fox News, Aexandria Ocasio-Cortez, And The Pygmalion Myth: A Minor Musing

Governor Kristi Noem has signed a bill that purports to promote intellectual diversity. Being the good conservative intellectual that she is, Noem surely will work hard to include expansion of a classic curriculum in addition to decrying the corrosive effects of Foucault's and Derrida's postmodern sophistry. (Were she writing this post, the Governor would surely take a moment to point out that sophistry, as is used here, is not merely pretty talk with no substance but a reference to the ancient Sophists who believed that truth was unknowable.)

One of the benefits of a classic education would be knowledge of the Pygmalion myth. Pygmalion feared women, so he created an ivory statute shaped as his version of the perfect woman. He then asked the goddess Aphrodite to make the statue a real woman. Aphrodite granted his request.

I was most recently reminded of the Galatea myth this morning when my Twitter feed featured this aclip of Fox News coverage of Aexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC). The fearful folk at Fox are not content to brand AOC as a liberal. She immediately became a poster child for socialism. That's an old tactic, but a Democrat who is merely a liberal or a socialist is not a Fox News commentator's or a former Republican presidential candidate's idea of a perfect Democratic woman.

This morning Mike Huckabee and Fox and Friends completed their transformation of a freshman congresswoman who frightens them merely because she knows how to use social media. She is their perfect Democrat, a liberal, socialist Manchurian Candidate. Clearly, AOC is an empty suit who is being fed the questions she asks at hearings.
For Noem and her Trumpist ilk this unsubstantiated, fear-based rumor and others like it will pass for intellectual diversity. Explanations that put the rumor in the context of a long trend of trying to create a perfect woman who doesn't cause men to fear her will be called liberal bias.

Saturday, March 16, 2019

A Minor Musing On Justice And Power And Implied Threats Of Violence

I was fortunate to coach some excellent Lincoln-Douglas debaters. (Whether they succeeded with my coaching or in spite of my coaching is an open question.) Lincoln-Douglas debaters debate propositions of value and frequently open their cases with the phrase "I will be upholding the value of justice. . . " The young'uns I coached and those they debated against would frequently argue whether justice meant rendering each their due or a more Rawlsian concept which aregued justice as fairness

Donald Trump swore to uphold a Constitutions designed to "form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity. . . " Trump, however, doesn't see justice as rendering each his or her due or fairness. Instead, he relies on a Sophist argument: "Justice is nothing but the advantage of the stronger." Earlier this week, he told Breitbart News:
. . . I can tell you I have the support of the police, the support of the military, the support of the Bikers for Trump – I have the tough people, but they don’t play it tough — until they go to a certain point, and then it would be very bad, very bad....
These words are a not-so-veiled threat premised on the idea that might makes right. It's unlikely that those who drafted the Constitution understood justice in those terms nor is it clear how the threat of violence promotes the general welfare or insures domestic tranquility. (If I may be forgiven a bit of snark, one wonders if those words constitute "riot boosting" in South Dakota under the recently passed SB 189 and 190.)

This recent rhetoric is just another example of Trump attempting to obliterate political norms. This particular violation moves politics one step further from debate and one step closer to angry confrontation and reveals Trump once again to be a weak man posing as a strong one. More importantly, it confuses the debate about what justice is or should be and returns the debate to what do the strongest and richest want it to be.

For those interested, John Tristan posts what may be a more coherent take.

Tuesday, March 12, 2019

One Question For The South Dakota Democratic Party Chair Candidates

At Dakota Free Press, Cory has a couple of posts up about the candidates for South Dakota Democratic Party Chairperson. One updates the lunchroom saga. The other presents candidate Cunningham's plan for the Democratic Party. (If I may be permitted a moment of snark, Cunningham was running for the position in early January; the plan is not so deep and detailed that it could not have been ready for the Yankton forum on March 2.)

I don't have a vote or a favorite candidate, but I always have questions. In this case, however, I'll ask only one.

Your friends and neighbors may like you, but when they hear the word Democrat, they don't see you; they see Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC). Even though she's a rookie congresswoman, they immediately start worrying that someone is going to take their guns and their cars. Some who listen to too much Limbaugh, Hannity, Ingraham, Hewitt along with the crazier folk on talk radio or YouTube likely worry they'll be forced to eat jicama gruel through a metal straw at least four days a week. What can you do to change that perception? (In fairness, some of you mentioned this problem in Yankton, but no one really discussed how to deal with it.)

Monday, March 11, 2019

Senate Bill 140: A Minor Musing

There were a couple of comments on this partisan divides post that got me thinking. The big question became: is it really possible that South Dakota or the entire United States can devolve into the Northern Ireland of the Troubles and is there an ounce of prevention available in South Dakota? 

Over the weekend, I read this David Brooks column wherein he announces his support for reparations for the decedents of slaves. He also alludes to Native Americans:
From these thoughts we can appreciate the truth that while there have been many types of discrimination in our history, the African-American (and the Native American) experiences are unique and different. Theirs are not immigrant experiences but involve a moral injury that simply isn’t there for other groups. 
Slavery and the continuing pattern of discrimination aren’t only an attempt to steal labor; they are an attempt to cover over a person’s soul, a whole people’s soul.
Let's be clear, these words were written by David Brooks, a writer who espouses radical ideas with the same frequency that Sanka causes caffeine jitters. If Brooks recognizes that Native Americans have suffered "a moral injury that simply isn't there for other groups," then surely South Dakota legislators should recognize the harm that has been done to Native Americans within the state.

No one should be naive enough to expect that the South Dakota legislature will seriously take up the topic of reparations for Native Americans. They should, however, be able to unanimously pass some small measures to help. Senate Bill 140 is indeed a small measure:

The Board of Regents is hereby authorized to develop programs to increase enrollment and improve retention and student supports for any student who is a member of one of the nine federally recognized tribes in South Dakota at state institutions, including exploration of tuition assistance or waiver programs.

The Board of Regents shall report to the Legislature by July first of each year on the activities and progress made in regard to this Act, beginning July 1, 2020.

The bill appropriates no money. The Board of Regents is not authorized to grant "tuition assistance or waiver programs." It is merely authorized to explore such programs. If any piece of legislation can be called anodyne, SB 140 should be the top example.

And yet, Representatives Beal, Dennert, Frye-Mueller, Gosch, Lana Greenfield, Hammock, Howard, Karr, Mulally, Pischke, Post, and Weiss could not bring themselves to allow someone to make it a little easier for Native Americans to attend state colleges and universities.

David Brooks has come out in support of reparations, but these 12 South Dakota legislators cannot support efforts "to increase enrollment and improve retention and student supports" for Native Americans in South Dakota. It does make one wonder if South Africa may be a better analogy than Northern Ireland.

Sunday, March 10, 2019

What's The Difference Between South Dakota's Political Leaders And A Junior High Student Council?

Sadly, the answer appears to be nothing.

Bob Mercer reports that legislators, like the young'uns, are leaving their homework until the last minute.

Then appropriators left a long list of agencies hanging Thursday because of a scheduling quirk that senators needed to be at their desks by mid-morning to start casting votes.
The panel isn't scheduled to official return to work until Tuesday, facing an agenda that has 16 big areas of spending, including state government’s largest departments such as social services, education, corrections, the state universities and the court system.

To make the analogy more cringeworthy, Mercer reports that Governor Noem is using candy as a thank you for votes. The treats apparently also served as a message to let everyone know who is and is not her friend.

14 senators who voted against industrial hemp last week found on their desks Thursday boxes of Dots candy and thank-you notes from Noem for sticking with her. 

The small treats strengthened the feeling among legislators and lobbyists that the governor indeed might veto the hemp bill, especially after two Senate votes went 21-14 in a chamber where a veto override requires at least 24.

Democrats then decided to squander their chance to look like adults by resorting to juvenile behavior of their own. Dakota Free Press reports that Ann Tornberg, the current party chair, and Larry Lucas her running mate as vice-chair candidate offered to buy voting delegates lunch when the South Dakota Democratic Party Executive Board and State Central Committee Members meet later this month. Commenters on the DFP post claim that the email did not go out to all members of the party's Central Committee. They implied that those who were not voting for Tornberg did not get the email invitation. Like the the young'uns, the Democrats' apparently have a tribal lunch room. 

The farm economy is hurting; nursing homes are closing, and schools are not being fully funded. Meanwhile, leaders in government and members of the loyal opposition are passing notes asking "Will you be my friend? Circle yes or no."


Monday, March 4, 2019

How Much Partisan Prejudice Do South Dakotans Exhibit?

This afternoon, I spent a little too much time clicking on South Dakota counties in the maps that accompanied this Atlantic article "The Geography of Partisan Prejudice."

First a caveat, I'm not vouching for the methodology behind the ratings.
To do this assessment, PredictWise first partnered with Pollfish to run a nationwide poll of 2,000 adults to capture people’s feelings about the other party. The survey asked how people would feel if a close family member married a Republican or a Democrat; how well they think the terms selfish, compassionate, or patriotic describe Democrats versus Republicans; and other questions designed to capture sentiments about political differences. 
Based on the survey results, Tobias Konitzer, the co-founder of PredictWise, investigated which demographic characteristics seemed to correlate with partisan prejudice. He found, for example, that age, race, urbanicity, partisan loyalty, and education did coincide with more prejudice (but gender did not). In this way, he created a kind of profile of contemporary partisan prejudice. 
Next, Konitzer projected this profile onto the broader American population, under the assumption that people with similar demographics and levels of partisan loyalty, living in neighborhoods with comparable amounts of political diversity, tend to hold similar attitudes about political difference. He did this using voter files acquired by PredictWise from TargetSmart, a commercial vendor. Voter files are essentially data snapshots about all American adults, based on publicly available records of voter registration and turnout from past elections, along with data about neighborhood variables and demographic traits. In this way, PredictWise was able to rank all 3,000 counties in the country based on the estimated level of partisan prejudice in each place. “What I find most striking is that we find a good degree of variation,” Konitzer says. Some states, like Texas, show a real mix of prejudiced and nonprejudiced counties; whereas Florida is very consistent—and fairly prejudiced—from place to place.
South Dakota, like Texas, has a mix of counties. According to the survey, Faulk County is in the 1st percentile which means that "99 out of every 100 counties are more prejudiced against the political 'other.'" On the other hand, Sully, Stanley, and Haakon counties are all in the 100th percentile which means no other counties are statistically likely to be more prejudiced against the other party.

If one looks at the home counties of a few random bloggers, Yankton is in the 56th percentile, Brookings is in the 85th percentile, and Brown is in the 96th percentile. As for South Dakota's county, Minnehaha is in the 93rd percentile.

Besides using a complicated methodology, a few reasons exist to doubt profile. When one clicks on Pennington, stats are presented for Perkins, and Potter seems to have moved next to Harding. (As an aside, the counties that I cited stats for all seem to be in the right spot.)

That caveat aside, the article cites a couple of other studies with some disturbing conclusions: 
In general, Republicans seem to dislike Democrats more than Democrats dislike Republicans, PredictWise found. We don’t know why this is, but this is not the only study to have detected an imbalance. For example, in a 2014 survey by the Pew Research Center, half of consistently conservative respondents said it was important for them to live in a place where most people share their political views—compared with just 35 percent of consistent liberals. But a more recent survey, conducted in December by The Atlantic and the Public Religion Research Institute, found that Democrats were the ones showing more ill will—with 45 percent saying they’d be unhappy if their child married a Republican (versus 35 percent of Republicans saying they’d be unhappy if their child married a Democrat). So it’s hard to know exactly what’s going on, but what’s clear is that both sides are becoming more hostile toward one another.
It also points out how the polarization can lead to deeper problems:
We are now judging one another’s fundamental decency based on whether we eat at Chipotle or Chick-fil-A. This may seem silly—harmless, even. But it is uncomfortably reminiscent of stories from conflict zones abroad. In Northern Ireland, for example, an outsider visiting during the Troubles had no way to tell unionists and nationalists apart. They were pretty much all white Christians, after all. But the locals themselves routinely guessed one another’s identity based on their names, the spacing of their eyes, their sports jerseys, the color of their hair, their neighborhood, or even how much jewelry they wore­. This process came to be known as “telling.” If a reliable cue didn’t exist, people would make one up. It was a way to move about in the world in a time of profound tribalism, during which 3,600 people were killed.
If anybody is wondering, I prefer to eat at Arby's and get my coffee at Caribou whenever I have the option.