Monday, January 21, 2019

Plains Pops: Pleasant Stuff Edition

While some may say that most of my musings aren't really worth full posts, "Plains Pops" is just a collection of items that I want to draw attention to with little comment. Today, as the title indicates, it's pleasant stuff

First, his answers at the first 2019 Legislative Cracker Barrel prove once again that Representative Ryan Cwach is a damn fine legislator even if he is a rookie. The Yankton Press and Dakotan coverage is here.

Second, local businessman Ben Hanten has started a podcast called The Lanyard. According to the description, Hanten will "be interviewing someone who is building an interesting business or helping to make their community a little more interesting." Today's inaugural discussion was with Sister Maribeth Wenztlaff, the prioress of the Yankton Benedictines.

Finally, this graphic just made me laugh. It came through my timeiine as an @joshbarro retweet of an @tpcarney tweet. I suspect it may be a good metaphor for how Americans of different political persuasions see the world.


Saturday, January 19, 2019

Quotation Of The Day: Is Donald Trump Trying To Make The Rest Of Us As Miserable As He Is?

I have to ask because this George Will analysis resonates with me.

By his comportment, the president benefits his media detractors with serial vindications of their disparagements. They, however, have sunk to his level of insufferable self-satisfaction by preening about their superiority to someone they consider morally horrifying and intellectually cretinous. For most Americans, President Trump’s expostulations are audible wallpaper, always there but not really noticed. Still, the ubiquity of his outpourings in the media’s outpourings gives American life its current claustrophobic feel. This results from many journalists considering him an excuse for a four-year sabbatical from thinking about anything other than the shiny thing that mesmerizes them by dangling himself in front of them.

Dislike of him should be tempered by this consideration: He is an almost inexpressibly sad specimen. It must be misery to awaken to another day of being Donald Trump. He seems to have as many friends as his pluperfect self-centeredness allows, and as he has earned in an entirely transactional life. His historical ignorance deprives him of the satisfaction of working in a house where much magnificent history has been made. His childlike ignorance — preserved by a lifetime of single-minded self-promotion — concerning governance and economics guarantees that whenever he must interact with experienced and accomplished people, he is as bewildered as a kindergartener at a seminar on string theory.

I'm never going to turn a phrase as well as George Will, so I won't try. I don't know about Trump's personal friendships and I don't really care. I know that all of us seem to think less and yell more whenever we discuss political issues. In short, Trump has brought us down to his level. I certainly feel suffocated by the oxygen that he takes out of the room, but ignoring him, a action that most other politicians make easy, is nearly impossible. He's driving a bulldozer through a china shop without worrying about the damage he's doing or those who will have to clean it up.

Friday, January 18, 2019

A Minor Musing On South Dakota SB 55 And God In Schools

I am bewildered as to why Senate Bill 55 exists. SB 55 requires that the national motto In God We Trust "shall be displayed in each public school. The display shall be located in a prominent location within each public school. The display may take the form of a mounted plaque, student artwork, or any other appropriate form as determined by the school principal."

When I had the privilege to teach world literature classes, I taught a unit on the Bible. I frequently supplemented the textbook with the Garden of Eden, David and Goliath, and Saul on the Road to Damascus passages. When I taught The Grapes of Wrath, I spent a class period discussing how Steinbeck inverted the biblical account of the search for the promised land.  I taught Flannery O'Connor stories every chance I got. I usually told students that O'Connor believed her "subject in fiction is the action of grace in territory largely held by the devil." It is difficult to teach literature with discussing grace, Christ figures, and a heavenly host of biblical archetypes and allusions.

Conservative and liberal students took my world lit, American lit, and AP lit classes. No conservative parent ever thanked me for exposing students to the Bible. They didn't show up at a parent-teacher conference and say that "the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart” and we know that "it shall not return. . .void, but it shall accomplish that which [God] please[s]." Nothing close to that ever happened.

Nor did liberal parents contact Cory Heidelberger to have him charge into my classroom followed by an army of ACLU lawyers wielding 666 cease and desist orders. I expect a few students whom I bored to tears would have welcomed the intrusion, but nothing close to that ever happened either.

If the goal is to get students to see the phrase "In God We Trust," directing that principals place the motto in "a school entryway, cafeteria, or other common area where students are most likely to see the national motto display" means that the motto will become background noise like lunch menus, daily announcements, and posters reminding everyone to wear school colors on Friday. I can guarantee that students will pay more attention to lunch menus than they will the motto. I doubt the motto will remind them to say a table grace before they eat.

Finally, I'm willing to bet that most, if not all, of the legislation's sponsors complain about students being addicted to their phones. They should know that young'uns will be checking Snapchat or Instagram or texts from work on every trip through all common areas.

In short, God is not absent from public schools and SB 55 is an ineffective solution in search of a problem.

Thursday, January 17, 2019

A Minor Musing: Skrulls And South Dakota Legislative Resolutions

Skrulls! That's right. Skrulls have apparently replaced many practical, no nonsense South Dakota legislators: good solid folk who believe that hard work is its own reward. How else does one explain the desire to hand out stickers and pass "give everyone a trophy for participating" resolutions? Shapeshifting Skrulls have taken on the form of South Dakota legislators and replaced the good folk South Dakotans elected.

Senate Concurrent Resolution 5 (SCR 5) provides the most obvious proof that something is amiss. SCR 5 commends Senators Thune and Rounds for supporting Brett Kavanaugh's nomination.

Let's review: a Republican state legislature commends the states's Republican federal senators for supporting someone nominated by a Republican president. Thune's and Rounds's votes were hardly profiles in courage. No South Dakota Democrat is going to win campaigning against the Kavanaugh vote. In fact, voting against Kavanaugh would have increased the chance of a Republican primary challenger. There's no need to commend someone for making a politically expedient vote. Republicans would know that. Skrulls probably would not.

More importantly, the resolution commends Thune and Rounds for supporting Trump, an act they perform with extreme regularity. Thune votes with Trump 95% of the time. Rounds is in line with Trump's positions on nearly 92% of his votes. The odds of the two men voting against Trump's nominee is only slightly higher than the odds of fictional Skrulls taking over the state legislature. (The odds of Trump's positions aligning with South Dakotans" best interests 90% of the time is likely lower.)

Republicans used to be republican. At the state level, they worried about the state first. Is it too much to hope that some work will get done about roads or nursing homes that are disappearing before the legislature devotes time to handing out participation trophies to politicians for taking politically expedient votes?

Monday, January 14, 2019

I Am Pleasantly Surprised ....

Even if the statement is late, Senator Rounds has demonstrated the ability to point out one of Trump's racist comments when Trump takes aim at something South Dakota specific.
Senator Thune and Representative Johnson have apparently given their social media team the night off.

Sunday, January 13, 2019

A Modest Proposal To Amend HB 1041

Last year, I wrote a post about my Republicanism. Since then, I have read a good number of conservative authors at places like The National Review and The American Conservative. These articles repeatedly pointed out that conservatives and Republicans believe in freedom and responsibility, Further, Republicans and conservatives understand, in ways that other mammals cannot, that the world is filled with bad actors.

HB 1041 is a bill to "provide for the carrying of a concealed pistol without a permit." The legislation's sponsors certainly will contend that they proposed the legislation because they realize that freedom to carry pistols without a permit is the only available method to stop unabated wickedness wherever a good conservative or Republican  may find it.

According to the Argus Leader,
Republican Rep. Drew Dennert is sponsoring a constitutional carry bill in the House. He says backers have the promise of the governor and support from the public and both legislative chambers.
Given that Governor Noem seems supportive, one hates to temper the enthusiasm of "constitutional carry" advocates. Obviously every Republican or conservative who carries a pistol under HB 1041 will train weekly to become as proficient with a pistol as Wild Bill Hickok, Such people will, of course, never crack under pressure nor will they ever miss their intended target.

That said, South Dakota still retains a few Democrats. Some have even been elected to the legislature. The state also has a university system, and these educational institutions are known to be the last bastions of socialists and other nefarious scoundrels. It is, therefore, not beyond the realm of possibility that an irresponsible person might take unfair advantage of the "constitutional carry" freedom provision and carry a concealed pistol or several concealed pistols. Because South Dakota is home to 800,000 resident, it is not unlikely that several thousand feckless folk may abuse the the "constitutional carry" freedom. These capricious citizens may accidentally wound themselves or others.

It, therefore, becomes one's duty to offer a modest proposal, with all due apologies to Jonathan Swift, in the form of an amendment to rectify the situation.

The amendment would require every person carrying a concealed pistol also carry a trauma kit. The kit would contain gauze with a clotting agent, a chest seal, a trauma bandage, medical tape, a tourniquet, and heavy duty medical gloves. It would also require that the person carrying the concealed pistol and trauma kit should be able to show proof of competency with the medical items being carried. This proof could be demonstrated either by certificate of training or a field test consisting of properly applying the tourniquet and other items in the kit.

Some conservatives or Republicans may contend that this proposal springs from some hidden liberal bias. In an effort to allay such fears, prudence moves me to point out that a Blue Force Gear Micro Trauma Kit NOW won the 2018 NRA Golden Bullseye Award for "Accessory of The Year." If it as an approved NRA accessory, surely conservatives and Republicans cannot object to making it part of a "constitutional carry" law. (Neither the NRA nor Blue Force Gear sponsor this blog.)

I cannot conceive of a Republican or conservative legislature not wanting to ensure that freedom is accompanied with responsibility, so I eagerly anticipate sponsorship, debate, and passage of the amendments proposed above.

Saturday, January 12, 2019

South Dakota Senate Acts Like An Abuse Victim

Per Axios, six of the ten states hardest hit by the shutdown voted for Trump. South Dakota is one of those states. Axios points out that "[o]ffices of the USDA's Farm Service Agency, which help farmers affected by China's soybean tariffs, are closed due to the shutdown. Further, agencies including the Indian Health Service and Small Business Administration are shuttered.

Meanwhile, the South Dakota Senate passed a resolution supporting Trump's monument to his own narcissism. Although Senator Stace Nelson's hyperbolic "black wind of death to race across this nation from coast to coast" will likely garner the most attention, it's Senator Lance Russell's plaintive desire to protect Trump from those with "nefarious motives" that indicates the need for an intervention.

After the original resolution was amended to reflect the historically accurate fact that nearly all walls including the Great Wall of China, Hadrian's Wall, and the Berlin Wall fail, Senator Lance Russel worried about Trump's feelings:

Lance Russell, R-Hot Springs, saw the amended version as a watered down version of the original resolution. He said that amending the resolution is on par with "the games that get played in Washington." He said he hopes the amended version doesn't send a message that South Dakota doesn't support Trump. 

The Senate needs to support Trump in constructing a wall across the entire southern U.S. border because the problems Trump is describing aren't "a manufactured crisis," Russell said. Trump is "trying to elevate all of us" by taking on the border issues, he said, adding that the South Dakota Senate needs to support Trump and the amended version of the resolution doesn't do that.
 

"It is a crisis, and Trump didn't manufacture it," Russell said. "It's been around for a while. ... When we are watering down what we're doing here, I understand the politics of the situation, but this gives people with nefarious motives to question what the president is doing and what he was elected to do."

Let's be clear. If the wall were that important, Trump had a Republican House and Senate for two years. They could have passed the funding, gone to reconciliation to avoid the filibuster, and started construction. Instead, South Dakotans are being hurt and the legislature is looking to protect the person responsible for causing the pain.

According to Russell, South Dakotans need to support Trump even when he creates policies such as tariffs and shutdowns that adversely affect South Dakotans. It doesn't take any reading between the lines to get to abuse victim phrasing: "Trumpie just wants what's best for me; my Trumpie doesn't want to hurt me; he just gets angry sometimes. It's my fault really."