Showing posts with label Budgets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Budgets. Show all posts

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Is The Deficit Shrinking Too Quickly?

This post from Investors Business Daily seems both counter-intuitive and troubling:
Here's a pretty important fact that virtually everyone in Washington seems oblivious to: The federal deficit has never fallen as fast as it's falling now without a coincident recession
To be specific, CBO expects the deficit to shrink from 8.7% of GDP in fiscal 2011 to 5.3% in fiscal 2013 if the sequester takes effect and to 5.5% if it doesn't. Either way, the two-year deficit reduction — equal to 3.4% of the economy if automatic budget cuts are triggered and 3.2% if not — would stand far above any other fiscal tightening since World War II.

Until the aftermath of the Great Recession, there were only three such periods in which the deficit shrank by a cumulative 2% of GDP or more. The 1960-61 and 1969-70 episodes both helped bring about a recession.

Far steeper deficit cuts during the demobilization from World War II and in 1937-38 both precipitated economic reversals.
No wonder economics is called the dismal science.

Saturday, December 29, 2012

A Minor Musing About Political Glasses: Rose-colored And Half Empty

I'm catching up on my South Dakota blogosphere reading and came across these little tidbits that I found interesting.

Pat Powers, as his his wont, shills for the Republican monopoly that has dominated South Dakota politics  and points to stats that say that South Dakota is the 7th best run state in the nation.

Meanwhile, Constant Conservative takes the bloom off the rose colored eyewear and points out that South Dakota gets more help from the federal government than most other states: forty-six of them to be exact.
South Dakota is number 4 in the nation for percentage of the state budget underwritten by the federal government. Check out the Tax Foundation for the details.
I know that I have a resolution to say something positive about Daugaard, but boasting about a budget surplus and preaching self-reliance while taking advantage of federal largess seems duplicitous at best.

Saturday, August 11, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Paul Ryan's Faux Fiscal Responsibility Edition

Daniel Larison sums it up in this post at The American Conservative:
Ryan’s proposals always exempt the Pentagon from any meaningful spending cuts, so he is elevated to the status of national leader . . . . Ryan gets a pass for his fiscal irresponsibility in the past mostly because people don’t remember it or they try to ignore it. His current credibility as a fiscal conservative is not based on what he has done while in office (which would show that he has not been a fiscal conservative), but rather on what he proposes that we should be doing years from now.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

$50 Million Here Today, Gone Tomorrow?

Earlier this week, a task force chaired by Paul Volker and Richard Ravitch released a report about state budgets.  A couple of conclusions should make everyone a bit less giddy about South Dakota's surplus:
State budget practices make achieving fiscal stability and sustainability difficult:
While almost all states have constitutional or statutory balanced budget requirements, “revenue” and “expenditure” are not defined terms. The use of borrowed funds, off-budget agencies, and the proceeds of asset sales are not uncommon practices, often rendering balanced budgets illusory.
The lack of financial transparency makes it more difficult for the public to understand the critical nature of problems such as pensions and other payment obligations. Temporary “one-shot” measures to avoid or delay hard fiscal decisions mask these underlying problems.
Opaque and untimely reporting, coupled with nonexistent multiyear planning, severely hampers efforts to address these problems in a serious manner.
Perhaps, this surplus is the result of good fortune and fiscal responsibility.  Bob Mercer thinks that it is. However, these results are as curious as the budget crisis that was never mentioned during the 2010 gubernatorial campaign and then revealed during Governor Daugaard's budget address to the 2011 legislative session.

That skepticism aside, the report concludes that all of the states will face problems in the future:
Since 2008, . . . state funding of K-12 education has declined as a share of state spending while Medicaid spending has increased in share. There have also been significant cuts in state funding of public higher education. Relatively uncontrollable Medicaid spending and rising obligations to contribute to pension funding crowd out spending for education and will continue to do so until these problems are brought under control. Continuing cuts in state funding have put access to
education and the quality of instruction and student performance at serious risk.
America’s aging infrastructure faces growing capital needs, most of which are funded by state and local governments. However, these critical needs suffer from low budgetary priority. Like education spending, essential infrastructure spending is now crowded out by more immediate spending pressures, pushing essential investments off to the future and increasing the risks to public health and safety and economic growth.
I doubt South Dakota's population is immune to the aging process or that its poorest citizens will reverse the Medicaid trend here.  I also doubt that South Dakota has fewer infrastructure needs relative to other states.

Slightly Related: I usually leave the Dakota War College questions to The Madville Times, but is there any explanation as to why the Bill Clay post that contained this statement has disappeared?
Does anyone wonder why exactly some would be pushing for a 1 cent sales tax increase when our state is coming up with $50 million budget surplus? Your thoughts are as good as mine. Somebody must like to spend money. . . .
The recent budget surplus indicates that amount is obviously not ”necessary,” Since our state is sitting on $50 million extra. Education and health care providers just need better lobbyists. Why would I as as citizen vote to pay another penny in sales tax when our state is flush with cash?

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

What Does One Do With A $50 Million Budget Surplus?

The Sioux Falls Argus Leader opened their July 16th story with a similar question.  There seem to be three answers.

First one can be blatantly political. The Dakota War College quickly trumpets the idea that the surplus means that the sales tax initiative should be defeated:
Does anyone wonder why exactly some would be pushing for a 1 cent sales tax increase when our state is coming up with $50 million budget surplus? Your thoughts are as good as mine. Somebody must like to spend money. . . .

The recent budget surplus indicates that amount is obviously not ”necessary,” Since our state is sitting on $50 million extra. Education and health care providers just need better lobbyists. Why would I as as citizen vote to pay another penny in sales tax when our state is flush with cash?
 Expect that talking point to become a drum beat over the next few months.

One can also be political and hopelessly naive.  South Dakota Education Association spokesperson Bryce Healy "said the budget surplus is 'good news for everybody.'” The Argus Leader reports:
“SDEA hopes our state leaders will look into investing those resources in our education system and not just putting them into reserves,” Healy said. “These dollars would help, but we still have a long way to go in education funding to get us back to the levels where we need to be.”
I'll let the attitudes and laughter from the following commercial provide my response to Healy's naivete.
The Press and Dakotan has the most believable outcome:
If history serves as a template, we will instead probably hear about uncertain times, the need for restraint and, of course, the obligatory IOUs from lawmakers that the money that has been or will be cut or unspent now will find its way back to our schools, our roads and our social programs ... some day.
"Some day" a prince will come, and the sun will come out tomorrow, and if everyone claps Tinkerbell will live

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Let's Kick Some Bad Cliches To The Curb

Or we could throw them under the bus.

The Madville Times and Dakota Today have been doing yeoman work to illustrate the vapid nature of the family budget cliche.

Equally ubiquitous and perhaps more useless, "we've got to stop kicking the can down the road" must disappear from our public discourse.

Instead, let's ask these three questions posed by Megan McArdle.
Which of these things shall we cut?  How shall we build a coalition to pass those cuts, and stick to them in the face of what is bound to be fierce and ugly resistance from those who the programs benefit?  And when we have decided that we can cut no further, what taxes will we raise to pay for what's left?
The focus group tested "kicking the can down the road" has allowed only one side of the political spectrum to dominate the argument.  I won't dignify what's happening by calling it a debate. The cliche doesn't allow for the third question at all.  Most importantly, the cliche dangerously oversimplifies a complex situation.

McArdle even includes this helpful chart to show how money is spent.


It should be clear to all but the most extreme partisan on either side that the solutions to the current mess will be painful and that both sides must kill a few of their own "zombie sacred cows."  The results of the current debate that has focused on "kicking the can" will probably result in the middle class being kicked in the groin.

I'm just guessing, but I expect if Americans were allowed to have a civil discussion based on McArdle's chart and questions, the budget cuts would be far different than the ones Americans will see over the next few years

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

South Dakota Leads And Follows In The Wrong Way

A new report shows that South Dakota made deep cuts to its budget despite having a greater percentage of its budget available in reserve funds than most other states.

The Center on Policy and Budget Priorities has analyzed 2011-2012 state budgets and determined that the cuts are deep and long lasting.
Of the 47 states with newly enacted budgets, 38 or more states are making deep, identifiable cuts in K-12 education, higher education, health care, or other key areas in their budgets for fiscal year 2012.
Further, CPBP has determined "the vast majority of states (37 of 44 states for which data are available) plan to spend less on services in 2012 than they spent in 2008 – in some cases, much less."

In the "this is not exactly news department," the study found
At least 23 states have made identifiable cuts in support for public schools. In many cases, these cuts undermine school finance systems that are intended to reduce disparities between high-wealth and low-wealth school districts, so the largest impacts may be felt in communities that are least able to compensate for the loss of funds from their own resources.
The report reminds South Dakotan that "South Dakota cut K-12 education by 6.4 percent, next year, an amount equal to $416 per student, and 8.8 percent in 2013."

Further, ". . . 25 states have made large, identifiable cuts in funding for state colleges and universities, with direct impacts on students."  Again, CPBP reminds us that South Dakota joined that trend.
South Dakota cut higher education (and most other agencies) by 10 percent. The Board of Regents voted to raise tuition by 6.9 percent, or $490 per student, on average. The tuition increase covers only part of the loss of state funding, and each university has to determine how it will make up for the remaining loss of funds.
Of course, everyone in South Dakota remembers that "South Dakota cut Medicaid funding by 6.6 percent. This includes an average provider rate cut of 7 percent, which may cause some doctors to stop taking new patients or to drop existing patients."  Whereas, a majority of states cut education, the report shows that fewer that half of the states cut health care.  According to CPBP, "[a]t least 20 states have made deep, identifiable cuts in health care that will reduce access to care for low-income children, seniors, families and people with disabilities."

South Dakota, however, was one of only "a handful of states [that] held onto substantial reserve funds they have drawn on to avoid some cuts to public services. Specifically, six states that faced shortfalls for fiscal year 2012 entered their budget deliberations this past spring with rainy day funds equaling about 5 percent of fiscal year 2011 spending."   South Dakota has reserves equal to 11% of the 2012 budget according to the report.

In short, South Dakota's governor and legislature cut deeper than they had to.  Further, as Bernie Hunhoff reminds readers in a Yankton Press & Dakotan letter, these leaders are attempting to give corporations a tax break.  Hunhoff writes,
Another wrong-headed policy is the notion that we should rebate some of the contractor’s excise tax (which otherwise goes to the general fund for schools and health care) to big corporations who plan projects of $5 million and above, at the discretion of the governor’s office. It would replace a current program that was revealed to be a boondoggle before being terminated by the legislature in 2010 because it cost too much.

The governor’s staff told the Press & Dakotan that 80 percent or more of the new rebates will go to wind and ethanol programs. They say that now because wind and ethanol has popular support, but nothing in the state law guarantees that and it’s unlikely to occur. TransCanada Pipeline, a major competitor to wind and ethanol, has been one of the beneficiaries in the past.

This newest tax give-away program might cost even more than the one we killed in 2010, and it comes at a time when the general fund is already strapped from the recession.
Hunhoff even offers a main street solution:
. . . let’s end the contractor’s excise altogether and then the state’s coffers will grow even more.

Let’s end the tax for farmers who build a machine shed or barn. Let’s end it for the family-owned car dealership under construction north of Yankton.     Let’s end it for the two women who tore down an old building on Howard’s main street and built a new coffee shop and eatery. Let’s rebate it for the entrepreneurs who restored the old bank building on Vermillion’s Main Street into a fine steakhouse.

Let’s end it for every businessman and farmer. But let’s not let government pick winners and losers. If big projects get a rebate, Main Street should qualify for the same. Everyone should be treated alike when it comes to taxation.

We all know that raising well-educated and healthy children is the best investment a government can make in economic development and the future. We’ve cut those priorities in recent years, and no community knows it better than Yankton, where we’re now seeking charitable contributions for extra-curriculars.

So if the administration wants to write rebate checks to big companies, it should find an appropriate funding source. Don’t take even more resources away from schools and our poorest families.
I don't know what the impact Hunhoff's proposal would have, but I doubt we'll get to debate its pros and cons, the CPBP report reminds us that South Dakota's legislative leaders and governor seem to want to lead only when it will hurt the average citizen and award corporations

Thursday, July 14, 2011

On The Need For Compromise: The Devil Is In The Defintions

At the Madville Times, Cory responds to this chart.


Cory writes,
This chart appears to support an observation I made over the weekend, that Democrats are actually the center, seeking practical solutions and good government, while Republicans are the wild-eyed ideologues, who view compromise as the root of our problems.
In certain areas (freedom of speech, human rights), compromise makes me queasy. But compromise lies at the heart of good governing. Compromise is how adults get things done. And if you’re looking for compromise, it appears you’re much more likely to find a home in the Democratic party.
 In the comments, Ken Blanchard writes,
. . . . The whole point of compromise is get as close as one can to one’s principles when other people are involved. . . .
There is a very good reason why a lot of Republicans are skeptical of compromise. They think that politicians go to Washington promising change and then do business as usual. They think that compromise means making promises you can’t keep and spending trillions you don’t have.
Nonetheless, I am tempted to accept your view that Republicans have principles and Democrats don’t. You’d think that when Obama criticized Bush’s national security policies, that the former was speaking from principle. If so, he compromised his principles in a hurry. You’d think that Democrats had a principle that a President can’t start a war without consent from Congress. Obama surely compromised that principle in a hurry, with his utter contempt for the War Powers Act. So maybe you’re right. Compromise is the way to get things done. Principles are just obstacles to good government. Thanks for setting me straight.
First the esteemable Dr. Blanchard correctly observes politics and values and principles create a complicated calculus.  For example, the Christan Right's support for Ayn Rand acolytes confuses me.  He also correctly observes President Obama has violated principle by refusing to follow the War Powers Act.  The President deserves to be condemned for his disdain for Constitutional principles.

It seems, however, that Blanchard has confused "negotiation" and "compromise"  when he asserts the "point of compromise is get as close as one can to one’s principles."  A standard definition of compromise* is
a settlement of differences by mutual concessions; an agreement reached by adjustment of conflicting or opposing claims, principles, etc., by reciprocal modification of demands. [emphasis mine]
In short, compromise means that both sides must make concessions.  Negotiate, on the other hand, seems to carry the connotation of success.  To negotiate is to "arrange or settle by discussion and mutual agreement."  Further, it can mean "to succeed in accomplishing or managing."  Here, the "mutual agreement" can be a win for one side or the the other.  There is an agreement, but there may not be "mutual concessions" or "reciprocal" modifications.  If one has superior talent or resources, one can manage to get everything that one desires through negotiation and refuse to compromise.

Today's New York Times leads with
The Federal Reserve chairman, Ben S. Bernanke, warned on Wednesday of a “huge financial calamity” if President Obama and the Republicans cannot agree on a budget deal that allows the federal debt ceiling to be increased. Moody’s, the ratings agency, threatened a credit downgrade, citing a “rising possibility” that no deal would be reached before the government’s borrowing authority hits its limit on Aug. 2.
"Huge financial calamity" and "a credit downgrade" indicate that the time for negotiation, getting as much as one can," has ended.  The time has come to compromise.

James Fallows illustrates what I hope most Americans want from their leaders in this situation.
It's easy to forget at times like these, but the whole ponderous U.S. political/governmental system is made of actual human beings, who -- even as they respond to large-scale ideological, political, financial, and interest-group pressures -- can still choose to behave better, or worse, in a given set of circumstances. And the difference between good and bad behavior can make a difference. (If JFK's national security council had been much more hair-trigger and impatient during the Cuban Missile Crisis, or if Khrushchev had been, world history would have been different.)
I'll add another distinction to Fallows's point.  By all accounts Cantor and Obama are intelligent men.  Right now, America needs their wisdom more than their intellect.

*I used the definition of compromise as a noun although I am comparing the definitions of two verbs.  The verb definition "to settle by a compromise" does not do much to further the discussion.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Debt Ceiling Questions

I was unable to attend Congresswoman's Noem's Yankton appearance.  This David Bell post at the Frum Forum makes me wish I had been there.

According to the Yankton Press & Dakotan coverage, "Noem . . . fielded audience questions on a number of subjects."  One of her responses was described thusly.
An audience member asked how the federal government could hit its debt limit of $14 trillion yet continue operating until August. Noem explained that U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner used what he termed “extraordinary measures” such as delaying payments to keep the federal government afloat.
The answer may be fine as far as it goes, but  Bell has a whole list of questions that he wants politicians to answer.
*ask the next Senator you see about the Credit Default Swap situation;

*ask the next Congressman you run across at a fund-raiser about the size of the global derivatives market;

*ask the next Washington, D.C. politician you meet how many swaps and derivatives contracts he or she has personally arranged.
I have to admit that I generally use "derivative" as an adjective meaning "lacking originality."  Were I to use the word in a sentence, I would say "Congresswoman Noem's statements were derivative of John Boehner's talking points."  I'm glad, therefore, that Bell concludes with this less technical question.
And, the coup de grace, just ask anyone if they think it is wise to test a theory about marketplace behavior when failure of that test could severely undermine the confidence of markets all over the world about the reliability and judgment of United States policymakers.
I would have loved to hear Noem's answer to that one.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

I Don't Think The Plan Is Going To Come Together

Because I am a vain human, I checked my blogger stats today.  I noticed that I had a few page views from this South Dakota War College post.  SDWC had quick hit about the opt out vote.  In the comments, Cory linked to this post about Paul Dorr so it's pretty obvious why a few folk came over.

Representative Bernie Hunhoff also weighed in on the results in the comments section.  "Some small retailers would have seen taxes rise $1,000 on up to $7,000 for a hardware store owner. Add that to the blue collar laborers making $10/hour and the seniors on fixed incomes and you’ve got a tough electorate."  I may have to use the "tough electorate" comment when I teach understatement during Dakota STEP test prep.

Hunhoff also writes
Democrats . , . . came up with a three-year plan that used some reserves, used some “sweeps” from excesses in cash flow accounts, used some of the earnings … not the principle, the earnings … off the $860 million in trust funds, implemented some selective cuts, curbed corporate welfare, etc. We could have frozen education spending until state revenues grow, as they are doing. It’s still a solid and workable plan.
In a subsequent comment he adds, "we had bi-partisan support until the powers-that-be dropped the hammer on it."

I'm unsure how any proposal in South Dakota, a one party state, can be considered bi-partisan.  Republicans dominate executive offices.  The Democrats in the state senate could caucus in a soccer mom's mini van.  Only four house Republicans, if memory serves, voted to oppose Governor Daugaard's final budget. I'll depress my Democratic friends by mentioning that redistricting will probably not make the situation any brighter.

I'm also less sanguine than Hunhoff about the growth providing enough funds to help schools, pay state workers, and do the other business of state government.  Were I a betting man, I would guess that everyone will just be happy preserve the status quo and not slip back.

Like the national GOP, South Dakota's Republicans sold the budget on the premise that austerity now would produce growth later. 

On today's Frum Forum Noah Kristula-Green writes, "Conservatives and Republicans have attempted to find empirical evidence to support their belief that economic growth can come with austerity.  They frequently cite a study done by Harvard economists Alberto Alesina and Silvia Ardagna."  Green continues,
The study looked at what the best ways for countries to reduce their deficits have been: whether through spending cuts or revenue increases. Their data shows that over the long-term, spending cuts are a better way to bring long-term deficits under control. A second study by Alesina went further and argued that “large, credible and decisive” cuts can be immediately followed by “sustained” growth.
America's problems must be solved.  Nationally, Republicans will pass an austere budget like the one proposed by Paul Ryan.  South Dakota has already passed one.  The state and federal budgets will harmonically converge and we'll get--let's be honest--austerity.  

Green thoughtfully reads more than the abstract and casts a wee bit of doubt on that theory.  (You'll have to excuse me; I'm not as good at understatement as Representative Hunhoff.)  Green writes,
So what’s problematic with Alesina’s results? Alesina has indeed found cases where reducing spending was followed by economic growth and reduced deficits. The problem: he found very few cases. More specifically he found 9 examples out of 107 attempts to reduce spending.

Even if we are more generous with our parameters, the data is still not an overwhelming majority. If we are only interested in times where reducing spending was followed by an economic expansion, the result is 26 cases. If we are interested in the number of times that reduced spending was followed by successfully reducing the deficit (doesn’t mean the economy had to grow!) we find 21 cases in his data. [italics in orginal]
Green concludes,
So the evidence for Republicans is much less heartening. It seems that reducing spending only causes economic growth in a minority of cases, and that in those cases, the reduction in spending needs to be off-set by a monetary policy that is expansionary. The GOP currently is in denial about how big the economic growth from spending cuts will be and opposed to monetary stimulus due to the intellectual capture of the party by gold-standard and hard money advocates.
The South Dakota Legislature doesn't have much influence on monetary policy, and the evidence behind the national party's theory which has been applied at the state level seems pretty thin.  I doubt that the next session will produce any more bi-partisanship or the growth necessary to move the state beyond austerity.