Showing posts with label language use. Show all posts
Showing posts with label language use. Show all posts

Thursday, August 25, 2016

Will Adult Republicans Ever Speak Up?

I'm not politically correct. I certainly use profanity more than most, and I am better capable than most of explaining how a certain short guttural verb that begins with "F" can be used in its participle forms as both an adjective and a noun in the same sentence.

On the other hand, I try hard to draw the line at using terms that demean entire groups of people. I also doubt that any human is "standard" I expect people seeking higher office and those who support them to adhere to both standards.

Apparently Donald Trump and Ann Coulter, one of his more vocal supporters, don't share that belief. My Twitter feed is full of photos of the following excerpt from Coulter's book which I found re-produced here:
Trump denied knowing that Serge was disabled, and demanded an apology, saying that anyone could see his imitation was of a flustered, frightened reporter, not a disabled person. It’s true that Trump was not mimicking any mannerisms that Serge has. He doesn’t jerk around or flail his arms. He’s not retarded. He sits calmly, but if you look at his wrists, you’ll see they are curved in. That’s not the imitation Trump was doing—he was doing a standard retard, waving his arms and sounding stupid: “’Ahhh, I don’t know what I said—ahhh, I don’t remember!’ He’s going, ‘Ahhh, I don’t remember, maybe that’s what I said!’” [emphasis mine]
If any Republican needs help in their efforts to explain to Coulter and Trump that "retard" should be used only as a verb and that no human is "standard," leave a comment and I'll be happy to use a short guttural verb in all its forms to explain it.


Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Tweet Of The Day: Obscure Collective Nouns Edition

I knew the murder of crows I also knew about the congregation of alligators, and the army of caterpillars.  I had no idea how to discuss a group of hipsters until I read this tweet. Does anyone know what a collection of hipster glasses is called?


Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Political Propaganda Done Well: Pat Powers Edition

I should be a better person, but I admit that I love seeing political propaganda done well. Something about seeing a paragraph that layers negative political implication upon negative political implication promotes a smile. This Pat Powers offering should be considered contemporary classic:
How else do you explain democratic activists abandoning a proven campaigner in former Congresswoman Stephanie Herseth Sandlin in favor of Brendan Johnson to replace his outgoing father. Despite the fact that charges of nepotism and a seemingly Kim Jong-Il like manner of political succession will dog him at every turn?
Let's break this masterpiece down a bit. First, there's the loaded term "activists." Countless politicians have made their careers running against "activists," but Pat's audience will have a special antipathy for the term; after all, most Republicans learn in the cradle that "activist" courts that have lead America to the edge of ruin. The term "activists" also connotes effort not merely desire

Second, Not only are Democrats "activists." They are rash, quick to reject the "proven." If there's one thing conservatives believe they embrace; it's tried and proven verities. Democrats now stand convicted of embracing the dangerous and rejecting the proven.

But there's more. These Brendan Johnson supporters are elitists who have created a hierarchical system that systematically supports sons replacing the father. Couple that implied elitism with "nepotism," a term heavy with negative connotations, and Johnson becomes the boss's undeserving son that nearly everyone despises.

The coup de grace is the allusion to Kim Jong-il who did indeed inherit rule of North Korea from his father. Americans are hourly reminded that Kim Jong-un, who inherited rule of North Korea from Kim Jong-il, is threatening nuclear war with the United States or South Korea or both. Transferring power apparently leads to dictatorships, the Bush example be damned.

Powers could have used a club and simply stated, "Democrats who support Brendan Johnson are dangerous elitists who actively seek to nuke America's traditional values." Instead he used the scalpel of allusion, connotation, and implications. It's propaganda done well indeed.

Saturday, July 7, 2012

Old People Shouldn't Try To Talk About Young People

Daniel Larison takes Michael Walsh to task for a rather ludicrous comment:
Michael Walsh describes Paul Ryan in a very strange way:
The first is that he speaks in the cadences of a younger America; he’s like a Quentin Tarantino character come to life, minus the profanity.
I confess that I don’t really know what this means. I am several years younger than Ryan, and there’s nothing in his “cadences” that I recognize as being all that similar to the way that I and other people in my generation speak. Which character would Ryan be? Mr. Orange? If he isn’t using profanity, I don’t think he can be a Tarantino character.
Walsh, who was born in 1949, apparently hasn't spoken to a young person in the wild for a long time.  Few are "without profanity."  Many are creatively profane.  Name dropping Quentin Tarantino doesn't provide hipness by association either.  There's a large swath of eighteen-year-olds who can't name a single Tarantino film.

Granted, the young do have a noticeable cadence.  Watch a segment of MSNBC's Up with Chris Hayes and a round table segment of ABC's This Week.  Economics professor Karl Smith, a regular on the former, speaks about economics differently than Paul Krugman, a regular on the latter.  (As a side note, it's unclear whether Chris Hayes and George Will speak the the same language.)

That being said, Ryan does have a distinctive cadence; it's reminiscent of the class nerd who speaks too quickly because he's afraid of being cut off before he reveals all of the amazing statistics he's discovered.  He's unlikely to attract the ironic hipster demographic to the fold.

Walsh seems to be the sort who would suggest "organizing this new thing I've heard about-a flash mob-to get young conservatives to the polls" while being blithely unaware that flash mobs have become passe.

Finally, predicting what will attract young voters should be an exercise is Socratic humility: admit that one knows nothing.  Only fools attempt to predict with certainty whether a song, a spokesperson, or a cadence. will attract the youth vote.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Plains Pops: Pleonasms Edition


Mental Floss lists 9 common phrases that are longer than they need to be.  Two strike close to home.  The first will change NFL broadcasters vocabulary forever: "frozen tundra" is redundant.
3. Frozen tundra. “Tundra” comes from the Russian word for Arctic steppes, and tundra is generally characterized by permafrost, frozen subsoil. Technically, there is non-frozen Alpine tundra, so-called from lack of vegetation, not temperature. Still, the vast majority of tundra is frozen. So, whether you’re talking about northern Siberia or poking fun at North Dakotan winters, this phrase is generally redundant.
The second truly breaks my heart; I take great joy telling students that the quiz will cause "weeping and wailing and gnashing of teeth."  Alas,
4. Gnashing of teeth. This one is a symbol of frustration and suffering. But “to gnash” already means “to grind one’s teeth” and has meant that since the fifteenth century. If the only thing you can gnash is teeth, this little turn of phrase is pitch-perfect pleonasm.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Some Minor Musings About Language Use

Language evolves; that fact is not news.  This Gary Gutting post in the New York Times "The Stone" provides a good reminder.
Debates about linguistic norms typically set traditionalists against revisionists. The two sides are particularly entrenched because each is rooted in a fundamental truth: the traditionalists are right that the rules are the rules (for instance, pronouns do need to agree in number with their referents), and the revisionists are right that language does change over time (nouns can come to be used as verbs).
Gutting's conclusion, however, goes far beyond the obvious.

The pure traditionalist and pure revisionist positions are both oblivious to what is at stake in arguments over language. The traditionalists claim they are just asking us to play by the rules of the game; revisionists say they are just asking us to accept the fact that language is always changing. But both sides ignore the profound consequences of how we speak.

Language usage is and should be a battleground. Our task is to make the conflict fruitful. To do this, we need to understand what precisely is at issue in any particular dispute. Does a new locution advance or retard our power to express our ideas effectively? Is the issue primarily one of different aesthetic sensibilities? Or is our argument over language rooted in deeper disagreements over who we are and how we should live? Once we understand what is really at stake, we may be able to learn much through arguing about language.
I tend to believe that language arguments are the "deeper disagreements," and that STEM can never adequately deal with the questions about "who we are" and "how we should live."

The cynic in me frequently wonders if Governor Daugaard's or Arne Duncan's emphasis on STEM isn't a concerted effort to distract people from contemplating deeper questions.

Friday, May 27, 2011

Metaphors

Nearly everyone acknowledges that language is powerful.  We may underestimate its power however.  A post at Psychology Today illustrates the effects of metaphors on people's perceptions
. . . . First, the researchers asked 482 students to read one of two reports about crime in the City of Addison. Later, they had to suggest solutions for the problem. In the first report, crime was described as a "wild beast preying on the city" and "lurking in neighborhoods".

After reading these words, 75% of the students put forward solutions that involved enforcement or punishment, such as building more jails or even calling in the military for help. Only 25% suggested social reforms such as fixing the economy, improving education or providing better health care. The second report was exactly the same, except it described crime as a "virus infecting the city" and "plaguing" communities. After reading this version, only 56% opted for great law enforcement, while 44% suggested social reforms.
The most frightening part of the study is that no one seems respondent's didn't know they were being manipulated.
Interestingly, very few of the participants realized how affected they were by the differing crime metaphors. When Thibodeau and Boroditsky asked the participants to identify which parts of the text had most influenced their decisions, the vast majority pointed to the crime statistics, not the language. Only 3%  identified the metaphors as culprits. The researchers confirmed their results with more experiments that used the same reports without the vivid words. Even though they described crime as a beast or virus only once, they found the same trend as before.
Political consultants have intuitively and skillfully used metaphors since Mark Hanna, and English teachers have bored students to tears about metaphors.  Now the government seems to be getting into the act.
A small research arm of the U.S. government's intelligence establishment wants to understand how speakers of Farsi, Russian, English, and Spanish see the world by building software that automatically evaluates their use of metaphors.
 The program is billed as a counter-terrorism effort.
All this to say: The Metaphor Program may represent a nine-figure investment by the government in understanding how people use language. But that's because metaphor studies aren't light or frilly and IARPA isn't afraid of taking on unusual sounding projects if they think they might help intelligence analysts sort through and decode the tremendous amounts of data pouring into their minds.
On the bright side, I get to use this article so show that studying metaphors is "practical."  On the other hand, I have this nagging worry about the government using part of that "nine-figure investment" to create super propaganda.  Orwell's warnings should never be far from one's mind with news like this.

(HT Big Boy Blogger Andrew Sullivan for links to original posts)

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

I Might Be Being Picky.....But ....

The Press & Dakotan published a thoughtful letter from Duane Grimme today.  Mr. Grimme writes,
Dr. Evelyn Hohf, academic dean during my time teaching at Yankton College back in the 1960s, said something like, “It is in our differences wherein greatness lies.” Any such greatness is in defending others’ rights to say something different (defending to the death, as Voltaire once put it).

There have been arguments thoughtfully put for and against the opt-out, positions begging child and adolescent needs and interests and where Yankton schools budgetary limits need be. And so there are “Yes For Kids” and “Citizens For Sustainable Education,” both for kids but differing in the extents this community and its schools can and need go while striving to educate its youth.

Let us hold high the right to disagree, to let our differences be heard, respectfully.
First, it's always good to see allusions to classic thinkers such as Voltarie.  Second, I agree wholeheartedly that differences and disagreements need to be aired and heard respectfully.

In the same letter, Mr. Grimme takes issue with Press and Dakotan's applying the the term "foes" to opt out opponents.  Mr. Grimme limits the definition to "a term defining one or any group who “'hates or seeks to injure another.'"

According to The Free Online Dictionary, "foe" means
1. A personal enemy.
2. An enemy in war.
3. An adversary; an opponent: a foe of tax reform. See Synonyms at enemy.
4. Something that opposes, injures, or impedes: taxes that were the foe of economic development. [emphasis mine]
Lest I be accused of picking an inferior dictionary, the Free Online Dictionary is version of the "The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2009. Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved."

The Merriam Webster Online Dictionary defines "foe" as
1: one who has personal enmity for another
2 a : an enemy in war
  b : adversary, opponent
3: one who opposes on principle --a foe of needless expenditures
4: something prejudicial or injurious [emphasis mine]
I hope that Yankton gets through the next week without prejudice, enmity, or injury.  At the same time the bolded definitions indicate that the P&D was not prejudicial or biased in its word choice.  In fact, the example phrase accompanying the second bolded definition indicates that their word choice was exact.  Opt out opponents claim that the school district has been making many needless expenditures.
Once again, let's have a civil debate, but let's also have an accurate one.  The P&D correctly used the term, and their use of the term does not reflect a bias nor is it a case of the “'pot calling the kettle black.'”

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Social Media Corrupts Everything, . . . .

Even language or phrasing that some with a puritanical bent might find corrupt.


Stolen from Brains on Fire.

Monday, March 28, 2011

Can I Swear In Class Now?

This past week, I jokingly told students that I wanted to teach a summer class in swearing.  My wife believes that I have a MFA level profanity.  I had one text in mind, but On Bullshit is really about lying and truth telling not swearing.  A PDF of the essay that became the book is here.

I was thrilled today when big boy blogger Andrew Sullivan pointed me to this John McWhorter article on swearing in pop music.  McWhorter asserts, "Modern English does have true curse words, however: Currently the main one is the N-word . . . and this is because a genuine taboo does continue to reign in American discourse when it comes to race."  McWhorter supports his proposition by reminding us that the FCC decided that Bono would not be punished for using an F-bomb because "his usage . . .did not refer to 'sexual or excretory organs or activities.' To wit, its meaning has changed despite its etymology, and it is no longer, properly speaking, a 'curse' at all. It is more informal than profane."

What would George Carlin say?  He, after all, made himself famous saying the 7 words one can't say on TV.  More importantly, how can I use a textbook that claims that the class is unnecessary?  McWhorter concludes,
Because change is gradual, the transition of our other “curse” words to informality is not yet a full one. Questions will continue, for example, as to whether children should be exposed to them and at what age. Even here, however, modern twelve-year-olds of many demographics use “curse” words among themselves with a fluency that further deflates any meaningful classification of these words as generally “inappropriate.” The main issue is that in real language, yesterday’s hot stuff is always today’s papier-mache. Hence language change is not only a matter of people giving up prithee and forsooth, but one of The New Yorker printing shit and ordinary people texting WTF 24/7 and dancing at weddings to a song called “Fuck You.” Zounds indeed. 
On a personal note, I always thought that the Chicken Dance at weddings was a bit profane, so McWhorter's prediction doesn't really phase me.

As far as teaching the class, McWhorter's assertion that twelve-year olds can render the content meaningless doesn't worry me either.  Most students think the content of grammar and literature class is meaningless.  The fact that the N-word is the only real curse word does give me pause.  I really can't teach a class on one word word, and I certainly don't want to spend a my whole summer using the N-word.

On second thought, I guess it really doesn't matter; no one is going to be able to offer anything new to the curriculum, not even classes with substantive content instead of fanciful classes about one or seven words.  The bullshit that is Governor Daugaard's budget fucked up that possibility.