Showing posts with label This Week in Opt Outs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label This Week in Opt Outs. Show all posts

Saturday, May 14, 2011

We Are Yankton: Reason #1 That Paul Dorr Is The Issue

The cheer that sticks in my high school memories is "We are the Tigers, the mighty, mighty Tigers . . . "  It was a clear declaration of school pride and support for the athletes on the field or court.  I've lived in Yankton for nearly two decades, but the cheer from this community that sticks with me is far different.   "We are Yankton" clearly declares community pride as a key element of school pride.  The full throated support for local competitors combines both school and community.

"We are Yankton" concisely describes the town's spirit.  Residents have argued about building the Yankton High School and Summit Activities Center.  People became passionate about how to best deal with the Memorial Park Pool, and bickered about how to use the Meridian Bridge.  Those disputes vanished when the Bucks won championships at the Dome.  They became insignificant when we united to mourn the fallen members of Charlie Battery.  Last spring, we united again to line the streets and cheer in the gym as Charlie Battery returned home.  The town has supported congregations that have had their sanctuaries burned down, and put thousands of dollars into collection jars placed a checkouts for cancer victims or families that have lost their homes.

Residents recovered from every disagreement and tragedy, in part, because of an unifying belief:: "We are Yankton."

Paul Dorr had a history of dividing communities.  In Lyle, Minnesota, 
Yet more than a month after the bond went through, the members of Save Our School and Community are hardly calling it a victory. On one of the hottest days of the year, Ron Frank is occupied with outdoor work, spraying fields and pitching in to help his customers where he can. Some of these farmers were "no" voters, and he suspects that his outspokenness on this issue has lost him some business. He agrees to meet outside of a small white church on a hilltop. It's one of the only buildings visible on a stretch of county road that's mostly decorated with manicured mazes of crops.

"Families were divided, friendships were ruined," he says, looking out over the fields. "It's no different than the Hormel strike. It's going to take time to get over."
In Blooming Prairie, Minnesota,
Anita Angell has experienced the same lingering friction with her neighbors. The pro-bond committee members have come out with statements that, Angell says, question a "no" voter's intelligence. And there have been personal attacks on Angell and others. She says she has received threatening phone calls, but declines to offer any specifics.

"I know for a fact businesses have been affected by this. There are things that happened," she says, her voice trailing off. "And I don't think I'll go to those businesses again. What's going to happen to downtown? I think this turned into somewhat of a tragedy."
After the Yankton School Board passed the opt out resolution, the community held a city and school board election.  In that school board election, three candidates supported the opt out; one opposed.  That election featured passionate but civil debate.  Then as now, opt out opponents argued that the school board has asked for too much over too long of a period.  At the conclusion of that election, people moved on with little ill will.

The upcoming election feels different because of Mr. Dorr's involvement.  If this opt out fails, Yankton will likely face several more divisive elections.  Now that opt out opponents have engaged Dorr's services, I'm relatively certain that all future board opt out resolutions will be put to a vote.    I also believe that opponents will continue to use Mr. Dorr's services, and the damage his involvement has caused in other communities will be repeated and multiplied here.

"We are Yankton" needs to be a yell.  Dorr's record indicates that his involvement in this election will turn that clarion call for unity into a mere whisper, "We were Yankton."

Friday, May 13, 2011

Opt Out Opponents Won't Answer Questions

Blogger has been down, so some posts and comments have disappeared, and this post may show up twice.  Because it’s been sent by email twice, the format may be a little off.

Shane Gerlach posted my questions from this post on this Press and Dakotan comment thread. I understand why there’s no comments here; Blogger has been less than cooperative.  However, even in that forum, opt out opponents (OOOs), refused to give any numbers in this response:

charlie wrote on May 12, 2011 3:00 PM:
" The school board is a government entity.
As such, they typically will not cut their budget voluntarily. Once a new position, schedule, service, sport, etc. is established (should have included taxes) it will remain forever. It is so much easier to request more money than it is to fine tune the budget. The school board has opted out. That is not a request for money, that is a statement that they are taking more money.
Taxpayers were not included in their decision making, but we will be now.
How much is too much and how long is too long?
My answer is to have the board ( who I heard is making plans for another less invasive opt out) show the taxpayers last years expenses compared to next years. Sell the taxpayers on a program that couples budget cuts with opt-out dollars, whatever that figure may be.
Length of each opt out should be no longer than one year at a time. It is a simple majority vote to make this happen.
Taxpayers can assess their opt out figures and do nothing or refer again if they consider it excessive.
In the words of one of our greater Presidents "Trust but Verify". "
Let's parse this response a bit. First, the anti-government rhetoric is straight from the starve the beast playbook. In short, starve the beast is an effort to destroy any government entity by refusing to fund it. Next, there's the salute to Ronald Reagan's repeated Russian proverb "Trust but Verify." I don't know who Charlie is, but I'm betting that Charlie and I both remember that Reagan used this phrasing when negotiating with the Soviets. In short, Charlie seems to be implying that public schools are linked to Soviet dictatorships. That tactic seems to come straight from the Paul Dorr playbook.

Most importantly, there are no numbers.  Sometimes what's not said is as important as what is said.  The stubborn refusal to even consider supplying numbers indicates that no amount will satisfy OOOs.  Every piece of information Charlie requests is available here and OOOs know it.

Let's review.  An OOO spokesperson uses starve the beast language and implies that Yankton School District is a relic of the Soviet Union.  Charlie also refuses to give any number that would be acceptable for an opt out.  Finally, OOOs hire Paul Dorr who has repeatedly stated he wants to insure the demise of public education.

There's another old saying that's as important as "trust but verify"; "Once is an accident . Twice is a trend. Three times is a problem."  OOOs have a problem:  their tactics, words or lack of words, and hired consultant all seem to indicate that their ultimate goal is to destroy Yankton's public schools.

Update #1:  This comment has been made on the thread accompanying "Opt-out Foes Hire Consultant."
charlie wrote on May 13, 2011 7:06 AM:
" I agree a mess is coming. As one opposed to the opt-out I am also opposed to bringing in outside consultants. Our community can fight it's own battles.
However, one must keep in mind that it was not CFSE or Dorr or taxpayers that threw the first punch. Our school superintendant and school board voted to shackle our homeowners, businesses, and farmers with a 41 million dollar ball and chain that they admit they may not need. Also, the board cannot possibly foresee 10 years down the road what income and expenses they will have. 
Had the board solicited taxpayer input prior to demanding this obscene amount of money for an obscene amount of time we would not be in this position.
We don't need Paul Dorr, but we also don't need a school board that frightens the taxpayers so much that they would hire him. "
Although I strongly disagree with Charlie's statement that the school board has said they won't need the money or that they "threw the first punch," I appreciate Charlie's response to Mr. Dorr's arrival.  It takes more courage to stand up to those in your own circle than it does to take on your opponents.

A hearty debate helps communities grow.  Mr. Dorr does not promote healthy debate; he will leave a divided, angry community in his wake.  He will also leave a weakened school system.   That divided community and weakened system make it unlikely that an opt out effort that meets Charlie's criteria will ever come about.  Mr. Dorr's arrival will permanently change Yankton's social and political landscape.  If this opt out fails, proposals for one year opt outs for minuscule amounts will be challenged, and Yankton will the see the current cracks in its social structure become chasms.

Update # 2:  This comments thread still has no answers to the questions posed here.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

What's Behind Dorr Number 3?: A This Week In Opt Outs Special Comment

Door Number 1:  Yesterday I wrote about Tea Party people who want eliminate public education.   

Door Number 2:  The Madville Times discussed South Dakota Republican Party's decision to hire an out of state person as the party's executive director.

Dorr Number 3:  Yankton residents who oppose the school district's effort to opt out may have combined the mysteries behind both doors number one and number two.  There's a rumor that those urging a no vote on the Yankton School District opt out may have created Dorr number three by availing themselves of the services of Paul Dorr, "an activist and home-school parent from Ocheyedan, [who] sells his services to taxpayers who want to derail school bond issues."  Dorr proudly proclaims that he fights bond issues such as the opt out "for a profit."  In 2007, "[Dorr] said he's opposed 54 ballot questions, defeated 46, and that one remains tied up in court."

In addition to being a proud capitalist with a winning record, Dorr seeks to eliminate public education. He believes,
The statist bureaucrats in education (affectionately known as educrats) are and have been self-consciously on a mission to destroy liberty in this nation, by destroying the founding Christian faith that made it possible and replacing it with their humanist group think "New Jerusalem." It has been an offensive action for them from the beginning. They’ve masked their freedom-destroying, anti-intellectual efforts for decades under the ruse of educational "neutrality." Well, the neutrality myth is about over.

These "freedom-destroying, anti-intellectual efforts" have lead Dorr to "'offend' [public schools] in any way that we can to hasten the day of their demise and the restoration of new schools formed and guided by the voluntary association of like-minded parents, grandparents, etc. and paid for with their own money." 

He later writes, "In the struggle for true liberty and in opposition to tyranny, we need to become more offensive minded and show that we have a superior educational program to replace the rapidly failing government system. And we need to do everything else we can to speed it on towards its certain demise." 

There's no doubt Dorr has some extreme views about public education and seeks to eliminate the universal public education mandated by the South Dakota Constitution.  If the opt out opponents have decided to use Dorr's services, they are working with someone who has stated goals that they have said that they don't share.  For example, Charlii Gilson has said that she opposes the opt out "not because she is against funding public education, but rather because she felt the public had a right to vote on the issue."  In her letter to the P&D, Gilson writes, "Let’s get creative and save the most important part: the classroom!"  Neither statement sounds as if she shares Dorr's stated goal to eliminate public education.

Leroy Bring was quoted as saying, "The petition isn’t about voting one way or another, it is about having a say. If we can get a vote, a lot of light will shine in on what is going on and that is a good thing. If they have a great story to tell, they have nothing to fear. But there are a lot of questions that need to be answered.”  Again, this statements doesn't sound as if opt out opponents see eliminating public education is a primary goal.

If they don't want to eliminate public schools, why would they want to use Dorr's services?  Isn't there some other anti-tax crusdader who doesn't support the elimination of public schools?  

People who have opposed Dorr in other campaigns have uncovered details that make the choice to use Dorr's services, if that is indeed happening, even more confusing.  In Lyle, Minnesota, 
They'd come across more colorful details about him, too. They had heard rumors about him selling Y2K goods. They'd heard that he once accused an Iowa judge of promoting bestiality because she was part owner of a Budweiser distributorship in northwest Iowa. His evidence was an ad featuring a talking chimp who flirts with a woman. (It ended up that it wasn't the judge, but her sister-in-law of the same name who owned the distributorship). All of these stories about Dorr turned out to be true.
Further, "a report posted on the Minnesota Association of School Administrators' website alleges that Dorr "skews" enrollment and test-score information, "distorts numbers and information," and that "his literature is less than truthful." It also acknowledges that he has "a very good legal sense" and "uses the law to get the information that he desires." 

In addition to acting as a bond issue gun for hire, in some cases getting up to $15,000 for a two to six week campaign, and using questionable methods, Dorr also seeks to destroy public schools "to advance the kingdom of Christ." 

When Christ sent out his disciples, he told them not to have "gold, nor silver, nor brass in your purses, Nor scrip for your journey, neither two coats, neither shoes, nor yet staves: for the workman is worthy of his meat."  Further, they were enjoined, "be ye therefore wise as serpents, and harmless as doves."  Dorr seems to be concerned about the gold in his purse.  Given the summary of his tactics, he also seems to be more like the serpent in the garden rather than a person possessed of the Spirit that descended upon Jesus in the form of a dove.

Some who oppose the opt out claim that those who live outside of Yankton  have submitted "a painless letter [to the editor] . . .since the writer won't have to pony up the dollars on this tax crippling opt-out"  The point seems to be that those inside the school district, not those who have moved away should make the decision about the opt out.  If that sentiment holds true for those who have lived in Yankton and moved, it should also apply to an outside agitator for hire.

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

This Week in Opt Outs--Special Update

People opposed to the opt out will meet at JoDean's at 7 pm tonight.  Because the meeting "is for opponents of the opt out only and is not open to the public," no one can confirm whether those attending will adopt a resolution to put the school district on double secret probation.

Ironically, this meeting occurs on the same day that the Yankton P&D began a series designed to "sort  out the opt out."  The editorial accurately points out "a lot of information, supposition and misinformation is making the rounds, mostly by word of mouth."  Having a meeting that is closed to the public seems designed to continue the spread of misinformation rather than engage in a dialogue for the truth.  I hope that the meeting goes beyond "I really hate those guys," but I'm afraid that an echo chamber will probably only produce fodder for a "food fight."

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Still More This Week in Opt Outs

This week saw twelve letters to the editor of the Yankton Press & Dakotan.  Seven support the opt out while five oppose. The Yankton County Observer published one letter opposing the opt out.  In addition, the YSD School Board held a forum.

On Monday, Dale and Sherry Oare opine ". . remember we can vote on the opt-out, and we can’t vote on any of these other budget busters. The kids will still get a quality education and most of the teachers that were laid off will be called back regardless of how this vote turns out. I believe that anyone who tells you otherwise is just flat out wrong."  I gave a brief rebuttal here. I will also note that the Oares do not cite any sources that back up their assertion.

In the same edition, Mike Gillis sees the situation differently.  He writes, "If the opt-out fails, the Yankton school board will be forced to make barbaric cuts deeper than already passed."  Gillis, like Robin and Jon Flom, urges a pay it forward approach.  The Floms write,
We pay it forward. We believe that is what members of a community do. We are not willing to passively accept the cutbacks already outlined in the newspaper, not to mention those still to come. When the time comes to vote on the opt-out, we will have yet another chance to repay a little of the debt that we owe. We will vote YES. 
One must note that the Tuesday school board forum lends credence to Gillis's and the Flom's assertions that more cuts will occur without the opt out.   Page 22 of the handout distributed at the forum shows that the equivalent of 12 full time positions will not be filled this year even if the opt out passes

On Tuesday, Larry and LaDawn Remington claim that "the school board “decisions” that cost us an arm and a leg in higher taxes."  Other parts of their letter have been discussed here.  Also, on Tuesday, the Yankton School Board held a forum attended by 500 citizens.  At the forum, board member Chris Specht reminded attendees that property taxes are lower now then they were were in the early 1990s.

On Wednesday, Leon and Arlene Heine assert that the school has become a "nanny state" that will "overtax parents to where they can’t feed their kids equals the school will send supper along with homework every night."  Several online commenters to their letter explain some facts about the meals that the school sends home.

Also on Wednesday, Carll Kretsinger publishes "research" that shows "something . . . a bit wrong" with the fact that 12 of the teachers laid off were paid with federal funds.  Kretsinger also claims "all teachers and staff over age 52, when they retire they get a bonus of 75 percent of their annual salary."  The latter bit of research is both unsourced and factually wrong.  Kretsinger does not explain why federal funding "smells" wrong or whether it is guaranteed to be renewed.  Wednesday also saw recent graduate Katy Adam share some fond remembrances of her YSD education.

On Thursday, John Trombly tries to apply the theory of "creative destruction" to the the school district's funding problem by asserting "make the tough cuts now or choose to increase your taxes to perpetuate the problem and likely end up with cuts regardless."  Because schools can't charge for the education that they provide, it seems unlikely that Joseph Schumpeter's theory applies to education.  If you don't trust the Madville Times's reading of South Dakota law, see page 16 of the school board forum handout.

Also on Thursday, Dr. John Sternquist writes,
I am a retired physician who over the years has been intimately involved in the recruitment of physicians to our community. I have been proud to tout the advantages to these young people of our great school system. I even recall a Redbook magazine article listing Yankton as one of the 100 best school systems in America, giving me additional ammunition. We have been able to develop and sustain a tremendous medical community by enticing well-trained young men and women with the promise of a great place to raise their families. The mainstay of that promise is an educational system of which we are proud. Degrading that system by these extreme measures will make recruitment of young business and professional people more difficult. 
On Friday, The Yankton County Observer printed a letter from Ruth Ann Dickman who claims that she knows how "important education is" because she has a daughter who "became a teacher."  Dickman takes issue with the recently built bus barn and administration building.  She doesn't indicate how those buildings which were funded from the capital outlay fund apply to the opt out which will provide funds for the general fund.  She also doesn't source how the opt out will "turn Yankton into a town without many business places."  She also doesn't recite any anecdotal evidence, something that Sternquist and Paige Elwood do.

In Friday's P&D, Dr. Paige Elwood echoes Sternquist's claims.  Duane Grimme offers some numbers that show the school board position in a favorable light, although I wish he had provided more context for the his research.  Finally, former candidate for the YSD School Board Matt Pietz writes to support the opt out "because I want my children, current students, and future students to have the same, if not better, opportunities to succeed as those before them. In order to maintain our schools and the ability to offer a high quality education that the Yankton community is accustom[ed] to, the opt-out is necessary."

Sunday, April 10, 2011

More This Week in Opt Outs

The Press and Dakotan covers the impacts so far:  22 teachers and 39 coaching and activities positions.  Those totals do not include retirees whose positions won't be filled or resignations whose positions will also remain unfilled.  The P&D also reports “The unfortunate aspect of this is this is just the first round of cuts,” [YSD Superintendent Joe] Gertsema said. “By law we had to notify the teachers by April 15, we are still looking at additional cuts to the non-certified staff as well as programs in the district.”

The P&D also covers some YMS students' response to the dismissal of their teachers and the cutting of their activities.

On Tuesday, the P&D reported that those who petitioned to have the opt out come to a vote believe that the public has not been given enough information.  Charlii Gilson is quoted as saying
“So many of the people coming in to my office to sign the petition are saying they just feel as though the school district has not given them enough information,” she said. “They want to know what cuts have been made, what the district has done to save money, why the opt-out needs to be for as much at it is. The are saying that there has not been enough public discussion on the issues, and by sending the opt-out to a vote, it gives them the opportunity to get that information.
On Wednesday, a P&D editorial illustrated that six public board meetings since May 2010 had discussed the opt out.  Further,
Shortly after the opt-out was announced last month, the Press & Dakotan did a rather extensive breakdown in its March 18 edition detailing what the opt-out would mean to residential, commercial and agricultural properties. (It can be found online at http://yankton.net/articles/2011/03/18/community/doc4d82d1923ac14597395120.txt)

(Along the way, we’ve also explored what the state budget cuts would mean to the school district and, consequently, to the students who are being educated there, not to mention the personnel who work for the district.)
The editorial concludes that "ultimately, it may be up to the residents of this school district to decide just how much a quality education is worth, and whether it’s worth maintaining."

The other reason cited for bring the opt out to a vote was that a matter this momentous needed to be approved by a public vote.
". . . Bud Merkwan and Leroy Bring also turned in signatures that they had collected by late Monday afternoon.

“This was never about whether the opt-out was good or bad, it was about giving the people their voice,” Bring said. “I think it is only right to vote. The right thing is to let the people have a voice. ... The petition isn’t about voting one way or another, it is about having a say. If we can get a vote, a lot of light will shine in on what is going on and that is a good thing. If they have a great story to tell, they have nothing to fear. But there are a lot of questions that need to be answered.”
The P&D, The Yankton County Observer, Superintendent Gertsema, and those who turned in petitions all fail mention previous incidents when 1100 local citizens have petitioned to bring to a vote a policy that they support.  I hope that someone will provide this information at Monday's YSD School Board meeting.

YSD Superintendent Gertsema,  however, did respond to the challenge to tell a good story.  Gertsema claims, “We have a very good story to tell and we are going to make sure that the public hears it and understands it. We are hopeful that after they see all the facts, that by election time, the voters will agree with the school board.”

Saturday, April 2, 2011

More This Week in Opt Outs

The Yankton Press & Dakotan published profiles of the four candidates for YSD school board.  Rick Altoff opposes the opt out.  Tim Kenney, Matt Pietz, and Jay Williams support it.  Writing in the Yankton County Observer, Dave Baumeister contends [p]eople who vote for a candidate only because of his position on the opt-out are doing themselves and the Yankton district a great disservice."  The editorial is hidden behind a subscriber pay wall.

According to The Observer's front page coverage of the petition drive, 110 signatures had been turned in by March 30.  Local realtor Charlii Gilson had 146 more signatures but she had been calling people to make arrangements to witness the signature because "the personal witnessing' part of the signing process got by her...."  Gilson hoped to have 250 signatures turned in by the end of the week.

The papers take turns covering the school board candidate forums.  The student newspaper The Woksape, which is printed by the Press & Dakotan, had a story with interviews of Superintendent Joe Gertsema and business manager Jason Bietz.

Finally, a Duane Grimme letter to the editor says that he "favor[s] a public vote on the opt-out, for the implications there are serious for all. But spare me the pizza ploys, child posters, either/or simplicity (divvy up or live with mediocrity), and tsunami references."  Wayne Wurth took out ads to urge people to sign the petitions to bring the opt out to a vote.  The signings could take place at JoDean's Restaurant or the Subway parking lot.