Wednesday, February 13, 2013

A Minor Musing About Moderate Principles

Over at DWC, Troy Jones and SDJammer engaged in brief civil colloquy over whether one can have moderate principles.

In South Dakota, I'm apparently a liberal. In Europe, I'd probably be a reactionary. That irony allows me to think I can offer a few principles that might fit.
1. Extremism is a vice. That fact holds true for both Michele Bachman and Shelia Jackson Lee.

2. Intellectual underpinnings matter. Prefer Hayek to Hannity or Stiglitz to Schultz. (That's Sean Hannity of Fox and Ed Schultz of MSNBC for those of you who were wondering.)

3. Read the whole book. The Wealth of Nations praises capitalism. It also condemns joint stock companies, the corporations of Adam Smith's day. Both the praise and the warning should be given equal prominence if one uses Smith to justify or create policy.

4. People haven't changed. The same sort of people who became robber barons and abused their workers in late 19th and early 20th century still climb the corporate ladder. The same sort of folks who wanted to control the unions in order to line their pockets try to climb the union hierarchy. The laws necessary to stop both types of exploitation are still necessary.

5. People need to chill. There's no reason to spend the money to put the 10 Commandments in every classroom.  Likewise, if the county spent $2,000 for a fancy creche in 1946, no one is harmed if county officials put it up on the corner of the courthouse square.

6. The nation can have a strong defense but does not have to be the world's policeman. Further, the US should not engage in national building.

7. When in doubt prefer competence and qualifications to catchy slogans. In short, a Jon Huntsman is always a better choice than Herman Cain.

8. Avoid the jerks. Further, the jerk who says things that one agrees with is still a jerk. There's no difference between Rush Limbaugh, Ann Coulter, and Bill Maher. Bombast and smarminess are unseemly from both sides of the spectrum.

9. Both parties have valid ideas; neither has a monopoly on the truth, the spokespeople for both parties notwithstanding.

10 All 10 Amendments in the Bill of Rights matter. Conservatives love 2 and 10. Liberals love 9. That doesn't mean the rest aren't important.

Monday, February 11, 2013

Tweets Of The Day: Barbarism Edition

Tweets of the day:

Sunday, February 10, 2013

A Minor Musing About Fear And Normativity

Over at The Madville Times, PNR offers the following bit of wisdom: It's always easy to say my fears are realistic and yours aren't."

He's speaking about South Dakota's proposed school pistolier bill and other gun laws. Although I am positive that some bean counter buried deep within the catacombs of some insurance company can provide a statistical certainty that additional guns in school increase the risk of innocents being killed, PNR rightfully asserts likelihood of a school shooter or a sanctioned pistolier in South Dakota killing someone are relatively small.

If one goes a level deeper, the real fear is that cherished norms may soon be violated. Professor Terry Eagleton in After Theory presents one of my favorite analyses of normativity:
It is a mistake, however, to believe that norms are always restrictive.  In fact it is a crass Romantic delusion.  It is normative in our kind of society that people do not throw themselves with a hoarse cry on total strangers and amputate their legs.  It is conventional that child murderers are punished, that working men and women may withdraw their labour, and that ambulances speeding to a traffic accident should not be impeded just for the hell of it.  Anyone who fells oppressed by all this must be seriously oversensitive.  Only an intellectual who has overdosed on abstraction could be dim enough to imagine that whatever bends a norm is potentially radical.Eagleton, AfterTheory 15
A similar norm would be that first graders are not to be shot in cold blood. I had always believed that norm provided the reason that guns stayed out of a school building. For as long as I can remember, those who wanted to hunt after school locked their guns in their vehicle before coming inside.

Further, I had always thought it a norm that the freedoms enshrined in the Bill of Rights had a few limits. One cannot shout fire in a crowded theater if there's no fire. The longer the school pistolier bill discussion goes on the more I'm beginning to believe that the bill's supporters don't see any limits to the second amendment except the size of one's wallet. In short, the only thing preventing one from owning a predator drone is the damned drone is expensive.

Perhaps I've lived in my own personal echo chamber. I don't recall ever having a discussion with anyone about the priorities within the Bill of Rights, but threats to Amendments 1, 9, 4, 5, 6, and 8 worry me far more that real or perceived threats to Amendment 2. (For the record, I have never seriously thought about Amendment 3 and probably couldn't state its subject if I hadn't just looked it up. For the curious but lazy, it forbids housing soldiers in citizens' home without the citizen's consent.) I have also always believed that one should not sacrifice one of the enshrined freedoms to preserve another

I'm guessing here, but it seems that my concern that putting guns in school irrevocably removes an essential norm may be similar to the concerns that opponents of gay marriage or opponents or legalizing marijuana or opponents of a fence across border the express: sanctioning gay marriage, legalizing marijuana, or building that fence somehow irrevocably violates a norm. Hence, the heat generated behind each issue.

Perhaps the discussion needs to move beyond guns, gay marriage, marijuana legalization or whatever the hot button issue is; instead, the discussion should begin by asking what norms should govern our living together.

Quotation Of The Day: Everything That's Wrong With American Politics In Two Paragraphs Edition

From this Ron Unz column:
Similarly, over the last couple of decades, the economic well-being of America’s working- or middle-classes seems to have been relegated to an afterthought, not merely among Republicans and conservatives, but also among their Democratic and liberal opponents as well. The shocking truth that the average American family is probably poorer today in real terms than they were fifty years ago has been almost entirely ignored by both parties, and therefore ignored by the media as well, presumably under the theory that what people don’t know won’t really hurt them.
Meanwhile, the loud battles over Gay Marriage and Gun Control, whose outcome would directly impact an utterly negligible fraction of our total population, generates front-page headline after front-page headline, perhaps because these issues excite the people who write those headlines or those who fund our campaigns. As a leading Democratic political consultant in California once joked to me during the late 1990s, no wealthy liberals he knew had any interest in funding a minimum wage increase or any similar meat-and-potato economic issue of the traditional Left; instead, the ideal initiative for fundraising purposes would promise to “Save the Gay Whales from Second-Hand Smoke.”


Friday, February 8, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Political Parties Edition

From this James Poulous piece:
But the real problem is thinking that an organization as dull and profane as a political party can have a soul at all. Parties are just collections of people, some of whom unfortunately let politics become an excuse to set aside their own soul, spirit, integrity, authenticity—whatever you want to call it.
Politics tends to paint us into a corner, a narrow space where we worry endlessly about what we know. “Change” tends to be limited to a supremely limited number of policy goals, usually targeted towards one interest group or another.

At Least South Dakota Is Not Idaho

I will thank the South Dakota Legislature for not proposing anything this inane:

John Goedde, chairman of the Idaho Senate’s Education Committee, introduced legislation Tuesday to require every Idaho high school student to read Ayn Rand’s “Atlas Shrugged” and pass a test on it to graduate from high school.
Goedde likes the book because it made his son a Republican. He also doesn't intend to push the legislation. Instead he is using the bill to threaten to those who have opposed other education initiatives that he has proposed. One could praise Goedde for living the values that Rand preaches, but that would also praise a foolish consistency.

Lest some South Dakota legislator begins to fear that Republicans are a minority or somehow thinks Rand's lengthy paean to selfishness a necessary read, The Daily Beast provides a reminder of review of Rand's magnum opus that I heartily endorse:
Writing in the pages of William F. Buckley’s National Review, Whittaker Chambers, a former communist turned vigorous anti-communist, offered what would become the most famous criticism of novelist Ayn Rand: “From almost any page of Atlas Shrugged, a voice can be heard, from painful necessity, commanding: ‘To a gas chamber—go!’”

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Obama's Kill List Memo Edition

From this James Joyner piece:
Even so, American citizens should nonetheless be wary of granting the president the power to single out citizens for killing based simply on his own judgment. Aside from being plainly unconstitutional, it's simply too much trust to place in a single individual. At the very least, the rules ought to be spelled out in legislation that has passed both Houses of Congress and survived judicial scrutiny for constitutionality rather than made internally.
Further, in addition to checks and balances, there has to be more transparency. The notion that the government can compile a list of citizens for killing, not tell anyone who's on it or how they got there, is simply un–American. Surely, a modern version of a WANTED: DEAD OR ALIVE notice could be publicly circulated, with a listing of the particulars. Maybe the named individual would turn himself in rather than wait for the drones to find him. Or maybe he'd hire an attorney to present evidence he's not actually an imminent threat to American citizens.
For centuries, civilized societies have understood that even wars must be fought according to rules, which have developed over time in response to changing realities. Rules are even more important in endless, murky wars such as the fight against Islamist terror groups. Currently, we're letting whomever is in the Oval Office pick and choose from among the existing rules, applying and redefining them based on hisown judgment and that of his advisors. We can do better. [emphais mine]
The bolded portions sum up my positions better than I could have written them.