Showing posts with label Ayn Rand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ayn Rand. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Sean Hannity And Glenn Beck To Appear In Anti-Christian Film Edition

This Elizabeth Stoker article does an excellent job of illustrating Ayn Rand's hatred of Christianity and asks why those who believe there's a war on Christians would participate in a film based on Rand's Atlas Shrugged:
Contrary to Randian logic, a third and final installment is due in September, and to drum up viewership, producers have indulged in a bit of novelty casting. Ron Paul will be metastasizing from the small screen to the silver screen in his acting debut in the upcoming film, and will be joined on screen by Glenn Beck and Sean Hannity, evidently in an effort to draw out the audiences each of them already commands. For the film itself, it's an embarrassing move, underscoring the painful degree to which Atlas isn't quite able to interest viewers on its own merits; for Hannity, Beck, and Paul, however, it begs a more profound moral question.
One can imagine the collective shriek of indignation that would come from right-wing pundits like Hannity if a left-wing politician and pundits summarily elected to appear in a film with a dubious moral message. If Joe Biden and Rachel Maddow were to announce joint appearances in a stylish remake of Caligula, for instance, the outrage would likely be intense and instantaneous. So why the sanguine agreement on the part of three outspokenly Christian political players to appear in a film so deeply and totally antithetical to Christian ethics?

Stoker concludes:
But Buckley, like Chambers, didn't capitulate to Rand and her philosophy; they understood correctly that there is no room for Objectivism in a coherent, genuine Christianity. While Rand's ideal human is self-interested and self-sufficient, the Christian person is devoted to serving others and is always in need: of God, forgiveness, grace, mercy, and the love of Christ. The ideal Randian person, on the other hand, is entirely capable of managing and perfecting his own satisfaction, a far cry from the Christian understanding of a person as perfectable, but not through his own means.
Of course, that aspect of Christianity is a problem for those who prefer to think of themselves as John Galt-esque supermen. Indeed, the disturbing trend of trying to force Christianity to accommodate Rand's antithetical philosophy is likely a result of her seductive appeal to the very egoism Christianity warns against. It's a shame conservatives like Paul, Beck, and Hannity have lost the courage of conviction that motivated Buckley and Chambers (among others) to call a spade a spade when it came to Rand; the resulting 'philosophy,' if it can be called that, amounts to a vitiated version of Objectivism as well as a pathetic Christian testimony. That Paul, Beck, and Hannity intend to peddle this mess to their broad audiences bodes poorly for a right wing that once knew better.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Of Losers And Self-Righteousness Edition

There is a certain breed of gabber, generally white men who have over-indulged in the fiction of Ayn Rand, afflicted by a conception of life as a competitive game in which everything they have marks them as “winners,” morally entitled to sneer at the “losers” who aren’t big, bold, swashbuckling independent creators-of-their-own-universe. Indeed, the founding of the Tea Party Movement is generally attributed to a televised rant about “losers” wanting his money from one such swashbuckler named Rick Santelli, who I am sure emerged from the womb a fully autonomous Titan who has richly earned every dime he’s ever been paid by dint of his own unassisted efforts.
We presumably must just let these people luxuriate in their own puerile sense of superiority; perhaps they will depart en masse to Galt’s Gulch and rid us of their company. But contempt for broad swaths of humankind as “losers” should not be quietly accepted more generally, particularly from those who claim allegiance to the Judeo-Christian ethic in which nothing is more damnable than self-righteousness unless it’s the inability to see the image of God in the faces of others.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Christians Were Always Wrong To Stand With Rand

Let me clarify. They were wrong to ever stand with those who advocate the philosophy of Ayn Rand. Standing with Rand Paul on drones likely indicates a working conscience.

Let's review: Mike Huckabee claims that conservative Christians will leave the Republican party if the party changes its stance on same-sex marriage.
In an exclusive interview with Newsmax TV, former Arkansas Gov. Huckabee — and ordained Southern Baptist minister — was asked if he sees the GOP ever pivoting and backing gay marriage.
“They might. And if they do, they’re going to lose a large part of their base because evangelicals will take a walk,” he responds.
In this instance, Huckabee sounds very much like South Dakota's own Gordon Howie:
The last straw would be the GOP supporting “gay marriage” (note: it’s NOT marriage). Christians would simple [sic] abandon the party and the GOP, which has seen decline in recent years would be destroyed.
Christians have been the first to “stay home” when the GOP ignores them on social issues. While there has been a small percentage who have been activists in the party for social issues, most Christians are inclined to “recline”… that is to say, stay home on the sofa. The party can’t afford to lose Christians. It’s why they have already lost the last two Presidential elections.
I'm politically displaced and an introvert.  I'm not sure I want a whole bunch of new folks walking the political desert with me, but I am no position to cast the first stone when it comes to walking away from political parties. I walked away from both of them years ago.

There is, however, a larger question to ask. What the heck were Christians, politically conservative, liberal, or moderate, doing with the GOP in the first place?

Remember the Idaho Republican legislator who wanted every student in Idaho to read Atlas Shrugged because the book turned his son in to a Republican. I suspect that the situation is not unusual.

Yesterday, Matthew Schmitz at First Things pointed out that Ayn Rand really, really hated C.S. Lewis, one of the great Christian apologists of the 20th Century:
Ayn Rand was no fan of C.S. Lewis. She called the famous apologist an “abysmal bastard,” a “monstrosity,” a “cheap, awful, miserable, touchy, social-meta­physical mediocrity,” a “pickpocket of concepts,” and a “God-damn, beaten mystic.” (I suspect Lewis would have particularly relished the last of these.)
These insults and more can be found in her marginal notes on a copy of Lewis’ Abolition of Man, as printed in Ayn Rand’s Marginalia: Her critical comments on the writings of over 20 authors, edited by Robert Mayhew.
Schmitz's post reproduces many of Lewis's original notes with Rand's marginalia.

Ed Kilgore points out that Ayn Rand would have disliked contemporary Christian conservatives just as she hated Lewis:
As I argued a while back in a long piece in Democracy on Rand and her contemporary influence, her boundless capacity for hatred was as often directed at religious conservatives as at “socialists.” And more than anything else, she most hated syncretism, the casual adoption by “second-handers” of bits and pieces of incompatible philosophical stances, particularly if it involved her own highly systematic thought
The question Huckabee and Howie now need to answer is why did politically conservative Christians ever side with the political party animated in large part by the philosopher who believes them to be mediocre abysmal bastards?

Friday, February 8, 2013

At Least South Dakota Is Not Idaho

I will thank the South Dakota Legislature for not proposing anything this inane:

John Goedde, chairman of the Idaho Senate’s Education Committee, introduced legislation Tuesday to require every Idaho high school student to read Ayn Rand’s “Atlas Shrugged” and pass a test on it to graduate from high school.
Goedde likes the book because it made his son a Republican. He also doesn't intend to push the legislation. Instead he is using the bill to threaten to those who have opposed other education initiatives that he has proposed. One could praise Goedde for living the values that Rand preaches, but that would also praise a foolish consistency.

Lest some South Dakota legislator begins to fear that Republicans are a minority or somehow thinks Rand's lengthy paean to selfishness a necessary read, The Daily Beast provides a reminder of review of Rand's magnum opus that I heartily endorse:
Writing in the pages of William F. Buckley’s National Review, Whittaker Chambers, a former communist turned vigorous anti-communist, offered what would become the most famous criticism of novelist Ayn Rand: “From almost any page of Atlas Shrugged, a voice can be heard, from painful necessity, commanding: ‘To a gas chamber—go!’”

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

What Would Ayn Rand Say About Her Most Public Disciple Now?

Paul Ryan stopped to get a photo op. There's nothing wrong with that. Politicians do it all the time. The problem for Mr. Ryan is two-fold. First, this particular photo op is at a soup kitchen, a charity. Ayn Rand, a person that Ryan claims influenced him greatly, would not be amused. She after all believed that charity was not a moral virtue; in fact, she made it her duty to "fight" that idea:
My views on charity are very simple. I do not consider it a major virtue and, above all, I do not consider it a moral duty. There is nothing wrong in helping other people, if and when they are worthy of the help and you can afford to help them. I regard charity as a marginal issue. What I am fighting is the idea that charity is a moral duty and a primary virtue.
The second problem is the fact that the photo op shows Ryan washing clean pots and pans:
Ryan had stopped by the soup kitchen for about 15 minutes on his way to the airport after his Saturday morning town hall in Youngstown. By the time he arrived, the food had already been served, the patrons had left, and the hall had been cleaned.
Upon entering the soup kitchen, Ryan, his wife and three young children greeted and thanked several volunteers, then donned white aprons and offered to clean some dishes. Photographers snapped photos and TV cameras shot footage of Ryan and his family washing pots and pans that did not appear to be dirty.
On second thought, if no one really benefited from Ryan's actions actions except Ryan, who got the benefit of appearing to care for 15 minutes even when he didn't, Rand might be very proud of her disciple. After all she believed that charity is only a "marginal issue." Apparently, charity is only political for Ryan as well.

Sunday, September 30, 2012

Job Creator Idolatry

Nick Hanauer, an American venture capitalist, puts the lie to many Romney/Ryan/Rand talking points. The best line of many great lines: "It's a small jump from job creator to the Creator"



HT: This David Frum post

 

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Quotations Of The Day: Why Rand Continues To Matter Edition

Paul Krugman uses an Eric Cantor tweet to explain how Ranidan thought dominates certain circles:
“Today, we celebrate those who have taken a risk, worked hard, built a business and earned their own success.”


This all makes sense in the Ayn Rand intellectual universe, where a handful of heroically greedy entrepreneurs are responsible for all that is good. And if you live in that universe, your dividing line between makers and takers isn’t drawn at the point where people make enough to pay income taxes; everyone who isn’t John Galt should be grateful for what the Galts do, and we’re all takers by asking those heroes to pay any taxes at all.
Ed Kilgore illustrates how this Randianism to its logical conclusion:
Think about it. A large percentage of GOP economic policy thinking is based on the assumption that minimizing business costs is the alpha and omega of growth and competitiveness. Not only taxes and regulations, but also wages and benefits, need to be kept as low as possible. The whole idea of “human capital” being a national asset worth cultivating—a universally accepted notion in the 1990s—has all but been lost on the right.
Accordingly, if you don’t fall into the charmed circle of “job creators;” if you don’t own your own business, or have enough wealth to make significant capital investments; then your job, it appears, is to bear down, shut up, and do what you can to make life easier for your bosses. Abandon that union; stop asking for pay increases; gracefully accept that shift from defined benefit to defined contribution pensions, or from any pension to none; pay your taxes and stop worrying about the tax rates paid by your superiors—you’re lucky they pay them at all, given the fact you already owe them your daily bread, everything you own, and your very life.
Kilgore and Krugman should have added that the current Randian Republicans have decided to treat their theory as a categorical imperative, blissfully forgetting that Kant's first formulation includes treating people as an end unto themselves and never the means an end.




Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Yes I Am Obsessed With Pointing Out That All Christians Should Reject Ayn Rand Edition

From this Ed Kilgore post:
It has taken many decades of laborious revisionist work for the devout, scripturally literalist adherents of the faith whose God and Savior was quoted as saying, “Again I tell you, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to enter the kingdom of God,” to become uninhibited enthusiasts for earthly success and wealth, and despisers of the “undeserving” poor. It’s the same revisionism, of course, that makes it possible for the Roman Catholic Vice Presidential Nominee of the Republican Party to fondly view Ayn Rand as an “intellectual influence,” instead of someone whose books any Christian should abjure like a Black Mass—someone whose fondest desire was to wipe both religion and altruism from the face of the earth.
I don't care if Ryan now claims she was only a small influence. Her work should never positively influence any Christian.

Monday, August 27, 2012

Ayn Rand Didn't Like The Wisdom That Came From The Prairie

Writing in The New Yorker, Judith Thurman examines the relationship between Rose Wilder Lane, daughter of Laura Ingalls Wilder, and Ayn Rand.

Lane and Rand exchanged collegial letters for a while in the late nineteen-forties and early nineteen-fifties. But when Lane invoked the Biblical imperative to “love thy neighbor as thyself,” and protested that “without some form of mutual coöperation, it is literally impossible for one person on this planet to survive,” Rand “tore apart [her] logic” and denounced it as collectivist heresy. That sor of impulse, she concluded (to help your neighbor save his burning house, for example) led inexorably “to the New Deal.”
Rand’s ruthless supremacism, however—her stark division of humankind into “makers and takers”—leads inexorably to a society like the one that staged “The Hunger Games.” And it’s to Lane’s credit that, for all her zealotry, she couldn’t quite transcend the instinct to give succor. Should Paul Ryan decide to revisit the “Little House” books, he will certainly hear the congenial echo of Lane’s polemics in them, though tempered by something more humane. They exalt rugged self-reliance, but as Lane suggested rather plaintively in her argument with Rand, the pioneers would have perished (in greater numbers than they did) had they embraced the philosophy of every man for himself.
South Dakota is still filled with people who believe "America elected a dictator" when Americans elected FDR. Some might still consider Social Security a "Ponzi scheme." Some might be "rugged individualists"who grow their own vegetables. Lane did all of these things. She also battled depression throughout her long life, but she still saw that Rand's theories taken out to their logical conclusion would create a dystopia. Hopefully, more South Dakotans will adopt that view as well as Wilder's libertarian individualism.



Monday, August 13, 2012

A Little More On Rand And Ryan

Let's play unpack the paragraph shall we. Today's selection comes from this P&R Miscellany post.
Frankly, I wouldn't care if Ryan were an atheist.  Such irreligion would still be preferred to Obama's religious infatuation with government and the fiscal bankruptcy to which it is driving us.  None of the candidates for president and vice president share my religious beliefs.  There are two Catholics (both vice-presidential candidates), one Mormon, and one Black Liberation/Christo-Marxist (Obama).  Religiously, I think they're all wrong.
First, The problem is not atheism; the problem in Rand.  This Reason article is far more friendly to Rand than I am, but still concludes:
For example, under Rand's schema would a person who abandons some passion in order to look after an elderly parent have a higher or lower moral standing than someone who doesn't (assuming that the parents are equally worthy)? Will the former be happier? More at peace? Rand gives us no real reason to believe so. In fact, the distinct impression one gets from her work is that an individual's first duty is to cultivating his own passions rather than nurturing his interest in the flourishing of those around him (with the possible  exception of one's romantic partner). No surprise then that the virtue of generosity or benevolence, though it has pride of place in the work of Aristotle—the only philosopher to whom Rand acknowledges any intellectual debt—occupies a second-class status in her own work.
The fact is that Rand gets harder to take as one grows older and concerns about those around us become more important than our own personal project of self development. The relentless, single-minded dedication to one's passions that Rand seems to favor requires a coldness of the soul, a narrowing of one's humanity—the natural interest in the fortune of others that Smith alludes to—that most people find is not exactly conducive to their happiness,
This has profound and unfortunate political consequences. On the practical level, it makes it difficult to build a strong and growing anti-government movement based solely on Rand's philosophy, because the older cohort of her followers is falling off on a regular basis. On the theoretical level, Rand's ideas offer no real possibility of developing robust civil society responses to address the needs of those down on their luck. It is difficult to imagine a Randian qua Randian, say, volunteering in a soup kitchen to feed the hungry, or even founding the Fraternal Order of Fellow Randians to provide free health coverage and housing to jobless and homeless Randians. Since misfortune and distress are a normal part of the human condition, a philosophy that offers no positive, private solutions to deal with them will just have a harder time making the case against government intervention stick. [emphasis mine]
Granted Ryan has attempted to distance himself from Rand, but I maintain now as I did in May:
I'm happier than most when someone sees the light and rejects Rand's pernecious, over-rated ideology, but somehow this conversion strikes me as being closer to that experienced Ananias and Sapphira not the one experienced by the Apostle Paul.
Second, I concur that worship of government, the flag, or the politician constitutes idolatry. I should have been more critical of some of messianic rhetoric that some Obama supporters used in 2008. That being said, this paragraph seems forget that the Bible teaches that God establishes government:
1 Let everyone be subject to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. 2 Consequently, whoever rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves. 3 For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and you will be commended. [Romans 13:1-3 New International Version]
15 By me kings reign and rulers issue decrees that are just;16 by me princes govern,and nobles—all who rule on earth. [Proverbs 8:15-16]
Further, describing Obama as "Black Liberation/Christo-Marxist" ignores a basic that Get Religion concisely enunciates:
In what can only be called a stunning defeat for those who still considered him a Muslim, President Barack Obama yesterday confirmed that he is, in fact, a perfectly ordinary liberal Protestant Christian.
Finally, this series of tweets seems right to me. Burkean conservatives should look for third party alternatives.


Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Plains Pops: Ayn Rand Taken Out To Her Logical Foolish Conclusion

Over lunch I ran across an Ayn Rand trifecta.

First, this comment and some that follow on a Madville Times thread.

Then, there's the advice of Ayn Randers. The first conversation reveal Ayn at her loving best.
Dear Ayn,
I’m dating a man who I think I love, but I’m afraid he’s having an affair. He comes home late, he acts suspiciously, and he even has red lipstick on his collar. Should I confront him or just hope for the best?
— County Affair
Dear County,
Red lipstick? Your husband is a communist. Divorce him and sell his clothes, children, and pens to make money to spend on cars, human slaves, and bigger pens. This will simultaneously stimulate the economy and punish the slaves for not having jobs. Slaves: what lazybones!
Hope this helps,
Ayn
The second illustrates her talent at delivering a witty rejoinder.
Dear Ayn,
I don’t mean to be offensive, but your writing is overwhelmingly juvenile and one-note. How did you become such an influential figure, a cornerstone of the landscape of American conservative politics? You write like a petulant child.
—Hollis Hurlbut, Professor of Comparative Literature, Harvard University

Dear Hollis,
Your mom’s juvenile.
Hope this helps,
Ayn
HT: Rod Dreher


Finally, there's this story of successful parenting using Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged.  The key paragraphs:
Since the day Johanna was born, we’ve worked to indoctrinate her into the truth of Objectivism. Every night we read to her from the illustrated, unabridged edition of Atlas Shrugged—glossing over all the hardcore sex parts, mind you, but dwelling pretty thoroughly on the stuff about being proud of what you’ve earned and not letting James Taggart-types bring you down. For a long time we were convinced that our efforts to free her mind were for naught, but recently, as we’ve started socializing her a little bit, we’ve been delighted to find that she is completely antipathetic to the concept of sharing. As parents, we couldn’t have asked for a better daughter. . . .
After all, we’ve managed to raise a bright, self-reliant girl who achieves her goals by means of incentive and ratiocination and never—or very rarely—through the corrupt syllogism of force. We know, despite what you and a number of other parents we’ve met have said—as they carried their whimpering little social parasites away—that Johanna’s defiant, quasi-bellicose nature only superficially resembles that of an out-of-control toddler, and in truth posits her as more of a latter-day Dagny Taggart than any kind of enfant terrible.
Yes, she’s blossomed into everything we ever hoped or post hoc rationalized she would. In our house we no longer say, “Who is John Galt?” Instead we say, “Who’s our little princess?”
HT: David Mills 

Friday, April 27, 2012

Has Paul Ryan Been On A Road To Damascus?

Or W.W.A.R.S.? (What Would Ayn Rand Say?)

Think Progress reports that Paul Ryan has thrown Ayn Rand under the proverbial bus.
From an interview with National Review’s Bob Costa this week:
“I reject her philosophy,” Ryan says firmly. “It’s an atheist philosophy. It reduces human interactions down to mere contracts and it is antithetical to my worldview. If somebody is going to try to paste a person’s view on epistemology to me, then give me Thomas Aquinas,” who believed that man needs divine help in the pursuit of knowledge. “Don’t give me Ayn Rand,” he says.
Of course Rand has not always been so dismissive of Rand. Think Progress points out,
In 2005, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) heaped praise on Ayn Rand, a 20th-century libertarian novelist best known for her philosophy that centered on the idea that selfishness is “virtue”. The New Republic wrote:
“The reason I got involved in public service, by and large, if I had to credit one thinker, one person, it would be Ayn Rand,” Ryan said at a D.C. gathering four years ago honoring the author of “Atlas Shrugged” and “The Fountainhead.”
I'm happier than most when someone sees the light and rejects Rand's pernecious, over-rated ideology, but somehow this conversion strikes me as being closer to that experienced Ananias and Sapphira not the one experienced by the Apostle Paul.


Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Quotation Of The Day: Ayn Rand Followers Are Frequently Wrong Edition

From this Noah Kristula-Green post at Frum Forum:
The moral of the story: just because the person talking has a lot of money doesn’t mean they always know what they are talking about, especially if they never grew out of their Ayn Rand phase. 

Thursday, October 20, 2011

A Dead Cult Leader Makes A Current List Of Overrated Thinkers

The New Republic has published a list overrated public intellectuals, including one dead "thinker."  The list includes some easy targets:  politicians Newt Gingrich and Paul Ryan, former New York Times columnist Frank Rich, and CNN's Fareed Zakaria.  It includes one person who had previously been unknown to me: Parag Khanna who is
“a frequent speaker at international conferences” who briefs “corporations on global trends, systemic risks and emerging market strategies.” He has hosted an MTV show, was the first video blogger at ForeignPolicy.com, and directs something called the “Hybrid Reality Institute.” His recent book is actually called How to Run the World. It is a self-congratulatory anthology of clichés and platitudes—the life of the mind, Davos-style.
The list also includes Rachel Maddow,someone I had never consider in intellectual.  The list does not include Sean Hannity, Bill O'Reilly, or the crew from Fox & Friends.  These inclusions and exclusions leave open the question of whether it is worse to be an overrated thinker or not be considered a thinker under any circumstance.

My favorite inclusion on the list, however, is the dead thinker, Ayn Rand who
earned her presence on this list by the astonishing persistence of her theories, which seem to have attained particular volume as of late, receiving endorsement from everyone from American Enterprise Institute President Arthur Brooks to Representative Paul Ryan (who supposedly requires his staffers to read Atlas Shrugged) to Wall Street Journal economics writer Stephen Moore (“‘Atlas Shrugged’: From Fiction to Fact in 52 Years,” he wrote). Despite the fact that Rand’s worldview is a crackpot Manicheanism, in which the world is divided between virtuous, productive individuals and lazy parasites, Rand’s hold on American conservatism continues to grow, as if real thinking is ever compatible with a cult.  (Emphasis mine for any of my Christian brothers and sisters who might erroneously believe she's compatible with Christianity)

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Minor Musings From A Road Trip

Last evening, I needed to take road trip that began shortly after 8 pm and ended around 2:45 am.  Since my passengers slept after midnight, I had a bit too much time to myself and had a few recollections and committed some bumper sticker philosophizing.

At some point I noted that during the early 1980s I met people who had the same beliefs as Tea Party members now hold.  The biggest difference between those people and the current Tea Partiers is tone and volume. I now hear pompous anger; in the 1980s, I heard sincerity and reflection.

I also came to the conclusion that it's more Biblical to start a home church than it's American to start a home school.

I wondered if more fundamentalist Christians would accept the arguments about climate change if they had been told that they were right when they claim God gave humans dominion over the whole world and sent humanity out to subdue it, but there's a huge difference between subduing and destroying.  We have reached the point where we are destroying.

Before she went to sleep, my wife mentioned  this NPR interview with Ryan Lizza, author of this New Yorker article about Michele Bachmann's rise to prominence.

During the interview, Lizza lists Francis Schaeffer, Nancy Pearcey, and John Eidsmoe  as authors who have influenced Bachmann.  I have not read anything by Pearcey or Eidsmoe, but I did read Francis Schaeffer's A Christian Manifesto in the early 1980s.  As Lizza points out, Schaeffer and Pearcey believe that Christian faith should dominate believer's lives and worldviews.
"Michele Bachmann has mentioned Pearcey's book [Total Truth] as one that was important to her," . . . . "[The book] is in line with the Schaeffer-ite view of taking your Christian faith and making sure that it permeates all parts of your life. The key thing here is Christians should not just be go-to-church-on-Sunday Christians. Their religion should permeate all aspects of life."
It's not too difficult develop that principle when the Bible contains injunctions like Romans 12: 1-2.
1I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, that ye present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service.
 2And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind, that ye may prove what is that good, and acceptable, and perfect, will of God.
The Bible says faith should affect philosophy.  It also says I should start losing lots of weight.  I can understand why Christians who believe in absolutes would take issue with ideas like these presented by Stanley Fish.  I have no clue why people who hold that view can ally themselves with Ayn Rand's followers.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

More on Randians and Christians

Joe Carter who used to write at the Evangelical Outpost and now writes at First Things takes the critique of Ayn Rand and her philosophy's incompatibility with Christianity to a higher level.  He points out that Anton Lavey used Randian thought to create his Satanic Bible.
Perhaps most are unaware of the connection, though LaVey wasn’t shy about admitting his debt to his inspiration. “I give people Ayn Rand with trappings,” he once told the Washington Post. On another occasion he acknowledged that his brand of Satanism was “just Ayn Rand’s philosophy with ceremony and ritual added.” Indeed, the influence is so apparent that LaVey has been accused of plagiarizing part of his “Nine Satanic Statements” from the John Galt speech in Rand’s Atlas Shrugged.
Devotees of Rand may object to my outlining the association between the two. They will say I am proposing “guilt by association,” a form of the ad hominem fallacy. But I am not attacking Rand for the overlap of her views with LaVey’s; I am saying that, at their core, they are the same philosophy. LaVey was able to recognize what many conservatives fail to see: Rand’s doctrines are satanic.
Carter goes on to bolster the idea that supporting Randians just because they may claim to have some of the same views that Christians share is a fool's errand.
But to be a follower of both Rand and Christ is not possible. The original Objectivist was a type of self-professed anti-Christ who hated Christianity and the self-sacrificial love of its founder. She recognized that those Christians who claimed to share her views didn’t seem to understand what she was saying.

Many conservatives admire Rand because she was anti-collectivist. But that is like admiring Stalin because he opposed Nazism. Stalin was against the Nazis because he wanted to make the world safe for Communism. Likewise, Rand stands against collectivism because she wants the freedom to abolish Judeo-Christian morality. Conservative Christians who embrace her as the “enemy-of-my-enemy” seem to forget that she considered us the enemy. [emphasis mine]
Carter also shows a bit of wit in his take down of conservative Christians who adhere to Rand.  First,
You can replace the pentagrams of LeVayian Satanism with the dollar sign of the Objectivists without changing much of the substance separating the two. The ideas are largely the same, though the movements’ aesthetics are different. One appeals to, we might say, the Young Libertarians, and the other attracts the Future Wiccans of America.
Later,
But we are sustaining a climate in which not a few gullible souls believe she is worth taking seriously. Are we willing to be held responsible for pushing them to adopt an anti-Christian worldview? If so, perhaps instead of recommending Atlas Shrugged, we should simply hand out copies of The Satanic Bible. If they’re going to align with a satanic cult, they might as well join the one that has the better holidays.
Perhaps some conservative Christians should try to worry more about the wolves in sheep's clothing in their midst rather than Muslims or gays.

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Why Do Christians Vote For Randians?

I posted about Ayn Rand's contempt for religion here.

This ad does a far better job of allowing her condemn herself with her own words. (HT Michael Tomasky)


Conservatives like William F. Buckley did a great service by reminding Americans that ideas have consequences.  Rand's ideas taken to their logical conclusion will produce consequences as pernicious as the totalitarian state she criticizes.

Update: I missed this post by big boy blogger Andrew Sullivan yesterday.  He gives full treatment to this issue.  HT @coralhei

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Why Atlas Shrugged When Jesus Died

Big Boy Blogger Andrew Sullivan posted this entry last Friday.  Cut and pasted in its entirety, I think it's worth far more as a Sunday morning sermon, especially in an era when Christians have let themselves be uses as pawns of the economic elites.  All I can add to Mr. Sullivan's post and the post he links to is a loud Amen!

Ayn Rand vs Jesus Christ

It's not an easy co-existence, Mr Gingrich. Some contrasts:

“Run for your life from any man who tells you that money is evil. That sentence is the leper's bell of an approaching looter.”

“For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, and in their eagerness to be rich some have wandered away from the faith,” - I Timothy 6:10.

Or this:

“It is one’s own personal selfish happiness that one seeks, earns, and derives from love.”
 
“This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you. No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends.”

Or this:

“I swear, by my life and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”
 
“Those who love their life lose it, and those who hate their life in this world will keep it for eternal life.”

It is possible to read the Gospels as entirely a personal and not political message, and certainly not view Christianity as a short route to socialism. But it is impossible even in one's personal life to be a Christian and to be a Randian. The whole point of the Gospels is that Rand's value system leads to profound misery and spiritual loss. And the whole point of Rand is that Nietzsche was onto something.