Thursday, August 7, 2008

A Lifehack That Should Have Been Self-Evident but Wasn't

I've frequently thought that multi-tasking is overrated. For example, this Atlantic article contends "multi-tasking is dumbing us down and driving us crazy." I have trouble working on more than one major task at a time, so I believe the article has it straight. In fact, I still think that M*A*S*H's Charles Emerson Winchester III had a nearly perfect theory of everything when he said, "I do one thing, I do it very well, and then I move on." I tried to apply the principle to every part of my life. I've always been proud of the fact that I can remember minutia of plot details of a TV show or novel. I love knowing useless details. The only way I could remember those little details was by concentrating on only the the thing I was watching, reading or listening to.

I often tell my students that they need to concentrate on only the material for a test or quiz while studying. They insist that they can watch TV, study, text, play Halo, and argue with their parents at the same time. Their test scores usually tell a different story, so I have always assumed I'm right about multi-tasking.

I can empathize with the kids. They want to do everything and they don't have time to do it. I'm in the same boat. I want to be prepared to teach, grade papers, watch TV, read serious novels, read comic books. I have always tried to concentrate on doing one thing at a time. During the past two weeks of this sucky summer, I have decided to multi-task entertainment. It's helped. I can catch up on some light reading like Rolling Stone reviews or a comic book and watch baseball. It's not going to work when I correct papers or read articles for debate, but it should buy me some extra time with little cost.

I know everyone else in the world probably has been multi-tasking entertainment since they were in diapers, but I haven't been able to. It's been one thing at a time until now when I no longer have that luxury because I seem to have been doing far too good of a job of wasting time.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Getting Ready: What I Learned during Summer Vacation, Part 1

The letter came last week, the one that welcomes teachers back to a new school year and announces the meeting schedule.

I am not ready; I don't want to go back. I didn't accomplish anything, nor did I refresh myself in any meaningful way; so I decided to assign myself a short series of essays about the summer to see if I can find something to build on to have a productive school year and avoid having the same problems in the future. It's a variation of the cliche essay "How I Spent My Summer Vacation."

The first thing that I learned is that I, like everyone else, am a creature of habit who repeats mistakes. This isn't the first summer that I've wasted. I have wasted more time this summer than I have in past summers, but that waste is really a difference of degree not a substantive change in habit.

The second thing that I learned is that time matters. I can't get the months back. They are irretrievably gone. I have always known that wasting time is costly, but now that I'm older with an AARP card with all rights and privileges that membership, the fact that wasted time is indeed lost time has become frightening.

The logical conclusion is that I must change. I remember a Linda Ellerbee commentary on NBC Overnight a long, long time ago. She claimed that the real time of new beginnings was September, the start of the new school year, not December. I hope she's right, but that hope brings me to the last thing that I learned this summer. I'm not sure that I know how to change. I guess I'm going through the ennui that makes rich guys buy motorcycles and marry trophy wives. Maybe they buy trophy wives too; I'm not a rich guy, so I don't know.

I think that's what I learned. I have a few additions to "My Summer Vacation" assignment that I want to get to, but none of them fit here, so I'll save them for another post. For right now, I've got to get ready for the new school year. I probably should see if Ellerbee is right and try to make September the time of new beginnings instead of waiting for December.

Monday, July 28, 2008

Some Musings on Great Divides

Great divide number 1 is between students and teachers. I was overjoyed to find this quotation by novelist Zadie Smith whom I have never read.
When you finish your novel, if money is not a desperate priority, if you do not need to sell it at once or be published that very second - put it in a drawer. For as long as you can manage. A year of more is ideal - but even three months will do. Step away from the vehicle. The secret to editing your work is simple: you need to become its reader instead of its writer. I can't tell you how many times I've sat backstage with a line of novelists at some festival, all of us with red pens in hand, frantically editing our published novels into fit form so that we might go on stage and read from them. It's an unfortunate thing, but it turns out that the perfect state of mind to edit your novel is two years after it's published, ten minutes before you go on stage at a literary festival. At that moment every redundant phrase, each show-off, pointless metaphor, all of the pieces of dead wood, stupidity, vanity, and tedium are distressingly obvious to you.
I try to tell my high school students to write a draft of their essay, walk away from the draft for a day or two, and then revise. I'm lucky if they let it sit for a minute or two because they usually begin writing the essay a couple of hours before it's due. I am, of course, supposed to reward all such efforts with an "A" because ....well, I've never heard an answer that I could agree with, but I know students think I'm supposed to.

Clicking through links to find the origin of Smith's quotation and innate curiosity lead me to this post about innumeracy, and this post requesting comments from humanities academicians, and then this post which offers another take on the divide between the humanities and the hard sciences/math.

Most high school students seem to consider math/science more important and more difficult than literature or the social sciences. High schools seem to privilege science and math. The smart kids are funnelled into math and science classes. No one is really funneled into a literature or humanities class. Wendell Berry offers my sentiments more eloquently than I can.
Now, according to those institutions of the “cutting edge,” the purpose of education is unabashedly utilitarian. Their interest is almost exclusively centered in the technical courses called, with typical ostentation of corporate jargon, STEM: science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. The American civilization so ardently promoted by these institutions is to be a civilization entirely determined by technology, and not encumbered by any thought of what is good or worthy or neighborly or humane.
After reading the posts and skimming comments, it seems that both sides are a bit defensive. Also, it seems that both sides of this divide are hampered by an anti-intellectual or anti-education bias. I don't have any scientific poll to back me up, but I'd be willing to bet that teachers and college professors are held in lower esteem than nearly any other profession.

On a more substantive level, it seems that high schools are doing a lot wrong. First, we don't really teach students to love any any discipline. We buy into the utilitarian logic that Berry decries. That logic seemingly is counterproductive because math and science types are encountering and decrying innumeracy and scientific illiteracy.

Thursday, July 24, 2008

Some Basic Thoughts about Education

This is the third or fourth or fifth effort to try to blog regularly. Let's see how it goes.

Thought #1: I agree with Charles Murray (mostly), at least this time.

Last spring, I read a Charles Murray article about the philosphy that he described as educational romaniticism. A version is here. Murray makes at least three trenchant points and one mistake.

Trenchent point #1

"Many laws are too optimistic, but the No Child Left Behind Act transcended optimism. It set a goal that was devoid of any contact with reality."

To quote the great philosopher Stan Lee, "Nuff said."

Trenchent point #2

"To sum up, a massive body of evidence says . . .that we do not know how to change intellectual ability after children reach school. . . ."

Once again, "Nuff said."

Trenchent point #3

"In public discourse, the leading symptom of educational romanticism is silence on the role of intellectual limits even when the topic screams for their discussion. Try to think of the last time you encountered a news story that mentioned low intellectual ability as the reason why some students do not perform at grade level. I doubt if you can. Whether analyzed by the news media, school superintendents, or politicians, the problems facing low-performing students are always that they have come from disadvantaged backgrounds, or have gone to bad schools, or grown up in peer cultures that do not value educational achievement. The problem is never that they just aren't smart enough." (Italics mine)

This is tricky ground. No one wants to claim that disadvantaged students are inherently less intelligent than middle-class or upper-class students. I am certain that a smart student who comes from a disadvantaged background has more hurdles to overcome than a smart student with wealthy student. Even with that caveat, a smart student from any background will usually be more successful in school than a less intelligent student, and Murray is correct to assert that schools ignore that fact. (I'll put off the success in school does not equal later success discussion for another day.)

The mistake (and I think it's a whopper)

"The good news is that educational romanticism is surely teetering on the edge of collapse."

I wish and I pray, but unfortunately, Lake Woebegone is here to stay. I don't think there's a teacher in the system that I work in that could keep her job is she uttered the phrase, "I don't think your child has the intellectual capacity to earn an A in my class." Further, I doubt that there are more than a handful of teachers who believe its OK to utter that phrase, even though they may think it quietly. Finally, I haven't seen any young teachers who have been taught that they should even think it.

Thought #2: On-line grading programs suck.

Change the brand names, but the problems this post outlines reflect my experience.

Thought #3: I wish I had the answer to this problem

Dennis O'Neil correctly observes,

"Over the past few years, I’ve come to believe that not everyone gets the same education, even if schools and transcripts are identical. Some folk mentally compartmentalize: church goes here, family here, school stuff here, life in general there. So when they pass tests on what they’ve heard in classrooms, and at the end of a span of time, usually16 years and some august personage hands them a rectangle full of fancy lettering, they’re done with it. No more schooling, and no learning above what’s needed to live comfortably. Schooling in its compartment yonder, not touching this compartment, which is where we live."

And

"The problem, I think, is this: There might be information over in the school compartment that is relevant to the contents of the living compartment. It might supply answers, or at least stimulate thinking.

"Left in the ghetto of the school compartment, denied access to other compartments, and it is useless, and it will die. Worse, its lack might cause you to blunder."

I see the compartmentalization every day. School is in a box that gets shelved the second students walk out the door to their real lives. In fact, all school seems to be is an interruption to the lives they want to lead.

Monday, August 13, 2007

Education: Radio or TV?

Every morning, I watch a Mike and Mike in the Morning on ESPN 2. For those unfamiliar with the goodness that is Mike and Mike, it's a simulcast of an ESPN Radio morning drive talk show. In other words I watch the radio for a couple of hours every day.

The other day, I happened to see the end of the program where the hosts, Mike Golic and Mike Greenberg, schmooze with the hosts of the First Take, the interview and sports analysis show that follows the Mike and Mike show on ESPN 2. Golic was wearing a polo shirt and jeans; Greenberg was wearing an unbuttoned dress shirt over a t-shirt and business casual slacks, but the First Take hosts were wearing suits. The image got me thinking about what the concerns that people seem to have with "professional dress."

I really don't think that anyone can claim Golic and Greenberg are unprofessional. (At some point I probably should switch to Greenberg and Golic so Greenberg doesn't feel slighted. Of course, that thought implies that Greenberg has time to read a blog written by a nobody in SD.) Both men do a wonderful job interviewing guests and they play off each other well. I'm entertained and informed when I watch/listen. Obviously the fact that they're not wearing suits and ties doesn't lessen the quality of their work. When Greenberg does Sports Center and Golic does NFL Live, they wear suits, but the suits don't make them any more entertaining or informative. It's just that TV anchors are expected to wear suits and no one seems to care what morning drive radio hosts wear. I suppose it has something to do with the fact that suits are supposed to project power, but I really don't know.

Next week I'll be sitting in a teacher meeting and someone will ask about blue jean Fridays. One of the administrators will grouse and grumble and exhort teachers to dress professionally before giving the appropriate blessing. The whole performance seems to be premised on the idea that without these exhortations from serious determined leaders, teachers will show up wearing clothes that were stolen from the homeless. I've never seen anyone show up for work dressed poorly, but apparently, teachers need to be reminded they are in a profession. No one, however, seems to want to discuss what kind of profession. If professional dress is based upon the situation, then educators need to decide if education is a radio profession or a TV profession.

I'm leaning radio. Teachers are in a room with 20-30 students who are sitting in uncomfortable desks doing tasks that most of them don't want to do. They want to be entertained, and if they learn something while being entertained, they can consider it a good day. A suit or a power tie doesn't matter to them. The classroom is not about projecting power; it's about cajoling and tricking students into learning and then creating a desire to learn. Besides, a polo and jeans probably project power over sweats and t-shirt.

At another level, teaching is like morning drive radio. I don't know what the audience is going to react to. I have a plan, begin to work the plan, and then student questions or other reactions determine how I proceed. If I can react with some wit and detail, they listen and hopefully learn.

Finally, this little issue is worth a blog post because it is emblematic of education as a whole. We waste time on superficial issues and never get to the big picture. At the pre-school meetings, we're going to waste time on the dress code, but we're not going to talk about how to teach better.

Saturday, August 11, 2007

Listening to Students and Other Stuff

This LA Times article about students who evaluated some LA schools makes some thought provoking points.

First, schools should listen to students. Of course 16-year-old students are going to want glitz and glamour, probably more than is good for them. Of course adults need to act like adults and make decisions that produce the good not just the fun. The solutions these students recommended seem to go beyond glitz and "make it fun." They want to "[h]ire more teachers who care. Slash overcrowded classrooms. Stop sending failing students to the next grade."

On a positive note, I haven't met many South Dakota teachers who don't care. The vast majority sincerely try to perform to the best of their ability each day. Some may not be warm and fuzzy, but they are concerned about the welfare of their students.

On the other hand, South Dakota's largest districts seem to be trying to do more with less and classrooms are getting more crowded. We're certainly not at LA levels, but it's getting worse.

The comment about passing failing students really hits home. I don't know if it's the self-esteem tidal wave or the fact that South Dakota borders Minnesota and South Dakotans think that we have to compete with Lake Woebegone. The practical people that we are, we forget that Lake Woebegone isn't a real place. After all, we hear about it on the radio every week and no one who works for a living has time to have their heads in the clouds so often that they could make up that stuff!! It's gotta be real. Whatever the reasons, I see failing students get promoted/passed more often than they should, and other grades are inflated as well.

In short, the kids" analysis squares with what I see every year.

The second thing that struck me was how easy I have it compared to urban teachers. I really don't think that any of my students have to worry "about the rival gangs surrounding [the school.]" I doubt that any of them live in a situation where they're "taking a risk just to walk to school" as Earl Moutra, one of the students covered in the article, does.

Finally, I really think that the article points to a key reform. Sofia Freire, one of the few LA administrators to respond to the students, "said her campus of 5,200 students has been carved into 12 academies of 350 to 400 students so that teachers can get to know their students better." Freire claims "small learning communities . . . personalize education for our students and make sure they don't fall through the cracks."

South Dakota doesn't have any 5,200-student high school campuses. Nonetheless, this idea makes perfect sense for any school over 600 students. For one thing, teachers would probably get to teach students during three or four semesters instead of just one or two. It takes me up to two or three months to get to know some little personal tidbit about every kid who comes through my door in a semester so that I can interact with them on something resembling a personal level. Two months later the students move on and I have to start the process again. The academies that Friere is championing would by necessity mean more contact with students throughout their high school career and increase teachers' ability to treat students as persons instead of commodities to be produced.

Thursday, August 9, 2007

Something Education Should Borrow from Pop Culture

Maybe it's just a local phenomenon, but it seems like many of my students are fascinated with personality quizzes.

Both guys and girls take and discuss the Cosmo "What Kind of Sexual Partner Are You?" They take Harry Potter quizzes or try to determine which House character they are. Although the true slackers make study hall meaningful by reading the police report published in the daily paper, the nerds and geeks make study hall worthwhile by discovering which sci-fi character they'd be. The more sophisticated determine if they are or are not feminists.

On a more serious level, one can take the Keirsey-Bates Sorter or the the IPIP-NEO. If one wants to combine books with on-line tests, one can read First, Break All the Rules: What the World's Greatest Managers Do Differently, Now, Discover Your Strengths, and Go Put Your Strengths to Work: 6 Powerful Steps to Achieve Outstanding Performance. And if one wants to show that one is truly a member of the digital age, one can read StrengthsFinder 2.0: A New and Upgraded Edition of the Online Test from Gallup's Now, Discover Your Strengths. Ya gotta love those hipsters who can adapt that wacky hi-tech terminology.

Teachers can read Teach with Your Strengths: How Great Teachers Inspire Their Students, a book endorsed by South Dakota Secretary of Education Rick Melmer. According to Melmer's blurb, the book "challenges all educators to recognize and reward the best in our profession. The book describes in detail what great teachers do or say each day."

Obviously, there are a great number of resources that determine a person's comfort zones and general tendencies. I'm sure that dozens of learning style inventories exist, BUT I don't have access to any of it for the students that I will be teaching. I don't have any research on how different students will interact with 5 dominant strengths that I allegedly have available to inspire my students.

Let's review:

  1. Teachers are supposed to insure that every student meets minimum standards.
  2. I have anecdotal evidence that students like taking personality surveys.
  3. Some surveys about learning and teaching styles exist.
  4. Some surveys seem to have research behind them that demonstrates that the survey has some degree of accuracy.
  5. Schools don't use those tools to pair students and teachers to insure the best possible learning outcomes.
I hate the touchy-feely stuff more than most, and I admit that some teachers and kids would hate the surveys and view them the same way that I view horoscopes. I am also aware that these surveys could be one more way to type/track/limit students although I doubt that they would be used any more maliciously than current student information is.

Anyway, it seems that the hit and miss approach isn't really working, so why not try something new?