Showing posts with label Multitasking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Multitasking. Show all posts

Thursday, April 21, 2011

Failures of Multitasking

I frequently vent about multitasking, so I'm surprised that I have only one post that reveals that frustration.  There's no time like the present to correct an error.  Kevin Drum of Mother Jones contends that multitasking ruins one's brain.

Drum begins by quoting an email sent by a "professor friend" of his who begins by making a complaint that I share: "Fully half of my 60 person general physics class this semester sits in the back of the room on either phone or laptop. They're not taking notes. The good ones are working on assignments for other classes (as if being present in mine causes the information to enter their pores). The bad are giggling at Facebook comments."  I teach in a high school that attempts to ban cell phones in the classroom, but students think they should be allowed to do homework for other classes in my class.  I guess I should be flattered that think that I have the omnipotence to force them to learn by just being in my presence.

Drum then quotes a Frontline interview of Stanford psychologist Clifford Nass.
What did you expect when you started these experiments? 

Each of the three researchers on this project thought that ... high multitaskers [would be] great at something, although each of us bet on a different thing. 

I bet on filtering. I thought, those guys are going to be experts at getting rid of irrelevancy. My second colleague, Eyal Ophir, thought it was going to be the ability to switch from one task to another. And the third of us looked at a third task that we're not running today, which has to do with keeping memory neatly organized. So we each had our own bets, but we all bet high multitaskers were going to be stars at something. 

And what did you find out? 

We were absolutely shocked. We all lost our bets. It turns out multitaskers are terrible at every aspect of multitasking. They're terrible at ignoring irrelevant information; they're terrible at keeping information in their head nicely and neatly organized; and they're terrible at switching from one task to another.
 Let's review; Research says that "multitaskers are terrible at every aspect of multitasking."  Surely, multitaskers must be able to discover that fact.  Alas, Nass reports,
One would think that if people were bad at multitasking, they would stop. However, when we talk with the multitaskers, they seem to think they're great at it and seem totally unfazed and totally able to do more and more and more. We worry about it, because as people become more and more multitaskers, as more and more people -- not just young kids, which we're seeing a great deal of, but even in the workplace, people being forced to multitask, we worry that it may be creating people who are unable to think well and clearly.
Nass goes on to show what gets lost as people lose the ablility to think well.
Some things that we know get lost are, first of all, anytime you switch from one task to another, there's something called the "task switch cost," which basically, imagine, is I've got to turn off this part of the brain and turn on this part of the brain. And it's not free; it takes time. So one thing that you lose is time.

A second thing you lose is when you're looking at unrelated things, our brains are built to relate things, so we have to work very, very hard when we go from one thing to another, going: "No, not the same! Not the same! Stop it! Stop it!" It's why people who aren't multitaskers, like me, often experience when we're typing and someone walks up and starts talking with you -- you've probably had this -- you start typing their words and go, "Ah, what happened?" And that's because your brain loves to mix. So we're spending a lot of time trying to beat down this combining brain we have. ...

At the end of the day, it seems like it's affecting things like ability to remember long term, ability to handle analytic reasoning, ability to switch properly, etc., if this stuff is, again, ... trained rather than inborn. If it's inborn, what we're losing is the ability to do a lot of things that we're doing. We're doing things much, much poorer and less efficiently in time. So it's actually costing us time.

One of the biggest delusions we hear from students is, "I do five things at once because I don't have time to do them one at a time." And that turns out to be false. That is to say, they would actually be quicker if they did one thing, then the next thing, then the next. It may not be as fun, but they'd be more efficient.
Multitasking costs more than time, long term memory, and efficiency.  Nass concludes with a reminder of what Americans used to find important and have now lost.  "One of the biggest points here I think is, when I grew up, the greatest gift you could give someone was attention, and the best way to insult someone was to ignore them. ... The greatest gift was attention. Well, if we're in a society where the notion of attention as important is breaking apart, what now is the relationship glue between us?"

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

This Research Applies to Students Who Try to Do Biology In English Class Too

Few good multitaskers exist according to the New York Times.  The key quotation:

In the meantime, Mr. Strayer and the researchers say most people should not expect to successfully supertask. And they absolutely should not try to do so behind the wheel of a car because, he said, they face significantly inflated crash risk.

“Some readers may also be wondering if they too are supertaskers,” said the paper by Mr. Strayer and his colleague, Jason Watson. “We suggest the odds of this are against them.”
 Most students probably will take 2.5% chance that they are supertaskers.  Gotta love enthusiasm.

Thursday, August 7, 2008

A Lifehack That Should Have Been Self-Evident but Wasn't

I've frequently thought that multi-tasking is overrated. For example, this Atlantic article contends "multi-tasking is dumbing us down and driving us crazy." I have trouble working on more than one major task at a time, so I believe the article has it straight. In fact, I still think that M*A*S*H's Charles Emerson Winchester III had a nearly perfect theory of everything when he said, "I do one thing, I do it very well, and then I move on." I tried to apply the principle to every part of my life. I've always been proud of the fact that I can remember minutia of plot details of a TV show or novel. I love knowing useless details. The only way I could remember those little details was by concentrating on only the the thing I was watching, reading or listening to.

I often tell my students that they need to concentrate on only the material for a test or quiz while studying. They insist that they can watch TV, study, text, play Halo, and argue with their parents at the same time. Their test scores usually tell a different story, so I have always assumed I'm right about multi-tasking.

I can empathize with the kids. They want to do everything and they don't have time to do it. I'm in the same boat. I want to be prepared to teach, grade papers, watch TV, read serious novels, read comic books. I have always tried to concentrate on doing one thing at a time. During the past two weeks of this sucky summer, I have decided to multi-task entertainment. It's helped. I can catch up on some light reading like Rolling Stone reviews or a comic book and watch baseball. It's not going to work when I correct papers or read articles for debate, but it should buy me some extra time with little cost.

I know everyone else in the world probably has been multi-tasking entertainment since they were in diapers, but I haven't been able to. It's been one thing at a time until now when I no longer have that luxury because I seem to have been doing far too good of a job of wasting time.