Thursday, August 9, 2007

Something Education Should Borrow from Pop Culture

Maybe it's just a local phenomenon, but it seems like many of my students are fascinated with personality quizzes.

Both guys and girls take and discuss the Cosmo "What Kind of Sexual Partner Are You?" They take Harry Potter quizzes or try to determine which House character they are. Although the true slackers make study hall meaningful by reading the police report published in the daily paper, the nerds and geeks make study hall worthwhile by discovering which sci-fi character they'd be. The more sophisticated determine if they are or are not feminists.

On a more serious level, one can take the Keirsey-Bates Sorter or the the IPIP-NEO. If one wants to combine books with on-line tests, one can read First, Break All the Rules: What the World's Greatest Managers Do Differently, Now, Discover Your Strengths, and Go Put Your Strengths to Work: 6 Powerful Steps to Achieve Outstanding Performance. And if one wants to show that one is truly a member of the digital age, one can read StrengthsFinder 2.0: A New and Upgraded Edition of the Online Test from Gallup's Now, Discover Your Strengths. Ya gotta love those hipsters who can adapt that wacky hi-tech terminology.

Teachers can read Teach with Your Strengths: How Great Teachers Inspire Their Students, a book endorsed by South Dakota Secretary of Education Rick Melmer. According to Melmer's blurb, the book "challenges all educators to recognize and reward the best in our profession. The book describes in detail what great teachers do or say each day."

Obviously, there are a great number of resources that determine a person's comfort zones and general tendencies. I'm sure that dozens of learning style inventories exist, BUT I don't have access to any of it for the students that I will be teaching. I don't have any research on how different students will interact with 5 dominant strengths that I allegedly have available to inspire my students.

Let's review:

  1. Teachers are supposed to insure that every student meets minimum standards.
  2. I have anecdotal evidence that students like taking personality surveys.
  3. Some surveys about learning and teaching styles exist.
  4. Some surveys seem to have research behind them that demonstrates that the survey has some degree of accuracy.
  5. Schools don't use those tools to pair students and teachers to insure the best possible learning outcomes.
I hate the touchy-feely stuff more than most, and I admit that some teachers and kids would hate the surveys and view them the same way that I view horoscopes. I am also aware that these surveys could be one more way to type/track/limit students although I doubt that they would be used any more maliciously than current student information is.

Anyway, it seems that the hit and miss approach isn't really working, so why not try something new?

No comments: