Saturday, August 11, 2007

Listening to Students and Other Stuff

This LA Times article about students who evaluated some LA schools makes some thought provoking points.

First, schools should listen to students. Of course 16-year-old students are going to want glitz and glamour, probably more than is good for them. Of course adults need to act like adults and make decisions that produce the good not just the fun. The solutions these students recommended seem to go beyond glitz and "make it fun." They want to "[h]ire more teachers who care. Slash overcrowded classrooms. Stop sending failing students to the next grade."

On a positive note, I haven't met many South Dakota teachers who don't care. The vast majority sincerely try to perform to the best of their ability each day. Some may not be warm and fuzzy, but they are concerned about the welfare of their students.

On the other hand, South Dakota's largest districts seem to be trying to do more with less and classrooms are getting more crowded. We're certainly not at LA levels, but it's getting worse.

The comment about passing failing students really hits home. I don't know if it's the self-esteem tidal wave or the fact that South Dakota borders Minnesota and South Dakotans think that we have to compete with Lake Woebegone. The practical people that we are, we forget that Lake Woebegone isn't a real place. After all, we hear about it on the radio every week and no one who works for a living has time to have their heads in the clouds so often that they could make up that stuff!! It's gotta be real. Whatever the reasons, I see failing students get promoted/passed more often than they should, and other grades are inflated as well.

In short, the kids" analysis squares with what I see every year.

The second thing that struck me was how easy I have it compared to urban teachers. I really don't think that any of my students have to worry "about the rival gangs surrounding [the school.]" I doubt that any of them live in a situation where they're "taking a risk just to walk to school" as Earl Moutra, one of the students covered in the article, does.

Finally, I really think that the article points to a key reform. Sofia Freire, one of the few LA administrators to respond to the students, "said her campus of 5,200 students has been carved into 12 academies of 350 to 400 students so that teachers can get to know their students better." Freire claims "small learning communities . . . personalize education for our students and make sure they don't fall through the cracks."

South Dakota doesn't have any 5,200-student high school campuses. Nonetheless, this idea makes perfect sense for any school over 600 students. For one thing, teachers would probably get to teach students during three or four semesters instead of just one or two. It takes me up to two or three months to get to know some little personal tidbit about every kid who comes through my door in a semester so that I can interact with them on something resembling a personal level. Two months later the students move on and I have to start the process again. The academies that Friere is championing would by necessity mean more contact with students throughout their high school career and increase teachers' ability to treat students as persons instead of commodities to be produced.

No comments: