Showing posts with label Why I Coach Speech Events. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Why I Coach Speech Events. Show all posts

Monday, April 21, 2014

A Post Wherein I Offer A Plainsman's Corollary To Godwin's Law

First, let's go to the definitions. Godwin's Law "is an Internet adage asserting that 'As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1'—​ that is, if an online discussion (regardless of topic or scope) goes on long enough, sooner or later someone will compare someone or something to Hitler or Nazism."

The most famous and canonical corollary is often confused with Godwin's actual law:
. . .there is a tradition in many newsgroups and other Internet discussion forums that once such a comparison is made, the thread is finished and whoever mentioned the Nazis has automatically lost whatever debate was in progress. This principle is itself frequently referred to as Godwin's law.
Before I enunciate my corollary, let me explain how I discovered it. In a recent post, Cory Heidelberger, a debate coach par excellence, makes the case that a Gordon Howie candidacy has the potential to help Rick Weiland win the U.S. Senate race in November.
Tom Lawrence gives Rick Weiland more cause for hope, identifying national historical precedent for a crowded ballot leading to a win for a presumed underdog in a one-to-one race. While Democrat Weiland enjoys easy sailing through spring with no primary challenger, GOP frontrunner Marion Michael Rounds has to face the punches of Stace Nelson, Larry Rhoden, and Jason Ravnsborg (and Stace, Larry, Jason, you all realize that job #1 for each of you at the big SDNA debate in Pierre this morning is to take Rounds down a peg, right?). If Rounds withstands the primary challenge (and his ads show that if he wins, it will be on inertia and money, not on skillful messaging), he still won't be able to focus fire on Weiland. Larry Pressler will harass him from the nostalgic middle, and Gordon Howie will harass him from the right. Weiland could focus on getting Dems to show up and stick together (dangit, Dems! do it!), draw a third of the Indy vote (oh, think big: half!), and beat Rounds with something in the forties
No one in the Madville Times comment section alleged that the scenario provided hollow hope. In the high school debate world, hollow hope disadvantages generally involve the United States Supreme Court's inability to produce a desired result, it has been run on in conjunction with political movements. Most objective observers would accept that a Howie candidacy would produce fewer efficacious results than any court decision.

I thought the matter dead until yesterday, but Representative Steve Hickey ran an old Republican staple, the abortion disadvantage. For the debate coach audience, Hickey's uniqueness is Rounds will defeat both Weiland and Pressler in the status quo. The link is Howie's entering the race as an independent will drain off the disaffected "hell no" voters and allow Weiland will win an election he would have lost. The impact is a pro choice person will be put on the United States Supreme Court; therefore, abortions will continue unabated because Roe v Wade will not be overturned. It's not a nuclear war or extinction scenario, but it's pretty good.

If this were a regular debate round, I'd expect a threat con kritik. For the non-debate folk, threat con is an argument that says enunciating a threat, in this case causing more abortions, is a means of making the threat a reality. Hickey, however, ran his argument on a conservative blog, so no oneengaged Hickey's argument; they merely called each other RINOs, Republicans In Name Only.

Then the Plainsman Corollary struck me: on any conservative blog, as the discussion grows longer, the probability of someone being called a RINO approaches 1'—​ that is, if an online discussion (regardless of topic or scope) on a conservative blog goes on long enough, sooner or later someone will call a person on the other side of the issue a RINO.

I even have two sub-corollaries. First, the person making the charge believes that calling someone a RINO means he or she has won the debate. Second, the person making the charge cannot define the term RINO.

Friday, December 6, 2013

SDHSAA Oral Interp Festival 2013

I have been to many SDHSAA speech and debate events, but I thought this one might be different. Based on recent press reports, I expected to encounter Mafioso exchanging envelopes filled with cash when I arrived this morning. No cash filled envelopes were in sight. I then looked for some shady characters trying bribe young'uns to perform poorly. I didn't see anyone doing that, nor did I spot any leg breakers. SDHSAA Executive Director Wayne Carney and Assistant Executive Director James Weaver are on hand, but no one has addressed them as Godfather. They aren't carrying around two sets of books or talking about today's number either. I am sorely disappointed.

Scott Walker and the rest of the Watertown High School coaching contingent along with some of their students are doing an excellent job of running registration. Scores of students are excited to perform their humorous, prose, and dramatic selections. I expect a few students to actually learn. That outcome, of course, doesn't generate headlines like sour grapes complaints do.
posted from Bloggeroid

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Five Quick But Interesting Reads Around South Dakota Blogosphere: March 21st Edition

David Montgomery posts some South Dakota politicians March Madness brackets. I really don't care which teams the politicians or South Dakota's first lady picked. I find it interesting, however, that Ben Nesslehuf and Jason Frerichs, who are both under 40, filled out their brackets digitally whereas the older politicians still pulled out a pen or pencil. There seems to be a digital generation gap.

Ken Santema has two good posts about the dangers of CISPA

This P&R Miscellany post points to troublesome efforts to limit speech is provocative.

Finally, I have to admit that I'm ashamed of myself that I missed this one until yesterday, but Cory's report on the South Dakota High School Activities Association State Debate Tournament makes me feel good about coaching debate.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

A Minor Musing About Devolution And The Gun Debate

Every year I sit down with young Lincoln-Douglas debaters, and we discuss two views of the social contract. The debaters only have thirteen minutes to present their position and refute their opponent's position on any issue, so we flatten some deep ideas a bit more than we should, but the debaters are at least exposed to texts and ideas that are foundations of America's political discourse.

We discuss Locke's view that humans left the state of nature and created society to preserve the products of their labor and that Locke wanted individuals to preserve as much liberty as possible. I usually throw out Ben Franklin's famous statement: "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."

We also discuss Hobbes's premise that the state of nature was a time when humanity lived "without a common power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which is called war; and such a war as is of every man against every man." In the state of nature, Hobbes contends the"life of man, [is] solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." Hobbes then goes on to advocate a much larger state than Locke.

Both believed that society had moved beyond the state nature. Yet, the current gun debate in United States seems predicated on the idea that America is the devolving or soon will devolve back to the state of nature. Last week, on ABC's This Week, Peggy Noonan asserted:
Yes, two things I'd like to say, one is that people are buying guns like crazy now. Not because they're nutty, not enough because they're angry, but because I really think they fear their country is falling apart.
It's defensive and it's something that I think we all have to be talking about. There's so much anxiety out in America. And they also fear their government.
I find the idea that banning guns will keep me safer confusing. I have the same risk of dying in an automobile accident as I do dying as a result of gun violence, and no one is talking about banning cars.

I also find the idea of arming teachers or expanding exponentially the number licences to carry concealed weapons confusing.  I doubt that stocking my house with guns will make me safer. First, the government has drones and tanks.  I have neither.  Second, a lot of private citizens can afford more guns and ammunition than I can. I will certainly lose nearly every arms race

Third, and most importantly, I also teach a unit on the Trojan War. Now that I'm closer to age 60 than I am to age 50, this passage resonates:
And maybe you ask, what was Priam’s fate.
When he saw the end of the captive city, the palace doors
wrenched away, and the enemy among the inner rooms,
the aged man clasped his long-neglected armour
on his old, trembling shoulders, and fastened on his useless sword,
and hurried into the thick of the enemy seeking death
In the centre of the halls, and under the sky’s naked arch,
was a large altar, with an ancient laurel nearby, that leant
on the altar, and clothed the household gods with shade.
Here Hecuba, and her daughters, like doves driven
by a dark storm, crouched uselessly by the shrines,
huddled together, clutching at the statues of the gods. . . .
So the old man spoke, and threw his ineffectual spear
without strength, which immediately spun from the clanging bronze
and hung uselessly from the centre of the shield’s boss.
Pyrrhus spoke to him: “Then you can be messenger, carry
\the news to my father, to Peleus’s son: remember to tell him
of degenerate Pyrrhus, and of my sad actions:
now die.” Saying this he dragged him, trembling,
and slithering in the pool of his son’s blood, to the very altar,
and twined his left hand in his hair, raised the glittering sword
in his right, and buried it to the hilt in his side.
This was the end of Priam’s life: this was the death that fell to him
by lot, seeing Troy ablaze and its citadel toppled, he who was
once the magnificent ruler of so many Asian lands and peoples.
A once mighty body lies on the shore, the head
shorn from its shoulders, a corpse without a name.
I will never be "a magnificent ruler," but in any armed struggle, I am much more likely to wind up like Priam than I am to survive.

I have long thought that Constitution was written by men blessed with genius. They understood that Hobbes may have correctly analyzed what happens when humans live without limits or controls, but they believed that humans had God-given reason and should be allowed to preserve as much liberty as possible just as Locke advocated.  Hence, the Bill of Rights expresses the goal that people should be secure in "their persons, houses, papers, and effects." The people were recognized as having reason, a tool necessary to live their faith in the public sphere, express their opinions, gather together peaceably, and petition the government for redress of grievances, acts that do not rely on brute force.

The current gun debate seems to illustrate that the founders were wrong; humans, at least those with the loudest voices in the gun debate have lost all sense of reason. In fact, both sides seem to wish to submit to fear, an emotion devoid of reason. If these loud voices have their way, the devolution into a world in which lives are nasty, brutish, and short can't be far behind

Thursday, January 3, 2013

Implementing Common Core In South Dakota May Mean No Debate

Or at least no high school debate classes.

Currently South Dakota high school students must earn 4 language arts credits.  Those credits must include 1.5 writing credits, 1.5 literature credits. That literature requirement specifies that a student must take a semester of American Literature. The requirements also mandate a half credit of speech or debate and allow for a half credit language arts elective.

A new proposal that I'm told will be taken up this spring will operate under the principle that "each standard need not be a separate focus for instruction and assessment." In short, students many no longer be required to take American Literature along with speech or debate in order to earn a high school diploma.

Eliminating the speech or debate requirement is problematic and counter-intuitive on several levels.

First, the Common Core emphasizes non-fiction reading. Preparing debate cases requires that students read news articles, research students, white papers, and philosophical texts. No one sites Flannery O'Connor or Nathaniel Hawthorne in a policy debate round. Sometimes, I wish they would, but that's a topic for another day.

Second, debate requires students to evaluate sources and be aware of source bias. More importantly, speech and debate textbooks have units on propaganda techniques and recognizing logical fallacies. Given that fact checking has of necessity become a cottage industry. Politicians and pundits make a career by using facts to prove points that those facts were not intended to prove. TV advertisements use every logical fallacy imaginable to get consumers to buy products the consumer probably doesn't need. In short, recognizing logical fallacies and propaganda seems a necessary 21st Century life skill

Senator Russel Olson wants colleges and universities to teach students to be primarily good workers not necessarily good thinkers. If Olson's bill passes, high school speech and debate classes may be one of the few chances students get to question presumptions and construct arguments.

Of course, it's possible that Olson and those behind the proposal that will eliminate the debate requirement don't want citizens to think but just do what they're told. If that's the case, then South Dakota needs more not fewer debate classes.

Sunday, December 2, 2012

State Oral Interp Festival Recap

Blogging has been light for the past few weeks for a few reasons, but the biggest was the effort to complete the tasks on the to-do list for hosting the SDHSAA State Oral Interpretation Festival. Fortunately, the administration, faculty, custodial and maintenance staff, and the food service staff at Yankton High School made the job easy. Lisa Scheve of the Yankton Convention and Business Bureau hosted a great hospitality lounge  and Julia Hussein and the Yankton Parents of Debaters did a marvelous job with concessions. Most importantly, fellow coaches Terri Mandel and Matt Termansen along with the YHS interp and debate students went above and beyond the call of duty to help everything run smoothly. When we host in the future, I'm going to get a lawn chair and sip some lemonade instead of worrying.

I'd like to highlight just a couple of other highlights from the weekend in no particular order:

1. Re-uniting with Darren Jackson, an impressive young man, who suffered through my classes for his entire high school career.

2. Catching up with Cory Heidelberger--one needs to read that term figuratively; no one can catch up with the indefatigable one who walks faster than any other human I have ever seen.

3. Seeing our cat spit his Friday morning pill into the opening of a Coke Zero can.

4. Watching some young'uns from Milbank High School, still wearing their competition dress clothes, use light sabers to complete an assignment over Othello.

I hope to resume regular blogging.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Today I Really Like Google Edition

Marissa Mayer, Goggle's "vice president of local, maps, and location services—and the driving force behind more than a hundred of Google’s products and services, including search, news, gmail, earth, books, and toolbar" just made my school year seem worthwhile.  In a Daily Beast interview, she asserts,
"One of the more interesting things they’ve found is that programming aptitude and excellence is more tied to verbal SAT scores than to math SAT scores,” she explained. “Beyond basic mathematical aptitude, the difference between good programmers and great programmers is verbal ability.”
Clarity of expression is something Mayer prizes so dearly that she uses it as a litmus test when evaluating new ideas. Disruptive technology should solve big problems and have widespread applications, but it should also be easy to understand. “I think about my mom,” she told Brown. “She’s very smart. She’s a little intimidated by technology. So when a new idea comes up, I think, ‘How would I explain it to her?’”

Saturday, December 3, 2011

It's The Little Things

The Madville Times has already indicated my disgruntlement about a new limitation at the SDHSAA State Oral Interpretation Festival/Tournament/Competition/Event.  I am a curmudgeon, even though my mother taught me that I should say nice things.  Tonight, I will listen to my mother and look at some good things that happen at this event.

First, two young women prepared pieces in events they don't really like in order for the team to participate in every event.  Both worked hard to get their pieces ready for competition.

Second, three sophomores got better throughout the season.  One earned a superior today.  The other two perform tomorrow. Seeing young students become accomplished practitioners of their craft makes it a little easier to get up in the morning.

Third, a senior in her second year of competition grew from a nervous young woman who seemed scared of her shadow last year to one of the most confident and polished performers on the team this year.

Fourth, having a skilled senior nail a performance and cover up my limitations as a coach is always humbling and rewarding.

Finally, seeing a first time performer recruited from the football team get into the part, become better each practice, and become a vital part of readers' theatre performance makes it hard to stay a curmudgeon for long.