Showing posts with label Public Intellectuals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Public Intellectuals. Show all posts

Friday, April 26, 2013

Where Will The Next Great Conspiracy Theory Come From?

Apparently, Ron Paul's Institute for Peace and Prosperity may become the home of those who specialize in  twisting a single fact into bad theories about how the world works. James Kirchick runs down the roster that will staff Paul's think tank.  Among the intellectual luminaries eccentric people Paul has hired, two stand out. One considers Abraham Lincoln a monster.
. . . Walter Block, an anarcho-capitalist professor of economics and fellow at the Mises Institute. Like many in Rockwell’s neo-Confederate circle, Block believes that the wrong side won the “war against Southern succession” and blames most of America’s current problems on “the monster Lincoln.”
 The other has the conspiracy theory down to an art.
Southwestern Law School professor Butler Shaffer, in an article for Rockwell’s site titled, “9/11 Was a Conspiracy,” asks, “In light of the lies, forgeries, cover-ups, and other deceptions leading to a ‘war’ in Iraq, how can any intellectually honest person categorically deny the possibility of the involvement of American political interests in 9/11?”
Read the whole thing.

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

An Anti-Intellectual Dog Whistle?

Wheaton Universiy's Allan Jacobs quotes this Claes Ryn piece:
Official professions to the contrary, many self-described American intellectual conservatives have a thinly veiled disdain for philosophy and the arts. Even among academics indifference to what lies beyond broad ideas and popular culture is common. The ruling assumption of the now dominant strains of intellectual conservatism seems to be that the crux of social well-being is politics: bad politicians ruin society; good politicians set it right. . . .
Many supposedly intellectual conservatives seem to consider ideas and culture from afar, as it were, feeling no deep personal need for or intimate connection with them. Some are in a way attracted to the arts or even to philosophical speculation, but see no significant and immediate connection between these and the life of practice. Ideas and the arts are mainly pleasant diversions. Many others have only slight interest in philosophy and culture for their own sake. More or less consciously, they tend to assess either thought or imagination from the point of view of whether it advances or undermines the political cause that they assume to be incontestable. Does the book, lecture, play, movie, or song help or hinder the cause? Although such works may enlighten or entertain, they do not strike these individuals as having intrinsic and independent authority. Works of thought and imagination are for them not intriguing and potentially unsettling forces that might trigger painful self-examination and unpredictably reconstitute one’s own accustomed views; making sense of them is not so much a matter of soul searching as of locating them on the political spectrum.
At the outset, let's stipulate that liberal politicians are not immune to seeing art or ideas as tools to further or hinder the cause. Still disdain for the pointy-headed intellectual seems to be a view held by more on the right than the left.

It does, therefore, make me curious if this Dakota War College post is an anti-intellectual dog whistle. Pat Powers takes after Matt Varilek ostensibly for being a an environmental zealot. The only quotation Powers uses, however, begins with a discussion of Varilek's two post-graduate degrees:
Matt will be pursuing a M.Phil degree in Environment and Development at Queens College where he will investigate how market mechanisms for environmental regulation, such as emissions trading, can be applied effectively in developing countries. This is not the first M.Phil that Matt has gotten. After spending a year as an environmental policy research assistant at the Biosphere 2 Center in Arizona, Matt studied at the University of Glasgow under a Rotary Scholarship. At Glasgow Matt did a dissertation on how to maximize developing country’s benefits from Clean Development Mechanism investment under the Kyoto Protocol in the Economic Development Program.
There are numerous ways to engage in the war of ideas. Dr. Blanchard does it well in this post on a series of Matt Ridley articles. Peter Heck does it poorly. In his post, Powers seems unwillingly to deal with the substance of the ideas; instead, he seems more concerned that Varilek has advanced degrees.

Varilek and Representative Noem have vastly different political views on environmental issues. Her supporters should engage the ideas instead of using dog whistles which are easy and cheap. For example, one could argue that Representative Noem's major environmental accomplishments have been her work on pine beetles and her efforts to carry water for Speaker Boehner, he of the orange face and inopportune weeping.

Saturday, August 25, 2012

A Minor Musing About The Lack Of Both Intellectuals And Community

Some people, when they wish to describe intellectuals derisively, claim that an intellectual is someone who cares more about ideas than people. That description may be shrugged off when the world is afloat an a sea of good ideas; it's damning when there's a dearth of good ideas. Rod Dreher illustrates that the United States currently faces the latter situation:
Liberal intellectuals have their own problems and challenges, of course, and I don’t care about them. For my side, it seems to me that conservative intellectuals have become so fossilized as a class because they responded to the two devastating shocks to the Standard Conservative Model by essentially doubling down on ideology. Just say the same old things, but louder and more insistently, and rely on tribalist instincts and hive-mindedness to marginalize dissenters, and that will carry the day. That, and the fact that liberalism hasn’t come up with a dynamic and compelling vision either for the post-Iraq, post-crash world — that is, a post-1980 world in which assumptions generally shared by both parties about American foreign policy and globalized capitalism have proven inadequate to the world as it is.
Of course, the people who damn intellectuals as uncaring elitists would contend that caring communities will thrive without the highfalutin pronouncements from the ivory tower. They can rely on friends and neighbors to get through the tough times together.  Writing in the Yankton Press & Dakotan, Kelly Hertz contends that sense of community seems to be shrinking as well:
It’s also possible that the small turnout reflected that aforementioned symptom: a growing lack of community within this community. We are seemingly becoming a lot of separate parts, not a unified whole, when it comes to such affairs.

But Yankton isn’t alone in dealing with this affliction, for this is what our 21st century society is becoming.
I'm hardly an intellectual, but I don't get out much, so I won't comment on the Yankton situation. It seems, however, that the entire country is becoming a bit more isolated at least economically:
Rising income inequality has led to a growing number of Americans clustering in neighborhoods in which most residents are like them, either similarly affluent or similarly low-income, according to a new study detailing the increasing isolation of the richest and the poorest.

A report released Wednesday by the Pew Research Center said the percentage of upper-income households situated in affluent neighborhoods doubled between 1980 and 2010, rising to 18 percent. In the same time frame, the share of lower-income households located in mostly poorer neighborhoods rose from 23 percent to 28 percent. The percentage of neighborhoods that are predominantly middle class or home to a wider mix of income levels shrank.
Communities are losing cohesion and rich and poor are becoming more segregated. Although the country may be less racially segregated, Mitt Romney is currently polling at 0% among African Americans. The only cohesive group seems to be intellectuals who are increasingly tribal but have have few ideas. In short, the only segment of the population that has community is one that should be providing ideas. It's good to know they are failing together.

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

South Dakota Republicans: Any John Birch Society Port In A Storm?

These are trying times. South Dakota's Senate Majority Leader and other Republican legislators are beset and bothered by postcards and robocalls. Leader Olson deems those behind the communication terrorists. The cards and calls claim that the Republicans are not true Republicans but merely Republicans in name only (RINOs).

Pat Powers, late of the South Dakota Secretary of State's office and founder of Dakota War College, a South Dakota Republican organ, has rushed to assure Olson and other afflicted Republicans of their conservative bona fides. This succor comes from the John Birch Society.

Somewhere the body and spirit of William F. Buckley must be mimicking a whirling dervish. Buckley laid the intellectual base for modern conservatism.  Geoffrey Kabaservice sums up the Buckley's view of the John Birch Society:
Nonetheless, in February 1962 National Review ran a six-page editorial against Welch, arguing that he was damaging the anti-Communist cause by “distorting reality” and failing to distinguish between an “active pro-Communist” and an “ineffectually anti-Communist liberal.” It would be several years before Buckley excommunicated all Birchers from the conservative movement, but his editorial emphasized that “There are bounds to the dictum, Anyone on the right is my ally.”
Recalling a meeting that led to the editorial,  Buckley quotes Russel Kirk, author of The Conservative Mind, one of contemporary conservatism's founding texts, volunteering to take a rather a rather direct approach when describing Robert Welch, the John Birch Society's founder:
What would Russell Kirk do? He was straightforward. “Me? I’ll just say, if anybody gets around to asking me, that the guy is loony and should be put away.”
Buckley died believing that he, Kirk, and others had dealt the death blow to the John Birch Society:
The wound we Palm Beach plotters delivered to the John Birch Society proved fatal over time. Barry Goldwater did not win the presidency, but he clarified the proper place of anti-Communism on the Right, with bright prospects to follow.
Paranoia is apparently more resilient than the brilliant Buckley realized. In South Dakota, the Republican party has apparently decided that allying itself with a political zombie is preferable to calling on its intellectual roots.

Buckley used "scorn and derision" to defeat the John Birch Society's paranoia fifty years ago. South Dakota Republicans have used those tools against Democrats; they can use them against those behind the robocalls and postcards. Instead they have chosen to ignore Buckley's injunction: "There are bounds to the dictum, Anyone on the right is my ally." They have chosen to accept the comfort afforded them by a group that true conservatives decried fifty years ago and ought to continue to denounce today.

Conservatism has well-developed and formidable intellectual base. South Dakota Republicans, through one of their most conspicuous organs, have chosen ignore that intellectual history.  Instead, they have decided to ally themselves with a paranoia that should have died long ago.

Thursday, October 20, 2011

A Dead Cult Leader Makes A Current List Of Overrated Thinkers

The New Republic has published a list overrated public intellectuals, including one dead "thinker."  The list includes some easy targets:  politicians Newt Gingrich and Paul Ryan, former New York Times columnist Frank Rich, and CNN's Fareed Zakaria.  It includes one person who had previously been unknown to me: Parag Khanna who is
“a frequent speaker at international conferences” who briefs “corporations on global trends, systemic risks and emerging market strategies.” He has hosted an MTV show, was the first video blogger at ForeignPolicy.com, and directs something called the “Hybrid Reality Institute.” His recent book is actually called How to Run the World. It is a self-congratulatory anthology of clichés and platitudes—the life of the mind, Davos-style.
The list also includes Rachel Maddow,someone I had never consider in intellectual.  The list does not include Sean Hannity, Bill O'Reilly, or the crew from Fox & Friends.  These inclusions and exclusions leave open the question of whether it is worse to be an overrated thinker or not be considered a thinker under any circumstance.

My favorite inclusion on the list, however, is the dead thinker, Ayn Rand who
earned her presence on this list by the astonishing persistence of her theories, which seem to have attained particular volume as of late, receiving endorsement from everyone from American Enterprise Institute President Arthur Brooks to Representative Paul Ryan (who supposedly requires his staffers to read Atlas Shrugged) to Wall Street Journal economics writer Stephen Moore (“‘Atlas Shrugged’: From Fiction to Fact in 52 Years,” he wrote). Despite the fact that Rand’s worldview is a crackpot Manicheanism, in which the world is divided between virtuous, productive individuals and lazy parasites, Rand’s hold on American conservatism continues to grow, as if real thinking is ever compatible with a cult.  (Emphasis mine for any of my Christian brothers and sisters who might erroneously believe she's compatible with Christianity)