Thursday, February 27, 2014

Is Rounds Beginning A Campaign For Junior High Student Council President?

Let's get two things straight off the top. First, I can foresee few instances that will allow me to vote for Mike Rounds. Second, South Dakota Legislators should debate and pass or defeat legislation that can become law not resolutions that have no practical effect.

Until yesterday, I thought Rounds voters could justify their vote for Smiling Mike because he is a slick politician. In fact, one might have argued that he is slick enough to play the Washington game like a Washington insider. Were he to use that skill to benefit South Dakota, a highly questionable but not totally unbelievable hypothesis, a South Dakotan could vote for Rounds and still sleep at night.

Yesterday, the Rounds camp showed that they are confused what office they're running for. Tim Rounds and Brian Gosch's procedural moves with Stace Nelson's "Let's Praise Ron Paul Because I Like Him Alot Resolution" is far closer to political games played by junior high school student councils than the political games played by politicians seeking to elect someone to the United States Senate.

Using a blood relative play "Poke the Stace And Get Him Mad" because it's so much fun is a bush league move. Are you all going to get together to see if you can make him cry when you walk home from school too?

I've got no reason to vote for Nelson, but there's one less reason to think about voting for Rounds. If one is going to build the campaign on one's ability to be a polished, competent insider and by extension paint one's most vocal opponent as an inept, loud bumbler, the one should have surrogates who don't play junior high politics.

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

A Minor Musing About Online Polling And Perception

Over at Madville, Cory has a poll asking his readers to pick South Dakota's best choice for governor. As I begin this post, Joe Lowe leads Susan Wismer 98-39. 

Let's be clear, if online polls were baseball players, their accuracy average would be well below the Mendoza Line. In this case, I doubt there's a groundswell of support for Mr. Lowe. Were I a gambler, I would bet a few Republican bloggers are spending the afternoon clearing their browsers' history and voting in the Chicago manner, early and often. (If they're using their laptops, they should use CCleaner ever so often. It's a free download that I highly recommend.)

These polls mean little. Still, Wismer made her announcement with South Dakota's Democratic establishment, such as it is, as props. If the Wismer people can't find a 12 year old to sit in front of his or her computer and keep her ahead of Joe Lowe in an online poll on the most Democratic blog in the state, they don't really understand the power of perception or organization. Appearing inept is sometimes worse than being inept

Oh by the way, Lowe now has 101 votes to Wismer's 39. A vote a minute is a pretty good online pace.

A Modest Proposal That Should Allow Businesses To Refuse Service To Anyone

I thought we were through with religious freedom/we don't want gay customers legislation after it met defeat in Kansas and South Dakota, but PNR brought up the issue yesterday and Cory responded. More importantly, Arizona is waiting for Governor Jan Brewer to decide what to do with Arizona's version of the bill*, so I guess this post is still timely.

First, let me say that I feel a bit sorry for my conservative businessperson friends. They spend their lives preaching the doctrine of self-reliance, but when a few gay people want to use their services or shop at their stores, they have no recourse but to beg for government assistance in order to refuse service. I can't imagine the angst that this conundrum must cause.

I, therefore, offer a modest proposal to ease the emotional distress: create your own religion. For example, one could establish the First Church of The Wedding Photographer and Baker. Some bakers might have problems with traditional Christianity. Jesus multiplied those loaves and Elijah helped the widow with the oil and flour. Neither miracle could have been good for the local bakers' bottom line. Photographers have, from time to time, had to deal with those folks who contend that photographs are nothing more than two-dimensional graven images.

Appropriately, there is a business set up to provide ordination credentials. Doctrines also exist that should serve these businesschurches: the concept of moral therapeutic deism should work well for most businessclergypersons. (That title might need a bit of work but being a blergyperson just doesn't have a good ring to it.) The doctrine's chief tenets are pretty straightforward.
1. A god exists who created and ordered the world and watches over human life on earth.
2. God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other, as taught in the Bible and by most world religions.
3. The central goal of life is to be happy and to feel good about oneself.
4. God does not need to be particularly involved in one's life except when God is needed to resolve a problem.
5. Good people go to heaven when they die.
Given that the term was first used in Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers  published in 2005, these businesschurches should be a hit with the coveted 18-29 demographic. Businesslogians (or is it theonessians) will have the thorny problem of determining whether coveting a demographic breaks the 10th commandment, but I doubt those concerns will affect their advertising campaigns adversely. More importantly, it doesn't seem to differ much from the discounted grace preached by megachurch luminaries like Joel Osteen.

This is too short of a post to deal with the tax issue, but I'm sure bureaucrats can work it out fairly quickly. Once that issue is solved, each businesschurch (I suppose they could be called busurches) can set up its own membership criteria and provide services to members only. As long as they don't get stupid and make everyone wear those jackets from the 90s, no one should complain.

*the post originally called the legislation a law, but Governor Brewer has not signed it. I should have been more careful.

Monday, February 17, 2014

Do South Dakota Republicans Really Want Someone To "Care For" Them?

Via Dakota War College, I see that Annette Bosworth has put out a campaign video that is as confused as her finances.



Let's ignore the Freudian undertones of an attractive woman in white lab coat offering to "care for you" and focus on the politics.

Bosworth, Larry Rhoden, and Stace Nelson are all attempting to position themselves to the right of front runner former Governor Mike Rounds. To be fair, that's the only viable strategy any of them have. The South Dakota Republican party has no primary voters to Rounds's left.

That fact makes this commercial odd. One would think sending someone to Washington to "take care of" South Dakotans would strike Republicans as nanny statism. Perhaps, the few holdouts who still yearn for the George W. Bush administration would see "compassionate conservatism." Neither philosophy seems to be something South Dakota's Republican base is clamoring to hear.

Maybe the tea party and libertarians have grown old and soft, but being taken care of by someone in Washington doesn't seem to make one think of the rugged individualism that South Dakotans claim to possess. If this year's legislative measures are any indication of how South Dakotans want to be taken "care of", all South Dakotans want are few more guns to carry into every building in the state.

Having someone in the U. S. Senate to "care for you" should have been a Rick Wieland tag line. Rounds, Rhoden, or Nelson should have no trouble using this ad to show libertarians and tea party members that Bosworth has no political core philosophy. Then all they have to do is overcome the voters' Freudian impulses.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Why The Death Penalty Needs To Be Abolished Edition

From this Andrew Cohen piece in The Week:
Last week was a memorable one in the annals of American justice. The national Exoneration Registry announced that 87 people were exonerated last year, a new record. From Brooklyn,The New York Times reported on a wrongful conviction scandal its editors called "a tidal wave that could dwarf other exoneration clusters." In Louisiana, Jerome Morgan walked out of prison after 20 years when a state judge found his murder conviction to be marked by "deception, manipulation, and coercion" on the part of the New Orleans Police Department. And an appellate court in Texas told death row inmate Larry Swearingen that he had no right to DNA test the murder weapon used in his case.
All of these stories, the good and the bad, remind us of the arbitrary and capricious nature of our nation's justice systems. Whether you are executed or not, whether you are wrongly imprisoned or not — it doesn't just depend on the evidence against you. It depends on your race and the race of the victim, on the political predilections of your prosecutor and your judge, on the honor of police detectives, on the accuracy of the eyewitnesses testifying against you, on the skill and competency of your defense attorney, and on the mercy of the governor who makes a judgment on clemency. Oh, and it depends on which state you live in and which county in that state.
Read the whole thing and then tell your legislator to support Rep. Steve Hickey and his efforts to repeal South Dakota's death penalty with HB 1138.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

What Headlines Will Bosworth's Campaign Receive In Traditional Media?

Messrs. Montgomery, Heidlebeger, and Powers have all illustrated that the Bosworth campaign bears a stronger resemblance to the film The Grifters than it does to Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.

The open question about her "interesting" finance report is whether it will affect the other Republican candidates. That answer will depend on the KELO, Argus, and Journal headlines. If the headlines read "Bosworth Raises $350,000," then candidates Nelson, Rhoden,  and Rounds need to worry. The total, even if it's been spent, will make Bosworth appear to be a legitimate candidate and the boys will have to start raising cash fast. 

If the headlines read "Bosworth Campaign Broke," Rounds can relax while Rhoden and Nelson fight over who will come in a distant second. 

There May Not Be Enough Of A Shrinking Middle Class To Gamble In Deadwood

The optimistic Representative Reverend Steve Hickey recently tweeted:
Perhaps he's correct: there's powerful magic in the words "If you build it they will come." Deadwood may have been constructed near a wormhole that connects to a corn field in Iowa, and people who travel through that wormhole may pay to watch Ray Kinsella play catch with the ghosts of his father and Shoeless Joe Jackson.

On the other hand, a recent Pew study shows there aren't as many middle class folk to come to Deadwood.
The proportion of Americans who identify with the middle class has never been lower, dropping  to 44% from 53% in 2008 during the first months of the Great Recession, according to a survey conducted Jan. 15-19. The share of the public who says they are in the lower or lower-middle classes rose by 15 percentage points, from 25% in 2008 to 40% today.
Further, many do not believe their lives will get better.
A Pew Research Center analysis of government data found that, since 2000, the middle class shrunk in size, fell backward in income and wealth, and shed some — but not all — of its characteristic faith in the future. 
Seth Michaels points out businesses seem to be ahead of the game.
As politicians and pundits in Washington continue to spar over whether economic inequality is in fact deepening, in corporate America there really is no debate at all. The post-recession reality is that the customer base for businesses that appeal to the middle class is shrinking as the top tier pulls even further away.
Businesses answer is to take steps to shrink the middle class even further.
As an employer like Darden Restaurants — owner of Olive Garden and Red Lobster — sees profits falling from their mid-priced outlets, it’s easier for them to shift focus to higher-end restaurants than pay Olive Garden employees enough to afford to eat there.
Deadwood is an indicator of a far larger problem that South Dakota's legislators seem willing to blithely ignore because it's easier to throw red meat about the evils of sin or seek simple solutions like selling more booze.