Showing posts with label Death Penalty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Death Penalty. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Quotation Of The Day: Why The Death Penalty Needs To Be Abolished Edition

From this Andrew Cohen piece in The Week:
Last week was a memorable one in the annals of American justice. The national Exoneration Registry announced that 87 people were exonerated last year, a new record. From Brooklyn,The New York Times reported on a wrongful conviction scandal its editors called "a tidal wave that could dwarf other exoneration clusters." In Louisiana, Jerome Morgan walked out of prison after 20 years when a state judge found his murder conviction to be marked by "deception, manipulation, and coercion" on the part of the New Orleans Police Department. And an appellate court in Texas told death row inmate Larry Swearingen that he had no right to DNA test the murder weapon used in his case.
All of these stories, the good and the bad, remind us of the arbitrary and capricious nature of our nation's justice systems. Whether you are executed or not, whether you are wrongly imprisoned or not — it doesn't just depend on the evidence against you. It depends on your race and the race of the victim, on the political predilections of your prosecutor and your judge, on the honor of police detectives, on the accuracy of the eyewitnesses testifying against you, on the skill and competency of your defense attorney, and on the mercy of the governor who makes a judgment on clemency. Oh, and it depends on which state you live in and which county in that state.
Read the whole thing and then tell your legislator to support Rep. Steve Hickey and his efforts to repeal South Dakota's death penalty with HB 1138.

Thursday, January 2, 2014

Plains Pops: Items That Warm The Heart On a Cold Night Edition

Representative Hickey's lucid explanation of why South Dakota's death penalty needs to be repealed. A pdf is here.

Adam Smith, the economist conservatives love, thought poetry important.
The role of language is an essential component of Smith’s moral philosophy because it is the fundamental connection between the individual and the community. In his Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres, Smith expounded on the virtue of both poetry and prose, which “provide the capacity for exchange and agreement” in different contexts of human relations. It is in the sections of Adam Smith’s Pluralism on the importance of language that Shaftesbury’s influence on Smith shines through the strongest, particularly with Shaftesbury’s stress on language as a vehicle for unifying “the good and the beautiful.”
On a less serious note, the Minnesota Twins will open Spring Training in about six weeks. Pitchers and catchers report on February 16. Although I'm a bit skeptical, some experts like the Twins off season moves. Hope springs eternal.

Finally, Andrew Sullivan posts this video of Peanuts going Punk.




Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Good News: Hickey To Introduce Bill To Repeal Death Penalty In South Dakota

After my week in the South, I'm catching up on South Dakota blog reading. The best reading to date is South Dakota legislator Representative/Reverend Steve Hickey's announcement he will introduce a bill to repeal the death penalty in South Dakota.

I've long opposed the death penalty because humans are fallible. If a jury convicts an innocent person who is sent to prison, there are ways to compensate that person for time, pain, and suffering. There's no way to return someone to life.

Additionally, I have yet to see a consistent explanation of why giving the state the power to kill doesn't convey upon it the power to take away every other natural right at a whim. Further, there's little evidence of a deterrence.

I doubt the bill will pass this session, but I hope that it will begin a debate that will end the death penalty  in South Dakota within a decade.

Sunday, January 1, 2012

Barbara Walters Gets Her Own Color

Rod Dreher posts this little tidbit on his blog at the American Conservative:
Have you ever heard of the color “Barbara Walters Beige”? You have now. I’m told by a friend who works at Angola State Penitentiary, which is in the northern part of West Feliciana Parish, that a few years ago, Barbara Walters did a show from the lethal injection room at the prison. In doing pre-production prep work, she decided that the color of the paint on the wall did not flatter her skin tone. So she had her own people come in and repaint the walls of the death chamber to go better with her skin. At the prison, the new death chamber color is informally referred to as “Barbara Walters Beige.”
I may be reading too much into this anecdote, but this little event, if true, says a lot about America's cult of celebrity and cavalier attitude toward retribution.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Troy Davis And The Death Penalty

Will Wilkinson sums it up best.
The point, I would submit, is to enforce and reinforce not only the good rules of liberal order, but also the humane ethos of liberal civilization. We punish to deter. We punish to acknowledge the harm brought to the victim, to their loved ones, to their community. We punish to shame and to publicly dishonor the criminal. But the way we do it should embody ideals of humanity, magnanimity, and improvement. Punishment thus should be as light as is consistent with the requirements of security and harmonious society. We must learn, against the grain of our vengeful retributive instincts, to find satisfaction in justice that leaves the thief with his hands, the murderer with his life.
Troy Davis didn't need to be killed in order to achieve any of the goals of a civilized system of criminal justice. Nobody needs to be killed to do that. That's why the people of decent societies oppose the death penalty. The folks at the GOP debate in Tampa who cheered for Texas' record of execution under Rick Perry showed just how indecently uncivilized America remains. But sooner or later enlightenment will dawn and we'll stop perversely killing in the name of justice. Let's hope the killing of Troy Davis helps make it sooner.
I wish I could be as optimistic as Wilkinson, but reading the comments on this Madville Times post makes me believe that states will kill more innocent people.