Wednesday, June 26, 2013

DOMA Decision: Best Tweets Of The Day

James K. A. Smith, a professor of philosophy at Calvin College, sent out a historical reminder:

John Fugelsang calls out a bit of hypocrisy:

Good News: Hickey To Introduce Bill To Repeal Death Penalty In South Dakota

After my week in the South, I'm catching up on South Dakota blog reading. The best reading to date is South Dakota legislator Representative/Reverend Steve Hickey's announcement he will introduce a bill to repeal the death penalty in South Dakota.

I've long opposed the death penalty because humans are fallible. If a jury convicts an innocent person who is sent to prison, there are ways to compensate that person for time, pain, and suffering. There's no way to return someone to life.

Additionally, I have yet to see a consistent explanation of why giving the state the power to kill doesn't convey upon it the power to take away every other natural right at a whim. Further, there's little evidence of a deterrence.

I doubt the bill will pass this session, but I hope that it will begin a debate that will end the death penalty  in South Dakota within a decade.

Quotations Of The Day: Common Core History Edition

First, there's this history lesson from Valerie Strauss who responds to Secretary of Education Arne Duncan:
The Core initiative was started in 2007 by the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers, a bipartisan effort to come up with a common set of K-12 standards in English language arts and math across states that would better prepare students for colleges and careers than in the past.
The standards were written by school reformer and entrepreneur David Coleman, who now heads the College Board, and Susan Pimental of Achieve Inc., an organization created to advance “standards-based” education.  Starting in 2009, the Obama administration, in its main education initiative, required states that wanted to compete for Race to the Top reform dollars to adopt the standards. It also gave some $360 million to two consortia of states developing standardized tests aligned to the Core, exams whose results would be used to evaluate teachers, another controversial part of the Obama reform agenda.
Later she writes,
Duncan, in his speech to the newspaper editors, said the federal government didn't start or write the standards, and that is true. He said that it wasn't mandated either, though critics argue that it was coerced. He was also right when he said the Core is not a curriculum (even though the Core authors released a book of criteria to education publishers about what should be in Core curriculum).
But he didn't mention the rushed implementation, nor the hundreds of millions of dollars the federal government has plowed into the testing creation effort. He has said for years that the Core-aligned tests would be “game changers” and be able to assess students much more broadly,  but he didn't say Tuesday that that isn't true. It turns out there wasn't enough time or money to create those kinds of tests.
Diane Ravitch quotes Strauss and then sums up the Core's history:
Another angle: the Gates Foundation plowed more than $100 million into every aspect of the Common Core: the development, the evaluation, the implementation, the advocacy, on and on.
It seems that most of the nation’s grassroots are growing in Seattle, then watered inside the Beltway.

The Ties That Divide

Will Wilkinson provides a quotation of the day,
The energetic ideological base of the Republican Party is a nationalist, identity-politics movement for relatively well-to-do older white Americans known as the "tea party". The tea party is interested in bald eagles, American flags, the founding fathers, Jesus Christ, fighter jets, empty libertarian rhetoric, and other markers of "authentic" American identity and supremacy.
A similar list could be made for the Democrats' ideological base. Off the the top of my head, there's a list of "D" words that interest Democrats: discourse, diversity, the downtrodden.

Of course, there are two important caveats. First, Democrats are also interested in the founding fathers and Jesus, and Republicans are interested in the downtrodden. More importantly, these interests aren't really about the diversity or fighter jets; they're about the respective base's ideas about what each of these things are and what each represents.

That latter caveat helps explain the country's political stalemates and cultural divides. Empty libertarian rhetoric combined with discourse about discourse produces nothing but empty discourse. It's difficult to use religion to find agreement on basic principles when one side sees Jesus as a moral philosopher who loved the poor while the other sees Jesus as a Rambo who destroys sinners. The founders are equally malleable figures.

It's worrisome that these divides will continue to perpetuate current stalemates. It's nearly impossible to work on immigration, taxes, health care, education, or, more importantly, be an "indivisible" nation, if no one can agrees on the basics.

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Plains Pops: The More Things Stay The Same Edition

I spent last week in Birmingham, Alabama judging some congressional debate and eating some good barbecue at a place called Moe's. The food was so good that I didn't even think about a Homer Simpson joke until two days later.

I came back to lots of humidity that I would have liked to have left behind and what seems to be the same news cycle I left.

1. Rick Weiland is still running an ineffective campaign.

2. South Dakota's conservatives are still looking for an alternative to Mike Rounds in the U.S. Senate race.

3. Congress is still unable to function. The young folks I judged are better speakers and legislators than the folks elected to Congress. They are able to debate and dispose of legislation far more quickly and logically than the folks in DC.

4. One quick prediction, the South Dakota conservatives will frame the effort to replace Tony Post as a struggle for the soul of the party.

Monday, June 17, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Reading Literature Helps One Deal With Ambiguity Edition

From this Tom Jacobs piece at Salon:
Are you uncomfortable with ambiguity? It’s a common condition, but a highly problematic one. The compulsion to quell that unease can inspire snap judgments, rigid thinking, and bad decision-making. 
Fortunately, new research suggests a simple anecdote for this affliction: Read more literary fiction.
A trio of University of Toronto scholars, led by psychologist Maja Djikic, report that people who have just read a short story have less need for what psychologists call “cognitive closure.” Compared with peers who have just read an essay, they expressed more comfort with disorder and uncertainty—attitudes that allow for both sophisticated thinking and greater creativity.
Researchers offer the following reasons why fiction has this effect on readers but non-fiction does not.
“The thinking a person engages in while reading fiction does not necessarily lead him or her to a decision,” they note. This, they observe, decreases the reader’s need to come to a definitive conclusion.
“Furthermore,” they add, “while reading, the reader can stimulate the thinking styles even of people he or she might personally dislike. One can think along and even feel along with Humbert Humbert in Lolita, no matter how offensive one finds this character. This double release—of thinking through events without concerns for urgency and permanence, and thinking in ways that are different than one’s own—may produce effects of opening the mind.” 

Friday, June 14, 2013

Plains Pops: Travel Edition


I am traveling to Birmingham, Alabama with one of my debaters who qualified in congressional debate, so posting will be light and erratic. Also, I am trying a new phone ap, so I don't know if the font will match. If necessary I'll try to fix things when I return. It may also take me a day or two to respond to comments

I'll offer a few observations about what I have seen today as we passed through areas south of Kansas City.

First, South Dakota cattle look healthier than most of the cattle we passed.

Second, I'm sure the folk who live in the towns we have driven through love Jesus, but their churches look like warehouses. I'm not sure what I think about warehousing Jesus. (I know He doesn't live in the buildings, but.  . . )

Third, I am travelling with another coach and his students. We need to get the young'uns travelling with us to eat grits in a Waffle House. Their education will be incomplete if we don't.