Thursday, February 7, 2013

Statistic Of The Day: Fair And Balanced Becomes Divisive And Distrusted Edition

The Daily Beast flags a Public Policy Poll about citizens' trust in television news. The results show an unsurprising divide.
Among Democrats, 72 percent trust PBS, with only 11 percent in the distrust category. Following next were NBC (61 percent trust, 16 percent distrust); MSNBC (58 to 19 percent); CBS (54 to 16 percent); CNN, . . .  (57 to 21 percent); ABC (51 to 16 percent), and—yes—Comedy Central (38 to 28 percent).
Among Republicans, 27 percent trust PBS and 48 percent distrust it. Following next were NBC (18 to 66 percent); CNN (17 to 66 percent); ABC (14 to 70 percent); MSNBC (12 to 68 percent); CBS (15 to 72 percent), and Comedy Central (8 to 66 percent).
According to the poll, 46% of the respondents mistrust Fox News; however, "Democrats trust most television news other than Fox, and Republicans don’t trust anything but Fox."

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Quotation Of The Day:Andrew Bacevich May Turn Me Into A Conservative Edition

From this post at The American Conservative:
Well, I’ll admit to prejudices, so let me lay them out.
(Fans of Ayn Rand or Milton Friedman will want to stop reading here and flip to the next article. If Ronald Reagan’s your hero, sorry—you won’t like what’s coming. Ditto regarding Ron Paul. And if in search of wisdom you rely on anyone whose byline appears regularly in any publication owned by Rupert Murdoch, well, you’ve picked up the wrong magazine.)
The conservative tradition I have in mind may not satisfy purists. It doesn’t rise to the level of qualifying as anything so grandiose as a coherent philosophy. It’s more of a stew produced by combining sundry ingredients. The result, to use a word that ought warm the cockles of any conservative’s heart, is a sort of an intellectual slumgullion.
Here’s the basic recipe. As that stew’s principal ingredients, start with generous portions of John Quincy Adams and his grandson Henry. Fold in ample amounts of Randolph Bourne, Reinhold Niebuhr, and Christopher Lasch. For seasoning, throw in some Flannery O’Connor and Wendell Berry—don’t skimp. If you’re in a daring mood, add a dash of William Appleman Williams. To finish, sprinkle with Frank Capra—use a light hand: too sweet and the concoction’s ruined. Cook slowly. (Microwave not allowed.) What you get is a dish that is as nutritious as it is tasty
Niebuhr and Lasch challenge and are as relevant today as ever. A student gave me a single volume collection of Henry Adams works. His life in politics was, to put it mildly, fascinating. I admit that I don't recall reading anything by Williams or Bourne. Further, Capra is cloying, but every thinking person should read O'Connor's short stories annually.

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Let's Fold The Flag In The Applebee's Parking Lot

There once was a pastor in St. Louis who went to Applebee's as a member of a group of ten. The restaurant, as many do, added an 18% gratuity to the bill because the group was larger than six. The pastor then crossed out the gratuity on the bill and wrote that she gives God 10 percent, so the server should not expect more than God. The server's co-worker photocopied the bill and posted it on Facebook. She was subsequently fired at the pastor's urging. After the story broke, a bunch of people want to boycott Applebee's.

There was once a school janitor in Fort Pierre who got mad that a fellow custodian was not folding the American flag but rather leaving it in clump.  He claims to have complained to his superiors. After not getting a response he posted pictures of the flag on Facebook. He was fired.  A South Dakota blogger got mad became obsessed.

I have a 4 point modest proposal.

1. When tempted to post stuff online in order to get even, wait at least 24 hours before hitting submit or publish or whatever the heck Facebook asks you to hit so that the item gets published. (I have no Facebook account because I don't want people to find me, or I'm worried no one will want to find me. The reason changes daily.)

2. Play by the rules when out in public. There are rules for folding the flag and tipping. Both are published.

3. Read the Bible's book of James at least once a week, especially these verses from Chapter 1:
19 My dear brothers and sisters, take note of this: Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry, 20 because human anger does not produce the righteousness that God desires.
4. Listen to some Aretha

Quotation Of The Day: Politics And Christianity Edition

From C.C. Pecknold:
In our post-election reflections, Christians should be the ones asking the really substantial questions, not the ones asked at our very insubstantial presidential debates – but the questions we would want our children to ask: questions about existence, such as why there is something rather than nothing; about justice, and to whom it is owed; about truth, and making ourselves truthful; about the nature of goodness and how we can be formed in accordance with it. Questions like these are pre-political, but they matter for politics too. If these sorts of question whither, we will get the politics we deserve. Amongst ourselves as well as with others, we must be asking what it means to be a Christian in our excessive, polarized, political order.

HT: Rod Dreher


Sunday, February 3, 2013

The NRA Hates Hallmark

In Septemember, the NRA published an enemies list. The list includes dastardly folk like the American Medical Association and the American Psychological Association. I'm guessing both groups might expand the number of people deemed too mentally unstable to buy a firearm.

The list also includes Hollywood luminaries like Kevin Bacon whose character asked for a gun from the FBI on a recent episode The Following.

My personal favorite is a member of the list of Anti-Gun Corporations/Corporate Heads: Hallmark Cards. I'm guessing it's because Hallmark didn't publish a card with doggeral like

Roses are red
Violets are blue
We got shotguns at our wedding
And so can you



A Post Wherein I Try To Explain To Gordon Howie That Reading Skills Matter

Mr. Howie is alarmed that South Dakota is not one the ten most conservative states according to a recent Gallup poll:
This once conservative state simply seems to have disappeared. Even the respected Gallop organization reports that South Dakota is missing!!
In a study of top ten conservative states done by Gallop, South Dakota is simply NOT THERE. Some of our neighbors made the list. Wyoming, North Dakota and Nebraska made the top ten, but for conservatives in South Dakota… some sad news… You didn’t make it to the playoffs!
Conservatives in South Dakota are probably not surprised by this sad news. We have seen the expulsion and dismissal of conservatives escalating for the past few years.
Howie than goes on to castigate South Dakota's leaders for not being conservative enough:
Most South Dakota Republicans are still good, conservative folks. They just don’t seem to be watching while their leaders and elected officials take them farther and farther down the path of more government, more regulation and higher taxes. 
The Gallup poll that Howie refers to did not examine states' regulatory or tax policies; instead, it was based on residents' self identification:
Alabama, North Dakota, and Wyoming were the most conservative states in the union in 2012, with between 49% and 50% of residents in each identifying their ideology as conservative. Residents of the District of Columbia were by far the most likely to identify as liberal (41%), followed by Massachusetts (31%), Oregon, and Vermont (each at 29% liberal).[emphasis mine]
In short, South Dakota did not make the top 10 most conservative states because a smaller percentage of South Dakotans than North Dakotans say they are conservative. When it comes to policies North Dakota has a state owned bank; one can't get much more collectivist than that.

South Dakota didn't rank as one of the most moderate states:

http://www.gallup.com/poll/160196/alabama-north-dakota-wyoming-conservative-states.aspx
Nor did it make the list of liberal states:

http://www.gallup.com/poll/160196/alabama-north-dakota-wyoming-conservative-states.aspx
Had Howie bothered to go to page two of the Gallup report, he would have found that 41.6% of South Dakotans self-identify as conservative; 35.8% self-identify as moderate, and 19.9% self-identify as liberal.

Howie concludes:
While Gallup didn’t just survey Republicans, this alarming decline to the left has happened as moderates have taken control of the Republican Party.
It seems Howie doesn't have a problem with moderates or liberals; he has a problem with the idea of representative democracy. The poll indicates that moderates and liberals outnumber conservatives 58.4% to 41.6%. If South Dakota has become more moderate, a fact that Howie asserts but does not document, shouldn't the policies become more moderate as well?

I think Gallup's numbers for moderates are at least 5% too high, but that's the risk of relying on self-identification. What the poll doesn't show is South Dakota lurching to the left.
Update: Madville has a take here. I don't know who hit publish first. Cory probably did. I'm a lousy typist.

Friday, February 1, 2013

I Seriously Want An Answer To These Questions

The Second Amendment absolutists are out in full force at Dakota War College. I have asked these questions in other forums but never got a direct answer so I hope some Second Amendment absolutists will give me an answer here.

1. Why are so many gun rights advocates willing to go after Hollywood and the manufacturers of violent video games? Is the Second Amendment absolute but the First Amendment is not?

2. I find stands against government tyranny commendable. Where were all of the gun groups when the Patriot Act was passed? That act has done more to endanger freedom than any gun law.

3. In the same vein, where is the outcry over warrentless wiretaps of cell phone conversations? The 4th Amendment still requires a warrant doesn't it?

4. I have heard some Libertarians scream about the fact that we are engaged in two armed conflicts without a formal Declaration of War, but where's the broader conservative outrage? In fact, where's the outrage over the standing army that the Founders expressly wanted to avoid?

5. Why do gun rights folks think people like me unpatriotic when we ask questions about the Patriot Act, warrantlesswiretaps, undeclared wars, or standing armies but want to avoid leaving a world where everyone can conceal carry?