Monday, January 21, 2013

Quotation Of The Day: Inequality And Opportunity Edition

From this Joseph Stiglitz commentary in the New York Times:
Our skyrocketing inequality — so contrary to our meritocratic ideal of America as a place where anyone with hard work and talent can “make it” — means that those who are born to parents of limited means are likely never to live up to their potential. Children in other rich countries like Canada, France, Germany and Sweden have a better chance of doing better than their parents did than American kids have. More than a fifth of our children live in poverty — the second worst of all the advanced economies, putting us behind countries like Bulgaria, Latvia and Greece.
Our society is squandering its most valuable resource: our young. The dream of a better life that attracted immigrants to our shores is being crushed by an ever-widening chasm of income and wealth. Tocqueville, who in the 1830s found the egalitarian impulse to be the essence of the American character, is rolling in his grave.

A Little Humor For The NFL Playoffs


Sunday, January 20, 2013

Scripture And Song Of The Week: Second Timothy Edition

2 Timothy 1
KJV
7 For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind.

A Minor Musing About Devolution And The Gun Debate

Every year I sit down with young Lincoln-Douglas debaters, and we discuss two views of the social contract. The debaters only have thirteen minutes to present their position and refute their opponent's position on any issue, so we flatten some deep ideas a bit more than we should, but the debaters are at least exposed to texts and ideas that are foundations of America's political discourse.

We discuss Locke's view that humans left the state of nature and created society to preserve the products of their labor and that Locke wanted individuals to preserve as much liberty as possible. I usually throw out Ben Franklin's famous statement: "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."

We also discuss Hobbes's premise that the state of nature was a time when humanity lived "without a common power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which is called war; and such a war as is of every man against every man." In the state of nature, Hobbes contends the"life of man, [is] solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." Hobbes then goes on to advocate a much larger state than Locke.

Both believed that society had moved beyond the state nature. Yet, the current gun debate in United States seems predicated on the idea that America is the devolving or soon will devolve back to the state of nature. Last week, on ABC's This Week, Peggy Noonan asserted:
Yes, two things I'd like to say, one is that people are buying guns like crazy now. Not because they're nutty, not enough because they're angry, but because I really think they fear their country is falling apart.
It's defensive and it's something that I think we all have to be talking about. There's so much anxiety out in America. And they also fear their government.
I find the idea that banning guns will keep me safer confusing. I have the same risk of dying in an automobile accident as I do dying as a result of gun violence, and no one is talking about banning cars.

I also find the idea of arming teachers or expanding exponentially the number licences to carry concealed weapons confusing.  I doubt that stocking my house with guns will make me safer. First, the government has drones and tanks.  I have neither.  Second, a lot of private citizens can afford more guns and ammunition than I can. I will certainly lose nearly every arms race

Third, and most importantly, I also teach a unit on the Trojan War. Now that I'm closer to age 60 than I am to age 50, this passage resonates:
And maybe you ask, what was Priam’s fate.
When he saw the end of the captive city, the palace doors
wrenched away, and the enemy among the inner rooms,
the aged man clasped his long-neglected armour
on his old, trembling shoulders, and fastened on his useless sword,
and hurried into the thick of the enemy seeking death
In the centre of the halls, and under the sky’s naked arch,
was a large altar, with an ancient laurel nearby, that leant
on the altar, and clothed the household gods with shade.
Here Hecuba, and her daughters, like doves driven
by a dark storm, crouched uselessly by the shrines,
huddled together, clutching at the statues of the gods. . . .
So the old man spoke, and threw his ineffectual spear
without strength, which immediately spun from the clanging bronze
and hung uselessly from the centre of the shield’s boss.
Pyrrhus spoke to him: “Then you can be messenger, carry
\the news to my father, to Peleus’s son: remember to tell him
of degenerate Pyrrhus, and of my sad actions:
now die.” Saying this he dragged him, trembling,
and slithering in the pool of his son’s blood, to the very altar,
and twined his left hand in his hair, raised the glittering sword
in his right, and buried it to the hilt in his side.
This was the end of Priam’s life: this was the death that fell to him
by lot, seeing Troy ablaze and its citadel toppled, he who was
once the magnificent ruler of so many Asian lands and peoples.
A once mighty body lies on the shore, the head
shorn from its shoulders, a corpse without a name.
I will never be "a magnificent ruler," but in any armed struggle, I am much more likely to wind up like Priam than I am to survive.

I have long thought that Constitution was written by men blessed with genius. They understood that Hobbes may have correctly analyzed what happens when humans live without limits or controls, but they believed that humans had God-given reason and should be allowed to preserve as much liberty as possible just as Locke advocated.  Hence, the Bill of Rights expresses the goal that people should be secure in "their persons, houses, papers, and effects." The people were recognized as having reason, a tool necessary to live their faith in the public sphere, express their opinions, gather together peaceably, and petition the government for redress of grievances, acts that do not rely on brute force.

The current gun debate seems to illustrate that the founders were wrong; humans, at least those with the loudest voices in the gun debate have lost all sense of reason. In fact, both sides seem to wish to submit to fear, an emotion devoid of reason. If these loud voices have their way, the devolution into a world in which lives are nasty, brutish, and short can't be far behind

Thursday, January 17, 2013

I Read It But I Still Don't Believe It: Kucinich To Join Fox News

From this International Business Times report:
Dennis Kucinich, the former Ohio congressman and Democratic presidential candidate, has taken a job as an analyst with Fox News. Kucinich’s first appearance with the network will be on Thursday night’s episode of “The O’Reilly Factor.”

The IBT report does not indicate whether Fox News plans to let Kucinich speak when he appears.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Can The Young'uns Be Made All Right?

I've spent the better part of the past three days writing letters of recommendation for scholarships, and, a new recommendation experience for me, prep school admission. That fact may help explain why this Alan Jacobs paragraph has had a disconcerting impact:
It’s often said that the current generation of twentysomethings are distinctively narcissistic, but the available evidence strongly suggests that that is not true: any narcissism that has set in to American society set in forty or more years ago, just as Christopher Lasch told us. But if they’re not any more narcissistic than their predecessors, these young people do often seem bereft of a moral vocabulary with which to assess their lives — and, perhaps equally often, they seem to be craving such a vocabulary. For that lack they have no one but their elders to blame.

Jacobs is certainly correct that they young'uns don't have the tools to access their lives. They know how to take pictures and post the photos to Facebook, but they don't know how to explain why the smiles are plastic. They know how to say they are bored but they are confused by concepts such as angst or ennui. If they can't express emotion, it's difficulty for me to believe they examine their moral or spiritual condition or can explain to anyone what they believe that condition to be.

I also worry that the "elders" will continue to fail the young'us. Some of my fellow educators remain so concerned with students' self esteem that they forget that pain is a necessary to improve one's self physically, intellectually, and spiritually. Some of my uber-bosses advocate Common Core and believe that STEM has saving properties. They, unfortunately, dominate state and federal departments education. Their efforts to remove from the curriculum the novels, myths, and poems that gave most of us the vocabulary we use to describe our moral selves will exacerbate the problem. Tech manuals don't build one's moral vocabulary, and I doubt that anyone will have the time to assign Lasch's work.

Many seem to believe that the 1950s were bland, but at least everyone understood the pathos inherent in James Dean's admontion to live fast, die young, and leave a beautiful corpse. I'm not sure that the young'uns today can express that pathos. What's more frightening is that I'm not sure that they want to.


Thursday, January 10, 2013

Depressing Stat Of The Day: Half Of The World's Food Is Thrown Away

From Britain's The Independent,
As much as half of all the food produced in the world - two billion tonnes worth - ends up being thrown away, a new report claims.
The waste is caused by poor infrastructure and storage facilities, over-strict sell-by dates, "get-one-free" offers, and consumer fussiness, according to the Institution of Mechanical Engineers.
Each year countries around the world produce some four billion tonnes of food.
But between 30% and 50% of this total, amounting to 1.2 to two billion tonnes, never gets eaten, says the report Global Food; Waste Not, Want Not.
Larry might have to cast a wider net to catch all fo the Earth haters or to paraphrase a rather famous polical statement: we're all Earth haters now. That's not something we should wear as a badge of honor.