Saturday, September 15, 2012

Two Major Reasons That Politics Is Broken: Flattery And Lies

A frequent commenter at the Madville Times contends that politics is about knowing ones audience and telling them what they want to hear. That sort of pandering has created all sorts of problems and prevented the United States from solving many of its problems.

People naturally seem to want to hear that they're wonderful. Andrew Sullivan points to an Andrew Polasky post that illustrates the dangers of flattering voters:
Flattery and pain don’t mix well. After all, if we the people have been as dedicated and selfless as our leaders tell us we are, then we cannot possibly be responsible for the mess we’re in. And if we have been so virtuous, surely we should not be asked to pay (through reduced benefits, higher taxes, or both) to clean up the situation. ... Flattery works as a political tool, but a public that has been told only of its goodness will not understand why it should be penalized for its virtue. When the American people wake up the morning after the great political seduction, they will have a nasty hangover.
If one is worried about the effects of flattery, one can always just tell people whatever pops into one's mind even if those thoughts are lies. Conor Friedersdorf posts about a Karl Rove effort that takes one of Obama's sentences and twists it beyond recognition:
You'd think it would be uncontroversial to note that, for a lot of folks a bit farther down the income scale, certain moments in life aren't the best time to blow a lot of money on a Las Vegas binge. So when President Obama said in 2010, for example, "You don't blow a bunch of cash in Vegas when you're trying to save for college," fair to say he's expressing a truism, rather than casting aspersions on wining, dining, gambling, Celine Deon, or performance artists covered in blue.   

Enter Karl Rove's political ad factory, a shop of hackery so shameless it sees common sense and reacts with attacks like this:


The promises of bread and circuses cannot be long in coming.

Quotation Of The Day: Bob Dylan Poet? Edition

From this Ian Bell post:
Writing about all of this, I reached a couple of rough conclusions. First, it seemed to me that the 'problem' of Dylan and poetry was poetry’s problem. It stands as a difficulty, in other words, for those who claim to define the form, even by a process of elimination, in an age that has witnessed the collapse of formalism.
Second, I thought I could see and hear something inherent to recent American verse in Dylan’s performances of the words. It struck me that there is a line of descent from the 'stepped triadic' of William Carlos Williams, to Ginsberg’s 'breath unit', to 'Like a Rolling Stone'. There is an identifiable tradition at work, in other words, one founded ultimately in American speech.
How do you arrive at a major literary artist, one who in no sense compares with the standard songwriter, one who employs the strategies, allusiveness and metaphorical density of poetry, yet who isn’t – cannot be? – a poet? As I say, the arbiters of verse have a problem, not least in the era of 'open form'. The name of the problem is Bob Dylan.
HT: Prairie Progressive




The Middle Class Loses Unless It Makes $200,000 Per Year

I know that the poor people have refrigerators and cell phones. Therefore, according to some, they should just chill and call someone who cares.

This chart from Andrew Sullivan's blog shows that it's not just the poor who are falling behind; it's everyone not in the upper 20 percent.

Sullivan also quotes Jared Bernstein who points out that the chart shows that for many growth has been a spectator sport.

Bernstein invokes one of my favorite debate phrases when he calls the chart "stark reminder that when it comes to the living standards of middle- and low-income families, overall economic growth is necessary but not sufficient."

I'll add another favorite phrase that has become repeated so often that it is being reduced to a cliche: "insanity is doing the same thing over and over but expecting different results." The policies that led to these results have been in place for decades, but no one seems willing to change them. At best, politicians from both sides of the aisle come up with new names for legislation that will continue this trend.

I'm sure Mitt Romney will want to bet me $10,000 dollars that I'm wrong. He'll also tell me that middle income is $250,000 when that figure really puts one in the top 5%, the cohort that actually has experience growth

Friday, September 14, 2012

A Minor Musing About Rounds And "Profit Is Not A Dirty Word"

Pat Powers previews former Governor Mike Rounds's talking points as Rounds explores a U.S. Senate candidacy. The former Governor will apparently be testing the tweetable clause: "Profit is not a dirty word." It's unclear if Rounds will try to appropriate the music that accompanies the Billy Joel lyric "honesty is such a lonely word" or just repeatedly utter the phrase while standing in front of church choir humming "The Battle Hymn of the Republic."

Rounds, like many politicians, is offering a solution in search of a problem. No one considers profit a dirty word; many, however, consider profit a get out of jail free card. One needs look no further than the investment bankers whose schemes ushered in the recession that bottom 80% hasn't recovered from. None has faced any consequences for scamming investors and regulators.

The new talking point is confusing for another reason:. Rounds could just use a tried and true line that would have the virtue of being more honest.





Roger Ailes Throws Christian Right Under Bus

Writing in USA Today, Steve Deace fills in the gaps:
On Tuesday, News Corp. chieftain Rupert Murdoch, who oversees the parent company of Fox News, tweeted the following:

"Election: To win Romney must open big tent to sympathetic families. Stop fearing far right which has nowhere else to go."

My translation: Romney should embrace homosexual "marriage" just as the Democrats have, and publicly betray the Christians who have done most of the heavy lifting for the Republican Party since 1980 (not to mention making up most of the audience for Fox News). Just sell out these sad saps as we're about to, and they'll put up with it because the Democrats don't want them either.
I've long warned my Christian friends who vote conservative that they were nothing more than political cannon fodder. It's still surprising, however, to see them so publicly dismissed.




Thursday, September 13, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: 1950s Nostalgia Edition

E.J. Dionne asserts that the Western World is seeking to return to the 1950s.
But understanding politics now requires an appreciation for the nostalgic roots of our current struggles. It’s not hard to understand the yearning of many of Romney’s supporters for past cultural certainties. Obama’s coalition is, in cultural terms, the coalition of the future — younger and both ethnically and racially diverse. Yet Obama’s core pledge is to a new social compact that provides many of the guarantees of the old one.
Thus the choice in 2012 may be, more than we realize, about which parts of the 1950s we yearn for most, and whether there is any way to bring back the best aspects of an old era while leaving the rest of it behind.


Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Why Don't Billionaires And Politicians Want Students To Think?

Jan Carr, a self described "scrappy public school mom" points out that real education is more than a bubble test; she rightfully asserts that a complete education is "inextricably entwined with books, literature, writing, and the life of the mind; it develops critical thinking." She also asks some questions I would like to hear answered:
For me, many years later, the task is this: determine the bias of those currently attempting to bury our public education system in data and testing requirements. One motivation is obvious: there’s profit to be made. If education can be wrested from the classroom – from teachers, principals, and other actual educators – and the focus shifted to cold data and analysis, then tech companies and faux educational corporations can gorge themselves at the public trough. Hey, if it looks like greed and smells like greed, it’s greed! But there’s another, underlying motivation. It seems no accident that prominent among those who would hijack our nation’s public education system are powerful billionaires such as Eli Broad, Bill Gates, Michael Bloomberg, and Rupert Murdoch. . . . Why do they want students reduced to a string of data, our kids to fill in bubbles, not learn to think? Perhaps because kids who think critically will ask questions, key questions. For instance, why is there an increasing and radical disparity of wealth in our nation? And who exactly controls our nation’s political system now that corporations are free not only to pour money into lobbying, but also to anonymously contribute boatloads of bucks to political campaigns?

To have a real democracy one needs an educated populace. Why don’t these billionaires want our kids to think critically? And why are they trying to bust the union that serves and protects our nation’s schools? What exactly are they afraid of?

HT: Diane Ravitch