Thursday, May 10, 2012

A Little Perspective Would Be Helpful

Yeah, I'm going to be the guy that ruins everyone's party.

Now that President Obama either has been canonized as Saint Barack I or has been consigned to the 10th circle of Hell for his same sex marriage evolution, I'll point out that he's still got a terrible record on K-12 education and civil liberties.  By the way, Mitt Romney would probably be worse on both.

A few days ago, Conor Friedersdorf compared Obama to Lucy as she holds the football for Charlie Brown to kick.  He concludes,
Obama has a whole roster of would-be kickers, and a habit of teeing up the ball only to callously pull it away.

Don't progressives see this? 
•Obama tricked the cannabis community into thinking his Justice Department would go easy on medical marijuana in states where it is legal, broke his promise, then misled voters about his options.
•Obama tricked anti-war voters into thinking that he wouldn't order American troops into battle unless there was an imminent threat to America or a declaration of war from Congress, then went to war in Libya, violating the War Powers Resolution, even though neither condition was met.
•Obama tricked transparency advocates into thinking he'd celebrate whistleblowers and set new standards in open government. He has prosecuted whistleblowers as aggressively as any president in history, and presided over a dramatic escalation in what the federal government does in secret.
•Obama tricked executive-power critics into thinking he would roll back the excesses of the Bush Administration. He has transformed those excesses into matters of bipartisan consensus, and gone farther in some respects, as when an American citizen was killed extra-judicially on his order.
•Obama tricked immigration-reform advocates into thinking he was a fellow traveler, then upset them with Secure Communities, record-breaking deportation levels, and a failure to improve immigration detention.
•Obama tricked Iraq War opponents into thinking that he would exit the country by the withdrawal date that George W. Bush negotiated. The Iraqi government wouldn't let him keep troops in the country beyond that date, although he tried to break his promise. Now the Obama Administration pays a small army of private-security contractors to protect America's presence in that country.
•Obama tricked critics of indefinite detention into thinking that he abhorred the practice, only to sign a bill that institutionalized it.
•Obama tricked critics of signing statements into thinking he wouldn't issue them. But he's done so on many occasions.
•Obama tricked critics of the state-secrets privilege into thinking he'd reverse Bush-era uses of the tactic. Instead he's continued it.
Presidents and Congress have been stealing our civil liberties since 9/11, if not before, by distracting us.  It happened again yesterday.

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

On Education Issues It's RomBama Or OBamNey

The lede from this Fiscal Times article sums it up.
On the surface at least, President Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney see eye to eye on a number of key education issues:
Both politicians place great store in standardized testing to evaluate teacher performance and student progress, and both generally back former President George W. Bush’s No Child Left Behind program. Both favor charter schools as an alternative to failing public schools and merit pay to attract better teachers. And both have had their run-ins with teachers unions.
The rest of the article discusses their more substantive differences on student loans.

At the K-12 level, however, the only difference seems to be that Obama wants to spend more money.  Does that fact mean Pearson will support Obama?


Quotation Of The Day: Creativity And Artistic Vision Edition

From this Charles Murray essay in the New Criterion:
To generalize my argument regarding the importance of the transcendental goods, I believe that when artists do not have coherent ideals of beauty, their work tends to be sterile; when they do not have coherent ideals of the good, their work tends to be vulgar. Without either beauty or the good, their work tends to be shallow. Artistic accomplishment that is sterile, vulgar, and shallow does not endure.

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

The Light At The End Of The Tunnel Is A Probably A Train

South Dakota Secretary of Education Melody Schopp has announced members of the HB 1234 work groups.

The first few lines of the Johnny Cash classic come to mind: the train is a comin' and the policies will come from people who sit in back rooms and smoke big cigars.


Damn, Cash was a genius,

Plains Pops: Ayn Rand Taken Out To Her Logical Foolish Conclusion

Over lunch I ran across an Ayn Rand trifecta.

First, this comment and some that follow on a Madville Times thread.

Then, there's the advice of Ayn Randers. The first conversation reveal Ayn at her loving best.
Dear Ayn,
I’m dating a man who I think I love, but I’m afraid he’s having an affair. He comes home late, he acts suspiciously, and he even has red lipstick on his collar. Should I confront him or just hope for the best?
— County Affair
Dear County,
Red lipstick? Your husband is a communist. Divorce him and sell his clothes, children, and pens to make money to spend on cars, human slaves, and bigger pens. This will simultaneously stimulate the economy and punish the slaves for not having jobs. Slaves: what lazybones!
Hope this helps,
Ayn
The second illustrates her talent at delivering a witty rejoinder.
Dear Ayn,
I don’t mean to be offensive, but your writing is overwhelmingly juvenile and one-note. How did you become such an influential figure, a cornerstone of the landscape of American conservative politics? You write like a petulant child.
—Hollis Hurlbut, Professor of Comparative Literature, Harvard University

Dear Hollis,
Your mom’s juvenile.
Hope this helps,
Ayn
HT: Rod Dreher


Finally, there's this story of successful parenting using Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged.  The key paragraphs:
Since the day Johanna was born, we’ve worked to indoctrinate her into the truth of Objectivism. Every night we read to her from the illustrated, unabridged edition of Atlas Shrugged—glossing over all the hardcore sex parts, mind you, but dwelling pretty thoroughly on the stuff about being proud of what you’ve earned and not letting James Taggart-types bring you down. For a long time we were convinced that our efforts to free her mind were for naught, but recently, as we’ve started socializing her a little bit, we’ve been delighted to find that she is completely antipathetic to the concept of sharing. As parents, we couldn’t have asked for a better daughter. . . .
After all, we’ve managed to raise a bright, self-reliant girl who achieves her goals by means of incentive and ratiocination and never—or very rarely—through the corrupt syllogism of force. We know, despite what you and a number of other parents we’ve met have said—as they carried their whimpering little social parasites away—that Johanna’s defiant, quasi-bellicose nature only superficially resembles that of an out-of-control toddler, and in truth posits her as more of a latter-day Dagny Taggart than any kind of enfant terrible.
Yes, she’s blossomed into everything we ever hoped or post hoc rationalized she would. In our house we no longer say, “Who is John Galt?” Instead we say, “Who’s our little princess?”
HT: David Mills 

Why There's No Longer Any Useful Public Policy Debate

David Brooks begins his analysis of current economic policy arguments by observing,
The country is divided when different people take different sides in a debate. The country is really divided when different people are having entirely different debates.
 Brooks's analysis is correct and serves the purpose of his column, but it doesn't go far enough.  This Steve Martin clip illustrates some problems that Brooks misses

First, there's the labels: caf, de-caf, half-caf.   Brooks himself has to label one side as "structuralists" and the other as "cyclicalists."  Brooks's dichotomy pales beside labels people claim for themselves: liberal, conservative, paleo-con, neo-con, progressive, or left-leaning libertarian.  Then there's the ad hominem labels: communist, facist, Kenyan anti-colonial Alinskyite, corporatist, globalist, new world order supporter, RINO, DINO, Christianist, theocrat, or New Ager.  If anyone needs more examples,  head over to the Madville Times and look for Steve Sibson comments.  Nearly every thread has a few new labels.

In public policy debates, the first impulse is to defend the person from one's camp and oppose the person from the other camps. As people become more narrowly defined, it becomes easier to ignore and attack potential solutions because the person proposing the idea wears the wrong label.

Second, there's the problem of agreement.  Everyone wants the lemon.  In the political world, everyone wants to spend more on the military than the next 10 top spending nations combined.  Public policy makers also seem to agree that governments, schools, and in some cases, churches need to be run like businesses.  No one seems be able to explain how those institutions that aren't designed to make a profit are supposed to emulate profit making institutions.

I have a modest proposal.  First, all public policy discussion must mention only the contents of the plan.  Second, everyone disagrees with everything.  Third, everyone orders only black coffee.  The last one is negotiable.  I doubt anyone will advance these proposals.  After all, I'm just an educrat working in a government school indoctrinating children in theocratic Alinskyite fascism. Next week, someone will call me a new-age RINO corporate socialist.


Monday, May 7, 2012

Some Items That Make Me Feel Really Old

First, this news and photo from the Washington Post.
George Lindsey, who made a TV career as a grinning service station attendant named Goober on “The Andy Griffith Show” and “Hee Haw,” has died. He was 83.
The Marshall-Donnelly-Combs Funeral Home in Nashville said Lindsay died early Sunday morning after a brief illness.
Lindsey was the beanie-wearing Goober on “The Andy Griffith Show” from 1964 to 1968 and its successor, “Mayberry RFD,” from 1968 to 1971. He played the same jovial character on “Hee Haw” from 1971 until it went out of production in 1993.
“America has grown up with me,” Lindsey said in an Associated Press interview in 1985. “Goober is every man; everyone finds something to like about ol’ Goober.”
As a 54-year-old perpetual adolescent who still loves comics, I can identify with the last sentence.


From a picture of an everyman to a picture of an artist as a young man.  From The Atlantic, this picture of a very young Sir Paul McCartney.