Wednesday, January 4, 2012

A Quick Musing On Why Being Displaced Sucks

I think I have a sense of empathy with Iowa Republican voters.
Before the Iowa Caucuses, David Brooks wrote,
The Republican Party is the party of the white working class. This group — whites with high school degrees and maybe some college — is still the largest block in the electorate. They overwhelmingly favor Republicans.

It’s a diverse group, obviously, but its members generally share certain beliefs and experiences. The economy has been moving away from them. The ethnic makeup of the country is shifting away from them. They sense that the nation has gone astray: marriage is in crisis; the work ethic is eroding; living standards are in danger; the elites have failed; the news media sends out messages that make it harder to raise decent kids. They face greater challenges, and they’re on their own.
The Republicans harvest their votes but have done a poor job responding to their needs. The leading lights of the party tend to be former College Republicans who have a more individualistic and even Randian worldview than most members of the working class. Most Republican presidential candidates, from George H.W. Bush to John McCain to Mitt Romney, emerge from an entirely different set of experiences.
Last evening according to this New York Times article
Republicans appeared sharply divided between those whose top priority is defeating President Obama and those seeking someone representing traditional conservative principles and religious values, according to a poll of voters entering the Iowa Republican caucuses on Tuesday. . . .

Self-identified Tea Party supporters made up almost two-thirds of caucus attendees. But they did not appear to favor any one candidate by a large margin. Rick Santorum, the former Pennsylvania senator, received about 30 percent of their support.
In short, 75% of the voters voted against winner, and 70% of those who would seemingly be natural Santorum voters turned against him.

This pattern Brooks predicts will lead the United States to vote in another "election that is Harvard Law versus Harvard Law."  I'm not opposed to the idea of intellectual folk being in charge.  Plato may have been on to something with his philospher kings. 

I can however emphathize with Republicans who have trouble finding a candidate that shares their values.  I'm not looking forward to choosing between Republicans who seem to gearing up for a
war with Iran and a Democrat who Conor Friedersdorf reports
imprudently empowered the executive branch: the fact that President Obama himself concedes as much. "I want to clarify that my Administration will not authorize the indefinite military detention without trial of American citizens," he said in a statement released when he signed the bill. "Indeed, I believe that doing so would break with our most important traditions and values as a Nation." Put another way, our shortsighted president, knowing his own intentions, has assured us that he won't exercise powers in the bill that he regards as un-American, but doesn't mention that the restraint he vows won't bind future presidents one bit.
When it comes to choosing between war mongering imperialists and civil liberty denying imperialists, the choice between Harvard Law and Harvard Law doesn't looks so bad until one notices that both Harvard Law guys are the imperialists.
You'd think a litmus test presidents would use when bills come across their desk would be, "Does this empower my successors to do anything that would break with America's most important traditions and values?" You'd think if the answer were yes, prudence would demand a veto. But Obama has signed a bill that fails that very litmus test. This reflects badly on his judgment.

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Indie Teacher Edition

I want to teach like an indie listener. I want to be open to quality ideas, regardless of how indie or mainstream they may seem. I want to hear about what works. I want to listen to ideas from public and charter and homeschool and unschool as long as it moves me and makes me think and ultimately transforms my practice.
I want to teach like an indie artist. I want to be a teacher who does something different, not for the sake of novelty, but because it is meaningful. I want depth, not for intellectual snobbery, but out of a desire to think well about life. I want to remember that it's not about being noticed, but about doing what matters.
 I blogged about Spencer's earlier use of the term here.  This updated definition raises the bar.

A Snapshot Of Rural America

Rod Dreher points to this Chad Oldfeather post about Oldfeather's Minnesota hometown.  Much of the post reminds me of my North Dakota hometown and what I have found on recent visits back.
A place where I walked into a store over twenty years after I had left and conversed with the cashier like I’d been there the week before and would undoubtedly be back sometime soon. Folks generally don’t greet one another with a handshake where I am from, and I think that’s because handshakes are for people who enter and leave your life rather than for those who are part of the community and therefore always around.


The people of this community – my people – are by many measures deeply conservative. A lot of what I took from growing up is that you work hard and you don’t complain and you say the Pledge of Allegiance and mean it and you go to church and mean it. But I also learned that education is important. (To refer to it as public education would, in this context, be redundant.) And that while you don’t ever want to be seen looking for a handout, if you see that somebody’s car is stuck in the snow you stop and help push them out. . . .


I write this from a distance, with all the advantages and disadvantages that confers. . . .         [M]y direct experiences as a resident featured me as an insecure, self-absorbed, and generally disagreeable teenager. But even accounting for the distorting effects of my perspective, it is clear that the people . . . .have cared about their community. They kept their houses up. They paid enough in taxes to have nicely paved streets with curbs and gutters and sidewalks, and to build what in retrospect was undoubtedly more water tower than they needed when the old one started leaking. They funded a school system that punched well above its weight in terms of fancy degrees earned by its graduates, even though getting fancy degrees was not the point, and even though that good school led to opportunities for their kids that were almost always somewhere else. . . .
The lone remaining grocery store has been through a couple periods of municipal ownership to keep it going. (Some might call that socialism. I think the folks back home would call it doing what needs to be done.). . . .
Too often, in the circles I now tend to find myself in, I am part of conversations in which I hear a casual disdain for rural people. I find the prejudice inherent in these comments every bit as misguided as the prejudices the speakers seem to imagine all rural people harbor. No doubt there are small places where many or even most – it is never all – of the people hold views that we should rightly condemn. But I can assure you they are not all that way, and I am skeptical of the suggestion that there are even all that many that are that way.
I don't want to wax too idyllic about small town America.  Like Dreher, I understand that Mayberry never was real:
It won’t do to replace one flawed vision with another. This is one reason I find Garrison Keillor’s Lake Wobegon stories so interesting is that he manages to write with affection about the people in his fictional small town without sentimentalizing them (well, without overly sentimentalizing them), or ignoring their flaws and foibles. I find that people who denounce the “Mayberry” view of small towns (charming, folksy, etc.) tend to do so with some sort of agenda. Of course Mayberry is a lie! But who actually believes in Mayberry? Nobody who actually lives in a small town, unless they’re some sort of kook.
Even with that caveat, small towns seem to give more than they demand of their expatriates.

Monday, January 2, 2012

Modern Technology Makes Classic Comic Books Creepy

I don't know enough Freud, Jung, sociology, philosophy, history, art, Nietzsche, or Nitschke to make sense of this.


IO9.com has more here and here.

Plains Pops: Quitting While Ahead Edition

I found this CNN opinion article discussing Tony LaRussa's decision to retire after winning the World Series with the St. Louis Cardinals interesting.  The contrast between the Beatles and Michael Jordan was provocative, but these paragraphs really caught my eye:
There is one kind of resolution, though, that very few of us will ever be in a position to make.

Somewhere today, someone at the very pinnacle of his or her career is thinking of doing in 2012 what Tony La Russa did in 2011:

Get out on top.

Willingly walk away and declare victory
The cynic in me wonders if people don't quit on top because they never get to the top or because being on top in a normal career doesn't offer enough financial security.

On a slightly happier note, Jim Kleinsasser retired on his terms after a 13 year career with the Minnesota Vikings.  As a fellow North Dakota native, I have always rooted for Kleinsasser who may have been one of the best blocking tight ends of the past twenty years.  I do wish they would have targeted him for a chance at one pass completion.

Finally, gamblers seldom get out while ahead, so the increase in Power Ball ticket prices may cause problems for some.  I voluntarily tax myself about $25-$50 a year playing Power Ball. I get as much entertainment value out of it as I do taking my wife out to a movie.  If I buy popcorn and soda, the movie probably costs $30.  Still, South Dakota uses scratch games and Power Ball to generate revenue by taxing the most gullible; this price increase may cause trouble for some.

2012 Resolutions

I'll start with the boring albeit necessary ones everyone makes: eat better, exercise more, be more frugal.

I want to read more.  I think I'm going to try reading a fiction and non-fiction book every month.  I also want to read the daily reading from The Intellectual Devotional and A Year With Thomas Merton.  I want to check in on John T. Spencer and Alan Jacobs more regularly than I have during the past year.

I should do a better job of using time shifting tools like Hulu and DVR to watch TV.

I would like to listen to music a little more.

I need to do a better job of responding to social emails and keeping in touch with people.  I also need to call my mother more.

I need to find the tools to calm down; worrying is depriving me of time and energy.

Finally, I need to write more concisely and proofread better before I hit publish.  I need to upgrade my snark game a bit too.

Sunday, January 1, 2012

Barbara Walters Gets Her Own Color

Rod Dreher posts this little tidbit on his blog at the American Conservative:
Have you ever heard of the color “Barbara Walters Beige”? You have now. I’m told by a friend who works at Angola State Penitentiary, which is in the northern part of West Feliciana Parish, that a few years ago, Barbara Walters did a show from the lethal injection room at the prison. In doing pre-production prep work, she decided that the color of the paint on the wall did not flatter her skin tone. So she had her own people come in and repaint the walls of the death chamber to go better with her skin. At the prison, the new death chamber color is informally referred to as “Barbara Walters Beige.”
I may be reading too much into this anecdote, but this little event, if true, says a lot about America's cult of celebrity and cavalier attitude toward retribution.