Thursday, January 13, 2011
An Uncomfortable Personal Question
Which is worse: the fact that the so-called History Channel spends so much time broadcasting programs about Nostradamus or the Maya calendar and its alleged prophecy about the end of world or the fact that I spend so much time watching them?
Labels:
Is it Weird Enough?,
Personal question
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
A Great Education Editorial
Everyone should read this Robert Samuelson editorial.
The quotation no one will believe:
The quotation no one will believe:
The most pessimistic view of the study is that, on average, American schools do as good a job as schools in other wealthy nations. We're worse than some and better than others. The overall loss of economic competitiveness is likely modest and would be swamped by other factors (government policies, business management, exchange rates, the willingness to take risks). But a more detailed evaluation of the study - comparing similar students in different countries - suggests that U.S. schools still rank high in the world. [emphasis mine]The perceptive conclusion:
For half a century, successive waves of "school reform" have made only modest headway against these obstacles. It's an open question whether the present "reform" agenda, with its emphasis on teacher accountability, will do better. What we face is not an engineering problem; it's overcoming the legacy of history and culture. The outcome may affect our economic competitiveness less than our success at creating a just society.The statement Governor Daugaard will use to justify paying math and science teachers more than English, history, music, or art teachers:
American schools are hardly perfect. Math scores, though showing the same pattern, are lower than reading scores. We can learn from other countries better ways to teach math.I would guess that this last statement will become one of the holy texts of science and math religion.
Labels:
Education,
math and science
Monday, January 10, 2011
Teachers and Students and Texting
The Madville Times ended 2010 with a post that the Brookings School District is considering banning teachers and students texting each other, following each other on Twitter, friending each other on Facebook, or using any social media to communicate with each other.
Apparently, Virgina will see one South Dakota district and raise a whole Southern state. In addition, they will ban student teacher gaming as well, so my online poker reference my not be legal in Virgina either.
I don't have too many dogs in this fight. I don't have a Facebook account and am actively working to be the only person in the United States without one. I have a Twitter account. I've made 150 posts, none since October. I text some of my debaters to let them know about practice times or discuss case ideas. At a tournament a few years ago, I couldn't find a debater and had to text her to tell her she was in the final round.
I also know that some people hired to teach are wolves in sheep's clothing so schools need to be careful. That being said, these rules are ludicrous and unenforceable. They will insure that teachers appear out of touch with the "real world." Some teachers and students will be punitively punished for innocent communication. More importantly, the predators will find new ways to exploit kids.
The logic behind limiting teachers' use of social media seems akin to an effort to prevent a teacher in 1901 from using an Underwood No. 5 typewriter because the machine allowed one to write letters quickly and anonymously without revealing one's identity through one's handwriting. Instead of banning social media or texting, schools need to find ways to teach students how to use these tools as adults not as expensive toys.
Apparently, Virgina will see one South Dakota district and raise a whole Southern state. In addition, they will ban student teacher gaming as well, so my online poker reference my not be legal in Virgina either.
I don't have too many dogs in this fight. I don't have a Facebook account and am actively working to be the only person in the United States without one. I have a Twitter account. I've made 150 posts, none since October. I text some of my debaters to let them know about practice times or discuss case ideas. At a tournament a few years ago, I couldn't find a debater and had to text her to tell her she was in the final round.
I also know that some people hired to teach are wolves in sheep's clothing so schools need to be careful. That being said, these rules are ludicrous and unenforceable. They will insure that teachers appear out of touch with the "real world." Some teachers and students will be punitively punished for innocent communication. More importantly, the predators will find new ways to exploit kids.
The logic behind limiting teachers' use of social media seems akin to an effort to prevent a teacher in 1901 from using an Underwood No. 5 typewriter because the machine allowed one to write letters quickly and anonymously without revealing one's identity through one's handwriting. Instead of banning social media or texting, schools need to find ways to teach students how to use these tools as adults not as expensive toys.
Labels:
Social Media,
Teaching
Sunday, January 9, 2011
A Teacher's View of the Giffords' Shooting
I also want to echo the sentiments of John Spencer Spencer's Scratch Pad: State of Fear. His winning argument,
I don't blame Sarah Palin for what happened, but I do believe that symbols take on powerful meanings and far too much of her rhetoric has been fascist. I don't blame the Republican Party, either. Many of my friends and family members are GOP and they aren't joining a terrorist movement. They simply believe in small government and national security.
Bottom line is that this isn't about politics.It's about death.
It's about racism and bigotry.
It's about an ideology that sees anything public as a threat to anything individual.
Real World Interruptions
I had hoped to have daily updates after Friday posts, but certain real life activities like a debate tournament followed by an unplanned five and half hour trip prevented posting.
I want to echo The Madville Times contrast between high school debate and the increasingly, dangerously weird world of American politics.
I found ABC's The Week's roundtable discussion rather fascinating. I thought Dick Armey seemed to be whistling past the graveyard as he eschewed "pop sociology." I thought George Will's hope that this one is closer to Columbine rather than Oswald or John Wilkes Booth interesting, but hollow; no matter the reason, scores of people have been killed or wounded in similar shootings since 1999.
I want to echo The Madville Times contrast between high school debate and the increasingly, dangerously weird world of American politics.
I found ABC's The Week's roundtable discussion rather fascinating. I thought Dick Armey seemed to be whistling past the graveyard as he eschewed "pop sociology." I thought George Will's hope that this one is closer to Columbine rather than Oswald or John Wilkes Booth interesting, but hollow; no matter the reason, scores of people have been killed or wounded in similar shootings since 1999.
Labels:
rhetoric
Friday, January 7, 2011
2011 Week 1--The Good, The Bad and The Scary
I survived the first week of the new semester with few wounds. I haven't blogged much since school started, but I really would like to get back to regular posts, so I thought I'd begin with something that can become a recurring post.
The Good: Bert Blyleven finally got elected to Major League Baseball's Hall of Fame. How it can take 14 years for someone who has struck out over 3700 hitters to gain entry to Cooperstown is beyond me.
The Bad: South Dakota may cut funding to K-12 education by 10% instead of 5%.
The Scary: The South Dakota Retirement System will run out of funds by 2035.
The Good: Bert Blyleven finally got elected to Major League Baseball's Hall of Fame. How it can take 14 years for someone who has struck out over 3700 hitters to gain entry to Cooperstown is beyond me.
The Bad: South Dakota may cut funding to K-12 education by 10% instead of 5%.
The Scary: The South Dakota Retirement System will run out of funds by 2035.
Labels:
The Bad and The Scary,
The Good
Monday, October 11, 2010
Yet Another Restart
School started. Papers piled up. I got tired or rushed or something I didn't post. More importantly, I didn't really think about much serious stuff. I didn't really think about anything except grading essays and quizzes. I did veg out in front of the TV a bit, but vegetating and thinking ain't the same. It's tough to blog if one doesn't think first, even if the thinking is about something frivolous.
Last week, I got to return to the Plains. The little drip necessitated my being by myself in a car for at least 14 hours. I actually got to think a bit. The topics changed, but every train of thought seemed to come back to the same question: what the heck are we doing?
On the political front, I saw dozens of commercials in two states. Ninety percent took the same tone. My opponent is out of touch with residents and therefore evil. I guess it's no longer possible to disagree agreeably.
According to a Slate article, classrooms need to change for the 21st Century. the contrarian in me forced me to think about he minimal tools I would need to get the job done. It turns out that I could live with 19th and 20th Century tools.
Students would need to bring paper and writing tools. I would need some sort of chalkboard. Whiteboards are nice, but each board basically is place to write notes so that students can copy them. I think I could teach all the classes I need to with with the following literature.
A Doll House
Ken Burns The Civil War mini-series
Macbeth
Some random collections of Superman, Spider-Man, and The Avengers.
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
The Bible
The Big Sleep
The Complete Flannery O'Connor
The Complete Robert Frost
The Iliad
The Killer Angels
The Odyssey
I believe these works have relevance and would allow for great discussion and writing assignments. The classroom doesn't have to be high tech. It has to have tools that teachers and students can use.
Last week, I got to return to the Plains. The little drip necessitated my being by myself in a car for at least 14 hours. I actually got to think a bit. The topics changed, but every train of thought seemed to come back to the same question: what the heck are we doing?
On the political front, I saw dozens of commercials in two states. Ninety percent took the same tone. My opponent is out of touch with residents and therefore evil. I guess it's no longer possible to disagree agreeably.
According to a Slate article, classrooms need to change for the 21st Century. the contrarian in me forced me to think about he minimal tools I would need to get the job done. It turns out that I could live with 19th and 20th Century tools.
Students would need to bring paper and writing tools. I would need some sort of chalkboard. Whiteboards are nice, but each board basically is place to write notes so that students can copy them. I think I could teach all the classes I need to with with the following literature.
A Doll House
Ken Burns The Civil War mini-series
Macbeth
Some random collections of Superman, Spider-Man, and The Avengers.
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
The Bible
The Big Sleep
The Complete Flannery O'Connor
The Complete Robert Frost
The Iliad
The Killer Angels
The Odyssey
I believe these works have relevance and would allow for great discussion and writing assignments. The classroom doesn't have to be high tech. It has to have tools that teachers and students can use.
Labels:
comics,
Contrarianism,
School Reform
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)