Showing posts with label Contrarianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Contrarianism. Show all posts

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Echo Chamber Edition

From this John T. Spencer post:

I am quick to point out that social media seems to push people toward extreme echo chambers. I sort Facebook by relevance. I choose Twitter friends who are teachers. I blog about education. However, these echo chambers have always existed. Whether they were Rotary Clubs, churches, neighborhoods, political parties or social clubs, they were always echo chambers.
I'm still concerned about echo chamber. However, I'm beginning to see that an echo chamber is often simply a community with shared values. Often, echo chambers become  a place to hash out the nuance on shared ideas. We need a few homogeneous spaces to let us geek out about interests that we share with others. It is part of thinking deeply about a topic. True, they can get myopic. However, it takes a certain level of narrow-mindedness to delve deeply into an idea.

It isn't always a bad thing to connect with others based upon shared experiences, interests or values. It only becomes dangerous when it becomes the only definition of "normal" or when it turns tribalistic toward outsiders. So maybe the solution isn't to bash the group. If I want to make a difference, I need to enter into other echo chambers and ask questions, tell stories and challenge the presuppositions of each community.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Yet Another Restart

School started.  Papers piled up.  I got tired or rushed or something  I didn't post.  More importantly, I didn't really think about much serious stuff.  I didn't really think about anything except grading essays and quizzes.  I did veg out in front of the TV a bit, but vegetating and thinking ain't the same.  It's tough to blog if one doesn't think first, even if the thinking is about something frivolous.

Last week, I got to return to the Plains.  The little drip necessitated my being by myself in a car for at least 14 hours.  I actually got to think a bit.  The topics changed, but every train of thought seemed to come back to the same question:  what the heck are we doing?

On the political front, I saw dozens of commercials in two states.  Ninety percent took the same tone.  My opponent is out of touch with residents and therefore evil.  I guess it's no longer possible to disagree agreeably.

According to a Slate article, classrooms need to change for the 21st Century.  the contrarian in me forced me to think about he minimal tools I would need to get the job done.  It turns out that I could live with 19th and 20th Century tools. 

Students would need to bring paper and writing tools.  I would need some sort of chalkboard. Whiteboards are nice, but each board basically is place to write notes so that students can copy them.  I think I could teach all the classes I need to with with the following literature. 

A Doll House
Ken Burns The Civil War mini-series
Macbeth
Some random collections of Superman, Spider-Man, and The Avengers.
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
The Bible
The Big Sleep
The Complete Flannery O'Connor 
The Complete Robert Frost
The Iliad
The Killer Angels
The Odyssey

I believe these works have relevance and would allow for great discussion and writing assignments.  The classroom doesn't have to be high tech.  It has to have tools that teachers and students can use.