Showing posts with label Teaching Tools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teaching Tools. Show all posts

Monday, August 12, 2013

A Minor Musing Wherein I Ask Advice About Teaching

I'm getting ready for the upcoming school year. As always, I want students to learn to write more concisely. (Insert your own "Do as I say, not as I do joke here.).

This morning Alan Jacobs, a Baylor University professor, tweeted the following series that made me think about trying to use Twitter as a tool.

Trying to put complex ideas in a series of 140 character sentences requires careful word choices especially if one cannot use "2" for "to" or "b4" for "before." Jacobs illustrates that one can easily create a series of events that can become a paragraph. Certainly dealing with Pascal or reducing a key thinker's main idea to a tweet requires careful thought.

Further, Twitter seems to be growing as primary source of news. Major news sources tweet, post, and broadcast simultaneously. One can certainly gauge reactions to events by following trending hash tags.

On the other hand, most people seem to believe that Twitter is still reserved for status updates: "I'm watching Colin Cowherd on ESPNU, writing a blog post, and petting my cat." That perception will cause a few emails to be sent to the boss's office. Further, unless things have changed dramatically, web filters will block Twitter and getting anything unblocked takes God, Congress, and 47 scissors to cut the mountain of red tape. YouTube became available for teachers at my school last just last year.

So Jacobs makes a great point, but I'm left with questions. Are parents willing to accept their students using Twitter or do parents believe it's the ultimate time waster? Most importantly, is it worth the effort to get Twitter unblocked so that I can use it in the classroom?

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Sunday Confession: Wrath At A Fellow Teacher Edition

Bless me readers, for this morning I have committed the sin of wrath. I read these paragraphs:
A high school English teacher in New York state who had students pretend to be Jew-hating Nazis in a writing assignment has been placed on leave.
The teacher at Albany high school caused a storm of criticism after having students practice the art of persuasive writing by penning a letter to a fictitious Nazi government official arguing that "Jews are evil".
I had a moment of charity when I thought that this is a rookie teacher, but "[t]he district has not named the teacher, who was described as a veteran."

It was at that point that I uttered "how can anyone be so stupid and still breathe?" I may also have used a few words that are not safe for work, but I did not take the Lord's name in vain.

The goals of the assignment could have been met with a dozens of  prompts that do not smack of antisemitism.
For the assignment, the teacher asked students to research Nazi propaganda, then write a letter trying to convince an official of the Third Reich "that Jews are evil and the source of our problems".
"Review in your notebooks the definitions for logos, ethos, and pathos," the teacher's assignment said. "Choose which argument style will be most effective in making your point. Please remember, your life (here in Nazi Germany in the30s) may depend on it!"
Perhaps, the teacher should have read this recent New York Times article and learned that Nazis along with many regular citizens did not need much convincing:
Dr. Dean, a co-researcher, said the findings left no doubt in his mind that many German citizens, despite the frequent claims of ignorance after the war, must have known about the widespread existence of the Nazi camps at the time.

“You literally could not go anywhere in Germany without running into forced labor camps, P.O.W. camps, concentration camps,” he said. “They were everywhere.”
Although Hitler's Willing Executioners has been criticized as hyperbolic, the book makes the point more forcefully.

A bit of research and a little common sense would have prevented this whole situation.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Please, Please, Please Let This Become An Educational Trend

Writing at College Guide, Keith Humphreys points to a college text book innovation.

Everyone who has spent time on campus has had to buy a "Big Book of Everything [that] is incredibly handy both for established experts and students"  because . . . they’ve got everything in them . . . ." Of course everyone who has had to carry one of the books across campus can attest that the BBoEs "are as portable as anvils and they cost a mint.":

Humphreys reports that at least one publisher is willing to change that:
Enter an innovation of which I just learned after agreeing to write a chapter in a forthcoming Big Book of Everything: The publisher is going to let each buyer order the subset of chapters he or she wants rather than hawking the work as an all-or-nothing venture.
The high school BBoEs aren't quite as big nor quite as expensive, but the difference is not that great. Besides, high school freshmen and sophomores are much smaller than college students. I haven't done a scientific study, but I'd be willing to bet that most high school students are carrying more pounds of books per pound of body weight than most college students carry.

As an English teacher, I would love being able to buy only the short stories and poems I knew I was going to teach. Now a lot of students are carrying around a huge book that I can't possibly get through in a semester. Given shrinking budgets, this innovation would be a Godsend. Further, Kindles, Nooks, and tablets of all sorts are becoming ubiquitous. Being able to purchase electronic licenses for the book chapters or stories one needs to teach and loading them on these devices seems to be rare act of common sense.

If this idea catches on at the college level, it should eventually trickle down to the high school level. I may be able to customize at least one textbook before I retire.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Sometimes Learning Is Hard

A fellow staff member came into my room just after the bell rang because to show me this cartoon. I expect a dozen students to show it to me before the day is over. Every student who has taken one of my classes in the past 10 years has probably had this image in their mind as I have threatened defenestration for some minor infraction.



I didn't ask for permission; the original can be found here.
 Alan Jacobs quotes Orwell while musing about the same principle when discussing learning how to write well:
And then, as is typical of Orwell at his best, comes the unexpected kicker:
It is a mistake to think such methods do not work. They work very well for their special purpose. Indeed, I doubt whether classical education ever has been or can be successfully carried on without corporal punishment. The boys themselves believed in its efficacy. There was a boy named Beacham, with no brains to speak of, but evidently in acute need of a scholarship. Sambo was flogging him towards the goal as one might do with a foundered horse. He went up for a scholarship at Uppingham, came back with a consciousness of having done badly, and a day or two later received a severe beating for idleness. ‘I wish I’d had that caning before I went up for the exam,’ he said sadly — a remark which I felt to be contemptible, but which I perfectly well understood.
I doubt whether classical education ever has been or can be successfully carried on without corporal punishment. What a terrible thing to say — but what if it’s true? What if there are certain valuable skills that children aren’t going to learn unless we let Sambo have his riding crop and the nuns their hand-smacking rulers? I wouldn’t make that choice — I wouldn’t let some sadist with a riding crop within a mile of young boys, and I wouldn’t let the nuns have their beloved rulers back — but the belief that certain unpleasant rote-oriented skills can be learned without strong negative reinforcement may be a wish-fulfillment fantasy.
I don't want to use a hand-smacking ruler. Jokingly threatening defenestration is far better than actually carrying out a real defenestration. I have to agree, however, sometimes learning can be a difficult process, and teachers harm their credibility if they deny the truth of that fact to themselves or their students.

Friday, August 24, 2012

Comics Matter And They Still Belong In The Classroom

Artist Kerrith Johnson captures the iconic nature of many of contemporary comics major heroes. Because these characters have become icons, they can easily remind readers, teachers, students, and skeptical members of the public, that there's something more the mundane of day-to-day life. Johnson's "Believe" series attempts to keep superheroes "iconic but positive." This artwork would be far more effective than some of the motivational crap that clutters school hallways and classrooms.

A few of my favorites:

For the Lincoln-Douglas debaters:


For all other students who write, speak, act, or create:



Because we all make mistakes and need a little help:



There are good people out there:


Lightening strikes every day:


When all of these things come together, there can be a little magic:




Saturday, August 11, 2012

Pop Culture Teaching Tools

I need to keep these in one place, so I'll write a post on the off chance that someone else is as weird as I am.

The Odyssey illustrates "to be human is to be troubled": one of those troubles is mortality. This IO9 post posits that mortality may be less of a problem in the relatively near future: Russian Scientists assert it may be possible to achieve immortality by 2045. IO9 also asks a question students should be experts at discussing: would it be boring if we could live forever? The accompanying illustration is also worth an assignment:


I do a brief lit theory unit. This post about science fiction's philosophical roots may be helpful. So will this post about Paul Ryan's Ayn Rand fixation. The irony of a devout Catholic also being a follower of a rather noisy atheist opposed to charity opens the door to discuss several of the predominant theories.

Speaking of irony, does it qualify as irony that adult film star Ron Jeremy calls Mitt Romney a good man? If not does Jenna Jameson's endorsement qualify? I probably shouldn't use either example in class even if I can use the name Jenna Jameson to discuss alliteration.

This Jim Holt video may be a good start to the creation myths unit:




This Holt video may work with the play Fences or any other death literature:




Tweets like this one should help teach about language use and conciseness


Finally, because the undead never go out of style, one can discuss zombie nouns.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Plains Pops: How Teachers Can Approach Tech And The Web

At Lifehacker, Adam Pash advocates a fragmented approach. He notes that Facebook does everything competently, but requires a large investment:
Facebook is a microblogging platform, a blogging platform, a photo-sharing platform, a location-sharing platform, a chat platform, an email client, a pseudo-music-sharing platform, a gaming platform, and so on. It's an incredibly powerful service. For many, Facebook isn't just a site on the internet; it's the internet.

And that's why you're locked into Facebook; that's why it's so hard to leave. You've invested so much, not just in sharing photos or posting links, but in the whole ecosystem.

Facebook does about everything well enough. It's a full-fledged internet operating system. But like most operating systems, the stock applications aren't as good as the apps and services built by companies who are passionate about one thing.
Pash contends fragmentation offers the following advantages:
1. If, say, I decide Instagram has made some bad choices and all of the sudden totally sucks (a completely realistic but not necessarily inevitable possibility now that they've been acquired by Facebook), I can abandon Instagram and start using one of a million other photo-sharing services. If Facebook mucks up their photo sharing, I'm probably going to write a series of short, angry status updates, grit my teeth, and keep using Facebook.

2. You can easily define your communities based on what you're sharing. On Rdio, for example, I specifically follow people whose musical habits I'm interested in. I may be interested in your listening habits but have no interest in the pictures you're sharing. I'll follow you on Rdio and not on Instagram. Handy.

3. People who make just one thing tend to really care about it and have really great ideas about how to make it better. Cf. the discussion above about stock apps.

This whole discussion swings back to something we've talked about a couple times before: The Unix philosophy, the core of which surrounds the virtues of software that does one thing well. It's a fantastic philosophy that has implications well beyond software, and the more experience I have (with software, systems, people, etc.), the truer it rings.
John T. Spencer adds another reason to go piecemeal: one can use the technology in the "wrong" way:
I don't think I've ever known anyone else who uses a spreadsheet as a calendar. For me, it works, though. I have the date, the day, the task or event, the type of task and the location. For recurring events, I simply write "every week" or "every day." Then, I use the sort function to see what I need to do each day or to see the timeline of a particular project (sorting by category).  I like being able to ask, "When is Galileo testing?" and simply sorting it with one click. Calendars don't allow me to do that.
I'm not suggesting everyone should use a spreadsheet for a calendar. I'm odd. I get that. I like every event in one place and I find the calendar to be inefficient. But it has me thinking about technology and customization. It has me thinking that maybe acceptable use should be broadened to also mean, "Use the tools in the way they weren't intended to be used."
Too often, students learn a rigid definition of how a particular technology tool should be used. PowerPoint and Google Presentations are meant for presenting new information. Spreadsheets are for crunching numbers. Twitter is for telling people what you're doing. Blogging is for short writing entries. Google Docs should be used for writing only.
At one level, Pash's desire for the perfect tool and Spencer's urging to use tools in the "wrong" way may seem mutually exclusive, but both writers require and allow for user autonomy and experimentation. Both will get results that a do everything site like Facebook will never provide.

Friday, July 20, 2012

Why The Internet Is A Tool Not A Teacher

Writing in today's New York Times, Mark Edmundson concludes:
A truly memorable college class, even a large one, is a collaboration between teacher and students. It’s a one-time-only event. Learning at its best is a collective enterprise, something we’ve known since Socrates. You can get knowledge from an Internet course if you’re highly motivated to learn. But in real courses the students and teachers come together and create an immediate and vital community of learning. A real course creates intellectual joy, at least in some. I don’t think an Internet course ever will. Internet learning promises to make intellectual life more sterile and abstract than it already is — and also, for teachers and for students alike, far more lonely.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

A Beer Commercial As Vocab Lesson


Equanimity
Colleagues
Vernacular
Substantiate

Not bad for 30 seconds.  Hooray big word usage and stuff!

Monday, July 9, 2012

Comic Book Movie Business And Teaching Literature

There can be little doubt that comics have become mainstream cultural artifacts. Money talks: The Avengers has earned over $1 billion since its May release.  The Amazing Spider-Man earned $65 million over the past weekend.

The New York Times adds more proof.  Valiant Comics, a publisher that went bankrupt in the 1990s, will have at least two of its characters adapted for a film:
Mr. Kothari said he expects Bloodshot to be the first Valliant character to make the leap into theaters. Sony is working on the property with the producer Neal H. Moritz, perhaps best known for the “Fast & Furious” film franchise. The director Brett Ratner, whose films include “X-Men: The Last Stand,” has committed to Harbinger.
Bloodshot is a former mob hit man who becomes a super soldier:
Angelo Mortalli has become the ultimate killing machine. His memories have been erased and his blood has been infused with microscopic computers called nanites. These nanites allow him to heal wounds quickly, dominate electronic devices, and fully control every aspect of his body to maximize his physical capabilities. A modern-day Frankenstein, he wages a one man war, taking out the mob, the police and his covert government creators, in his struggle to find out who he was and what he has become.
Harbinger is a bit more complicated:
Toyo Harada is the first Harbinger, and unlike subsequent Harbingers he was able to make his powers manifest at will, or activate the powers of others. Other Harbingers exhibit powers only rarely and this activation is always brought on by severe stress. 
Harada is an Omega Harbinger: he commands the full spectrum of psionic abilities, including telepathy, telekinesis, mind-control, and many other talents. He uses these powers to create a multinational corporation and amass a large fortune. Fearing the world is on a course to destroy itself, he plans to take it over and mold it to his specifications. To this end he creates the Harbinger Foundation, which actively searches for potential Harbingers (whose powers Harada triggers with his psionic abilities).
Pete Stanchek is a normal teenager until he develops Harbinger abilities. After seeing an advertisement he contacts the Harbinger Foundation. Harada is intrigued by Pete, who is the only other Harbinger to have triggered his own powers and who exhibits multiple abilities. Harada is no longer the only Omega Harbinger.
Harada tries to persuade Pete to join the Harbinger Foundation and become Harada's right hand man, but when Pete's best friend, who had been vocal about his distrust for Harada, is murdered by the Foundation Pete realizes the truth.
Pete, along with Kris (a high school cheerleader who Pete had first been unconsciously mentally controlling so that she would go out with him) become renegades. They decide to recruit Harbingers themselves, activate their abilities, and form an army capable of challenging Harada.
The Valiant publishers believe these relatively unknown characters will succeed at the box office:
When it comes to movies, Peter Cuneo said he is not worried that Valiant’s characters are not well known outside comic circles.
“The general public didn’t know Iron Man and look at him now,” he said of the Marvel character that has starred in two hit movies and anchored “The Avengers.” “What matters is the quality of the movie you make.”
The comic book movie article has now become teaching tool.

First, what constitutes a good quality movie or, for the English teacher, a good work of literature

Second, when comparing items make sure to compare similar items.  Cuneo seems to be comparing two different things.  Iron Man and the Avengers debuted in 1963.  They have nearly 50 years worth of readers to draw from; the Valiant characters have fewer than 20 years of history.  Further, the Avengers in both the comic and movie versions have Captain America, a character who was created in the 1940s and Thor who has thousands of years of thunder god history.

More importantly, Iron Man can draw on the knight archetype.  His armor, while technologically advanced, can be associated with hero stories developed over centuries.  Nanites seem to be technological bugs; they have little heroic history.  In fact, they seem more likely to engender a discussion of the advisability of genetically modified food than a discussion of heroism

Appealing to the Frankenstein motif instead of the knight in shining armor may create a niche film that will appeal to audience more willing to explore darker side of human nature.

In literature and so-called real world, people judge characters on the story they have lived and how well they can tell it.  Valiant seems to be trying to tell a new story that relies on the technology.  The most successful characters use technology as a tool and tell a familiar story in a new way.

Saturday, May 26, 2012

Yes, I Have No Life . . .

School's out; it's a Saturday night during a holiday weekend, and I'm sitting at home.

That being said, this adaptation of The Avengers is funny.  It also makes me think that I should find ways to incorporate creating a silent film into my mythology class.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Students, Schools, And Social Media: Chart Of The Day

From this Charlie Osborne post at ZDnet.com,


A few numbers from the article:
  • 63 percent of students want online textbooks with communication facilities;
  • 40 percent want online texts with collaboration tools.
  • 43 percent stated social media is one of the main ways they communicate with friends online.
  • 62 percent  of student use the Internet as a new source; whereas 17 percent use it to gain knowledge concerning topics generally difficult to talk about — such as drug use.



Sunday, October 23, 2011

Sunday Afternoon Lesson Planning And Musing

Andrew Taggart wants to return education to the Renaissance.  I agree with him.  Taggart writes,
This is one place where public philosophy as a form of public education can and should stake its claim. The Latin word educare retains the agrarian sense of “rearing,” “bringing up,” and “leading forth.” One task of public philosophy, I submit, could be to lead us in a certain direction without pandering, bullying, or nannying. “Leading forth” is neither hand-holding nor forcing your hand. It’s not florid rhetoric or hard-nosed criticism, both of which are concerned with getting us to admit the flaws in our arguments, to make up our minds regarding our deepest commitments, or to change our positions about public affairs. Instead, public philosophy as educare urges us to follow a certain line of thought, to strike out on a path and see where it takes us. From there and throughout, we would ask, “Does this bring us greater clarity about ourselves and our world?”
Assuming that this is a worthwhile endeavor (and I think it is), I’m not entirely sure how to go about it. One essay in educare could be to reinvigorate the commonplace book tradition—to reintroduce it with a twist. Commonplace books, popular from the Renaissance up through the seventeenth century, were scrapbooks of maxims, drawings, lists, inspirational quotations, and marginal notes. By design, they were meant to be hodgepodge: a recipe here, a line from Horace there. In this serendipity there was exquisite beauty. However, insofar as they were unsorted collections of curiosities and wonderments, they didn’t seek to develop the collector’s mind in any one direction. And, my God, how many collages, mélanges, bric-a-bracs, shards, and fragments are lying about us today?
I wonder whether we could retain something of the magic and surprise of the commonplace book but also order the bits and pieces so that they appear as if they were making an argument, giving us a better, more holistic way of seeing things, or leading us down a path toward higher understanding? I wonder whether the parts can be gathered together into a synthetic whole
First, I love the idea that education's goal should be "leading forth" without "pandering," " bullying," "nannying," "hand-holding," or forcing others' hands.


I also like the idea of a directed common place book.  I've used a quotation book as an assignment in the past; Taggart's post may lead me to resurrect and modify it.  I had students write down quotations from the reading and react to them. The quality of those reactions varied greatly.

Using Taggart's principle of gather parts into a "synthetic whole," I'm considering having them pull quotations from the literature we're reading and try to find connections from the "real world"news stores.  I'll also have them add items from other academic disciplines.


All of us live in an increasingly disconnected world, and learning to make connections may be one of the most important things schools lead students forth to do.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Science And Religion And Education, Oh My!

These three things are more frightening than lions and tigers and bears.

At South Dakota Politics, Dr. Blanchard has written a provocative post about science having the authority that religion formerly along with the schisms that still plague the faithful.
Science enjoys the kind of unique authority in modern civilization that religion once enjoyed. It is the one source of wisdom that is all but immune to challenge. To be openly "anti-science" is to be discredited in modern eyes.
Blanchard goes on to quote Steven Hayward who writes,
But rather than stopping with the simple observation that ideology or politics drives acceptance or rejection of certain domains of science, it is worth pressing on to ask why liberals dislike some kind of science, and conservatives other kinds. Liberals in the case of childhood vaccinations and GM organisms dislike certain forms of authority
If I can carry the religious analogy a step further, modern personal technology like mp3 players, tablets, laptops, and smart phones function as the paten and chalice.

Public schools are legally mandated to worship at the alter of science.  NCLB demands no less:
The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, which reauthorized the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, calls for the use of "scientifically based research" as the foundation for many education programs and for classroom instruction.
 A lengthy New York Times article "In Classroom of Future, Stagnant Scores" shows that schools, like the larger culture, struggles with the limits of science and technology.  The article profiles the Kyrene School District's efforts to "offer what some see as a utopian vision of education’s future."  The schools "[c]lassrooms are decked out with laptops, big interactive screens and software that drills students on every basic subject."

The school seeks to change the nature of education.
The digital push here aims to go far beyond gadgets to transform the very nature of the classroom, turning the teacher into a guide instead of a lecturer, wandering among students who learn at their own pace on Internet-connected devices.
The problem here is that some of the results have more to do with "the substance of things unseen, the evidence of things hoped for" rather than scientific fact.
But to many education experts, something is not adding up — here and across the country. In a nutshell: schools are spending billions on technology, even as they cut budgets and lay off teachers, with little proof that this approach is improving basic learning.
This conundrum calls into question one of the most significant contemporary educational movements. Advocates for giving schools a major technological upgrade — which include powerful educators, Silicon Valley titans and White House appointees — say digital devices let students learn at their own pace, teach skills needed in a modern economy and hold the attention of a generation weaned on gadgets.
Some backers of this idea say standardized tests, the most widely used measure of student performance, don’t capture the breadth of skills that computers can help develop. But they also concede that for now there is no better way to gauge the educational value of expensive technology investments.
“The data is pretty weak. It’s very difficult when we’re pressed to come up with convincing data,” said Tom Vander Ark, the former executive director for education at the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and an investor in educational technology companies. When it comes to showing results, he said, “We better put up or shut up.”
Despite that admission, Vander Ark illustrates both the faith of a believer and the depth of the schism.  The Times continues,
And yet, in virtually the same breath, he said change of a historic magnitude is inevitably coming to classrooms this decade: “It’s one of the three or four biggest things happening in the world today.”
Critics counter that, absent clear proof, schools are being motivated by a blind faith in technology and an overemphasis on digital skills — like using PowerPoint and multimedia tools — at the expense of math, reading and writing fundamentals. They say the technology advocates have it backward when they press to upgrade first and ask questions later.
I will offer a few observations that may or may not serve as theses to nail to the school house door.

1. American society has become so tech centric that schools need to have tech in place and teachers need to use it in order for their classes to be taken seriously.

2. John Naisbitt was correct in the 1980s and 1990s when he asserted that society was becoming high tech and high touch. Literature teachers in particular must help students learn to "balance material wonders of technology with the spiritual demands of our human nature."

3. Schools will always be behind the curve when it comes to the latest technology; therefore, they must do more to teach about the principles of using technology than the specifics of currently fashionable programs and platforms.

4. There is nothing new under the sun.  Some of us of a certain age remember filmstrips and mimeograph machines.  A power point and a film strip do not differ that greatly.  When done well, both help students learn; when done poorly, both put students to sleep.  Likewise, worksheets are worksheets.  It doesn't matter if they were mimeographed or photocopied.  Photocopies do lack that ink odor that may or may not have destroyed many fourth graders' brain cells from the 1950s through the mid-1980s.

5. All of this is a long way of saying that schools are rightfully prevented from teaching a specific religion.  Likewise, they should not be mandated to use a specific scientific method or technological tool.  All require a bit of faith and a skilled practitioner.

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Common Core Training Treats Literature Like Pop Songs

I think this is a a sign I'm old.  I love albums; remember those?  Some are famous: The White Album or Boy.  Others, Flat as a Pancake, may have been forgotten unless one is of a certain age. Still others, Martinis and Bikinis, appeal to a small fan base. 

In addition to being old, I'm cantankerous; some might even call me a curmudgeon.  It seems to me that most current music is designed to get put on compilations like Now 39.  A song needs only a catchy hook and melody that can become an earworm; the song doesn't have to be an integral part of a larger composition.

Some education reformers apparently believe that the Common Core standards mean that literature teachers should treat literature like pop music.  The whole no longer matters; teachers should just use snippets to achieve the standards:
I attended a 2-day Common Core training sponsored by the NC Dept of Ed. In the English Language Arts (ELA) workshop, we were told that one of the GREAT things about the common core was that we no longer should teach entire novels. Snippets and targeted short passages from novels were all we needed to teach ELA concepts. There was an audible, collective gasp from the people in the room. But I was the only one who raised my hand and questioned this pronouncement. And the trainers continued to tout the wonders of using shorter texts.
I don't know what Melody Schopp has in mind as South Dakota begins to implement Common Core.  Given that textbook companies write many of the tests that states use, it strikes me as probable that South Dakota may look at adopting some of the training that North Carolina uses.

Schopp wants to emphasize STEM, so she may put reading and literature on the back burner.  I hope she understands that treating literature like a Britney Spears song won't help teachers teach or students improve their reading.

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Comics And Education

People have reacted strongly to Marvel Comics new Ultimate Spider-Man, the bi-racial Miles Morales.  The Washington Post calls the response "thumpingly out of scale and crazy."

Glen Beck claims it's Michelle Obama's fault.
Glenn Beck has a problem with the new Spider-Man, and he thinks Michelle Obama is to blame.
In one of Marvel’s comic series, Peter Parker has been killed off and the mantle of Spider-Man will be taken up by a new character: Miles Morales, who is half-black and half-Hispanic.
On his radio show today, after repeatedly telling listeners that “I don’t care” about the new Spider-Man and that it is just a “stupid comic book”, Beck got his real opinion out. He explained why the new bi-racial Spider-Man can be attributed to Michelle Obama.

“I think a lot of this stuff is being done intentionally. What was it that Mrs. Obama said before the campaign? Because its strange how so much of this seems to all be happening,” he said. Beck then played an audio file of Michelle Obama saying that “we’re gonna have to change our traditions.”
Fox News questioned whether Marvel had taken a radical turn to the left.



As usual, John Stewart put things in perspective.

                       
The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
Culture War Update - The Dividening of America - Lou Dobbs vs. Biracial Spider-Man
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show Full EpisodesPolitical Humor & Satire BlogThe Daily Show on Facebook

The right may want to reconsider their view of the new Ultimate Spider-Man.  Many are fans of Waiting for Superman, a film that Valerie Strauss points out was "edited the film to make it seem as if charter schools are a systemic answer to the ills afflicting many traditional public schools."  Conservatives would argue with Strauss when she asserts was the film was "not good/accurate enough to be selected" for an Oscar.  She also writes,  "The snub to Davis Guggenheim’s tendentious film was well-deserved, given that classic documentaries are factual and straightforward, and don’t, as did "Superman," fake scenes for emotional impact."

Marvel Comics Chief Creative Officer Joe Quesada and Ultimate Spider-Man writer Brian Bendis are apparently fans.  According to an interview published at Comic Book Resources.
We're talking to a lot of the folks involved with the new "Ultimate Spider-Man" series this week on CBR, but I wanted to get your take on the creation of Miles along with them. From your perspective, when did you first hear about Bendis' ideas for Miles, and what was your initial reaction? What did you feel were the most important aspects this character needed to make him worthy of the Spider-Man name?

The weeks following the Ultimate Summit, Miles was just about the only thing Brian and I could talk about when we got on the phone. So, between many a late night call and a couple of late night meetings over coffee and junk food in LA, while we didn't have a name for him yet, Miles was starting to take shape. We discussed his family and upbringing at length and slowly you could see how he was becoming his own person and not just a copy of Peter. Now while I don't want to give too much away, over the years I've been really intrigued by the revolutionary work being done by educator Geoffrey Canada, and as we looked deeper into Miles' character, I suggested to Brian that he watch the documentary, "Waiting For Superman" (ironic, I know!). Bri loved it, and the wheels started turning. Pretty soon he was building a world and cast that would support Miles in some fantastically intriguing ways that were relatable but also different from Peter Parker's world. I have a sneaky suspicion that Brian is going to make people fall in love with Miles very quickly.
At Think Progress, Alyssa gives this take about Bendis and Quesada using the movie to make the character "relateable."
Obviously I can’t pass judgment on how those themes play out until I see it happen, though it would be pretty weird to see a comic book where Morales fights a teachers’ union that’s secretly entirely made up of Skrulls or something. But no matter how it turns out, I’m glad to see this kind of thinking be part of the comic book process. Assuming that getting bitten by radioactive spiders doesn’t induce amnesia, there are factors in Spider-Man’s past other than Uncle Ben’s dying words that influenced him. And while many superhero stories propel newly-made supermen and women into larger worlds, whether it’s from a gated mansion into the slums of Gotham, or from Westchester County to the Blue Area of the Moon, there’s something to be said for superhero stories that take on problems closer to home. It may take a single bug bite from a very special arachnid to make a hero, but it takes a village to raise all the kids who are only lucky enough to get nipped by mosquitoes.
 Alyssa seems to have a balanced approach to the situation.  My fear isn't that every public school teacher featured in the comic will be characterized as an incompetent.  My fear is that the politicization of the comic will make it more difficult to use comics in the classroom or even have intelligent discussion about using comics like the conversation The Tempered Radical has here and here.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Fallor Ergo Sum-- I Err Therefore I Am

Every teacher needs to watch this Kathryn Schulz talk since we'll never get to see anything this good at an inservice.



Key Quotation:
1,200 years before Descartes said his famous thing about "I think therefore I am," this guy, St. Augustine, sat down and wrote "Fallor ergo sum" -- "I err therefore I am." Augustine understood that our capacity to screw up, it's not some kind of embarrassing defect in the human system, something we can eradicate or overcome. It's totally fundamental to who we are. Because, unlike God, we don't really know what's going on out there. And unlike all of the other animals, we are obsessed with trying to figure it out. To me, this obsession is the source and root of all of our productivity and creativity
Summary:
So here we are again. And that's how it goes. We come up with another idea. We tell another story. We hold another conference. The theme of this one, as you guys have now heard seven million times, is the rediscovery of wonder. And to me, if you really want to rediscover wonder, you need to step outside of that tiny, terrified space of rightness and look around at each other and look out at the vastness and complexity and mystery of the universe and be able to say, "Wow, I don't know. Maybe I'm wrong."
To effectively teach one must learn to be wrong.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

Two YouTube Videos Every Speech and Debate Teacher Needs

A Useful Warning about Mistakes Inherent in Visual Aid Speeches



 A Reminder about What Every Persuasive Speech Needs