Showing posts with label Movies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Movies. Show all posts

Thursday, July 3, 2014

This Independence Day Be A Patriotic American: Watch A Movie About Nazis

I'm serious. Take some time to watch Conspiracy, an HBO dramatization of the Wannsee Conference, a two hour meeting that created the framework for what became known as "the final solution."

If nothing else, the film is a firm and frightening reminder of what happens when those in power actively act against the principle "that all . . .are created equal and . . . endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights. . . " It took less than ninety minutes to begin the process that took six million lives.

I also found Colin Firth's portrayal of Dr. William Stuckart, co-author of the Nuremberg Laws, compelling and chilling. His demand that laws be created so that the property of Jews killed by the regime could be legally transferred is shocking. More jarring, however, to the sensibilities of one inculcated with the belief that no one is above the law is the ease that the participants had in dismissing the need for law altogether.

Finally, the film ends with General Reinhard Heydrich retelling a story allegedly told to him during the conference. Briefly, a man loved his mother but hated his father. When his mother died, the young man could not weep or mourn. When the father died, the man became inconsolable because because hatred had given him a reason to live and now the object of hate was gone.

A recent Pew survey showed Americans developing a deep antipathy toward members of the opposing political party:
More than one-third of Republicans and just over a quarter of Democrats see the other party as a “threat to the nation’s well-being,” reflecting a widening partisan division in the country that has congealed into animosity and distrust.
Through two decades of political battling across the presidencies of Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama, the ideological divisions among Americans have deepened. The percentage of Americans who hold consistently liberal or conservative views has sharply increased, and the antipathy between the two groups has shot upward.
Among those with a high level of political engagement – consistently voting in elections and following government and politics carefully – nearly half say they would go so far as to describe the other side as a threat to the country.
Given those results, it seems long past time to rein back contempt toward those who hold a different political view.

The movie is available for streaming on Amazon Prime. I stumbled across a YouTube copy the other night. I have no idea of the legal status this version. Use your own judgement,

Monday, July 9, 2012

Comic Book Movie Business And Teaching Literature

There can be little doubt that comics have become mainstream cultural artifacts. Money talks: The Avengers has earned over $1 billion since its May release.  The Amazing Spider-Man earned $65 million over the past weekend.

The New York Times adds more proof.  Valiant Comics, a publisher that went bankrupt in the 1990s, will have at least two of its characters adapted for a film:
Mr. Kothari said he expects Bloodshot to be the first Valliant character to make the leap into theaters. Sony is working on the property with the producer Neal H. Moritz, perhaps best known for the “Fast & Furious” film franchise. The director Brett Ratner, whose films include “X-Men: The Last Stand,” has committed to Harbinger.
Bloodshot is a former mob hit man who becomes a super soldier:
Angelo Mortalli has become the ultimate killing machine. His memories have been erased and his blood has been infused with microscopic computers called nanites. These nanites allow him to heal wounds quickly, dominate electronic devices, and fully control every aspect of his body to maximize his physical capabilities. A modern-day Frankenstein, he wages a one man war, taking out the mob, the police and his covert government creators, in his struggle to find out who he was and what he has become.
Harbinger is a bit more complicated:
Toyo Harada is the first Harbinger, and unlike subsequent Harbingers he was able to make his powers manifest at will, or activate the powers of others. Other Harbingers exhibit powers only rarely and this activation is always brought on by severe stress. 
Harada is an Omega Harbinger: he commands the full spectrum of psionic abilities, including telepathy, telekinesis, mind-control, and many other talents. He uses these powers to create a multinational corporation and amass a large fortune. Fearing the world is on a course to destroy itself, he plans to take it over and mold it to his specifications. To this end he creates the Harbinger Foundation, which actively searches for potential Harbingers (whose powers Harada triggers with his psionic abilities).
Pete Stanchek is a normal teenager until he develops Harbinger abilities. After seeing an advertisement he contacts the Harbinger Foundation. Harada is intrigued by Pete, who is the only other Harbinger to have triggered his own powers and who exhibits multiple abilities. Harada is no longer the only Omega Harbinger.
Harada tries to persuade Pete to join the Harbinger Foundation and become Harada's right hand man, but when Pete's best friend, who had been vocal about his distrust for Harada, is murdered by the Foundation Pete realizes the truth.
Pete, along with Kris (a high school cheerleader who Pete had first been unconsciously mentally controlling so that she would go out with him) become renegades. They decide to recruit Harbingers themselves, activate their abilities, and form an army capable of challenging Harada.
The Valiant publishers believe these relatively unknown characters will succeed at the box office:
When it comes to movies, Peter Cuneo said he is not worried that Valiant’s characters are not well known outside comic circles.
“The general public didn’t know Iron Man and look at him now,” he said of the Marvel character that has starred in two hit movies and anchored “The Avengers.” “What matters is the quality of the movie you make.”
The comic book movie article has now become teaching tool.

First, what constitutes a good quality movie or, for the English teacher, a good work of literature

Second, when comparing items make sure to compare similar items.  Cuneo seems to be comparing two different things.  Iron Man and the Avengers debuted in 1963.  They have nearly 50 years worth of readers to draw from; the Valiant characters have fewer than 20 years of history.  Further, the Avengers in both the comic and movie versions have Captain America, a character who was created in the 1940s and Thor who has thousands of years of thunder god history.

More importantly, Iron Man can draw on the knight archetype.  His armor, while technologically advanced, can be associated with hero stories developed over centuries.  Nanites seem to be technological bugs; they have little heroic history.  In fact, they seem more likely to engender a discussion of the advisability of genetically modified food than a discussion of heroism

Appealing to the Frankenstein motif instead of the knight in shining armor may create a niche film that will appeal to audience more willing to explore darker side of human nature.

In literature and so-called real world, people judge characters on the story they have lived and how well they can tell it.  Valiant seems to be trying to tell a new story that relies on the technology.  The most successful characters use technology as a tool and tell a familiar story in a new way.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Hollywood May Get Religion Wrong: What Are The Odds?

Rod Dreher sums up an upcoming Hollywood release.
Just so you’re clear: from the director of “Showgirls” and the team that brought you “Pulp Fiction” and “American Psycho,” comes a new cinematic life of Christ that claims the Virgin Mary was raped and that Jesus was no miracle worker, but rather the world’s greatest ethics guru.
Dreher neglects to mention Paul Verhoeven also directed Robocop, Total Recall, and Basic Instinct, so I don't know what could go wrong.

Ok, I will admit that I'm a little worried that Verhoeven might recycle some material..  I hope he doesn't have John the Baptist say, "Here at Security Concepts, we're predicting the end of crime in Old Detroit within 40 days. There's a new guy in town. His name is RoboCop."

Also, Robocop's analysis of eternal life lacks metaphysical nuance:
Emil: Smoke?
Dougy: Nah. You know those things'll kill you.
Emil: Yeah. You wanna live forever?
I would also hate to see "love your neighbor as yourself" reduced to Prime Directives "Serve the public trust, protect the innocent, uphold the law.  Those directives seem so, for lack of a better word, robotic.  I also don't want hear Jesus call the disciples by saying, "Dead or alive, you're coming with me!"

Total Recall's discussion of eternal life is also a bit weak: "Relax. You'll live longer."  Likewise, when Jesus talks with his disciples about who people believe him to be, I'd prefer not to hear: "If I am not me, then who the hell am I?"  Also, these lines really won't work as a description of either Hell or the apocalypse:
The walls of reality will come crashing down. One minutie, you'll be the savior of the rebel cause, and the nest thing you know you'll be Cohaagan's Bosom Buddy, you'll also have fantasies about alien civilizations as you requested. But in the end back on Earth, you'll be lobotomized.
Taking lines from Basic Instinct would also be problematic.  I don't want either the woman at the well or the woman that Jesus saved from being stoned to ask: "What are you gonna do ? Charge me with smoking?"

On the plus side, Verhoeven could cast Samuel L. Jackson as a pharisee and have him ask the deeply profound theological question about hamburgers from Pulp Fiction:
Well, if you like burgers give 'em a try sometime. I can't usually get 'em myself because my girlfriend's a vegitarian which pretty much makes me a vegitarian. But I do love the taste of a good burger. Mm-mm-mm. You know what they call a Quarter Pounder with cheese in France?

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

When Film Does Bad Things To Great Literature

After seeing this trailer for The Great Gatsby,



I have one thought that gives me comfort.  It won't be as bad as this Demi Moore retelling of The Scarlet Letter.

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Captain America Vs. Cowboys & Aliens: Philosophy Without A License Edition

I think I have made a startling discovery.  Captain America: The First Avenger and Cowboys & Aliens are the same movie.

Both protagonists gain access to advanced alien technology and use it to help destroy an existential  alien threat.  Both movies also have benign and dangerous aliens.  Further, both protagonists have have been redeemed:  Steven Rogers has been saved from being a perpetual victim whereas the love of a beautiful woman turned Jake Lonergan, the Daniel Craig character from a life of crime.  Both movies have characters with a healing power make the ultimate sacrifice to bring down a dangerous flying machine, and both contain resurrections although in Cowboys & Aliens, the resurrection is only implied.  Finally, both films make use of every cliche available to them.  Captain America uses war movie types including a gruff colonel, leggy USO girls, and a corps group of loveable, battle hardened vets.  Cowboys & Aliens contains a gruff but wise preacher, a bully who is the spoiled son of a rich cattle baron, a saloon piano player joyfully pounding the keys, and the drifter who saved the town rides away alone.  Fans of Westerns couldn't ask for anything more.

I'm not enough of a movie critic to comment about each movie's use of lighting, color, sets, or boom mikes.  I think that Captain America tells its story better than Cowboys & Aliens, but not enough better to justify that fact Rotten Tomatoes finds that only 44% of critics give Cowboys & Aliens a positive review whereas 78% give Captain America a positive review.

Instead, the difference stems from the fact that Cowboys & Aliens jars sensibilities in ways that Captain America doesn't. Those alien flying machines shouldn't be buzzing across those quintessentially American vistas

More importantly, Captain America is clean and shiny; the film's garbage cans are clean and shiny; the Red Skull's prison cells are clean and shiny.  Were I feeling cynical, I might allege that even the dust and mud in that Steve Rogers crawls through is clean and shiny.  On the other hand, the Old West cowboys, gang members, Indians, and townspeople, and even the evil aliens are scarred and grimy.

In Captain America, the Asian, the Irishman, the African-American, and the kid from Brooklyn come together with not problems.  In the alien infested West, the rich rancher, the career criminal, the townspeople, and the Native Americans struggle with what is at best an uneasy alliance.  The former is comforting, the latter a touch too close to reality.

Most importantly, the aliens invade the Old West and steal bodies, memories, and metaphoric souls to get gold.  The subtle reminder that the United States displaced Native Americans for the same reason may make some a bit uncomfortable.  A Nazi obsessed with Teutonic mysticism is far easier to hate.

I'm not saying that Cowboys & Aliens is a better film that Captain America.  I enjoyed Captain America more.  Both films are important, however.  Captain America shows Americans at their best and reminds us what we should strive to become.  Cowboys & Aliens reminds Americans that we're flawed humans with vices that prevent us from becoming the virtuous people we tell ourselves we want to be.

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Epic Sadness

I had hoped that the Clash of Titans remake would do two small thinks.  First, it would take myths and heroism seriously.  Second, it would be a good movie.  According to Rotten Tomatoes, I'm going to be disappointed.  I haven't seen it, but these reviews mean that I'll wait until it's on HBO.  I suppose I shouldn't be surprised; after all, the publicity emphasized one of the most stupid movie lines of all time, "Release the Kracken."