Showing posts with label Sports. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sports. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Football and Morality Edition

From this Travis Waldron  post:
Football isn’t our most beautiful game, but it is our most pure. It combines speed, grace, and unadulterated brutality in a way that no other sport does, and there is something uniquely attractive about that. But I’m starting to question whether I should find that attractive, or whether I should even watch at all. . . . .
At what point does it become too much? At what point is our game more than just a weekend break from reality, a Friday night under the lights, a Saturday afternoon on campus, a Sunday on the couch? At what point do we — do I — become too conscious of the damage caused by the sheer violence of the game we love? At what point do we see our Junior Seaus and Dave Duersons as modern day gladiators who sacrificed their well-being, and ultimately, their lives for our entertainment? At what point do we realize that our Matt Saracens are jeopardizing their futures by playing a game they hope beyond hope will be their futures?

Thursday, July 19, 2012

NFL Team Makes Political Contribution

A football team donates to Jan Brewer's PAC:
The Arizona Cardinals have yet to win a Super Bowl, but they’re champs when it comes to super PACs.
A $5,000 donation last month from the Cardinals to Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer’s JAN PAC committee appears to be the first time a National Football League club has institutionally contributed to a federal super PAC, which may raise unlimited amounts of money from individuals, corporations, unions — even sports teams
Brewer's PAC doesn't seem do deal with sports issues unless one believes that Obamacare will make it more difficult for millionaires to get ACL surgery or proper treatment for a concussion:
A PAC spokesperson could not be reached for comment, although JAN PAC’s website states that the super PAC is “dedicated” to four goals, including “securing the border and restoring integrity to our immigration system,” “fighting ObamaCare,” “creating jobs – getting Americans back to work” and “reducing the size of government.” The super PAC formed in October. Brewer frequently takes to national television to tout these positions and has notably sparred with President Barack Obama, earning her accolades from conservatives in particular.
Travis Waldron points out that there may be other reasons for the Cardinals political interests:
The Cardinals’ donation to Brewer isn’t huge, and given the nature of Brewer’s PAC (aptly named JAN PAC), why the team made the donation now is unclear. The implications for the future, however, aren’t hard to imagine, as the franchise’s choice to get political demonstrates how the Court’s decision in Citizens United, together with subsequent decisions expanding the allowance of corporate campaign cash in our elections, has changed the game for professional sports franchises the way it did for other corporations.

Across the country, professional sports franchises have negotiated various tax breaks and other public financing deals to get what they want — new stadiums, improved infrastructure, a more generous split of gameday (and non-gameday) revenues. The deals are popular with politicians, who soak up the promises of economic boosts and who, faced with threats of the team moving to a new city, are scared to be part of the group that let the team walk away. Popular as they may be, though, the deals leave taxpayers footing the bill when they fail to provide the promised economic boom, instead pushing cities and states into debt.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Teachers Should Learn From Football Players

Given the continuing budget crises affecting the states and the nation, public education will face a few difficult years.  One can expect every state to lay off scores, if not hundreds, of teachers.

Sports Illustrated reports that the National Football League's Players Association (NFLPA) Executive Director DeMaurice Smith faced a similar situation with the National Football League (NFL) lockout.
From the moment he was elected executive director of the NFL Players Association in March 2009,  DeMaurice Smith always took the long view when it came to negotiations with the owners on a new collective bargaining agreement. Hope for the best, plan for the worst.
It's one of the reasons that slightly more than a year ago he received approval from the executive committee to secure insurance that would pay each player roughly $200,000 if there were no football in 2011.
Thankfully, it looks as if there will be football in 2011.  Since the situation seems a bit less optimistic for teachers,the National Education Association (NEA) and the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) should undertake similar long term thinking and investigate buying similar "lay off" insurance for their members.

Let's be clear, I don't want a $200,000 policy.  According to Business Week, the average NFL salary in the National Football League is $1.9 million and the median salary is $770,000.  South Dakota teachers average somewhere between $40,000 and $45,000 per year.  A quick guess is that a comparable policy for South Dakota teachers would pay out about $8,000 to $10,000 to a laid off teacher.

I don't know what such policies cost or how one goes about getting them, but I thought that's why I pay dues.  I know I'd sooner have an insurance policy like NFL players have.  It would be far more valuable than that discount card that I've never used.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

On Writers and Athletes

Slate recently published an excerpt from Solid Fool's Gold: Detours on the Way to Conventional Wisdom by Bill James, the high priest of the Stats Are King denomination of the Church of Baseball.

In this excerpt, James points out that Topeka, Kansas currently has the same population that London had in AD 1600.  London at that time was home to Shakespeare, Christopher Marlowe, Francis Bacon, and Ben Johnson, all great writers still read and taught today.  It's doubtful that contemporary Topeka or any other comparably sized city will produce a similar number of great writers.

James claims,
Our society is very, very good at developing certain types of skills and certain types of genius. We are fantastically good at identifying and developing athletic skills—better than we are, really, at almost anything else. We are quite good at developing and rewarding inventiveness. We are pretty good at developing the skills necessary to run a small business—a fast food restaurant, for example. We're really, really good at teaching people how to drive automobiles and how to find a coffee shop.

Here, James identifies some core elements of American's perceptions about themselves.  They are doers not observers or readers.  They want the newest and the fastest toys.  Above all, they want to make a little money.  In this paragraph, James gives us sports and fast food, America's version of bread and circuses.

Although James seems to understand baseball stats and Americans' psyche, his explanation for the dearth of contemporary writers seems to miss the boat
It is simply because we don't need them. We still have Shakespeare. We still have Thomas Hardy and Charles Dickens and Robert Louis Stevenson; their books are still around. We don't genu­inely need more literary geniuses. One can only read so many books in a lifetime. We need new athletes all the time because we need new games every day—fudging just a little on the definition of the word need. We like to have new games every day, and, if we are to have a constant and endless flow of games, we need a constant flow of athletes. We have gotten to be very, very good at developing the same.

I love the classics as much as most people.  I agree with C.S. Lewis's reason to read the classics.  "Every age has its own outlook. It is specially good at seeing certain truths and specially liable to make certain mistakes. We all, therefore, need the books that will correct the characteristic mistakes of our own period. And that means the old books. All contemporary writers share to some extent the contemporary outlook. . . ."

Lewis even gives a practical method for reading old books.  "It is a good rule, after reading a new book, never to allow yourself another new one till you have read an old one in between. If that is too much for you, you should at least read one old one to every three new ones."

Even with those caveats, I believe we always need new stories or old stories in new clothes.  Despite his conclusion that we have enough great writers, James must agree.  He offers several lessons that Americans can learn from sports.  These suggestions would apply to scientists, doctors, or writers.
American society could and should take lessons from the world of sports as to how to develop talent. How is it that we have become so phenomenally good, in our society, at developing athletes?

First, we give them the opportunity to compete at a young age.

Second, we recognize and identify ability at a young age.

Third, we celebrate athletes' success constantly. We show up at their games and cheer. We give them trophies. When they get to be teenagers, if they're still good, we put their names in the newspaper once in a while.

Fourth, we pay them for potential, rather than simply paying them once they get to be among the best in the world.
I'm unsure whether Americans are willing to pay writers for their potential.  I'm also not sure that Americans are willing to pay engineers or scientists for their potential either.  James acknowledges this fact, but he reminds us that
We are very good at producing athletes, and maybe we are too good at producing athletes. Some­times the cost is too high. We should do more to develop the next Shakespeare and less to develop the next Justin Verlander.

But this situation is not a failing of the sporting world. Rather, it is that the rest of society has been too proud to follow our lead.