Showing posts with label NEA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NEA. Show all posts

Monday, July 18, 2011

Teachers Should Learn From Football Players

Given the continuing budget crises affecting the states and the nation, public education will face a few difficult years.  One can expect every state to lay off scores, if not hundreds, of teachers.

Sports Illustrated reports that the National Football League's Players Association (NFLPA) Executive Director DeMaurice Smith faced a similar situation with the National Football League (NFL) lockout.
From the moment he was elected executive director of the NFL Players Association in March 2009,  DeMaurice Smith always took the long view when it came to negotiations with the owners on a new collective bargaining agreement. Hope for the best, plan for the worst.
It's one of the reasons that slightly more than a year ago he received approval from the executive committee to secure insurance that would pay each player roughly $200,000 if there were no football in 2011.
Thankfully, it looks as if there will be football in 2011.  Since the situation seems a bit less optimistic for teachers,the National Education Association (NEA) and the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) should undertake similar long term thinking and investigate buying similar "lay off" insurance for their members.

Let's be clear, I don't want a $200,000 policy.  According to Business Week, the average NFL salary in the National Football League is $1.9 million and the median salary is $770,000.  South Dakota teachers average somewhere between $40,000 and $45,000 per year.  A quick guess is that a comparable policy for South Dakota teachers would pay out about $8,000 to $10,000 to a laid off teacher.

I don't know what such policies cost or how one goes about getting them, but I thought that's why I pay dues.  I know I'd sooner have an insurance policy like NFL players have.  It would be far more valuable than that discount card that I've never used.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Update: My Fellow Teachers Do Something Stupid

The National Education Association (NEA) endorsed President Obama and thus squandered whatever political influence it might have. Less than a week after that announcement, the President had a Twitter Town Hall and was posed with the following question.
MR. DORSEY:  So 10 percent of our questions now are about education, and this one was surfaced from our curator in California by Marcia:  “Public education here in California is falling apart, not graduating enough skilled workers or smart citizens.  Privatization looming?”
Given that Obama has just received NEA's endorsement, one would expect a ringing defense of public education.  Instead, President Obama offered the following:
THE PRESIDENT:  Look, when America was making a transition from an agricultural society to an industrial society, we as a country made a decision that we were going to have public high schools that would upgrade the skills of young people as they were leaving the farms and start participating in a more complex industrial economy.  When my grandfather’s generation came back from World War II, we made a decision that we were going to have a GI Bill that would send these young people to college because we figured that would help advance our economy.

Every time we’ve made a public investment in education, it has paid off many times over.  For us now to give short shrift to education when the world is more complex than ever, and it’s a knowledge-based society and companies locate based on whether they’ve got skilled workforces or not, that makes no sense.

     And so we’ve got to get our priorities straight here.  It is important for us to have a healthy business climate, to try to keep taxes low, to make sure that we’re not spending on things that don’t work.  It’s important that we get a good bang for the buck in education.  And so my administration has pushed more reform more vigorously across the country through things like Race to the Top than most previous administrations have been able to accomplish.  So we don’t just need more money; we need more reform.

     But we do have to pay for good teachers.  Young, talented people aren’t going to go into teaching if they’re getting paid a poverty wage.  We do have to make sure that buildings aren’t crumbling.  It's pretty hard for kids to concentrate if there are leaks and it’s cold and there are rats running around in their schools.  And that’s true in a lot of schools around the country.

We do have to make sure that there are computers in a computer age inside classrooms, and that they work and that there’s Internets that are actually -- there are Internet connections that actually function.

And I think that those states that are going to do well and those countries that do well are the ones that are going to continue to be committed to making education a priority.
I appreciate history lessons, but the list of public education successes should be followed by "I will do everything in my power to support public education."  Instead the declaration was followed by a paragraph that could have been written by the Cato Institute.  OK, Cato would not have endorsed Race to the Top, so I probably would prefer the Cato response to Obama's. 

I'm glad the NEA endorsement produced such positive results so quickly.

If NEA and Obama won't stand up for public education, I'll offer the following as a step by by step explanation of why public education needs to be preserved.

First, I agree with the statement attributed to Thomas Jefferson: "If we're going to have a successful democratic society, we have to have a well educated and healthy citizenry."

Second, as the astute Cory Heidelberger points out, Americans are "the first great nationality based on rational choice rather than blood."  Mr. Heidelberger could have added that Americans are not united by religion, language, crown, or geographic features.

Third, nations need both principles and institutions to unify the people.  (I don't have a source for this one, but I'll be happy to debate it with anyone who wishes.)

Fourth, absent a national religion or monarchy, I submit the the most logical unifying institution is the public school.

Private schools will produce the same unifying results as Coke, Pepsi, 7-Up, and Dr. Pepper.  Have you ever tried offering a Pepsi to a Coke drinker?  Perhaps I'm exaggerating a bit; they might unify as well as McDonalds, Wendy's, Taco Johns, and Burger King.

If President Obama can't or won't enunciate the essential need for public education, and apparently he will not, NEA had no reason to endorse him

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

My Fellow Teachers Do Something Stupid

The National Education Association voted to endorse Barack Obama for the 2012 election.  They also voted to direct
. . . . the NEA President to communicate aggressively, forcefully, and immediately to President Barack Obama and US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan that NEA is appalled with Secretary Duncan's practice of:. . . .
Blogger Teacher Ken tries to put the decision in historical perspective.
Let's provide some historical context for elections since 1988.

1988  Dukakis got 86%

1992 Clinton got 88%

1996 Clinton got 91%

2000 Gore got 86.5%

2004 Kerry got 86.5%

2008 Obama got 79.8%

2011, Obama got 72%.

Unlike Clinton, in his endorsement for reelection Obama dropped 7.8%, while Clinton went up 3%.

And Obama's percentage in 2008 was already the lowest in the past 5 elections.

This is far from "overwhelming" support by historical standards.
Those numbers according to Teacher Ken mean the vote was something other than overwhelming by historical standards.  Overwhelming or not, the endorsement is a stupid decision.

First, Obama's education record is dismal.  The Washington Post describes an individual teacher's frustrations that echo mine.  Teachers supported Obama to "stand strong for public schools and break from a federal education policy of 'testing, testing, testing.'"  However the results have been something different.
Three years later, all the standardized tests are still there. In some places, they are beginning to be used to fire teachers. Lately. . .  the solutions to all of public education’s troubles seem to boil down to a refrain: “Blame it on the teacher[s] who works [their] tail[s] off for 14 hours a day."
Further, education historian Diane Ravitch who tweets with the handle @DianeRavitch has tweeted the following:  "Obama education policy is worse than NCLB because of increased pressure for high-stakes testing, judging by teachers by scores." and "Suppose we might refer to the Bush-Obama education policy since NCLB and RTTT [Race to the Top] are so well aligned, bipartisan."

In short, President Obama has done nothing that teachers supported him to do and he may well have made matters worse.

Second, the vote to endorse and the vote to issue disapproval seems to indicate that Duncan is a wild card who is acting without Obama's approval.  The President appointed Secretary Duncan.  The President has shown a willingness to overrule his generals.  The New York Times reported,
Gen. David H. Petraeus, the top American commander in Afghanistan, said Thursday that President Obama’s new schedule for drawing down forces there was “more aggressive” than he had recommended and increased the risk that the military would not meet all its goals.
Teachers are now supposed to believe that the President can overrule a general but not a secretary of education. It's much more logical, Duncan is putting Obama's policies in place.

Third, NEA may have felt pressured to make the endorsement now so they hold the Representative Assembly every July.  The Chicago Tribune reports
Because the NEA's representative assembly, its primary policymaking arm, meets once a year, union leaders said they faced a dilemma of either being early or late in determining their political support. The group typically makes an endorsement in July preceding the presidential election.
The endorsement is the most important political tool that NEA has.  They have squandered it.

Given that Obama's policies are no better than President Bush's policies, all this early endorsement accomplishes is re-enforce the idea that teachers are lap dogs of the Democratic party.