Showing posts with label Sense of Place. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sense of Place. Show all posts

Friday, May 24, 2013

A Minor Musing On Place And Displacement

I'm politically displaced by choice as much as by circumstance, a little too liberal to be conservative and a little too conservative to be liberal. Perhaps, I'm liberal or conservative on all the wrong issues. In some ways, I'm like Kafka's Hunger Artist. (The story is well worth reading.) He starved himself because he never found a food he liked; geographically, I'm not sure I've lived in a place I've liked.

I suppose it is somewhat ironic that I have been following with great interest Cory's posts about place prompted by this David Newquist post. Coincidentally, I came upon this Ross Douthat post "When Place Is Not Enough"; Douthat makes two key points that I find pertinent.

First, Douthat writes, "[R]eal happiness depends, for many if not most people, on a connection between family, community, and place. But on the evidence of the recent American experience, place alone is not enough."

Second, he makes a key distinction: "I think the distinction . . .  — between a philosophy of rootedness and a philosophy that just stresses 'place' in general or idolizes the rural life in particular — is central to . . . [the] ability to offer a realistic response to the ills of contemporary American life." I'm a bit cynical,  so the idea that there's "a realistic response to the ills of contemporary American life" is a bit hyperbolic, but "rootedness" does seem more important than "place."

Applying Douthat's points to South Dakota prompts a few observations. First, South Dakota is not a monolithic "place"; the Bison-Lemmon metroplex differs significantly from the I-29 corridor region from Sioux Falls to Watertown.

In addition, Douthat points to a "connection between family, community, and place" as being central ingredients to "roots." I'm not sure that's enough; the practical concerns about paying to replace the family car's transmission or saving for retirement are things not solved by "family, community, and place."

Further, humans are not plants. The roots metaphor implied in "rootedness" ignores the desire for autonomy. Satisfactorily setting down roots demands that one be able to choose to remain. A person who lives in Illinois, New York, California, or Texas and quits a successful job and sells a comfortable house can move to South Dakota, buy a similar house and have money left over. The converse is not true. Although, one may still have "choices," those choices are rather like the ones Odysseus faced on his voyage home: sail close to the six-headed monster Scylla and lose crewmen or sail close to the whirlpool Charybdis and lose the whole ship.

Finally, to apply the roots metaphor, roots need good soil and cultivation to softened the ground. Politically and culturally, South Dakota seems to desire stability more than cultivation. Deserts are stable too, but little grows there.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Local Media Is Suffering

I grew up on the North Dakota side of the Bison-Lemmon metroplex.  My family listened to KBJM Radio 1400 and read The Bismarck Tribune along with a local weekly.  In my increasingly unreliable memory, the media covered local issues fairly well.  Apparently, local issues now get short shrift.  According a New York Times article,
An explosion of online news sources in recent years has not produced a corresponding increase in reporting, particularly quality local reporting, a federal study of the media has found.

Coverage of state governments and municipalities has receded at such an alarming pace that it has left government with more power than ever to set the agenda and have assertions unchallenged, concluded the study, which is to be released on Thursday.
Quoting from the study, the Times reports,
“Breathtaking media abundance lives side by side with serious shortages in reporting,” it said. “Communities benefit tremendously from many innovations brought by the Internet and simultaneously suffer from the dislocations caused by the seismic changes in media markets."
I have a few quick observations.  First, I am aware of the irony of quoting the New York Times to discuss local issues.  Second, the report illustrates a need for blogs such as The Madville Times, An Inland Voyage, and  David Lias's blog.  Third, South Dakotans may complain about their local media, but for the most part, the local daily and weekly newspapers seem to cover most of the official government meetings.  They probably don't do as much investigative work as they should, but situations like this example from the NYT article probably don't happen.
In researching the report, he and his staff interviewed scores of journalists to develop a fuller picture of the state of media. What they found was sometimes alarming. At one newspaper Mr. Waldman [author of the study] visited in Tennessee, he recalled, he asked an editor about a list of story ideas that was posted in the newsroom.

“There was one up there that said it was about the regulatory board that dealt with incompetent doctors. And there was a little red X next to it. I said, ‘What does that mean?’ And he said, ‘Well, we’re not doing that one.’ ” The reason the editor offered: the paper used to have two reporters assigned to cover that area, and now it had only one.
Finally, the larger problem may be we media consumers who have lost all sense of place.  Front Porch Republic observes,
Little regard is paid to the necessity for those overlapping local and regional groups, communities, and associations that provide a matrix for human flourishing.
Perhaps, the problem is a little simpler than that.  Little attention is paid to human flourishing. Each of us have started to view everything and everyone as a commodity.  The economy might be terrible, but James Carville's famous maxim should probably be rephrased to state "It's the relationships, stupid."  That personal connection should create demand for increased local coverage.