Showing posts with label Being Displaced. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Being Displaced. Show all posts

Thursday, July 5, 2018

A Minor Musing About The Political Left, Right, And Center

George W. Bush's No Child Left Behind foolishness and and his decision to invade Iraq despite the fact that there was no evidence Saddam Hussein was linked to 9/11 or had the weaponry to produce the mushroom cloud Bush's Vice-President Cheney ominously warned Americans about moved me leftward on the political spectrum.

In a sane political universe I would still be one step to the right of center. In South Dakota, therefore, I'm three steps to the left, a spot that most of South Dakota's conservatives believe is a full step left of Marx and Lenin.

As the name of this blog indicates, I am used to being in empty spaces, but two recent national columns give me a bit of comfort. First in yesterday's column, Max Boot writes that the Republican party has morphed. It was "a conservative party with a white-nationalist fringe. Now it’s a white-nationalist party with a conservative fringe." If memory serves, Boot was a NeoCon cheerleader for the Iraq invasion, so I should make some snide remark about getting a comeuppance, but his work also provided my policy debaters with DA link and impact cards, so I have a soft spot for Max.

I also agree with two trenchant bits of analysis from the column. First, he points out that Trump and his enablers
“want to transform the GOP into a European-style nationalist party that opposes cuts in entitlement programs, believes in deportation of undocumented immigrants, white identity politics, protectionism and isolationism backed by hyper-macho threats to bomb the living daylights out of anyone who messes with us.” 
More importantly, the cult of Trump has totally destroyed the GOP's soul.
If Trump announced he were going to spit-roast immigrant kids and eat them on national TV (apologies to Jonathan Swift), most Republicans probably would approve of that, too. The entire Republican platform can now be reduced to three words: whatever Trump says. 

The second quotation leads nicely into today's E.J Dionne column. Dionne points to an Alan I. Abramowitz book which points out that Republicans have moved further right than Democrats have moved left.

And the centrist heavenly chorus is off-key in another respect: While it sings mournful songs about the major parties becoming “extreme,” Abramowitz’s data make clear that the two sides are not equivalent. Republicans have moved significantly further to the right than Democrats have moved to the left.

Between 1972 and 2012, he notes, the proportion of Democrats who put themselves at the center of the ideological spectrum (or were unable to place themselves) dropped from 52 percent to 41 percent, an 11-point drop. In the same period, the comparable figures for Republicans were 44 percent and 22 percent, double the Democratic swing.

The upshot: The share of Democrats in the ideological middle is nearly twice that of Republicans.

Boot's and Dionne's analysis indicate what red state Democrats and moderate independents have long known. Republicans will continue to demonize moderate positions as leftist/socialist/communist not because those positions are actually left of center but because Republicans have moved so far to the right that the center has become distorted. More importantly, Trump may have made that situation irreversible.
 

Sunday, October 27, 2013

A Quiz To Determine How Displaced You Are

Time  has a 10 question quiz to determine the state that best matches a person's personality. Apparently, I belong in Indiana. I'm not only politically displaced; I'm geographically misplaced.

Friday, May 24, 2013

A Minor Musing On Place And Displacement

I'm politically displaced by choice as much as by circumstance, a little too liberal to be conservative and a little too conservative to be liberal. Perhaps, I'm liberal or conservative on all the wrong issues. In some ways, I'm like Kafka's Hunger Artist. (The story is well worth reading.) He starved himself because he never found a food he liked; geographically, I'm not sure I've lived in a place I've liked.

I suppose it is somewhat ironic that I have been following with great interest Cory's posts about place prompted by this David Newquist post. Coincidentally, I came upon this Ross Douthat post "When Place Is Not Enough"; Douthat makes two key points that I find pertinent.

First, Douthat writes, "[R]eal happiness depends, for many if not most people, on a connection between family, community, and place. But on the evidence of the recent American experience, place alone is not enough."

Second, he makes a key distinction: "I think the distinction . . .  — between a philosophy of rootedness and a philosophy that just stresses 'place' in general or idolizes the rural life in particular — is central to . . . [the] ability to offer a realistic response to the ills of contemporary American life." I'm a bit cynical,  so the idea that there's "a realistic response to the ills of contemporary American life" is a bit hyperbolic, but "rootedness" does seem more important than "place."

Applying Douthat's points to South Dakota prompts a few observations. First, South Dakota is not a monolithic "place"; the Bison-Lemmon metroplex differs significantly from the I-29 corridor region from Sioux Falls to Watertown.

In addition, Douthat points to a "connection between family, community, and place" as being central ingredients to "roots." I'm not sure that's enough; the practical concerns about paying to replace the family car's transmission or saving for retirement are things not solved by "family, community, and place."

Further, humans are not plants. The roots metaphor implied in "rootedness" ignores the desire for autonomy. Satisfactorily setting down roots demands that one be able to choose to remain. A person who lives in Illinois, New York, California, or Texas and quits a successful job and sells a comfortable house can move to South Dakota, buy a similar house and have money left over. The converse is not true. Although, one may still have "choices," those choices are rather like the ones Odysseus faced on his voyage home: sail close to the six-headed monster Scylla and lose crewmen or sail close to the whirlpool Charybdis and lose the whole ship.

Finally, to apply the roots metaphor, roots need good soil and cultivation to softened the ground. Politically and culturally, South Dakota seems to desire stability more than cultivation. Deserts are stable too, but little grows there.

Thursday, May 16, 2013

A Post About Fragmenting Everything And Creating A Really Bad Albeit Ironically Funny Mashup

We live in a scandal driven world that prefers heat to light. Consequently, Americans seldom deal with the funadmental issues.

Writing at First Things, Peter Leithart looks at capitalism's effect on families:
The most penetrating conservative analysts of family life, such as Allan Carlson, have always recognized the cultural contradictions of capitalism and of technological society. They have always recognized the costs (as well as the gains) of separating work and home; of geographic, vocational, and social mobility; of the indisputable wealth-generating power of capitalism. On the ground, though, conservatives look the other way when told that our economic system or our technological progress might inhibit the formation of what [Wendall] Berry describes as an economy that “exists for the protection of gifts, beginning with the ‘giving in marriage.’”
 Leithart describes most people's daily lives:
What kind of scrutiny can a community have over marriages when neighbors see neighbors only when both are comfortably encased in a sound-proof, air-conditioned bubble of glass and steel? How much help will your friends be to your family if you squeeze out time for real conversation only a few times a year, on the handful of evenings you’re not working late at the office? How much community scrutiny is possible when “live and let live” is a cultural axiom?
Peter Lovenheim begins his analysis of the Amanda Berry, Gina DeJeseus, and Michelle Knight captivity and rescue with similar questions:
Do you know your neighbors well enough to realize whether something horrible is happening in the house down the street? To call them if you need help? To trust that they’d put themselves at risk to help you?
Lovenheim continues,
The fault of this horrible crime, of course, is with whoever kidnapped and held these women. But I wonder what would have happened if the neighbors had spoken to one another more and shared their worries. I wonder if, collectively, they would have pushed law enforcement authorities to check things out, to get involved. I wonder if this tragedy could have been discovered much sooner if the neighbors on Seymour Avenue had been, well, a little more neighborly.
Both men seem to come to same conclusion:
Fragmented communities weaken marriages, and our society seems cunningly designed to fracture communities. The subtle threats are the most corrosive, and are deeply engraved on the physical arrangements and habitual patterns of our lives.
Both our civic and political leaders are ill-equipped to develop and espouse adequate solutions to fragmentation at the local and family level. Instead, Americans argue about whether Jesus was a Republican or Democrat, liberal or conservative. We fight about guns and Confederate symbolism. Meanwhile. we minimize the fact that all of us probably love money more than we ought. In short, our political and cultural discourse resembles this mashup that recently came across my Twitter feed.


It really doesn't matter which party is to blame. Neither are offering solutions to deal with the fundamental issues.

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Romney Or Obama: How About None Of The Above?

Troy Jones makes the standard Republican case to deny President Obama a second term. Cory offers a line by line rebuttal.  As an interesting side note, it seems a bit odd that Cory mentions Governor Romney only twice; Troy mentions Romney only in the concluding sentence's injunction to "vote Romney," hardly a ringing endorsement.

I'm going to unleash my inner Libertarian and argue that "None of the Above" is the best vote. Listening to Romney and viewing Obama's record makes it clear that checking the box for either is really a vote against the more evil of two lessers. In this election, the differences are not distinct enough to justify making that vote.

Troy and Cory focus on economic arguments. This AlterNet post may be hyperbolic but it contains this kernel of truth: "Republicans [are] more committed than ever to repealing every economic gain the working-class has achieved in the last century and the Democrats [are] seemingly unable to resist." Unwilling might be a better term than "unable." Both posts provide the necessary supporting evidence. Troy correctly asserts:
Too Big Too Fail banks are getting bigger and JPMorgan/Chase lost closer to $9Billion in activities banks should not be allowed to do.  D-F made our financial system more unstable vs. more stable.
Cory responds:
I’ll grant Dodd-Frank is flawed. But a Romney return to deregulation and high-finance free-for-all is not the proper response.
I have no confidence that Obama and the Democrats will prevent "return to deregulation and high-finance free-for-all."

Let's move beyond the economy. The tea party party folk frequently contend that health care reform is the biggest existential threat to liberty that the country has ever faced. The Affordable Care Act, whatever its flaws, is not a major assault on liberty.The biggest threats to liberty are the Patriot Act, the expansion of the security state and the dismissive attitude toward civil liberties. President Obama and the Democrats refuse to repeal the Patriot Act, Obama has expanded the security state beyond Bush's ambitions.

When it comes to civil liberties, the choice seems to be between a person who will take them away with an ironic smirk and a person who will take them away with a plastic smile.

The second non-economic issue is the military. The United States needs to cut back on foreign adventuring. Our military is stretched too thin; the suicide rate among veterans is alarmingly high, and the drone war justifies killing civilians. Governor  Romney is rattling the sabers at Iran, and President Obama seemingly hasn't seen a drone target he doesn't want to attack.

Finally, I've never seen Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and Mitt Romney in the same room.  When it comes to education policy, they may be the same person. Both will continue to pursue policies that harm more than help.

One may be less bad than the other.  For example on a Richter scale, a 10. 1 earthquake is twice as powerful as a 10; both would destroy my house, so there's no reason to hope for one over the other. Both Presidential candidates will ensure an increase in corporate influence on government, a decline in the working class standard of living, a decrease in civil liberties, and continued foreign adventuring; there's no reason to vote for one over the other.

Monday, June 18, 2012

A Minor Musing About Expanding Government Power

The local blogosphere on both the right and the left is hashing out Obama's immigration executive order; the local tea party is concerned about the rising numbers of corporations that are being crucified.  After all, some on the far right believe corporations are people whose life begins at the moment of incorporation.

The imperial presidency is a perpetual danger.  I wish the right had expressed more concern about the abuse of executive orders when George W. Bush expanded their use.  I also wish the tea party folk were more concerned about torturing actual human beings rather than the use of a hyperbolic metaphor about a corporation.

Meanwhile, both ends of the political spectrum should be worried about the government's seemingly insatiable demand for citizens' data.  Forbes reports,
In the second half of 2011, Google received 6,321 requests that it hand over its users’ private data to U.S. government agencies including law enforcement, and complied at least partially with those requests in 93% of cases, according to the latest update to the company’s bi-annual Transparency Report that it planned to release Sunday night.
That’s up from 5,950 requests in the first half of 2011, and marks a 37% increase in the number of requests over the second half of 2010, when Google received only 4,601 government requests and complied to some degree with 94% of them. And compared with the 3,580 requests for its data it received from U.S. agencies in the second half of 2009, the first time Google released the request numbers, the latest figures represent a 76% spike.
More alarmingly, the article continues, "Whether firms like Facebook, Microsoft, Comcast, AT&T and others have seen a parallel rise in requests can’t be determined."

Other governments are also increasing their requests for data:
Total government requests for users’ data from outside the U.S. have also been increasing steadily, spiking sharply to 11,936 in the second half of 2011 compared with 9,600 in the same period last year and 8,959 in the second half of 2009. And the number of foreign requests may be growing even faster than they appear to. Because mutual legal assistance treaties allow some countries to pass on their requests through U.S. government agencies, some portion of those foreign requests are lumped together with the U.S. requests.
Thankfully:
Google has a far lower rate of complying with foreign requests, however. It only fulfilled 64% of U.K. requests and 45% of German requests, for instance, and complied with none of the requests from Russia or Turkey.
Most of these requests probably claimed the information was necessary for national security, so the political right will smile, nod, and go along with these warrantless searches even though those information requests are as unconstitutional abusive executive orders.  Pat Buchanan had a broken clock moment when he asserted that the U.S. should be a republic not an empire.  Critics of a President as emperor should should be vigilant and condemn all imperial actions even if the actions institute policies the critics support.

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Why I'm Displaced Edtion

Writing about Wendell Berry's Jefferson Lecture of the National Endowment for the Humanities in the Financial  Times (registration required), Christopher Caldwell praises Berry's assertion that Americans' "essential mistake has been to ignore 'propriety of scale,'" and notes,
In the US, however, there is no political outlet for a conservatism that fears bigness in the private sector as much as in the public sector.
I fear bigness in both sectors, but I don't find many partisans who share both fears.

Monday, April 9, 2012

Quotation Of The Day: Purposeful Political Displacement Edition

From this Wil Wilkinson post at Marginal Revolution,
Politics makes us stupid. This is one of my recurring themes. This is the principal reason I refuse to be a partisan or ideological team player. People call me libertarian but I don't in part because I'm not one, but mostly because I suspect that accepting any such label dings my IQ about 15 points
The rest of the post is well worth reading as Wilkinson points to a study that indicates ". . . politics not only makes us stupid. It also makes us callous."

Friday, October 21, 2011

A Musing About Being Politically Displaced

I'm anticipating leaving my ballot for President blank next November.  It's early and I may change my mind, or I may scribble Paul Kucinich on the ballot, but right now I am both displaced and disillusioned.

Andrew Sullivan swoons over Obama's record here and here before concluding
To rid the world of Osama bin Laden, Anwar al-Awlaki and Moammar Qaddafi within six months: if Obama were a Republican, he'd be on Mount Rushmore by now.
I voted for Obama because I believed that he kept his cool as the financial crisis developed in September and October of 2008.  McCain imploded; he stopped campaigning, started campaigning and looked old and out of his depth.

I had hoped Obama would end torture as an official policy, mitigate some of the worst parts of the Patriot Act, fix NCLB, and reduce the effects of K Street. None of those hopes have materialized.

I certainly believed he would reduce America's foreign adventuring.  I was wrong about that too.  In short, I don't think he's Rushmore worthy.

I don't think any of those views are liberal.  I hope there are Republicans who can agree with most of those views.  The folks at Dakota War College are swooning over different members of the current crop of Republican candidates.  I don't see it.

Perry likes the death penalty too much, and those poor paying jobs he touts as the Texas miracle require that people who work a 40 hour week still need manna from heaven to get by.  Despite his debate lapses, I think he still might get the nomination.  I don't know if Romney can crack the glass ceiling that the far right constructed.

Huntsman seems competent but boring.  He's not going to get the nomination because he served as an ambassador for Obama.

Romney has had more positions than a double jointed porn star.  I would guess that both major parties have a hypocrisy line they hesitate crossing.  If he's the nominee, Republicans will have to apologize to John Kerry.  He also speaks better English than Perry which means his chances of winning the nomination are automatically reduced.

Gingrich has the same problem with the hypocrisy line.  Having an affair while one's spouse is fighting cancer reflects a moral lapse that would require that the Republicans apologize to Bill Clinton

Paul would want to do most of what I list above, but he has all of that gold standard baggage.  I don't think anyone would take him seriously if he won.

Bachmann scares me.  Trying to do my job well doesn't make me a fascist, no matter what Santorum thinks.

I think the tax system should get simpler, but Cain's 999 plan would destroy an already beleaguered middle class.  There's no way that he could shepherd anything through Congress without high powered help, and he won't tell anyone who advises him.

It's not like my vote will matter; South Dakota is a safe Republican state.  It's just depressing to have to no one to vote for and to have to settle for voting for the lesser of two evils

UPDATE:  7:55 CDT South Dakota Politics also has brief comments about the Republican field.