I hope that before I die I will have the opportunity to see one, just one, South Dakota television news reader expose a South Dakota politician the way Olbermann illustrates the inadequacies of Roger Goodell's two game suspension of Ray Rice after Rice knocked out his fiance and dragged her from an elevator.
Showing posts with label Football. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Football. Show all posts
Saturday, August 2, 2014
Sunday, September 15, 2013
A Fall Without Football
I've decided to stop being an American. I'm not going to renounce my American citizenship like Superman renounced his or Ted Cruz renounced his Canadian citizenship; I'm just not going to watch football or play fantasy football this season. Let's be honest, football is now America's game; fantasy football is something all the cool folks do, and not watching makes one a suspect citizen. I fully expect increased NSA surveillance.
The concussion stories of the past few years have given me pause, and I'm having a tough time justifying watching people voluntarily risk of brain damage for my entertainment. The NFL is taking a few steps but I'm not sure it's enough. I'm not going to go on a crusade. If I visit someone and the game is on, I won't demand the game be shut off. I'm not calling for a government investigation, and I'm not going to make hyperbolic comparisons to Roman gladiatorial combat. I'm just going to try to get through the fall and winter without turning on a game
I anticipate some problems like withdrawal. I have spent thousands of hours watching National Football League games. When I was a young'un I even spent a few hundred hours listening to Monday Night Football on the radio because ABC was not one of the networks our TV antenna picked up. I watched all through college. For the past few decades, it's been a habit to take a pile of work that needs to be corrected, turn on the game, and correct and watch.
Right now, baseball season will get me through most Sunday afternoons. After baseball, season, I expect a few problems. I'm not going to try to replace American football with soccer. I find soccer neither beautiful nor entertaining, and soccer fans grate worse than fingernails on a chalkboard.
I'll watch Sports Center so that I can talk with the young'uns. Knowing a bit about sports and pop culture has always been part of the job. I may be making a distinction without a difference, but I don't believer that my watching the news makes me responsible for violent crime or Assad's use of chemical weapons; the same holds true for Sports Center. When I watch a game, however, I'm helping provide the advertising dollars that fund the $9 billion industry that cannot avoid causing concussions.
The concussion stories of the past few years have given me pause, and I'm having a tough time justifying watching people voluntarily risk of brain damage for my entertainment. The NFL is taking a few steps but I'm not sure it's enough. I'm not going to go on a crusade. If I visit someone and the game is on, I won't demand the game be shut off. I'm not calling for a government investigation, and I'm not going to make hyperbolic comparisons to Roman gladiatorial combat. I'm just going to try to get through the fall and winter without turning on a game
I anticipate some problems like withdrawal. I have spent thousands of hours watching National Football League games. When I was a young'un I even spent a few hundred hours listening to Monday Night Football on the radio because ABC was not one of the networks our TV antenna picked up. I watched all through college. For the past few decades, it's been a habit to take a pile of work that needs to be corrected, turn on the game, and correct and watch.
Right now, baseball season will get me through most Sunday afternoons. After baseball, season, I expect a few problems. I'm not going to try to replace American football with soccer. I find soccer neither beautiful nor entertaining, and soccer fans grate worse than fingernails on a chalkboard.
I'll watch Sports Center so that I can talk with the young'uns. Knowing a bit about sports and pop culture has always been part of the job. I may be making a distinction without a difference, but I don't believer that my watching the news makes me responsible for violent crime or Assad's use of chemical weapons; the same holds true for Sports Center. When I watch a game, however, I'm helping provide the advertising dollars that fund the $9 billion industry that cannot avoid causing concussions.
Labels:
Football,
Point of Personal Privilege
Friday, August 30, 2013
How Far Does Responsibility Extend In A Virtual World?
Cory has an interesting post about New Jersey Court determining that people who send texts may be held liable if they know the persons they're texting are driving. According to the court, the texter is "electronically present." It's unclear how texters are to become omniscient so they know if they are initiating a text to person who is driving, but rulings like this one seem to spread. People may soon have to get used to dealing with the perils of being "electronically present" or "virtual world responsible."
If one may have a legal culpability for being "electronically present," one likely has a moral culpability for playing fantasy football. One certainly doesn't need to be omniscient to know to that professional football players will suffer concussions during every season
A.G. Gancarski examines a the "virtual world responsibility" by asking whether those who play fantasy sports, especially fantasy football bear for those players who suffer concessions or other brain trauma:
There is something sinister about fantasy sports, the idea of “owning” athletes whose careers are necessarily ephemeral and fetishizing their abstracted statistical performance. This is especially true with football, that most brutal of all mainstream entertainments.. . .
Now it’s easy to run as many fantasy football teams as one can manage, as sites like Yahoo and ESPN offer platforms with mobile phone apps—no matter where you are, you’re never without the chance to make a waiver claim on a hot new star at a skill position. The ubiquity of access to fantasy football and other fantasy sports has made it a billion-dollar industry with roughly 27 million players covering almost 20 percent of American males. Even Louisiana Governor (and possible 2016 presidential contender) Bobby Jindal live-tweeted his own fantasy draft last week.
Theres a hard reality behind the fantasy, however. Despite the best efforts of Max Boot—or was it Daniel Flynn?—to debunk The War on Football, those who watch the sport even sporadically know the stakes for those on the field: severe injury is a possibility on any given play.I realize professional football players play the game because they make millions not because fantasy football geeks play a game in which football players' statistics determines the winner of the fantasy game. That said, the fantasy player seems to bear a small moral responsibility for being a part, however small, of the revenue stream that creates the $9 billion National Football League.
If one may have a legal culpability for being "electronically present," one likely has a moral culpability for playing fantasy football. One certainly doesn't need to be omniscient to know to that professional football players will suffer concussions during every season
Labels:
Football,
Moral Obligation
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Is Consent A Lodestar? A Saturday Morning Musing About Football, Porn, And Responsibility
Big Boy Bloggers Rod Dreher, Alan Jacobs, Noah Millman, and Conor Friedersdorf have been having a long and interesting discussion about this n +1 essay about a reporter embedded with a company that produces BDSM porn. This Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry post has most of the links. The Friedersdorf post is here.
Before clicking on the article that starts the exchange, be warned; Jacobs writes, "Witt [the author of the n+1 essay] is an acute observer with no moral compass at all, and I find both her inability to orient herself ethically and her rather placid acceptance of that non-orientation disturbing. I read her essay with care but wish I had never seen it."
I've been working with the high school young'uns a bit too long to put together a cogent philosophical conclusion. If I can get them to see The Odyssey as an illustration that being human is being troubled, I think I've done my job.
In the matter at hand, all I have is troubling questions that I'm not sure the original essay, the Post article, or the bloggers satisfactorily address: How much autonomy does one really have to consent? Further, is there a consequential moraldifference between watching an paid porn performer beaten and bruised for her own gratification and watching a paid NFL player beaten and bruised to win a football game? More importantly, how much moral responsibility do consumers of pain for pleasure bear for the damage done to the performers?
Many of the posts discuss the moral implications people enduring pain for gratification. Friedersdorf views the crux of the argument as being about consent:
The ethos of consent is regarded as a lodestar because its embrace is widely seen as an incredible improvement over much of human history; and because instances when the culture of consent is rejected are superlatively horrific.
With an introduction that mentions BDSM, morals, consent, and something so "disturbing" that a well-read college professor wishes he "had never seen it," I have no choice but to write about the National Football League.
Yesterday's Washington Post has a Sally Jenkins, Rick Maese and Scott Clement article about a Post survey of National Football League players. The results are rather alarming:
- Nine in 10 former NFL players reported suffering concussions while playing, and nearly six in 10 reported three or more. Two in three who had concussions said they experience continuing symptoms from them.
- More than nine in 10 players reported suffering at least one major injury while in the NFL. More than half reported three or more; one in five reported five or more.
- Forty-four percent of former players said they have either had a joint replacement or have been advised they’ll need one.
The survey reports that most players played to make better life for themselves and their families. Most have no regrets:
The Post’s online survey of more than 500 retired players paints a rare portrait of the toll a career in the NFL has on the long-term health of those who competed in the bruising game. The results also present a striking paradox: Nine in 10 said they’re happy they played the sport. But fewer than half would recommend children play it todayThe money doesn't seem to last as long as the pain, however.
A Washington Post survey of retired NFL players found that nearly nine in 10 report suffering from aches and pains on a daily basis, and they overwhelmingly – 91 percent – connect nearly all their pains to football.The article continues the point about pain:
Few professions leave their work force with such lasting bruises and scars. The NFL and the league’s Player Care Foundation, an independent charitable organization, sponsored a study at the University of Michigan in 2009 that surveyed 1,063 former players. About eight in 10 reported suffering from pain that lasts most of the day. Among younger retirees, aged 30 to 49, one in three said he was unable to work or limited in work. And almost 30 percent of them rated their health as only “fair” or “poor.”
Ten percent of those under 65 in the Michigan survey needed surgery they could not afford, 16 percent needed dental care they couldn’t pay for and 8 percent could not afford prescription medicine.With one breath these men claim to have consented to endure pain so fans watch them perform; yet in the next breath, many seem to indicate doubts about consent:
Nine in ten players surveyed by The Post reported playing while hurt during their careers, and 56 percent said they did so “frequently.” Nearly seven in 10 (68 percent) said they felt they had no choice in doing so.
“If you didn’t hurt while you were playing, then you weren’t playing,” [former linebacker Darryl] Talley said.
Forty-nine percent of the former players surveyed said they wish they’d played while hurt less often.Dreher describes the events of the porn shoot as "torture" that the actress admits to having enjoyed. Enduring hits that causes three concussions sounds a bit like torture to me. So do the surgeries that Don Majkowski endured:
Seventeen years removed from his NFL career, ex-quarterback Don Majkowski says he can no longer hold down a job. He can’t stand for long periods, and sitting is also tough. He has undergone nearly 20 surgeries related to football, including 11 on his ankle, three on his shoulder and two on his back. He has a 12-inch scar on his stomach, and he can’t walk very far because his left foot is fused with his ankle by a pair of metal plates and 13 screws. “It’s like walking on a pirate peg leg,” he said.There's a sexual component to BDSM that most people find far more repulsive than the gladiatorial nature of the NFL. Yet, it all seems to come back to the fact that performers in both venues consent to suffer pain and debilitating injuries to entertain others and earn a living..
I've been working with the high school young'uns a bit too long to put together a cogent philosophical conclusion. If I can get them to see The Odyssey as an illustration that being human is being troubled, I think I've done my job.
In the matter at hand, all I have is troubling questions that I'm not sure the original essay, the Post article, or the bloggers satisfactorily address: How much autonomy does one really have to consent? Further, is there a consequential moraldifference between watching an paid porn performer beaten and bruised for her own gratification and watching a paid NFL player beaten and bruised to win a football game? More importantly, how much moral responsibility do consumers of pain for pleasure bear for the damage done to the performers?
Sunday, October 7, 2012
Quotation Of The Day: Football Fan Behavior Edition
Eric Winston, Kansas City Chiefs left tackle, on fans cheering Matt Cassel being injured:
"We are athletes, OK? We are athletes. We are not gladiators. This is not the Roman Coliseum. People pay their hard-earned money when they come in here and I believe they can boo, they can cheer and they can do whatever they want, I believe that. We are lucky to play this game. People, it's hard to economic times, and they still pay the money to do this.
"But when somebody gets hurt, there are long lasting ramifications to the game we play, long lasting ramifications to the game we play. I've already kinda come to the understanding that I won't live as long because I play this game and that's OK, that's a choice I've made and a choice all of us have made.
"But when you cheer, when you cheer somebody getting knocked out, I don't care who it is, and it just so happened to be Matt Cassel -- it's sickening. It's 100 percent sickening. I've been in some rough times on some rough teams, I've never been more embarrassed in my life to play football than in that moment right there. . . .
"Boo him all you want. Boo me all you want. Throw me under the bus. Tell me I'm doing a bad job. Say I gotta protect him more. Do whatever you want. Say whatever you want. But if you are one of those people, one of those people that were out there cheering or even smiled when he got knocked out, I just want to let you know, and I want everybody to know that I think it's sickening and disgusting. We are not gladiators and this is not the Roman Coliseum. This is a game. . . .
"It's sickening. And I was embarrassed. I want every single one of you people to put this on your station and in your newspapers because I want every fan to know that. This is a game that's going to cost us a lot down the road. That's OK. We picked it, we deserve it and I don't want your pity. But we have a lot of problems as a society if people think that's OK.
Labels:
Football,
Quotation of the Day
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Quotation Of The Day: Eternal Optimist Or Insane Prophet Edtion
From Richard Whalen, CEO of the Elite Football League of India, a group trying to introduce American football to India:
“One day the Mumbai Gladiators will be worth more than the New York Yankees.”However insane Whalen sounds, I'm willing to bet his prediction will come true before South Dakota sees the end of single-party domination in the state legislature.
Friday, May 4, 2012
Am I My Wealthy Bothers' Keeper?
In an April 30 Slate interview Malcolm Gladwell argues that college football should be banned. When asked about the National Football League, Gladwell responds,
Ta-Nehisi Coates, a senior editor for The Atlantic, believes that Seau's death makes the answer obvious.
The men who play professionally chose to do so and are handsomely rewarded for their efforts. It is, however, becoming more obvious that playing the game professionally kills many. The deaths are premature and painful. In the case of Seau and Dave Duerson, they seemed to become different people prior to their suicides
I spend a huge portion of my Sundays from September through February watching the National Football League. Like Coates, I use it as a language to communicate. It's a useful one with many students.
Coates and Gladwell are making me wonder if I need to change that habit and find other ways to communicate. I haven't thought about this as long as Coates, and I haven't made the decisions that he has, but I have difficulty ethically justifying being entertained by people who end their lives prematurely to provide that entertainment.
As long as the risks are explicit, the players warned, and those injured properly compensated, then I'm not sure we can stop people from playing. A better question is whether it is ethical to WATCH football. That's a harder question.Since then, Junior Seau committed suicide, shooting himself in the chest in an apparent effort to preserve his brain to be tested for concussion related damage.
Ta-Nehisi Coates, a senior editor for The Atlantic, believes that Seau's death makes the answer obvious.
I'm not so sure that it's hard at all. The answer, at least for those displeased with pro football's response, seems pretty clear. Doing the damn thing is the hard part.
I now know that I have to go. I have known it for a while now. But I have yet to walk away. For me, the hardest portion is living apart--destroying something that binds me to friends and family. With people whom I would not pass another words, I can debate the greatest running back of all time. It's like losing a language.Coates and Gladwell hit on two important points. The National Football League dominates America's sports calendar. It entertains and provides metaphors that organize businesses and individual's social lives. The League's coaches and star players are some of the most requested speakers. Any book that bears their names becomes an automatic best-seller.
The men who play professionally chose to do so and are handsomely rewarded for their efforts. It is, however, becoming more obvious that playing the game professionally kills many. The deaths are premature and painful. In the case of Seau and Dave Duerson, they seemed to become different people prior to their suicides
I spend a huge portion of my Sundays from September through February watching the National Football League. Like Coates, I use it as a language to communicate. It's a useful one with many students.
Coates and Gladwell are making me wonder if I need to change that habit and find other ways to communicate. I haven't thought about this as long as Coates, and I haven't made the decisions that he has, but I have difficulty ethically justifying being entertained by people who end their lives prematurely to provide that entertainment.
Thursday, April 5, 2012
Baseball Vs. Football: A New Twist And The Classic
It's MLB's opening day or opening week. Writing at The New Republic, Michael Kazin celebrates the current state of the grand old game.
Who would have thought that real life would make George Carlin seem a bit naive?
Meanwhile, few MLB players ever endure the concussions that are alarmingly routine in the NFL and present what may be the most troubling problem in contemporary pro sports. According to the Washington Post, as many as 1,000 former players are currently suing the NFL for ignoring or concealing the head traumas they suffered during their careers. The National Hockey League, which only recently prohibited hard checks to the head, may not be far behind.
Thus, at the opening of its 142nd consecutive season, major league baseball is healthier than it has been in years. This may make it easier for the casual fan to walk through the gates of a ballpark and take pleasure in a game whose rules and aesthetics have changed little since Grover Cleveland lived in the White House. In The Art of Fielding, Chad Harbach’s delicious first novel, a wise young college catcher reflects on “the almost unfair beauty of a professional ball field, the expensive riotous green of the grass, the scalloped cutouts around the bases, the whole place groomed like living art.” You get to drink beer and yell at the umpire too.Today is also features the release of this Greg Williams' audio. Williams, whom the National Football League has suspended indefinitely, uses a mix of profanity and an inspirational tone that I suspect is common in NFL locker rooms. I hope, however, that his hit the head and injure the ACL comments are rare. The following is NSFW.
Who would have thought that real life would make George Carlin seem a bit naive?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)